We've been here several times over the years, and our review is consistently 5-star. Started with a Broken Rake and a pineapple hard seltzer, and enjoyed the complimentary fresh bread and special Greek spread, solid! We both got the veal short ribs Stifado, so good! Big chunks of tender veal in the most aromatic sauce. Sweet onions carrots and fresh arancini balls finish this dish. Service excellent from Gabi, very knowledgeable on the menu items. AAA+++ thank you! read more

Another great meal at our favorite restaurant, Ithaki in Peabody. We went for the Tuesday Dollar Oysters and stayed for two main courses we had never tried: Whole Boneless Branzino and Mushroom Pappardelle. Both dishes were extraordinary. The fish was beautifully cooked and seasoned, accompanied by dandelion greens and mashed potatoes. The Pappardelle was served with a variety of mushrooms in a creamy sauce (which I drank with zest). We shared a bottle of La Crema Chardonnay. For dessert, we enjoyed the Galactobouriko and the Limoncello Cake, both among our favorites. We were well served by Kris, who gave us attentive and leisurely service. Once again, we left totally satisfied and can't wait for the next adventure. read more

Ithaki is one of my favorite restaurants on the north shore. It's right off route 1 and the restaurant is a lot bigger than what you'd expect. It's beautifully decorated on the inside. We're always welcomed with such a friendly staff when we come here. The food has always been great. Their bread and garlic sauce is delicious. My favorite dish is the clam pasta. All their plates are perfect portions. read more

See all

Great breakfast every time. So many great options and the staff is always friendly. Soft music plays in the background. read more

Ithaki Mediterranean Restaurant - Garden omelette with spinach - Mediterranean Near Me - Peabody, Massachusetts

Interesting spot! We're from out of town and have enjoyed a handful of restaurants in Saugus. We tend to stop here when flying in and out of Boston. We tried Ithaki without doing much research, and to our surprise it ended up being a bit fancier than we expected (the other places we've tried nearby are definitely more casual). The staff was warm, accommodating, and kind. They didn't have any availability (which actually surprised us) but offered seats at the bar for dinner. The bar ended up being a great experience, and we didn't feel out of place at all. The food itself was really good. My husband ordered the moussaka, one of his favorite Greek dishes, and he kept saying it was the best he's had in New England. My chicken dish was tasty and absolutely massive; I took half home. It came with these delicious carrots, though the sauce was a bit on the greasier side. We also split a halloumi salad that was good, but not the best salad I've ever had by any means. We'd definitely return, especially now that we know it's a solid date-night spot. The food was great and fairly priced, the staff was nice, and overall we really enjoyed our meal. read more

See all

My wife and I were driving back from the Cape and passed a bunch of breakfast places on the way as we couldn't make our minds up. Long story short we stopped at Ithaki in Peabody. We were greeted very kindly and sat right away. It was not super busy and a very eclectic crowd. The server came right away and we placed our order. Nothing fancy eggs, omelet and pancakes. The food had an interesting taste must have been the oil, butter or whatever everything was cooked in. The pancakes were rubbery and again odd taste. Overall, food was a 3, service was a 4 and the ambiance was a 3. Too many great breakfast places on the cape and in between so will probably not go back. Also it was fairly expensive for breakfast for two around $70. read more

I was pleasantly surprised.. this location has been a few different restaurants and this one is a winner!! It used to be located in Ipswich and has moved to a new location but the food and service was just as amazing as before. We went with a party of 8, everyone was happy with their meals. I would highly recommend to anyone looking for a delicious Greek meal. read more

Outstanding Experience at Ithaki in Peabody! Quickly became a favorite. From the moment you walk in, you're greeted with warm, attentive service and an inviting, elegant atmosphere. The Mediterranean-inspired menu is packed with fresh, vibrant flavors--everything is beautifully prepared and thoughtfully presented with upmost finesse. Ithaki delivered an amazing dining experience for our long overdue date night. Baked Feta An absolute must try dish. Served warm, the feta is perfectly creamy on the inside with a golden, slightly crisp top wrapped in phyllo, sprinkled with pistachio crumbs & drizzled with honey. The contrast of the warm cheese with the honey & the tangy pomegranate is perfection. Falafel a la Petros Crispy on the outside, soft and perfectly spiced on the inside--every bite is packed with fresh herbs and bold Mediterranean flavor. It's served beautifully with a delicious house made hummus and pita. Moroccan Crusted Tuna Cooked perfectly with a wonderful sear on the tuna. Packed with an abundance of Mediterranean flavor served with Harissa hummus puree, lentils with spinach & finocio. Youvetsi Braised lamb that just melts-in-your-mouth tender, perfectly seasoned, and served over orzo in a tomato-wine sauce that's both comforting and deeply flavorful. read more

See all

One of the best places to eat breakfast since we've been here for three days the food portions were big and delicious and the service was friendly and warm and the ambience was beautiful. Recommended 100% go anytime.. read more

Ithaki Mediterranean Restaurant - Breakfast: 2 steak, scrambled sausage and toast, and another dish of French toast - Mediterranean Near Me - Peabody, Massachusetts

LOVE Ithaki. Food is always excellent. I've been there multiple times and the quality and taste of the food is always is authentic and above average. read more

See all

This was our first time here and I had picked it for date night based on reviews and my fiancee's want for Greek recently. You can't go wrong! The food was absolutely amazing and great service. The atmosphere is wonderful! We definitely will be returning! read more

Ithaki Mediterranean Restaurant - Lamb skewers - Mediterranean Near Me - Peabody, Massachusetts

Celebrating New Year's Eve at Ithaki Mediterranean Restaurant was nothing short of a five-star dining experience. We had an 8:00 PM reservation, and despite the restaurant being lively with couples and families ringing in the new year, the atmosphere struck the perfect balance--festive and energetic, yet still comfortable enough to hold a conversation. From start to finish, the service was truly top tier. Even on such a busy holiday night, the pacing never felt rushed. Drinks, appetizers, entrées, and dessert flowed seamlessly, allowing us to relax and enjoy each course at just the right rhythm. The staff was professional, warm, and genuinely welcoming, making it clear that choosing to dine with them was appreciated. A special touch that stood out was the hostess making rounds throughout the dining room, personally checking in with guests to ensure everything tasted great and that no one needed a thing--an attention to detail that elevated the entire experience. We started with the Octopus Carpaccio (GF), served with jalapeño and sweet peppers, pickled onion pearls, lemon zest, olive oil, and fried capers. The octopus was cooked perfectly--tender, delicate, and never rubbery. It was lightly seasoned, allowing the natural flavors and freshness of the seafood to shine, while the bright acidity and subtle heat enhanced every bite without overpowering it. The presentation was elegant and restrained--just enough to showcase the dish before diving in. For entrées, we enjoyed the Rack of Lamb (GF) accompanied by potatoes, eggplant, and zucchini ratatouille-style. The lamb was cooked flawlessly--juicy, tender, and incredibly flavorful without being over-seasoned. Ithaki clearly trusts the quality of their ingredients, letting the natural juices and richness of the meat speak for themselves. Each bite was balanced and comforting, with vegetables that complemented rather than competed with the star of the plate. The Wagyu was equally impressive, served with whipped potatoes, asparagus, wild mushrooms, and a silky demi-glace. The meat was cooked to perfection--rich, buttery, and melt-in-your-mouth tender. Again, restraint was key here: no heavy seasoning, just thoughtful execution that allowed the natural depth of the Wagyu to truly light up the taste buds. The presentation was refined but not overdone, highlighting the food itself rather than distracting from it. What truly sets Ithaki apart is the value behind the menu. For the price point, you are getting exceptionally high-quality, fresh ingredients prepared by someone who clearly understands and respects Greek cuisine. Every dish reflects experience, intention, and authenticity--food cooked by a kitchen that knows exactly what it's doing. Overall, Ithaki delivered an exceptional New Year's Eve dining experience--from the atmosphere and service to the impeccable execution of every dish. We loved celebrating such a special night here and absolutely can't wait to return for another memorable occasion. read more

See all

Love this place! Great food, drinks and company! If I could eat here everyday- I would read more

See all

Great food and service! The inside is clean and inviting. It's a hidden gem next to The Holiday Inn.

Dinner tonight was the best I've had in a long time. The complimentary bread and house spread were great. The calamari was some of the best I've had, and the Avgolemono soup was perfect comfort food. The Broken Rake cocktail was fantastic as well, and the pistachio baklava for dessert was also excellent. Service was very fast and authentically friendly. We'll definitely be back soon. read more

A lovely, busy Greek restaurant. I started my meal with a nice expresso martini; my friend enjoyed the Persephone. I needed a light meal, so I chose the egg lemon soup and mussels. The waiter was right, there was enough for two. My friend had the cod. My only disappointments were the afterdinner masticha drink - a very light and aromatic drink. I think I did not care for their brand. Also the galatoboreko was over saturated with overly sweet syrup and needed more custard. Otherwise, a wonderful meal. read more

See all

I met some friends here so we could try something different. The colors inside were gorgeous. Even the water glasses were a bright blue that were stunning. Something small like a glass can easily be overlooked, or it can add a layer of color. For starters we tried the octopus and cauliflower to start and the bartender made us spicy margaritas, which weren't on the menu but created as a take on one of their mocktails. For dinner I had the short rib pappardelle which was very good. There was a large piece of the short ribs on a bed of pappardelle pasta. The table also ordered the lamb shank, branzino and the salmon. Everyone enjoyed their dishes, and portions were large enough to take some home. read more

The food and service were delicious. However, when we received our bill, we learned that there is a 4% surcharge for paying by credit card. (Apparently the prices listed on the menu are the cash prices, although this is not indicated on the menu). This seems like a very deceptive practice. It would feel far better if they listed the credit catd price, then offered a 4% discount for cash payment. That way you know up front what your bill will be. read more

Service and ambiance was awesome. It was within walking distance to our hotel which was a bonus.

We came here on a Friday night and everything was so good! If you'd like a booth, you may want to make a reservation but otherwise, we were seated right away. Jenny is a 5 star server, super attentive and went above and beyond our entire visit. I really appreciate her hospitality. We started with the souvlaki, the scallops and the octopus. The souvlaki is tender and flavorful. The scallops with the mushrooms, asparagus, whipped potatoes and cranberry were some of the best I've ever tried, and I would absolutely get the meal next time. The octopus was cooked to perfection and the fava with the garlic aioli + arugula is delicious. Their Broken Rake drink was amazing, as well as the desserts. The chocolate cake is extremely decadent and I especially loved the galactobouriko! broken rake 5/5 souvlaki 4.5/5 octopus 5/5 scallops 5/5 galactobouriko 5/5 choc cake 4/5 (if you're a choc lover it would be a 5) I highly recommend checking out Ithaki for their amazing food + service, and they're great for groups! I'll be trying everything on their menu. ambiance: 5/5 drinks: 5/5 food: 5/5 service: 5/5 Ithaki: 5/5 read more

See all

Ithaki Mediterranean Restaurant is a fabulous place to enjoy authentic Greek cuisine. We dined there last night with another couple and felt right at home. Chris was our server and allowed us to relax and enjoy each other's company while having drinks with our flaming saganaki and stuffed grape leaves. Dinner entrees included gnocchi with scallops in cream sauce, lobster and crab ravioli, lamb kebab and lamb shank with seasoned rice. Everything was delicious! The ambiance was great. We were able to pleasantly converse without accompanying loud music! Yay! We will definitely return soon to try breakfast here. read more

Great breakfast food and the hot cocos real good Also the workers are very friendly and kind read more

Our go to on Sunday, highly recommend this for breakfast or lunch - makes you feel like your overseas - even the music is greek! Food is delicious and clean, waitstaff are friendly and accommodating. Highly recommend! read more

We came here on Father's Day to celebrate the wonderful hubs. We were a bit early for our reservation, but they gladly sat us. The place is very large and open but elegantly designed and laid out. It would be very fitting for a large group gathering. We also noticed they had a function room tucked back behind the bathrooms. Ana was our server for the evening and did an exemplary job. She was always around when we needed her, made wine recommendations, and even gave me a tasting or two. Her smile was contagious! For starters, they offered complimentary bread and a tomato dip consisting of tomato, feta, garlic, and olive oil. The bread was soft, chewy, and warm. The dip was cold and refreshing, with a nice bite to it! Cocktails soon arrived. Hubs had their version of a mojito, which he thought was super yummy and refreshing. I opted for the hot and dirty, and it delivered! The appetizers were the layered hummus--divine! It hit all the taste notes and had lots of different textures! Keftedes were lamb and pork fritters with a nice tzatziki sauce. For dinner, I chose the blackened salmon over rice pilaf and a carrot ginger puree. This was a flavor bomb in my mouth--so delicious. Hubs had the lamb skewers with potato puffs. He noted that it was cooked perfectly and nicely seasoned. He loved the char on the vegetables, too. Who can pass up dessert when you are celebrating? Hubs chose the limoncello cake, which he absolutely loved! It was a bit too sweet for me, but that is okay! In chatting with a neighboring table, they loved their meal as well and wanted me to snap a pic of their dessert, lava cake, which was thoroughly enjoyed! I ended the night with Espresso Martinis, and oh my my! So yummy and my goodness those glasses! So cute! We will be back. Even that night, sitting there, we were debating who to invite on our next Ithaki adventure! read more

See all

Over the top Greek restaurant connected to a hotel is a bit surprising in a pleasant way. Access to parking from the highway is a bit tricky. Each dish was a work of art and tasty as well. Good place to stop if leaving Boston for more northern destinations. It's on the east side of the highway so if you are traveling south, no way to get to it. read more

See all

For the image they try to "sell" this is a big, plain space. Decoration has to improve drastically. The appetizers were average. The pork chops were seriously overcooked, hard to cut through, and tasteless. One of us had salmon and that same evening she felt sick. The service was average. During the 35+ years I have been in Massachusetts, I never had to pay a fee if I did not pay for a meal with cash; we were asked to do so at Ithaki. The strange thing is that since we paid with two credit cards, one was charged the full fee and the other one was not charged any fee. The bill claims we get a 4% discount if we pay the posted menu price with cash but we are charged extra if we do not pay with cash. I do not really understand what is the 4% discount I get if I pay the full posted menu price with cash. Further, I do not think it is legal to charge extra when customers pay with a credit card in MAssachusetts. if the restaurant wants to have such a policy should find a way to inform the customer prior to taking their order. I do not recommend Ithaki and personally I am not going back to this restaurant. read more

My friends have been raving about this place since they had recently relocated from Ipswich. I always appreciate private parking spaces for the convenience. The hostess quickly sat us as it was half full by the time we arrived around 6 pm on a Tuesday night but by the time we left it was almost entirely full. For an appetizer we shared the beet salad along with the complementary bread and dip. We asked what the dip was made of which is the same ingredients for a Greek salad so cucumbers, tomatoes, feta, and olives. The salad was incredibly refreshing and crisp. I would come again just for the salad. For entrees, my friends got Baked eggplant and Spicy crab and lobster spaghetti while I got the Pan seared duck. The eggplant had a well toasted layer of mashed potato-like topping and was delicious. We asked for extra spicy spaghetti and they definitely delivered on that front. The duck was beautifully cooked but the portion was a little disappointing as it was a single breast. The reduction over the carrots and purée was phenomenal. Dessert consisted of Limoncello cake and Galactonouriko. Although I am not a fan of citrus desserts, I did enjoy the texture of the cake and custard. I loved, loved the Galactonouriko as it was a cross between baklava and a custard. It was a unique warm and creamy dessert. Overall, we had a wonderful and I can't wait to go again. Our waiter was patient and kind. Our cups of water never went below half as there was always someone to refill it. It's a aesthetically decorated spacious establishment perfect for hosting large parties. read more

My dad and I recently returned to Ithaki, along with my stepmom. Happy to report our meal was just as good as it had been all those years ago and that my stepmom loved it too. It can be hard for all us to agree on cuisine, but southern European usually works, so this Greek restaurant was perfect. I highly recommend a reservation--we were lucky to get same-week reservations on a Saturday night. The vibrant atmosphere and nice decor really added to the experience. We ordered the fried calamari, paella, lamb hummus, saganaki, and pistachio baklava. I had the Persephone cocktail, which was refreshing, and my father's Greek white wine was great. We loved everything and it was hard to choose a favorite. I think my standouts were probably the lamb hummus and the pistachio baklava. The hummus was creamy and the lamb delicious. The baklava was the perfect sweet note to end our meal. The hostess was extremely friendly and welcoming. The only issue I have is with our service. Our server was quite busy and I don't fault her, but we felt deliberately overlooked, as she would pass our table several times without even looking at us, let alone checking in, though when she did, she was friendly. But sometimes you just know when you are being ignored. I'd still go back, but hopefully would have a better service experience. We all really appreciated that we were not rushed and that we could enjoy a leisurely meal. I'm glad Ithaki is now in a more accessible location and that it is closer to home. read more

See all

Ithaki, welcome to Mark's hall of fame! One of the places whose virtues I will extol to anyone who asks me for a recommendation. Other than a few minor notes, the food and the entire experience were sensational! The good thing about going with family is you can try more food! I had the distinct pleasure of trying: - Tuna Crudo - Lavraki Tartare - Taramosalata (spread) - Tzatziki (spread) - Tirokafteri (spread) - Moroccan Crusted Tuna - Greek Coffee - Galactobouriko Overall, EVERYTHING was fresh and tasty, with the flavors being more subtle and nuanced than bold, brash, in-your-face, and it works! The Tuna Crudo and Lavraki Tartare were great! The fish was very fresh and dressed/garnished beautifully! Regarding the Crudo: The gentle acidity of the citrus juice, the briny 'bite' of the capers, the creaminess of the avocado, and the oil to bring everything together made the tuna shine. The Tartare was like the Crudo's fraternal twin. Similar but very much its own dish. The lemon juice helped add a little acid and take away any fishiness. The pickled onions added some crisp tanginess, and the chimichurri some freshness and earthiness. The three spreads were great! These felt like they were made to order, too! The tzatziki, for instance, was not watery (as happens when it sits for a while). Taramasalata was savory without being fishy, the tzatziki was delightfully garlicky, and the Tirokafteri had a nice kick from the jalapeños. The only note here is I found the Tirokafteri a touch salty for my taste. House-made pita chips were terrific, also! The Moroccan Crusted Tuna was divine. The tuna had a tasty, not overdone, and not over-seasoned crust and perfectly transitioned into the raw fish inside. The spicy hummus was creamy and had an enjoyable kick. The chimichurri and couscous combination was a match made in heaven. The starch of the couscous with the earthy, savory, lightly acidic notes of the chimichurri went together like bread and butter! The piece of chicken I had the opportunity to taste was incredibly tender and tasty. For this being from the chicken breast, this is really something! The only note is that the chicken was just a pinch over-salted for my palate. For dessert, I had Greek coffee and Galactobouriko. Galactobouriko was terrific! It was thin, flaky, filo dough filled with a delectable and not over-sweet custard. Terrifically balanced all around. Greek coffee (similar to Turkish coffee) was a unique delight also! It was bold and somewhat intense, not acidic, and had that texture characteristic of unfiltered coffee ground very fine. The amount of sugar/possible spice was also perfect. What makes Ithaki so memorable isn't just the food; it's the service and vibe/ambiance. Our server, Adrienne, was phenomenal. She was kind, professional, and attentive. The rest of the service staff was similarly professional and attentive. For example, some of the coffee spilled (not due to the server's fault - trickiness with the cezve). Our cups were wiped, saucers replaced, and spill covered with a napkin. Little things, but life is made of little things. As for the vibe/ambiance, it is open, light, and inviting. The tables are spaced appropriately, so you are not bumping elbows or yelling over a table next to you. The music quietly playing can be heard but does not interfere with conversations. Everything was also immaculate. This brings me to my final 'note' - walking in, there is a faint smell of bleach/chlorine. However, I appreciate that they may have just started dinner service, and a distant scent of bleach indicates cleanliness, even though it's not the most pleasant. Before, when people asked me about my favorite restaurants in/around Boston, I would give them a list of four. Now when people ask me, I will provide them with five. I already can't wait to go back! read more

See all

Horrible experience at this restaurant. Staff was incredibly rude and mocked my husband within sight for raising his hand for another drink in an empty restaurant. Our waitress seemed irritated at every interaction. Staff overall was just blatantly arrogant and rude upon arrival. I would recommend McDonalds over this place to anyone looking for a decent meal and service. Food was okay, but I've had better authentic Greek at a mom and pop deli for a fraction of the price. Do not waste your hard earned money here. Shameful service and sub par Greek cuisine. Owner and staff should be embarrassed. Unprofessional joke of an establishment. Seriously, don't go here - worst dining experience ever. read more

We have been there a few times for breakfast and once for dinner! Will keep going Bach! Breakfast Shakshuka is fabulous. Roast potatoes and true Greek salad for dinner were excellent! read more

I'm pretty picky when it comes to Greek restaurants and this place came pretty damn close. Food exceeded my expectations and they had grilled octopus which I feel like it's hard to come across! read more

See all

Been to this restaurant many times, with different groups of people. No one has ever been disappointed. The atmosphere is lovely and calm, the wait staff polite and attentive, and the food and drinks are just sublime. Try the three dip combination with toasted pita, or the gnocchi with burrata cheese, or the pappardelle with short ribs - all of it is excellent. The galactoboureko is amazing. Try Ithaki for a quick lunch or a special dinner, you will not be disappointed. read more

Horrible experience! The patron next to me asked 'what does it take to get a drink around here' and I said oh the bar tender is over there here she comes... as she came over she immediately said ' what are you talking about with 'here she comes' immediately started yelling at me and continued as I waited 20 minutes asked for a glass of wine two times and never was served. Got sardines that were awful. Expensive and the worst service I've experienced. Never coming back again.... Go to koizina and get better food and waitstaff who smile and don't yell at customers read more

Not my first time here but probably my last. The lamb was well done, ordered medium rare. The pepper still had the produce sticker on it. The bathroom floor was so dirty it looks like it hadn't been cleaned in a week. And this was at 12:15 in the afternoon. It made me wonder how clean the kitchen was. And if Petros is going to put flowers in the bathroom they should not be brown and dead read more

See all

Went to Ithaki restaurant for the first time last night with a group of six. The restaurant was very nice the service from Demitri was out standing. I had a full body Greek wine that was very good and the meal was outstanding. Everyone loved it. The lamb was good to perfection and the Musaka was delicious. We had coffe and dessert after and it was very enjoyable evening I would recommmend that restaurant and I gave it five stars. read more

See all

Food and service are always excellent. Love the look of the restaurant as well. From the moment you enter , you are always treated as a special guest. read more

The food and drinks are amazing! This restaurant is so good! The location isn't the best being on route one attached to a hotel and parking is tight being near Starbucks but oh so worth it! read more

HORRIBLE EXPERIENCE. Save Your Money and get real Greek food from KUZINA and pay half of what they charge for mediocre Middle Eastern / Greek whatever their Kitchen Signature mixed up is !!!!!! When they first opened, the place was always empty, and we used to go there with different groups of people because they all loved Mediterranean Food. We would go for Holidays like Thanksgiving and Easter every year plus at least once a month with a party of 6 or 8 every single time. The Owner would answer "Yes of course " or "Any time" and would never ask for us to give our Credit Card so it would be on Hold in case we cancel the reservation. When I called to make a Reservation for this Sunday they asked for my Credit card and I asked what is the reason. And the answer was if you cancel and you don't show up we have to charge you a certain amount to protect the business. I told the owner I am your Customer and you never asked us before and very Arrogantly answered that that's how we RUN the business now. I told him that when your Restaurant was empty and we would make a reservation you would not ask for our Credit Card. His response was never slow and I am the best and I don't need you as a customer. The Manager and the owner were both arrogant and yelling especially the owner bragging how good his business was and he did not need to answer why he wanted the credit card when we wanted to make the reservation. I explained to all my company and their families why we were not going there and all agreed that it's a horrible experience and no wonder the place is empty most nights. read more

2nd visit and still my favorite Greek restaurant. Service is always on point. Food always tastes great and getting better. read more

See all