We have been going to DiBarris for years. We really order just one pizza. The vodka nona pizza with sausage. That pizza is phenomenal. It is just amazing. It is a sesame seed crust with vodka sauce, fresh mozz and big sausage crumbles. It also reheats amazing. The only real issue is that is a 15 minute drive each way from my house. read more

Di Bari's - Matawan, NJ I walked into Di Bari's for one thing: the bar pie. What I didn't expect was a full lineup of elevated, abundant, and reasonably priced dinner specials that turned my quick stop into a full-on feast. This place is absolutely not just a pizzeria. I started with the stuffed zucchini appetizer--so fresh and flavorful--and the pork osso buco, which was tender, comforting, and honestly restaurant-quality. From there I tasted the Tuscan haddock, the chicken balsamico, and the pappardelle... every single dish was delicious. Portions are generous too, so come hungry. I left stuffed in the best way. The bar pie? Amazing. Thin, crispy, full of flavor--exactly the kind of pie that deserves attention. Dave Portnoy, you need to get down to Matawan for this one. There is also an area for private gatherings. Another fun surprise: they carry L&B Spumoni by the quart and Nasto's gelato, which is such a treat to see on the menu. If you're in the area, definitely come for the bar pie--but stay for dinner. You'll love it just as much as I did. read more

See all

Dibari's has a nice old school rustic pizzeria charm to it. However, the ambiance doesn't necessarily live up to the quality of food. I expected more as the pizza was good not great. Their plain slice is a decent slice that I would be happy eating if I lived in a small town. Decent doesn't cut it in these parts of the woods. The grandma slices were okay but I preferred the plain. The chicken padrino hero was good. Who doesn't like a chicken cutlet sandwich on soft bread? Dibari's is a decent spot and if you are in or near the shopping center you will be treated to a decent meal. read more

DiBaris Main Street Pizza - Plain, grandma and vodka - Pizza Near Me - Matawan, New Jersey

See all

My family and I always are ordering from here and coming back for more! Their food is delicious, to me I love their pizza especially the crust. Their service is phenomenal always reaching for more. The ambiance is amazing too with some seatings to choose from. I would greatly suggest to come here!! read more

Has signed up for online ordering which comes with regular coupons or discount offers via email / text messages. I received a text and email today with coupon code for 10% off. Clicked on link but had trouble getting website to load (error message merit requesting I try again l). Finally got it to load after 10 minutes or so and entered my order. Entered the coupon code but received message indicating coupon was already used. Called DiBari's and young lady who answered told me it is probably an expired coupon. I advised her it was received via text today. She told me She told me I could not order and get the 10% discount by phone and to try again via online ordering. She also indicated she really doesn't know anything about how the online ordering works but that I should try again. I advised told that I have steady direct about 30min trying to place an order on line that normally would have taken less than 1 minute over the phone. I asked if she could take my order over the phone and I would give her the 10% code # but she advised that she couldn't she'd that I needed to try online again. Advised her I would not be doing that and call ended. Had only just started going back to this pizzeria restaurant as my wife liked the pasta with bolognese as previously had past similar issues with their discount program as well as service issues when dining in. Definitely will not go back. read more

Did delivery for a personal pepperoni pizza and a 6 piece order of buffalo wings ... The pizza 10/10, even had some leftovers the next day and that was delicious. Whereas the buffalo wings, those were pretty standard nothing special about them unfortunately. I'd totally recommend the pizza and would order again. read more

My favorite pizza. I love this place. Their vodka grandma pie is my favorite pizza. They have amazing salads and their rice balls/spinach balls are good too. All their food is good. So happy they stayed just as good if not even better as Tratoria Rustica! read more

Just got a meatball parm. It took an extremely long time the meatballs were bland and the gentleman making pies looked like he was in the worst mood. No one working there was happy be there. This will be my last time there. read more

I came across this pizza place while searching for places to try online. The images I saw looked so good, that I had to try it. And I only live a few minutes away. My first visit, I tried a bunch of different slices. They were all so good. Amazing actually. I went with a classic plain, a Buffalo Chicken Slice, and grandma slices. Everything was delicious. I especially enjoyed that Buffalo Slice. The sauce and chicken just worked so well together. On my second visit, I orderd a full pie of vodka grandma with sausage; as well as a chicken parm hero. The vodka grandma is now my new favorite here. I loved everything about that pie. Plus with the added sausage on it, it was so delicious. So flavorful and crispy crust. The chicken parm was to die for too. I love chicken parm, and they make a top notch one. This place is excellent. A must try for all. read more

See all

Pizza was good, not spectacular but not bad. My friend said the same about her slice. Tables available inside. read more

DiBaris Main Street Pizza - Mushroom slice - Pizza Near Me - Matawan, New Jersey

My husband and I stopped in for dinner and the food was as so fresh and delicious! Our waitress was very cheerful and accommodating! It has become our favorite place. One of the best restaurants around! read more

I'm giving this review two stars because we've visited DiBari's many times and always enjoyed the food. This is why I'm having a really hard time with my most recent meal. We ordered takeout last Friday night. A pie (always decent) and a meatball sub. The sub was without a doubt one of the most HORRIFIC things I have ever eaten. The bread was dry, but the meatballs were nothing but breadcrumbs. It was like eating sawdust! Absolutely ZERO taste. Just dry, tasteless garbage. Dear DiBari's, try adding some actual meat to the balls next time ...not that we'll be ordering again any time soon. We used to love this place but What a disappointment! read more

Great pizza and sandwiches. They also have the most amazing grilled chicken, the chicken Caesar wrap is the best. Don't order delivery, it takes forever! read more

Pizza, pasta and veal parm sandwich is very good. Best Italian in Matawan, without a doubt.

A solid tasty slice. Good crust and undercarriage. Large slice at good price. I enjoyed. Worth a stop. For thise who care for a tasty beverage, they sell Coca Cola and other housebrand sodas. Too many pizza places in the area force Pepsi on Cola patrons. read more

DiBaris Main Street Pizza - A regular slice - Pizza Near Me - Matawan, New Jersey

Unfortunately extremely overpriced. $31 for a medium pie with minimal toppings. Outrageous.

This place was trash!!! Ordered a Sicilian rice ball that was deceiving. When I cut into it , the inside was filled with meat and peas. Once I started to eat it, I was caught off guard with hard peas and flavorless ground beef and my side of sauce was cold. I also had a grandma slice which was to be honest mediocre at best. I'm not sure if the gentleman behind the counter was the owner or just the manager, either way he has no people skills whatsoever. The poor kids that work there need to get the hell away from a person like that. The miserable look on his face says it all.. read more

This is a great spot for pizza or sandwiches. Their hot rolls are fantastic also! They have probably the best Chicken Caesar wrap in the area. I get it every time I'm in the area. Quick, friendly service as well. It's a very comfortable place - good for dine in or take out. Always have a good experience here. read more

DiBaris Main Street Pizza - Chicken Caesar Wrap - Pizza Near Me - Matawan, New Jersey

Came with a party of 7. The tomato sauce on my friend's side of spaghetti was sour, I had a broccoli rabe and sausage pasta dish and it was so overpowering I could barely finish it. The vodka sauce wasn't bad but not great. I wouldn't return. read more

A great spot for pizza, sandwiches or Italian entrees. Plentiful indoor seating; outdoor seating available in season. Friendly counter and table service. Comfortable atmosphere for chatting with a friend over a meal. A large but busy parking lot. read more

Overall, it was an average experience. The pizza was okay--not terrible, but not great either. We tried a few slices and some garlic knots. The food was decent but didn't stand out. However, the staff was friendly and welcoming, which was a plus. I'd rate it a solid three out of five. If you're in the area and looking for a quick bite, it's worth a try. read more

Very consistently good food. Very predictable every time. I only do lunch there. The staff is very courteous and helpful. The unsmiling owner may turn you off but that's just personality. read more

Just stopped in for a quick bite. Holy smokes delish. The slices are large, and full of flavor. You know sometimes pizza places the crust is too thin, not enough sauce or cheese. Not this place. It was a hearty slice with enough sauce and cheese. My oldest loved his penne vodka slice (he only could eat half). I had either grandma or margarita, not sure but it didn't matter I inhaled it. The little one are his plain slice (also only could eat half), he even tried a bite of my square gma/marg slice and gave the thumbs up seal of approval. --he's 4 so you know it was good. I also had a chicken bacon ranch that I split with the hubby. I think the ranch dressing was cooked with the pizza, it wasn't drizzled on top like many other places. Also the chicken, pretty sure it was breaded chicken slices . Hubby had a cheesesteak, was able to take a pic of half. Go you won't be disappointed. read more

DiBaris Main Street Pizza - Cheesesteak - Pizza Near Me - Matawan, New Jersey

DiBari's is the best pizza around I usually go for the vodka grandma, the sesame seed crust is amazing, crispy but bubbly on the bottom. Classic NJ pizza read more

DiBaris Main Street Pizza - White spinach, White broccoli, Grandma, Sicilian Cheese Pizza, plain slices - Pizza Near Me - Matawan, New Jersey

Great environment! Clean establishment with phenomenal service & fresh food made to order! You won't be disappointed here!

I must share a great dining experience that I had at DiBari's in Matawan. I planned a date night to visit this restaurant on Friday Oct 27th. Aside from the food being delicious, which it was, the cleanliness of the restaurant, which was obvious, our MAIN take away from the evening was our server, MORGAN!! We had a magnificent experience with this young lady! A GREAT representative of your restaurant who was very personable treating us like the main reason she was working that night! As we ate our dinner, we noticed that at every table that she worked, there was that same energy! I can't say enough, and we will be returning to DiBari's very soon, and count on it being a Friday, so we could meet up again with this wonderful young woman! Emmett read more

They used to be good. Never again. Look at all the oil. Crust soggy and didn't hold cheese. read more

DiBaris Main Street Pizza - Soggy. Wayyyy too much oil. Cheese fell right off - Pizza Near Me - Matawan, New Jersey

Fantastic is all I can say. The prices are those of a Pizzeria but the food is comparable to a Five Star Restaurant! Highly recommended!!!!!

This is hands down the best food and service I have had in a long time, It is worth the trip to go try this place 10/10 highly recommend!

Amazing crispness, great pizza snap and great food. I loved the staff to so helpful and kind. Amazing food !!!!

Service can be slow but food is great If they says 25-30... make it 40-45 read more

I had heard about DiBari's from the All About Matawan page, where it is always a friendly debate about the best pizza joint in town. We finally gave this place a chance one night when I had a craving for a sub. We ordered two different subs, mozzarella sticks and my fiancé wanted to try a calzone. The subs options were one size, the young lady on the phone said 10 Inches. The menu also stated they are made with boars head (yum!). The price was great value for the size. See pictures. The subs were delicious: perfect ratio of meat to cheese to veg. Also the mayo/ o&v were great as well. It had a lot of salt pepper and oregano which next time I'll ask to hold (preference). Fiancé loved the calzone- it was "personal size" but it was huge! Had to be about a foot long. Second time ordering we went with dinners. I had a craving for carbonara. It was delicious, with peas, sweet onions and pancetta. I wish the pancetta was diced (as it is classically) as it would be easier to eat, rather that trying to chase around sliced bacony looking things. Fiancé had chicken parm. He loved the chicken but said the capellini was over done and he didn't love the sauce. We also got garlic knots (6 for 1.95!) and they were very good. Crispy and a little greasy on the bottom (good greasy! Lol) and not dry on top. First time ordering i called and ordered and it was seamless. Second time I ordered online which was easy and concise. They also allow you to "track" your order, which is cool because once the driver leaves you can see they are on the way. I also saw that once you order you accrue points in their loyalty club of some sort which can lead to coupons- which hey! Awesome :) Great value for great food. May be a new contender for us in town :) read more

See all

Sicilian pizza is fantastic. The salads are good when you actually get what you ordered. The last few salads were missing key ingredients like crispy chicken, bacon, egg. We order online so it's not like our orders aren't in black & white. This was our favorite pizza place but with the lack of attention & quality control we think it's time to look elsewhere for our weekly orders. read more

So good. When my parents come to visit I know they're going to want this at least one night for dinner. The portions are quite large, you easily have lunch for tomorrow! My dad ordered the veal piccata, which he raves about. The veal was very tender and the sauce was delicious, and also comes with veggies or pasta and bread. I had a Mediterranean salad with chicken, that had loads of toppings and the small probably would have been fine (portion wise). My mom ordered Verde. And that was just the bomb. Pasta, sauce, prosciutto, chicken, it was all amazing. That all being said, their pizza is eh, not bad but definitely not the best near me. I wouldn't go there just for pizza. Stick with their entrees, hero's, and salads! read more

I've ordered from here 3 times over the past 2 months, every single time they have messed up my order in some way. Insane how people can't get simple tasks right. 3 strikes you're out. read more

Was looking for a pizza place in the area, saw the sign and pulled into a very busy in a mini mall . Been wanting rigatoni bolognese & DiBari didn't disappoint. If you are in the area Rt 34 Matawan check this place out read more

Terrible. Have now ordered the Caprese wrap 3 times and every time it comes wrong. Every single time the wrap is missing something, when it only has 3 ingredients to begin with. Two times it has arrived just roasted red peppers and lettuce and tonight only Mozzarella and peppers. If a place isn't capable of preparing a wrap with minimal ingredients correctly, none of which are cooked then I'm not sure they have any business calling themselves a restaurant. Not to mention its a soggy mess. The amount of money I have wasted giving this place a chance is a real shame. I will be giving NO more chances and if you want a correct, edible order I advise you go elsewhere. In addition, the tiramisu they are offering as their own is deff from costco . read more

I have been on a diet for over 5 years. Pizza is the one thing out of all I've given up that I miss the most. Before tonight , I haven't had a slice of pizza in over a year. I heard about DiBari's so I thought it would be worth using my "once a year pizza card" here. It was so worth it. The pizza was amazing. Best I've had since leaving Brooklyn 35 years ago. Crust is tasty and delicate with just the right amount of crunch. The sauce is amazing. I was in heaven. The rest of the menu was just as amazing. I was here with 3 other people and they couldn't help but keep saying how delicious everything was after every bite. Let's just say it was so good that I may not wait another year for my next slice. read more

I love the shrimp scampi pizza but it's not on the online menu, which always creates an ordering problem. Their clam pies are also the best.

Called up Saturday night for a Vodka pie Grandma Style to pick up ! Got there about 9:15 was greeted by Owner Lorenzo. Found out he's the brother in law to a friend I played ball with and hung out in my days in Brooklyn. We chatted for awhile about things . When I got home to try the Vodka style Grandma pizza it was Out of this World ! The freshness of the vodka sauce and the "Muthz" to go with the crispness of the Crust ! I ordered it Welldone and to top it off the Sesame seed Crust Wow!!! The pie was Incredible. Growing up in Brooklyn you can tell when Fresh ingredients are used . The Vodka sauce was the star ! Anyway I can't wait to try the different variations of Di Bari Pizza and some of there dishes it's definitely worth my time to travel from Sayreville ! Thanks Lorenzo Will have to get Dave and Frankie there from Barstool Sports to do pizza review read more