We've stopped into Jersey Boy's many times over the years of visiting Whitefish, and I realized I've never done a review of the pizzeria. Dropped by on a Friday for a quick lunch... As always, Jersey Boy's was fire. The pizza is so good... This place honestly has some of the best pizza you will find (and not just in NW MT). The pizza is thin, crispy, tangy, and always cooked perfectly... It's no kidding as good as anything you'll find in Jersey or NYC. Plus, the food is really well priced (the lunch special is two slices, two drinks, runs $12 w/ tip). The pizzeria is clean, the staff is friendly/accommodating, and it's just a super chill place to come get high quality NYC-style pizza and cold MT craft beers. Be advised... The pizzeria recently moved (last year) so they're no longer in downtown Whitefish... They're now located on the outskirts of town on HWY 93 headed to Kalispell. It sucks they moved from downtown, but their new location is bigger and nicer. You will not be disappointed with Jersey Boy's. read more

See all

Food has always been good, online order service has been an issue a few times now. Follow up by phone if you order online. Especially if you have made plans around itl read more

We tried to go here on a Tuesday night at 6pm, but it was packed with no seating so we came back the next day for lunch. Like a lot of other places we've been to in Whitefish you grab a table and go up to order. The menu looked great...lots of interesting pizza and sandwich options along with some salads and sides. I had an antipasto salad and it was HUGE and so tasty. I loved the artichokes and all of the olives and the house dressing was also really good. My kids had a cheese pizza, so I had a slice of that too. It was really good, but I think I would have preferred one of the other options. My husband had a slice with sausage, mushrooms and onions and he said his was awesome and much better than the plain cheese. I definitely recommend this place! read more

Jersey Boys Pizzeria - Antipasto salad with house dressing - Pizza Near Me - Whitefish, Montana

The front restaurant staff were very helpful! Our food left a lot to be desired. $50+ for two sandwiches (quite bare and not very tasty) and a salad? Probably not again. read more

Best pizza in town quicker very friendly staff make sure that I had everything I needed ordered three pies not one disappointed Hawaiian was delicious read more

Food is excellent. Pizza is great not many pizza places in whitefish compare, by price value. Calzone was very satisfying, I'm used to a ricotta filled calzone, there's is good I didn't taste the various cheeses I'm used to. The extra toppings really are needed to fill the void. Canned beer and cider available. 14" pizza was gone quickly. Calzone was large I took half home. Service is awesome and helpful. Very busy and crowded. Nice deck to eat on. A few arcade games keep the kids busy. Lots of tables and big open space. $52.00 read more

See all

Highly recommend Jersey Boys if you're visiting Whitefish! The pizza is excellent, the staff is friendly, and the prices are very reasonable! Most of the beer and wine is served in cans, but there is a great selection. The restaurant is set up where you order your food at the counter, then pick a table at the indoor and outdoor seating. This is also a great option if you're looking to pick up dinner! read more

Jersey Boys Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Whitefish, Montana

Delicious pizza. Be sure to get a side of their hot honey for the right amount of sweetness on your slice. The service was great and pizza was great. We ordered the jersey buns as well and they were warm, soft, buttery and garlicky. The side of ricotta was a delicious dip for them. Their baked wings are also a favorite. They are some of the meatiest wings I've come across and would highly recommend. The wait time is a bit long but they are super transparent about it and definitely worth the wait! read more

Jersey Boys Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Whitefish, Montana

See all

Pizza was amazing and the people working there was also amazing helping us in every way I was born and. Raised in NJ so this was nice to come across the place was very nice and neat read more

I ordered the sausage pizza and buffalo wings- the pizza was good and the sauce was tasty, I just wish they would have put a little more on. The wings were good as well. Overall- id eat here again if in the area. read more

Very good pizza, with slices at reasonable prices. Flavor was NY, but the crust was too crackery. Decent rating for foldability. Also, no grease drippage, which is a staple of NY pizza. Taking off stars for the woman who asked no less than six times if we needed boxes or if there was anything she could clear away. This started right after we got our slices and continued throughout the meal. She did the same at other tables too. Poor guy near us had taken a bite from the first of two slices, and he's asked if he needs a box. He probably doesn't, but how should he know after one bite?!? Near the end of our meal, she apologized for being annoying and that she knew she asks a lot. Um, if you know you're annoying, stop being annoying. Four stars for food; two stars for the annoyance. read more

Jersey Boys Pizzeria - Cheese, pepperoni, sausage, and meatball - Pizza Near Me - Whitefish, Montana

See all

Best pizza ever and we have pizza a couple times a month all over the place. Yes this place can be super busy so you might be waiting but it's totally worth it. We got the antipasto salad, Jersey buns and our pizza was 1/2 BBQ 1/2 combo but added onion and artichokes. Everything was amazing and the people working there were very nice. The manager came up to make sure we were doing ok. Did not miss this gem read more

The absolute best pizza ever. I also love the staff, they are kind and helpful. A great family place for lunch. read more

Jersey Boys Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Whitefish, Montana

They moved to a larger location. Pizza here is delicious, i usually get a few slice and it always comes out perfect. I got the Philly, oriental, and cheese. It did not disappoint. read more

See all

First time here and it was amazing! I had the meatball sub, which I forgot to take a photo of, and it was the best meatball sub ever! Perfect size and the flavor was amazing! My husband also really loved his pizza. I'm a fan of baked wings vs fried, so I really like these but my husband did not care for them. It's located in a convenient location, and would be a fun hang out spot with friends. read more

Jersey Boys Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Whitefish, Montana

On our last night in whitefish we decided we didn't want to cook so we ordered from Jersey Boys. Ordering online was easy. When I went to pick up our order, this place was slammed, but our order was only a few minutes later than promised and the pizza was great. read more

What an amazing pizza place!!! The owner was a delight. It was so busy for a Tuesday which made me think the food would be great. And boy was I right! Amazing pizza. Delicious salad. And the Hazy was a perfect topper to everything! Highly highly recommend!! read more

Some really good pie at this place. The employees are great and really care about your experience. If you want good pizza in WF this is your spot. Luau and combo are straight money read more

They must be doing something right! This place is crowded on Monday night . Also, they go have beer and wine.

We were able to order Pizza by the slice which was perfect because we each got exactly what we want and it was delicious! We also got a meatball sandwich and it was good too. Great service, super friendly. The inside was clean and quaint. Highly recommend. read more

Excellent pizza and wings. You have to order at the bar. But the pizza came out in a timely manner. We are big on pizza in our family and do not mess around. We had jersey buns, pepperoni pizza thin crust, Philly cheesesteak pizza and gluten free pizza. Asian BBQ wings and garlic Parmesan dry rub. Fantastic! 8.5! read more

See all

Awesome pizza, our favorite pizza in the valley the Garbage Can is awesome. The garlic knots are great as well.

Great pizza, service, the manager sat and spoke to us for sometime. His concern is to constantly improve the pizza and service

Barely even got into the pizza and had to leave a review - the staff here was incredible. So friendly, personable, and accommodating. Food is also great which just felt like a cherry on top. It was a busy Friday night and still in high spirits and the nicest people. read more

Went there after a long day of bike riding, as we wanted some good pizza - something easy, and one of the guides/locals had recommended. We weren't disappointed. They had a good variety of pizza, pasta, sandwiches you could order. All 4 of us had different pizzas and all were very good. The crust was very good. I wish there was one in our hometown! We will definitely go back if in the area. read more

It's a really cute kinda hidden pizza place. Although my group and I did sit inside there was some outdoor seating as well as a bean bag toss game. The pizza you can get by the slice, it they are big slices, and super delicious. About three arcade games inside plus some other table games you can play. Service was nice. The food was delivered to us and then we were checked on twice by a waitress. read more

We have had the Garbage can several times. It always absolutely superb! Even when they are super busy the follow-up to make sure everything is fine. read more

Very casual spot but great pizza. We got the garlic buns and man I am dreaming of being able to have them again. You could tell it was a local spot. Nothing fancy but next time we visit I will def go back! read more

I love their new location! And the move didn't compromise the quality on bit! Great crust, sauce and toppings! One of my favorites in the Valley! read more

If you're craving pizza and you're around this area, this is a must try! My group of friends and I were visiting Montana for Glacier National Park. We were looking for places to eat, and saw this place had good reviews. Let me tell you that the pizza here is so good, that we had it 2 days in a row. We had to come back for a second time. The first time we tried this place, we dined in. They offer both indoor and outdoor seating areas. We ate outside because the weather was just so nice. Each table already had parmesan and chili pepper flakes to sprinkle on your pizza. Waters are self-served. They have a wide variety of tables outside, from large bench ones for larger groups like ours or smaller ones for smaller groups. The tables inside are smaller. When we ordered takeout for the second time, the pizzas were still very fresh when we got home to eat it. We got a classic pepperoni one and a white sauce with garlic and spinach pizza. Both pizzas were so delicious and fresh. I loved how crispy the crust was. I also like that you can order pizza by the slice too. The service here was also great. The people who took our orders were friendly. This is a very casual restaurant too. read more

Been here twice during our visit and really enjoyed what I had! Meatball pizza, pepperoni pizza, and the meatball sub were all good. Our second visit they accidentally lost our food ticket so they explained it and offered us free beer. That's how you do customer service! Totally made the wait better with free beer :) read more

Jersey Boys Pizzeria - Meatball sub - Pizza Near Me - Whitefish, Montana

It was a busy busy evening, but all the servers were super friendly and we got our food much faster than expected. The huckleberry beer was a nice surprise, and the pizza was excellent. It's not a huge place, so when it's busy it is loud. They also have outdoor seating. Definitely a great place for pizza read more

I was raised on Chicago-style deep dish pizza so thin crust is outside of my wheelhouse. I can and do enjoy super thin pizza however. Jersey Boys was pretty busy when we came in and upfront they told us it would be 45 minutes for a pizza. They said it would be much faster if we ordered slices so we told them we wanted 4 slices of the sausage+pepperoni+onion+ pepper. It was about 10-15 minutes for our pizza (acceptable) and the slices were ENORMOUS. Two slices covered up just about the whole pizza pan they served it on. We could only each eat 1 slice. The crust was thin and very crispy. I found it somewhat spicy and we didn't order bacon but I think that was bacon on there too. The pizza was not what I'm used to, but tasty and crispy and maybe a little salty. read more

See all

For my dollar, I don't know of a better grinder in the Flathead Valley than the Spicy Italian. Thanks guys.

We ate here twice after getting back Late (right before closing time) from GNP and the staff were still very polite and friendly. We shared a small salad and each got a slice of pizza, we were not disappointed. This was our first time at new location and we would definitely recommend it. read more

In town visiting family and pizza was the choice of the group. RM implemented the "he'll buy, if I fly" strategy. Not the best pizza I have ever had, but pretty darn good. Our ordered included the J-Buns and Fried Ravioli with a combo pizza. 1. J-Buns were amazing and a great twist on garlic bread. 2. Fried Ravioli was simple and enjoyed it. 3. Combo Pizza was very good and had a nice amount of toppings. I would recommend giving this place a try when in town. Thanks J-Boys read more

Honestly was expecting a bit better pizza given how long of a wait it took to get it. They were VERY busy on a Thursday night, and we waited over an hour for our pizza and side salad. After we ordered, the woman working at the register was very transparent with how long of a wait we had, but I wish she would have told us BEFORE we ordered so we could have made a decision to go somewhere else. The veggie pizza was good, but not an hour and 15 minutes wait good. While we were eating outside, a man was walking around greeting tables & checking in (I'm assuming the manager) and he was very friendly and personable. I'd recommend ordering here far in advance of when you want to eat and placing your order to go! read more

Jersey Boys Pizzeria - Veggie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Whitefish, Montana

Great flavor and service The best in glacier / flathead Montana I would say And their chicken wings are bomb We didn't find anything better read more

Someone recommended this place for us while vacationing in Whitefish. I am so glad we gave this place a try, the pizzas here were incredible good, service was pretty fast as well. I highly recommend this place. read more

See all

Delicious. Crust is light and thin with chewy edge! Love the larger place. Great staff!