What a pleasant surprise! Packed house on a Wednesday 2 minute wait for a table Pleasant service! Diner seating with tables and booths. Large counter for to go orders. Fantastic sour pickles Excellent Matzoh ball soup Terrific potato knish Lovely pastrami sandwich The best I have ever had, probably not but for the convenience and cost....fit the craving Ultra reasonable costs Plenty of food for 2 I will be back. read more

Pickled Herring - Full sour! - Delis Near Me - Englishtown, New Jersey

See all

Hubs and I have been wanting to give this place a try but we keep forgetting about it. We finally remembered as we were driving by and decided to stop here on our way to Costco. We were immediately seated after arriving and ordered the following: Bowl of Mushroom Barley Soup- this was delicious. Hubs missed it and haven't had it for a long time. It was nice and thick. Homemade sweet potato knish- . This was surprisingly good and sweet. It reminded him of knishes from NYC, except it was puffier and fluffier. Potato Pancake- this was ok. Hubs had latkes in mind and was surprised that this was literally a pancake. Hot Pastrami Sandwich- this was pretty soft and flavorful. We had a choice of salad and chose cucumber salad. It was nice, light and refreshing. I got a 7 layer cake slice to go and was very disappointed with this. I found out it's made with margarine and I guess I'm not a margarine fan. We saw a sign that had salmon tips for 7.99/lb. Service was friendly and quick. Will return next time for dinner! read more

We did a private party in the back room here for a birthday for about 25 people. The staff was amazing and the food was great. They really give you a lot for your money. We were very happy and would absolutely do another party here. read more

My wife and I last night were in the mood for deli, so decided to go to Pickled Herring. Arrived about 5:45pm, restaurant was not busy, we asked to sit at a table and they walk us to the back. Usually when you sit down a few mins late they bring over water and pickles- none. Looking at the menu a couple sits down next to us that staff seems to know well. Immediately they get water and pickles. We ask the waitress and she goes and fetches them, no sorry, nothing. Not really a big deal, but part of the overall story. We order, my wife and I both have soup- mushroom for her, matzoh ball for me. She orders a pastrami on rye, I ordered a brisket on rye and we share a potato pancake. Soup is fine, meal comes out. I am about 1/2 way through the first half of my sandwich when I discover a hair in it! I call the waitress, who says "ok, want me to ask them to remake it, or would you like something else?" I opted for a turkey on rye instead. A few mins later another woman brings over the sandwich and says "not sure how that got in there, all the guys in the back are bald" and walks away. I felt as if she was insinuating I somehow put a hair in my sandwich. Never "we sorry this happened", nothing. The bill comes and they charged me for the sandwich! really? Ok, at least comp a soup, or the 2 Dr. Browns sodas, something. Nope, Nothing and not a word from anyone again about the incident, no apologies, as if it never happened. I have read other reviews about the staff being rude. 100% true, one of the reasons why we don't go there as often as we would like. Staff is generally curt with customers, especially the ladies by the front register. It will be a long time before we go back. read more

I truly do not know how they can receive five stars on any point. The service behind the counter is horrible. The workers are nasty, especially the cashiers and the food is ok. I truly think the attitudes of the people there are the biggest problem. read more

This place was a throwback for me as I was a former deli counter worker. Busy place and fast service. Everybody pitched in to pull a larger order of takeout on their delicious looking food. Loved getting the new pickles. That's the mark of a pIace I want to eat at. read more

Pickled Herring - Hot Pastrami Sandwich - Delis Near Me - Englishtown, New Jersey

WOW! Excellence beyond expectations. When we entered, we noted it was bustling with customers. We had the chicken salad sandwich and hot corned beef sandwich. We also ordered the barley soup and a side order of kasha. The sandwiches were nicely packed. The soup was full of mushrooms and tasty. The kasha was like grandma would make. The gravy added a nice flavor. The service was attentive to needs. Sooo full and content!! If you are even 1hr away you OWE it to yourself to try here. Waddling out as we speak. read more

Located in a strip center, this quaint little restaurant welcomes you with a warm greeting from the ladies behind the counter as soon as you walk in. You can choose to dine in or, like us, opt for takeout. There were four of us ordering, and the four guys working the counter were incredibly efficient--everyone jumped in to help, so we had our order ready in no time. Once they prepare your food, it's placed in a basket and handed to the ladies at the register, where you're conveniently tempted by their homemade desserts right next to the counter--hard to resist a little impulse buy . We took home corned beef, egg salad, and salami sandwiches, along with a sweet potato knish, a sweet noodle kugel, rugelach, and a slice of 7-layer cake. The corned beef was tender and full of flavor, and the egg salad had nice-sized chunks of egg with just the right amount of mayo. It's also great that it's kosher-style, so you can still enjoy cheese on your sandwich! The knish was huge and packed with delicious sweet potato filling, and the kugel tasted just like my grandma's. The cake and cookies were the perfect sweet finish. So excited to have found a kosher-style deli that's even better than some in NYC! read more

See all

I've been to the Pickled Herring many times. The food is really just okay - I keep returning as it's only 5 minutes from where I live. My go to meal is a pastrami on rye and a side of fries. The fries are very good. The pastrami is a bit on the bland side. If you eat in the restaurant you get a side of coleslaw included. If the sandwich is to go you have to add it to the order (about $2 for a tiny side cup). The coleslaw dressing is quite thin (it's not creamy enough). Prices are good. Fred and Murray's is a much better choice, but at a higher cost (Fred and Murray's is also kosher). read more

Service . For a restaurant that has such a 5 star reputation for outstanding food the service and disturbing attitude of the staff behind the counter is appalling! I was never treated so poorly. They was the tall stocky guy with a salt and pepper grey beard who gets annoyed and gets very nasty at everything asked of him to get by a customer. Not a great way to keep your customers especially with the prices they charge thankfully the food speaks for itself. Outstanding and extremely delicious. I've remembered this business from when it was bagel nook . I go way back for many years . To come back after many years to be treated as I was I might just drive to Clark nj where I am treated with respect. read more

Amazing. An absolute hidden gem. The food, service, are top notch. Pastrami that can compete with the big boys ( harrolds, sarges, pastrami quenn). Theres soups, knish, turkey honestly the best i have had. They are really doing some EXCELLENT food at this place read more

It was my first time there, and I have no intention of going back. The way they speak to the younger employees is revolting. Everyone in there is a senior citizen. The man, who wears glasses, has white hair and a beard, is extremely disrespectful to one of the guys, who's probably in his 20s, behind the deli. I spoke with him and said that he really shouldn't be screaming like that in front of customers and his employees; he was also rude towards me. I will not be going back there. read more

Pickled Herring - Mac and Bri Roll. - Delis Near Me - Englishtown, New Jersey

Went there today very good everything great server Evan. Excellent will go back. Family owned place great place.

Food is excellent but should do a machine with number calling for deli takeout because 2 people cut in front of me because setup is not organized. Pastrami sandwich done right away but had to wait awhile for my onion rings. Counter where you pay the one woman a little rude had to ask for an extra mayo and gave me a hard time when I asked for plastic knife so I could spread on sandwich. In fact I had to say what do you expect me to use my finger. Also when they make your sandwich to go their back is to you so you can't see your sandwich. So for a pastrami on rye with onion rings came to $28.40. Also charged the 3 percent for using credit card. But must say was all delicious. Just a few kinks that I mentioned could improve the takeout deli counter and to pay for counter. read more

This has to be my favorite restaurant in the whole world. Love the food and choices. I would go there every day if I could.

Delicious sandwiches, very good service, ambiance is fair. Meats were perfect. Not a lot of privacy.

First time visit Friendly service Open every day Note: verify driving gps, map quest sent me too far south on Route 9 read more

Pickled Herring - Delis Near Me - Englishtown, New Jersey

See all

Wow don't have words. 2 huge containers of soup and they wouldn't double bag it. I said can I please have a bag and she said no no explanation nothing there was a ton of bags in plain sight. For the amount they charge they should give me a ton of bags. read more

I went back and picked up a few items for Mother's Day. This time the whitefish salad was much better! Still whipped too much with nothing in it, but it tasted good. Not like refrigerator like last time. The lox was great, but still the same problem with the slices. Nothing even, bits of scraps and overall not good. The slicer really needs to take some lessons on cutting lox properly! So a bit better, but still could use a little help. People in the place were very friendly. read more

Another great deli!!! Yummy hot pastrami! You won't be disappointed, and the price is right! Lived it. Good service. Ambiance ok. Try it. Glad I did. read more

Wow, a real deli with pastrami, corn, beef, and all the trappings food is excellent. Feel like I'm back in Brooklyn plus the services top-notch and they also have a selection of desserts that are outstanding. Give it a try I'm sure you'll be very pleased. read more

Recently revisited. Food just as good as before. service just as friendly and efficient as before. All together one of my favorite spots.

Unbelievable!! The Matzo ball soup was delicious, the matzo ball was light and fluffy and big. The potato knish and the pastrami were flavorful and lean. First time there but definitely not the last, so happy we found the Picked Herring read more

We are regulars at this establishment, and the food never dissapoints. They make excellent kreplach, and the kreplach soup reminds one of Grandma's :) Great burgers, great knishs's. The pastrami is good, but Ive been to Katz's many times, and I judge any pastrami I eat by the Katz's quality. So Ill say, it's good pastrami, but not Katz's. Good brisket. They also make a french dip sandwich that is excellent, roast beef and provolone, with Au Jus on the side. Very Good. Brisket Knish...AWESOME. If youre in the mood for good deli, highly recommended. They do get busy and or crowded, so depending on the time you might have to wait for a table. read more

See all

Can't imagine where 5 stars came from. Service was terrible/ our server forgot half the items and no refills on our drinks. Seemed more interested in socializing than working. Corned beef sandwiches were meh. Given the $$$ we expected more. He ordered what was supposed the "bigger" sandwich and I ordered the regular. Literally no difference except the higher price. This was a one and done for us. We will stick with Harold's in Edison, they are worth the trip and every $. read more

Classic looking deli with eat in or togo options. We ordered a classic turkey sub and a Rueben. Both are overstuffed with meat and delicious. The French fries were fried to perfection. Nice and crispy! Located in the Marlboro Plaza with plenty of parking and easy access from Route 9. read more

See all

i just had Lunch here.. the place looks like a standard Deli front with a great selection and has sit down table service. my server was very nice and friendly. i ordered a pastrami reuben which was delicious. it came with fries which i cant eat but snuck one....also delicious. overall a great dining experience read more

Pickled Herring - assorted pickles - Delis Near Me - Englishtown, New Jersey

See all

We live 2 1/2 hours away and still talk about stumbling on this place a few years ago. My daughter was in the area last weekend and we made her stop for knishes and stuffed cabbage. This place is the real deal when it comes to delis and knishes. read more

First time here, and I wish I came sooner. Great classic Jewish deli food. Matzoh ball soup was fantastic, and my hot pastrami was terrific, lean and tasty, not fatty or stringy. Will be back for a pot pie next time! Might have to grab some halvah on the way out... read more

Pickled Herring - Delis Near Me - Englishtown, New Jersey

I am a long time lover of all things at pickled herring. I went to a yearly family part where there was platter of Sloppy Joes... we have been eating their sloppy Joes on New Year's day for years... back to when they were Reitner's in Bayonne. This year the platter was awful. The meat and bread were so dry as to be inedible. I am hoping is not an indication of their going downhill, but an aberration. Whatever, it was a waste of a three hundred dollar order read more

Don't get the Rueben Sandwich! First, it was Open Faced, so not really a Sandwich, which on reinspection was not mentioned on the menu. The Waitress did offer to address this, but I wasn't sure that I was the one that missed that when I read the menu, and being it was already in front of me and being hungry, I figured I'd give it a try. My mistake. A sandwich, especially a Rueben with multiple ingredients needs and even requires balance. This did not. Not enough sauerkraut while putting on way too much dressing, overpowering the ample pastrami. On the positive side, the French Fries were great! Perfectly seasoned and cooked. My wife had the plain Pastrami and said it was very good. The store section had everything you could ever ask for in a Jewish Deli. I can only attest so far that the Rugelach is Top Notch, super flakey and tasty. We also really liked our waitress. Very good service. Next time I'll stick to a one ingredient sandwiches. After eating the Whitefish salad I'm giving it "A big thumbs down. " Too much of a purée without much of a whitefish taste. They blended in too much mayonnaise or whatever they used for filler. The Chopped Liver meh. Herring was ok l, although the sauce was a little weak. I guess my standards are pretty high, having eaten in and best Deli's in Northern Jersey and NYC. Oh well read more

This is the quintessential Jewish deli! My husband and I finally made it here and we really liked it. For a Wednesday evening, it was very busy, which is always a great sign! The dining area is nice and updated with a decent number of tables, all of which were occupied. Our waitress was so friendly and bubbly even though she was running around from table to table and she never seemed to break a sweat. A plate of 2 kinds of pickles and waters were served right away. We gobbled them up! We ordered 3 mini potato pancakes for a little "nosh" before our meals. They were nice and crispy (just how my husband likes them) and came with a side of apple sauce. They were really good! The only thing that would make it better is if it came with some sour cream too. I was having trouble deciding between a few options but settled on the turkey club sandwich. It came with a generous mound of fresh turkey, bacon, lettuce and tomato in between 3 layers of toasted white (you can pick white, wheat or rye) and a side of their coleslaw and some mayo. I love coleslaw and theirs is real good! My husband obviously ordered a Sloppy Joe. It was packed with the usual 3 meats: roast beef, turkey, and corned beef/pastrami. Right off the bat he noticed the pastrami was still warm and that was a game- changer for him. He's had many sloppy Joes in his time but the warm pastrami raised his eyebrows! The sandwiches are big and we only managed to finish half of ours, but we definitely asked for a box and brought the other halves home. Im definitely going to try something new next time. They have so many options so you should come with an appetite. If I'm ambitious enough I'm going to try their unique Knishwich.. and yes, it's exactly what you think it is! read more

Good, traditional Jewish food Deli. We love the pickles they put on the table. My husband and I split the pastrami sandwich and it was plenty for both of us for lunch. read more

Well, I came back, as promised, with some friends and it was a great experience! It was an opportunity to try many different things - and we did! In no particular order, we started with Pickled Herring in Cream Sauce, a slice of Derma, Potato Pancakes all around, a homemade Knish, 2 Matzo Ball Soups and the 2 Soup of the day. Remember, this was just a start! On to our meals: A Classic Reuben, 2 Turkey, Pastrami, Swiss with Coleslaw, A Hot Brisket Sandwich, a Fresh Roasted Frame Turkey Sandwich, a Create Your Own Triple and 2 Sloppy Joes. Many of us had Dr Brown sodas and no one wanted dessert. Go figure ... All in all a great meal with good friends and a lot of fun all around. read more

The food was excellent as it always is. We eat there or take out 2 or 3 times a month and buy a lot of food. Service is fair. The last time we were there, there were only a few people eating, but we had to hunt the waitress down a few times. The restaurant is starting to get very cheap with customers. They charge extra for every little thing. We had to pay extra for a single piece of bread. When we needed an extra bag for our leftovers, one of the cashiers gave us a dirty look and said we already had a bag. This was when we had just spent 60+ dollars on the meal. He never even said thank you or goodnight. The bottom line is that service tends to be rude. read more

their prices are ridiculous. I ordered 2 stuffed cabbages. not 6 stuffed cabbages, but 2 and i was charged $17.90. they were cold and in a container ready for me to heat up and that's how much they costed. no side dish either. when I got home i was hoping they tasted amazing at least. they were just ok. the sauce had weird beans and string beans in it and it was very sweat and sour tasting. I used to go there all the time for things here and there. but after spending all this money on 2 stuffed cabbages, I can't go there anymore. I'm done. I feel so ripped off and stupid for actually paying. read more

Pickled Herring - Delis Near Me - Englishtown, New Jersey

Take out often from them. Love all their fishes: herring, lox, smoked sable, sturgeon, smoked salmon and the list goes on and on. Place is always busy so you know they are good. Their salads are always tasty and I enjoy their homemade knishes. Sandwiches are good and plentiful. Not a fan of their soups as I make mine better. Service is consistent. read more

Every week after STRETCHLAB PILOT THE SERVICE DOG and I stop into our favorite deli: THE PICKLED HERRING is home-town friendly and the best corned beef and pastrami sandwiches rivaling Katz's NY. Absolutely the best service and friendliest staff anywhere. Delicious home style soups like my favorites mushroom or chicken and awesome mouth-watering coleslaw and pickles: half- sour for me please! The Puckle is a clean commodious place with a nice sized back section for a meeting or get together. Ample parking and shopping near at hand and of course you must wind up at the Pickled Herring for any meal or coffee and freshly made desserts! We love it! See you there! read more

BEST MATZO BALL SOUP EVA! I love this deli. It's always crowded but so worth the wait. The food is delicious, the people are friendly, and the pickles, my god the pickles. I love it so much they catered my Christmas dinner last month. My family couldn't say enough great things about the food and they took the holiday cooking stress away from me. read more

See all

Great Food. Best Deli in Town. Debbie, Robert, Janet, and Jesse and the entire Staff make everyone feel like family. Don't pass up the chance to eat their delicious food. Thank you all for a great place to eat and take out food. read more