The Cluck Norris is just a terrific idea that will probably be copied by places that are not as creative as this place Clean efficient and a very creative menu and wide variety of the classics with or without a twist and semolina bread is the default bread option Perfect for me I am sure I will be back here soon read more

See all

Don't get me wrong the food is very delicious. My issue is every time I get my order the food will be cold. Does this mean it's not fresh? I order grilled veggies they came freezing cold . I ordered grilled or fried chicken it also came cold. I order around 11 am. I won't order from here again because it's not fresh and I have to reheat the food. Thank you guys for the great recipes for sandwiches. read more

Di Santillo’s - cold chicken with cold wrap - Sandwiches Near Me - Marlboro, New Jersey

See all

An absolute gem. We were unexpectedly up in this area and needed a late lunch. A quick search found this place and I have to say, well worth the visit. They made a custom porkroll and cheese on a semolina roll. Wonderful ! And they made another sandwich with prosciutto, salami and capicola that was insane. The bread here is the best I've had since being in France a few years ago. The attention to detail, friendly service and delicious food are all terrific. Clearly rooted in napoleon tradition! Highly recommended!!!! read more

Di Santillo’s - Sandwiches Near Me - Marlboro, New Jersey

See all

Overpriced sandwiches. Corned beef Reuben got me sick. Preservatives? Just not good. My wife agrees. Steak sandwiches use to be good. read more

First post! New business offering artisan sandwiches and eatery. Menu is big, ordered the Sinatra, bread and ingredients are all very fresh. Will try other stuff on the menu next time! read more

Di Santillo’s - Sandwiches Near Me - Marlboro, New Jersey

PAT'S WAY CHEESESTEAK ----- Best dang cheesesteak I've ever had. I would post a photo with it but I ate it in four bites. read more

They offer a larger menu with sandwiches of many varieties. There is something for everyone here. A nice local Italian specialty deli offering premium cold cuts and other foods that are among the best in the area. Service is quick and friendly and the store has a neighborhood feel to it. Out of all the sandwiches we had my go to (and highly recommended) is the Di' Lino. Prosciutto, Sopprasata, beautifully creamy Burrata (which really makes this sandwich) Basil and Balsamic on beautiful Semolina bread! Hands down a perfect sandwich. Highly recommend this shop! 4 out of 5 stars only due to some items being a touch on the high side of pricing. read more

It was OK. Fried chicken cutlets might've been fresh, but once the refrigerated. They get hard. Philly cheesesteak tasted good. But where was the rest of it? Salt and vinegar chips were not really chip like. Fried pickles were very good, and the pretzel is delicious. Cheesesteak eggroll was more like a taquito. Make it a real eggroll. Sandwich shop should overwhelm your sandwich. You should never have to look for anything. Hopefully it'll change overtime. Good luck. read more

Di Santillo’s - Salt and vinegar chips, not very crispy, kind of soggy - Sandwiches Near Me - Marlboro, New Jersey

I can't believe how bad this place is. $17 for a sandwich that tasted like it was days old. I thought the bread was gonna be crispy but it was soft and chewy. The chicken was days old and ice cold. They slapped together a sandwich but try to make it look like it's quality ingredients. I couldn't even eat it. I literally took 2 bites and threw it out. I don't think the owners care about this place and thats sad. Would love to see them succeed. Take advice and fix the problems. read more

I was blown away by my dining experience at DiSantillo's. This is a casual eatery with a wide variety of menu items. I was extremely impressed with their abilities to make every item fresh and delicious. We started off with burrata over sliced tomatoes with a balsamic glaze. Perfect summer appetizer which was light, fresh, and the burrata was creamy and wonderful. You can never go wrong with burrata. We also tried the cheesesteak eggrolls which were a fun appetizer to try. They were crispy and cheesy and delightful and came with a great cheese dip. I had the '"pesty chicken sandwich" which was a phenomenal sandwich. I loved that it was served with stracciatella cheese! The pesto which tasted fresh was a wonderful compliment to the chicken sandwich. My friend had the drunken chicken sandwich and while I didn't try it myself, she was a big fan of the vodka and pesto combination with the chicken cutlet. Both of these are my ideal sandwiches and I will definitely order them for my next visit. We also tried the full rack of bbq ribs. I was hesitant ordering this at a sandwich shop but wound up being so astonished that they could make a phenomenal bbq rib. The sauce was zesty and smoky and the meat was falling off the bone. Totally droolworthy! We ended the night with chocolate lava cakes which were super tempting and beyond irresistible. The melty chocolate was heavenly and absolutely rich. We also tried the hazelnut gelato which was simply perfection. It was smooth and silky and creamy and a wonderful ending to a great meal. The staff was excellent and super attentive and prompt. We enjoyed our meal in a clean space. I would highly recommend DiSantillo's for a fantastic quick bite or an indulgent meal, and I will most definitely be back. read more

See all

I have been a customer since they opened, I love all their sandwiches, but I'm leaving this review based on their new brunch menu. It's is phenomenal, and the best part is they have their own delivery. I highly recommend their avocado toast. The restaurant is always clean, and and inviting. I highly recommend it read more

Meatballs were a little small and dense, but delicious. The mozz sticks were good, but I hated the sauce they came with. It helped a lot dipping them in the sauce with the meatballs and ricotta. Main event I went with the OG sandwich on a torpedo roll. The bread could have been a little crustier, but it was still pretty good. The spicy relish took over the flavors. My biggest complaint is that they add a lot of extras to all their sandwiches. It's either long hots, or chili spread, or something other than just tasty meat. I'll order again, but I'll have to do some customizing to get exactly what I want. read more

The bread is always delicious. However...i had an eggplant parm sandwich tonight that was the worst I've ever had. Tough to bite through, stringy and tasted like raw eggplant. Never again. read more

The chicken parm sub and the pesto chicken sub both had chicken that was so dry and chewy. It was like the chicken got cooked and microwaved several times before making its way into the sandwiches. We wound up not being able to eat it past a few bites which was very unfortunate. read more

Sandwich was ok. Had The Antonio. Chicken cutlet was hard and dry. Definitely not cooked fresh. No flavor and the entire sandwich was too dry. Needed some kind of balsamic or dressing. Probably won't go back. read more

I ordered on grubhub and the wrong order was delivered. The gentleman at di santillos offered to have a driver deliver the correct order, which is excellent customer service. The sandwiches are incredible. Great business! read more

Looks too good to eat... but I did it anyway. Love it here Everything is so fresh and delicious. Portions are huge. read more

Di Santillo’s - The O.G. On toasted semolina bread...have to say without a doubt there is no better hero's in this area. Made fresh to perfection. - Sandwiches Near Me - Marlboro, New Jersey

See all

3.5 I would have given 4 stars, but they use too much mustard on the sandwiches. I got the Cuban which comes with mustard, but they put too much on. It overwhelmed the sandwich. My wife ordered tuna with "a little mustard, please." Again, it overwhelmed the sandwich. The bread was good and so were the sandwiches, where we could find spots without too much mustard. I will try this place again, but stay away from the mustard. read more

We have been ordering from Disantillos almost weekly, and still really enjoy their salads. However, their sandwiches have gone downhill. It is very disappointing considering they just opened. We ordered the Pro today and the Semolina bread was stale. As well, there was barely any fresh mozzarella or meat in the sandwich. It is very convenient to our location, so we are hoping they improve their quality. read more

Second time we ordered lunch from theis new Artisan sandwich shop. The Summertime is bursting with fresh flavors and the prosciutto was delicious we've tried it on both the brick oven and schiacciata bread. We also ordered the Calabrian Stallion with grilled chicken. Amazing! read more

First timer here. Meh To be fair, only had a sandwich. Ordering process isn't great, you walk past the counter to a pair of check outs. Took my order, asked if I want my bread toasted. For a hero? I asked is the bread fresh? She said yeah. For $18, there are way better options around. And sandwiches. Not looking for a Wawa or subway value. I am willing to pay for quality. While the meats and cheeses might be, it was such a soggy clump inside my chewy bread that I couldn't tell what I was eating. Other establishments let you watch and mingle with the person making your sandwich. This was weird, the order taker got the order to the counter guys and then my order came out of the back room. Take my advice, go to Pastosa on Union Hill, Talercios in Middletown, or good ole Sorrento's in Freehold. Places like theirs get it. read more

Bread on the sandwiches was a little overwhelming and hard to chew. My jaw hurt a little bit after eating my whole sandwich. Felt like the ratio to sandwich toppings to bread was really skewed. The fries weren't too great... but it is an Italian restaurant so can't really knock that. Wasn't really a fan of the markup on a bottle of soda.. $3 is a little steep. The establishment itself was really nice, and this town can definitely do with a business like this. I will likely be back to give it another shot when the place isn't as new to tweak my rating. read more

Cannot recommend DiSantillo's enough! Truly authentic Italian deli. The food is consistently fresh and delicious. Ordered the focaccia sandwich platter for a family gathering this weekend and everyone raved about them. Will definitely be catering from them again. read more

Best Chicken Caesar Wrap ever. 10/10! Will be back! Huge portion and great fries. Service was exceptional.

Food is awesome! costumer service is excellent as well. My favorite sandwich is the antonio. It was excellent!!

Could not recommend this place enough! Been coming here since it first opened and they never disappoint. Food is consistently great and service is always friendly. Most recently I tried their Tillo's Toast for brunch and my god it was sooo good. Definitely worth a visit. read more

Wanted to like this place. Bread not fresh. And they put about 2 slices of meat on it. Comparing to places in Hoboken not even close. Sorry. JM read more

The sandwiches we bought tonight were spectacular. We ordered The Pesty Chicken and The Club. The bread was fresh and delicious. The grilled chicken was incredibly moist and plentiful. The sandwiches were so well made. We cannot say enough good things about this sandwich shop. We will definitely be returning very soon. read more

Stay away. $20 sandwiches for bread that isnt fresh (they could not tell me where it was from or how old it was) and they are very light on meats and toppings. The people raving about this place feel fake because there are 5 other premium sandwich shops in the area at half the price. read more

Amazing sandwich. I had the OG and it was quality meats and very flavorful. The place is clean and friendly service. Come try this place, you won't be disappointed. read more

The sandwiches were incredible and reasonably priced for the amount of meat you get. The deli meats and sandwiches mimicked the tastes of Tuscany sandwiches I've had in the past. Would highly recommend to anyone looking for a good quick bite to eat. read more

Went today was very happy food came out fast and fresh ! Tons of staff . Service was very accommodating. We had the cheesesteak was very good , and toast w pears also fresh and yummy . I think the bread was great on both things we had . Wish this place all the best and I will be coming back read more

Huge sandwhich. Super good. Super fresh. I rate 10/10. Absolutely love. Cannot finish so I have leftovers which I absolutely love because I hate meal planning. Service was amazing. I'm a pretty picky eater and I was able to find something that I like and it's not even basic, I got the summertime sandwich and all the ingredients go together so well, it was so good. The rice bowl was creamy and delicious. Definitely recommend trying this place. They were super nice I got really good vibes from this place. This sandwich feels like I'm back in Italy! read more