I've never had Jersey Mike's despite having lived in jersey for most of my life. I ordered the veggie small sandwich and my partner ordered the Buffalo chicken. The Buffalo chicken surprisingly had some spice, though it looked a mess. The small veggie sandwich was accidentally made into a regular size, though that's better than if it was the other way around. Taste wise, both were fine but it seemed to be so costly for the amount that was given. $20 for a regular sized hot chicken sub and a small veggie sub. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - #14 The Veggie - Fast Food Near Me - Freehold, New Jersey

See all

Upon arriving, the staff behind the counter didn't smile or say hello when we came up to get our order in. It almost felt like we were an inconvenience to him. I looked up as I was about to order and saw what appeared to be a cut of the turkey meat thrown on top of the other meats in the glass display. It did not look appetizing or sanitary in anyway. I told the staff member my order and he interrupted me to say "you can tell me your toppings later, all I need to know now is what sandwich you want." Fair enough. He appears to be doing multiple orders at the same time so I tried to be patient. After several minutes, he forgets to inform me that two of my three were already made and put in the bag without asking me what toppings I wanted. Not sure if he was having a bad day or not but it wasn't a good experience at all for me. Won't be back! read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - That doesn't look very appetizing. - Fast Food Near Me - Freehold, New Jersey

See all

Thank you, Nick! Great sub!!! After changing my mind, Nick said, "no problem." I appreciate your patience and attention to details.

I just paid $19 for a bread sandwich. I actually ordered the Philly cheesesteak. Didn't used to be so bad. Never going back now!! Ridiculous!! read more

1. The food was good but nothing great. Kinda what you'd expect from a chain store 2. Wrong order served for take out. Got steak instead of chicken. 3. The floor area behind the counter was filled from side to side with lettuce and used plastic gloves. Gross!! Not a place to eat in. 4. Prices were high but not too bad. 5. Will not go back read more

I walked in and walked out. One look at the counter where they keep the toppings made me feel grossed out. It was so sloppy and messy. Probably dirty, too. I don't understand how the counter was such a disgusting mess. The store was empty and it was later in the day. I guess the two kids working there were too busy on their phones. I've been to other locations where this is not the case. Come on Freehold, clean up and get your act together. read more

I have ordered subs from the Howell, and both Point Pleasant stores. The meat and cheese were a significant quantity. Today I tried the Rt. 9 South in the Freehold, NJ store, and was I surprised. It was the thinnest sub that I have ever eaten. When I asked the young man who was working the slicer if they were cutting back on the quantity of the meat and cheese, he was confused. What it seems to me is that they are told to put about 15 slices of thinly sliced meat and 8 to 10 thin slices of cheese on each sub. Iif you don't get a full diameter slice, you are out of luck. read more

Sandwich was loaded of salad dressing... made the sandwich a sloppy mess, also too much vinegar. The box for specifications in the app wasn't working, neither was the phone line, so if I wanted to call to tell them how I wanted my sandwich to be prepared I couldn't, ridiculous! I called a different Jersey Mike's to make them aware the phone line is down and they couldn't care less, so rude! read more

The best tasting subs using fresh, high-quality ingredients but with a smaller than expected portions with a hefty price tag. I'll be honest, I'm human like the rest of us and I absolutely love eating subs. And I will admit, Jersey Mike's uses the highest quality ingredients! But at the same time I'm disappointed that there are subs are smaller than everyone else's, and their prices are higher as well. Of course if I want the best tasting sub this is where I go and just suck up the price. They offer large and giant sized subs. The giant size sub is substantially smaller than other competitors. Even most pizzerias make larger subs. If they would just take their ingredients and make their subs at the same size as their competitors I would without a doubt give them five stars! Recently I ordered a bunch of subs for a party which included, Italian subs with salami ham and provolone; chicken Parmesan subs; and chicken cheesesteak subs. Well the Italian and chicken Parmesan subs were to die for, the chicken cheesesteak wasn't quite as good but still tasty. Fortunately I ordered more subs then I needed because I like to have extra, but due to the smaller sub size I had just enough for the party which worked out fine. Jersey Mike's is the place to go for the highest quality, best tasting subs. Just be prepared for smaller than typical subs with a higher than usual price tag. read more

See all

Contact service is horrible. I received a Fathers Day gift card however when I went to store the card didnt work. I was told to contact customer service which I messaged thru app, left a voicemail & called 4 days straight with no answer in sight. Communication has to be better especially for a franchise store with several locations. I guess I'll keep trying maybe 1 day someone will assist me if possible. read more

This Jersey Mikes just keeps getting worse and worse. Tonight we finally vowed never to go back again. We had tried to give them another chance because of the charity donation night tonight. Wanted to help out a good cause but it would have been more beneficial to just send a check to a charity and order an actually decent sub from sorrentos or primos. There was about a 1/4 cup of tuna in a "giant" whole sub. They were also extremely rude when we went to pick up our order. We will not be going back. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - #10 Tuna Fish - Fast Food Near Me - Freehold, New Jersey

It's a solid place....clean, incredibly polite staff, good subs/ cheesesteaks, and an easy customer appreciation points program based on your cell # that you earn free subs with. They often run free soda & chips promo with the purchase of a regular sized sub. I wish you could pay with the app, similar to Dunkin' or Chipotle. read more

Can only give 5 stars to this Jersey Mike's. Food is fresh, they give a good amount of meat and everyone here is friendly. A+++ to everyone here. Was here on June 7, 8pm. read more

Their staff cannot read a simple online order. Every time I order from there the sandwiches are all mix matched and it's OBNOXIOUS. Management is lacking as well. Good food just wish they could read. read more

Oh God where do I begin. First and foremost I truly hope the owner of this franchise reads this because change is absolutely needed. I used to frequent the Howell store but the last few times I've been, (spoiler alert) it smelled like urine mixed with vinegar. I absolutely love coming to the freehold location. The bread tastes fresher and seems bigger than Howell. The food just tastes better! Everyone I've seen adheres to the mask policy and the place is always clean and never smells bad at all. I've witnessed them telling customers to put their masks on which is amazing! The staff is very friendly even when they are swamped, which is often. The reason I can't justify giving you 5 stars is because I find it absolutely absurd that you have these beautiful big screen TVs that are off. They were never off pre-pandemic. The TVs in Howell and Jackson are on! Sometimes I'm waiting for awhile for them to make my 6 subs and it would be nice to watch something while I wait. I asked and they told me the cable is disconnected!!! This store is constantly busy so I know it can't be a finance thing! Come on now dawg! On top of that these guys are always working and doing so during COVID, arguably one of the hardest times in our history! One of the hardest times to work in, EVER and the owner decided to turn off the cable! What's next to go?? The heat??!! Think about your employees! Company moral is so important especially during these hard times. Since you're saving money on cable and making a killing during this pandemic, maybe show some love to the workers who are literally on your front line. read more

See all

Who comes to New Jersey and orders Jersey Mikes Subs! This Chick!! That's right. LOL crazy I know! Couldn't resist. I love coming to visit my family in NJ. My favorite part is visiting all the local mom and pop shops. Most have been around since the 50's or earlier. The personality of every business is so unique and different. That's what makes New Jersey so special (to me anyways) So what's the big difference between Jersey Mikes in NC and NJ---Well, for starters I've never seen the Family Size Lays chips bags! I always see the small ones with hardly anything in there. Sandwiches are just as good anywhere you go. The staff is really nice. The orders were correct. Prices are the same. The store is clean and neat. Lots of parking available. read more

We ordered two sandwiches at store, , when we got home found order was incorrect (insisted my wife was wrong), and noticeably less meat / ingredients than other JM locations - basically told me "tough luck. Manager was discourteous, disrespectful and unprofessional. We will not patronize this location as there are much better alternatives read more

Wow!!! We just ordered subs last night and for 3 subs it was about $40!!!! They charge you $14-15 each for giant of a tuna & Italian in this location, and $8-9 for 1/2 of that. The next town over charges maybe $11 for the giant. They say giant feeds 4 people, what?????? There are maybe 4-5 sections. Like a normal full Size sub. Nothing different. 2 people share it...We each eat 2-3. NOT 4 people! They claimed because they were a corporate store the charge more. Huh??? Ok, what is the difference? Like customers are going to even think like that. Wait, wouldn't corporate be less? We couldn't believe the amount of NOTHING that was added onto the subs too! Meaning the meat or fish! Kids working and they just don't care or understand. Truly insane! Def never ordering from this location again. Never had a problem with JM until this location. Oh, and they really push the tipping too which I feel is truly amazing. They get paid per hour to do a job, and it's probably NOT minimum wage since there are slicers etc there. why do they expect to have a tip? That's up to the customers if they feel outstanding and above and beyond service..... This isn't a sit down service restaurant..... they shouldn't have to feel pressured into it, with tip buckets and the on credit card slips..... It's really SO tacky! We're better off going to subway or an Italian place to order better quality or quantity for a fraction of the price! read more

See all

Stopped in here to grab a sub. Low and behold, NOT ONE PERSON BEHIND THE COUNTER HAD ON A MASK!! They're busy talking over the food when it's a known fact, you spit when you talk!! I GOT MY BEHIND OUT OF THE LINE AND LEFT!! HOW are they preparing food, talking over the food and NOT have a mask on is beyond my thought process. I will NEVER eat there. God only knows how much DNA customers are getting with their food. DISGUSTING!!!! read more

The guys in here are always super friendly, and food is so good. This place is perfect for your lunch break, and I love that they slice the cold cuts right in front of you. I often get the turkey wrap and it's amazing! read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Turkey wrap. Flour wrap with turkey, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, banana peppers, and honey mustard. Also got kettle BBQ chips! - Fast Food Near Me - Freehold, New Jersey

This joint is gross. I almost walked out but my friend said it was good so we stayed. Don't look behind the counter as you will lose your appetite for sure. Oh and the roast beef is so rare it moo's. YUCK read more

The staff is super friendly and helpful and it's always a joy to dine there. The number 13 is great, also the pastrami and cheesesteak are great choices for warm subs. The roast beef is a good alternative to the usual ham, cappicola, etc. and the turkey is also very good. If you have the appetite go giant sub. :) read more

Excellent service and delicious subs!! I was very satisfied with Jersey Mikes. Particularly, my servers Liam and Andrew were very helpful!

This location is down the street from my job I've passed it many times and never gave it a second thought. I finally got a chance to try it and I was somewhat impressed. Typically I'm not a sub type of person but the Philly cheesesteak sub with the grilled onions was was simply delicious!! I went back on a second visit and ordered a tuna sub and I was less than thrilled. It was flavorless and dry. My husband and son however loved their turkey and cheese subs so what can I say. I'll certainly go back but I think I'll stick with the hot subs instead of the cold ones. Each visit we took our food to go but there's a decent sized dining area if you want your food to stay. read more

"Where's the beef?" For spending over 30$ for only 2 subs with bare bones minimum meat on the bread I feel like i've been completely robbed at this location. The one in Howell overloads the subs, how they're supposed to be. This location put enough on an entire sub for one quarter. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Fast Food Near Me - Freehold, New Jersey

I love this chain. Quality ingredients that make for delicious subs. Great bang for your buck.

Tried this jersey Mikes after going to the one at the Marketplace. Good tasty sandwich but was a SHORTY for 9+$, their crazy to chg that amount, save your money go to firehouse subs for A REAL SUB over 12inches for same price and tastier too. read more

Although I'm a huge fan of the chain, I was very disappointed to find an employee there - at- register- with mask only over her mouth. 2 separate times. read more

Ordered delivery through an independent restaurant delivery service. Scrumptious!!! A friend had told me how good they are & that was sure no lie! Have not ordered any subs from anywhere else, since. The ingredients do taste fresh, fresh, fresh!!! You get what you pay for & you are paying for it here. My first time I did not order large enough - I'd ordered a mini, which I thought would be half a sub (which is what I order from pizzerias; there was no small, or 1/2 option), but I didn't know the small size of their subs. I felt like I'd eaten a finger sandwich! The sub rolls are petite compared to pizza shops & deli's. I'd honestly never seen sub rolls so small before. (And, I'm not a large person, or eater. That friend could have given me a heads-up on that part, but she's about 90 lbs. soaking wet & eats like a bird.) So, now I've got it down: I order 1 Giant + 1 Regular for 2 meals. I eat the regular w/1/4 of the giant as 1 serving. Typical orders are giant tuna & large cheesesteak. I imagine they'd likely be cost-prohibitive for large families on a budget. read more

I love love love this place. The ingredients are fresh, the subs are tasty, the place is clean, and they often hand out coupons for my next visit. The staff is always extremely friendly and fun, and I love chatting it up with them. I've been to other locations of this chain but this one is by far my favorite because of the service. Stop by here the next time you want to grab a quick but yummy bite! read more

Good sub shop good selection. There's good sub shops in Freehold this is another alternative of good selections for the price I go back-and-forth I tried between restaurants here in free old just to Keep It diverse. All in all good choice I like and recommend Stopping by the young guys behind the counter are real nice and fast friendly. read more

For a chain sub place, these guys got it going on. I am not sure about other locations, but these guys are always on target, personable, and always nail the order and don't play games. Highly recommended, and make sandwiches delicious! read more

Nice clean place, super friendly service, and a decent sandwich for the money. I gave it an extra star for their store cooked mediun rare roast beef. read more

The guys working in store were very friendly. They were helpful and inviting. They would make you want to come back. Restaurant is extremely clean. Subs were great. read more

Fast and fresh. Call ahead or use there online order system for super fast pickup. The sandwiches and great. This spot just opened and the sandwiches are super fresh. read more

By far my favorite sub spot. So fresh and delicious. I get the original Italian mikes way with mayo and banana peppers. So good!!!

Hands down my favorite Jersey Mike's. They use their customer's names and boy let me tell you - they know so many! Their friendly service, smiles, and great subs make customer's like myself return. The location has plenty of seating and is extremely clean. I love how JM's cuts the meat fresh for you before they put it on your sandwich - way better than Subway whose just sits there for hours on end. I always recommend this place to everyone! My favorite is a mini #7: turkey and provolone read more

The subs are delicious!!! The staff is always friendly!! The subs are always fresh and tasty!

First time I tried the Grilled Pastrami Rueben. Darn good! Plenty of meat and substance, unlike cheesy Subway, and the taste was fresh and the pastrami lean. I love the service at this location, like most Mike's anyhow, and the location. Only thing that is awkward is the payment process. When they ring you up and have to jump in to remind you that "before you swipe your card, we ask that you consider a satisfaction gratuity (or something like that", you are put on the spot. Management should just up salaries and keep the tip cup for those of us who know and use them. Other than that I love this franchise and am glad to see the recent expansion nationally. Just keep the quality and experience as good as it is now!! read more

Tried Jersey Mike's again. Friendly service and the roast beef sub was very good. I'm glad I tried them again. I will return.