Craving pizza and don't know how I missed this place in Winder, but thought we would give it a try and glad we did. Nice little place, clean well organized ordered two medium pizzas asked for it a little overdone because we like our crust crunchy and these came out perfect. Just a pepperoni and then a pepperoni with mushroom and black olives and these mediums were huge! About $16 each then we ordered the 12 garlic knots at OMG! Those are addictive. They're not your small garlic knots. This was more than a loaf of bread, but they were wonderful. Brought them home I like to get them out of the box on the plate add some Parmesan cheese and red pepper and we did add a little more red sauce to the pizza that we got with the bread and these were fantastic. They held their shape they were not overly greasy, which I loved, but only two slices of a medium pizza and I was full, so we'll be eating pizza again today and probably tomorrow lol. I'm not into the 6 pound pizzas with 4000 cal and so much grease. It will fry 25 pounds of chicken so this one made me really happy. Really great crust, and bringing it home. I can also add things and even got me some blue cheese dipping sauce while I watch Netflix. Perfect evening thanks for a great pizza! Highly recommend. read more

See all

I'm not even a big pizza person... but let me tell you this pizza was BUSSIN'. I was so hungry I completely forgot to take a picture of it It was thin, cheesy, perfectly greasy in the best way possible. I was a fat kid in heaven.LOL This spot is pretty far from where I live, but if I'm ever in the area again? Oh, I'm pulling up. No hesitation. read more

Italian Pie - Italian Near Me - Winder, Georgia

Where is the sauce? We ordered a pizza, half cheese and half pepperoni and we are still looking for the sauce -lol.

Just opened up and Winder the pizza was great. Service was great. Ordered five pizzas but to pick them up they were ready when I got there.

The brisket for tacos was great. It was seasoned and cook well. I wasn't expecting much from it, the pizza was good would have like for my crust to have been cooked a little more. But overall it was a good meal. The service was kind of hit or miss but to be fair it was a rush at the time I went. read more

See all

WELL........DONE!!!!!! I applaud you Italian Pizza Pie!! Extremely well done on this Philly. Perfect amount of crust on both bread and meat. Cheese was melted just right. And the flavor was above and beyond the call of duty! Picture does this delicious sandwich no justice. read more

Italian Pie - Philly Cheesesteak - Italian Near Me - Winder, Georgia

The double cheese and pepperoni was true NY thin crust and delicious with a good under carriage. The garlic knots were huge and marinara was spot on! read more

We love this place! The guys at our shop and the one next door enjoy the food and service here. We work just down the street and usually gather together and walk up here almost weekly to meet up for lunch together. The staff and owner are fast and friendly, they tend to serve food quickly. The lunch specials are a must-have. The atmosphere is great, too! read more

See all

Ordered take out and picked it up. The order process was easy with a live person. Order was ready when I arrived to pick up. The food was amazing and the portions were huge! Service and staff were very nice. read more

Let me start by saying the staff could not have been friendlier nicer and more helpful. That being said, I was very excited to see the opening of this location less than a half a mile from my office. I finally had a chance today to wander over and try the pizza and garlic rolls into my surprise the cookies as well. However, everything fell short, unfortunately. The garlic rolls were not typical pizzeria garlic rolls. They were more of a yeast roll, which was fine, but it's not what in my mind I pictured I pictured more of a pizzeria, garlic nut style. The marinara sauce had an acidic or sour flavor to it was not edible for the garlic rolls. The pizza I always order a little bit well done or crispy and this pizza had clearly been sitting prior to going in the oven because it came out the top very crispy yet it was somehow the soggy bottom pizza I've ever had. And the cookie while I was worn, they were slightly over baked this time around, looked amazing, but fell short as well. I will go back as I do not know how long they have been opened and so forth, but all in all this is not the pizza place. I was hoping it would be and it's a far cry from what it has replaced. read more

Great pizza and wings!! We have had their pizza twice. Service was good considering they just opened the week we visited. Definitely going back read more

Man winder has been hurting for a good pizza place. I used to eat at the one in Lawrenceville. The pies are phenomenal as well as all their food. I ate this pie and immediately thought to myself " this makes me happy ". read more

The pizza is very good and the slices are very big. The ambiance is also very nice and rustic looking with good music in the background.

Winder has been needing a good local pizza spot!!! It's nice to see the community supporting local business because this place is busy but the seating is very friendly for larger parties. It is family friendly and the atmosphere really feels that way. The service was good and of course the pizza was amazing. I've been to the other locations and I'm really happy to see it maintains its authenticity. read more

toppings good fresh. dough very tasteless and dry. Priced too high for the area. Would have been nice to know they have lunch specials.

The pizza was ok. I ordered the Italian special the veggies were under cooked and dough was soft. There are 4 long picnic style tables. that's it. Limited seating. it's more of a to-go style environment. The wings were ok and had too much sauce, could be cooked a little longer. I would recommend getting a slice to-go over ordering a whole pizza and trying to sit. The Slices seemed to be cooked properly better than the whole pizza. We had a party of 6 and each person ordered something different. The kids taking orders were nice and helpful. The restaurant overall was clean and staff were friendly. read more

Ordered chicken and spinach. Received cheese and spinach. Then the manger lied and said I ordered cheese and spinach. Mgr. Very rude! Will not be back read more