Love the location! Most of the food is very good! Some of it…read moreis OK. The server was good as well. We came here as a group of 6 for lunch. We sat outside. It was a beautiful day! We shared the fish dip (AMAZING!!), and the shrimp cocktail as our appetizers. The shrimp were Huge! We had a few bloody Mary's and they were also really, really good! Fresh, handmade. No mix! I had a mixed greens salad with a blackened tuna yellowtail on top. The salad was not good. The tuna was ok. A little cold. A little tough, not a lot of flavor, even though it was blackened and I squeezed lemon on it. The "mixed greens" were kinda disappointing. It was mostly big pieces of iceberg lettuce. So, overall, the salad (which came to $40) was the reason I gave 4 stars instead of 5 for the food. My friends ordered a cheeseburger, a soup, a mahi-mahi sandwich, and a chicken sandwich. I don't know how the mahi mahi was, but I know she didn't finish half of it. We had key lime pie for dessert. That was also very good! If I return I'll try something else besides a salad. Everything else that we had was really good! Just for my bill alone, it was $70 for tip, so also not a cheap place. But, you can't beat the location!

Our group came here after our off shore fishing trip because they will actually cook your fresh…read morecatches!! We actually caught Mahi Mahi and a Triple Tail. The staff here are super helpful and friendly. We went with their suggestions of doing family style and 3 fish preparations blackened, grilled, and jerk. We also had their ceviche preparation and buffalo tomatoes with mozzarella. Amazing lunch easy 5 Stars !!

This was the best meal we ate during our entire trip. I will make sure to come back every time. I…read morecan't recommend enough!! Staff was super friendly and helpful!

I've watched a couple YouTube videos about this place and the one thing I've been wanting to try is…read morestone crab. Finally, ITS IN SEASON!!!!! So of course, we went ahead and ordered 3 lbs. We got 2 lbs of medium, which are originally $27 but since they had a valentines special, if you bought 2 pounds of medium, it would be 15% off. So we did 2 pounds of medium....and one pound of large claws. The stone crab is on a sweeter flavor profile. The stone crab mustard sauce......it's so delicious. It complimented the crab so so well. We were stuffed with 2 pounds but of course we had to finish our plate. We also bought a souvineer mallet, $3.99. In total we spent $100. Which is an amazing price. Usually in other restaurants, 2 jumbos are like $60. It is so worth it to buy it from this location. The service was great, she asked if we wanted to eat there or for take out. We said we were going to eat it there, and they cracked the crab for us and it was so easy to eat. The ambiance is great. Live music, beautiful weather, the water, the boats......such a great experience. I will be back very soon.

I always stop at Alabama Jacks,The service is great,Never had a bad meal or bad service,Old Keysie…read morefeel.The music on the weekend will get you up and dancing.Stop and enjoy a Conch fritter,The best Dolphin Rueben sandwich anywhere , Sauerkraut not coleslaw.You may see a Manatee or a croc.Maybe a Florida man.

Conch fritters were good and the atmosphere was fun (the fish and birds kept us entertained while…read morewe waited for our food), but my wife and I both agreed that it wasn't worth a 40 minute round trip drive in the opposite direction of where we needed to go. Don't get me wrong, the food wasn't bad - my blackened fish was tasty - it just didn't seem worth the drive (or the price).

Five stars, and I want to explain this properly because High Tide in Key Largo is absolutely a…read moreplace people should experience at least once. This is one of those spots that immediately tells you it's a local favorite the second you walk in. It feels homey, lived in, and deeply rooted in the community. The average crowd definitely skews older, which honestly just shows how loyal the regulars are and how long this place has been doing something right. We stood for a minute or two when we arrived, which wasn't a problem at all, but the initial interaction felt a little abrupt. Nothing hostile, just very direct and urgent. We later found out that Cathy is the owner, and it became clear very quickly that this place is her whole world. She works hard, moves fast, and runs on urgency. That energy can sometimes come off sharp, especially to visitors who aren't used to that local, no frills style, but we gave her the benefit of the doubt. There were moments throughout our visit where the tone felt a little rough around the edges, and it wasn't just with us, we noticed it with other tables too. It didn't feel personal, more like someone who is stretched thin and running on fumes. To her credit, there were moments where she self corrected, and I genuinely believe this was just a long day rather than bad intentions. Running a place like this day in and day out is not easy, and you can feel how much effort goes into keeping it moving. This review isn't meant to tear anyone down, just to be honest for future guests so they know what to expect walking in. What truly changed our entire experience and pushed this from a four star visit to a solid five was our server. Her name started with a T, she wore glasses, and she was African American, and she was an absolute blessing. She treated us with warmth, patience, and genuine care, like we were family she was looking out for. When we sat down and the table needed to be wiped, she handled it gracefully without a single awkward moment. Everything she did felt intentional and kind. She was attentive without hovering, respectful, and genuinely happy to be doing her job. There was also a sweet older Latina woman clearing tables who was just as lovely and welcoming. It became very clear that despite the different personalities, this place functions as a team, and the heart of High Tide lives in the people who treat guests with care and humanity. If you get that server whose name starts with a T, you are in excellent hands. Now let's talk about the food, because this is where High Tide really shines. The hash brown casserole is a straight ten out of ten. No exaggeration. Comfort food perfection. Crispy, savory, and absolutely worth ordering. The country style platter we ordered was also a ten according to my friend, hearty and satisfying in the best way. The lobster benedict was good, I would give it about an eight. It's a fun, unique option if you want to try something different, but not the standout compared to the rest of the menu. And then there's the real star of the show, the Key lime pie. Even if you are not hungry, come for the pie. This is hands down the best Key lime pie I have ever had. Perfectly balanced, not overly tart, smooth and almost cheesecake like in texture. It's the kind of dessert that makes you pause after the first bite because it's that good. Beautifully presented too. The decor is charming and thoughtfully cluttered in a way that feels authentic, not staged. The bathrooms are old but very clean. Parking is a little quirky but manageable, and there is parking available if you're patient. Overall, the vibe is cozy, memorable, and unmistakably local. Would I come back? Absolutely, especially for the food and that pie. Cathy, you are clearly working your ass off, and I hope this was just a rough day. This review comes with honesty and flowers, not shade. Five stars for the food, the heart, and the people who make this place what it is. I do recommend it.

High prices Red and white wines were bith very bad…read more Fish 5* Bad service, got mostly served by a trainee who knew nothing about being a waitress. Very long wait after placing food order. Then salad came, and 2 minutes later, the main dishes were delivered. Very good onion rings. Caesar salad dressing was thin with no taste.

Oh my goodness what a hidden gem! This was one of many restaurants on our Florida trip and let me…read moresay it was the BEST one, I still weeks after... reminisce about the spicy crunchy fish sandwich I had. Everything I had there was fantastic the sides, the drinks not to mention a great atmosphere. So bummed I'm not closer I would seriously be a regular there !

Our first and probably last visit. We came because of the reviews and did not have the same…read moreexperience with our meal. I loved being on the water, our service was friendly and prompt but the food was less than 3 stars. We both ordered the Mahi, one of our favorites. The fried mahi was overly battered and dry, the recommended pasta salad was overdressed, it tasted like it was all mayonnaise. The blackened mahi was seriously overcooked, dry and barely edible. The side salad was fresh and large , that along with the jalapeño tartar sauce were the highlights of the meal. I hope the kitchen was just having a bad night as I always pull for the local dives to succeed.

We were hunting down a great Lobster Roll as we were visiting the Key Largo area. The Lazy Lobster…read morehit absolutely every point we were looking for! The Lobster roll and Cheeseburger were some of the best we've had, the lobster roll has two types a Thea, Pricilla traditional roll and a variant Lobster Roll with a Lazy Lobster twist which was truly amazing, refreshing and good till the last bite! The service and ambiance is just as amazing as the food! Priscilla, Thea and Tanner were so attentive nice and on top of everything! The Lazy Lobster also have live music and a cool outdoor seating area. If in the area I highly recommend this gem!

This is one of our favorite places to eat down here and come back every time. I would give it a…read more4.5. Menu is very extensive so there is something for everyone. Lobster is their speciality but tonight we both had lobster and had to use a knife to really saw through the meat. It was quite tough. Still very flavorful. The shrimp and scallops with the meal were delish and cooked perfectly though. To pay that much, it was just a little disappointing. Service was good. The banana bread to start is soo good! The octopus starter was good. Just a heads up, i always bring a light long sleeves. The mosquitos can get annoying. Overall, we will continue to come back!

This place was cool. Came on a Friday night and barely waited 10 mins which was awesome. It was…read morepacked with people. Everyone is close together but nobody bothered us. Our food came quickly after ordering. We just got some apps and drinks. Everything was really good! Deff a great stop to grab some seafood!

So The Fish House was a bright spot in an otherwise uninspiring culinary experience during our most…read morerecent trip to the Florida Keys, The restaurant itself has some serious homegrown Florida vibes with many unique decorations and accoutrements all over the restaurant, loosely pirate themed. It was featured on Diners Drive In's and Dives as well. We were seated in a little alcove near the entrance which gave our group a private space. Service was prompt and friendly and we really enjoyed the whole thing. I got the mahi mahi maracumbe style, which was recommended by our server as a house specialty. It did not disappoint! It was light, flavorful, and quite surprisingly really one of the most delicious fish dishes I've ever had at a restaurant. Everyone else enjoyed their food as well. We had key lime pie with meringue for desert which was also fabulous. Overall it lived up to the hype. Five stars

Absolutely the best meal we have had in quite a while! We…read moresat at the bar, had great friendly service and good cold beer. We started with potato skins, a special, they were huge, hot and delicious. We split the shrimp risotto with mushrooms in a Alfredo sauce, plenty for 2, the shrimp was perfectly cooked and the dish served hot! The only improvement I can suggest would be crisp up the garlic bread that was served on the side. Do not miss this spot in Key Largo

What a beautiful restaurant. They had high ceilings (unheard of in the Keys) and nice decor. They…read moreeven put sound proof panels on the ceiling to help keep the noise level down (thoughtful!). We ate inside (Floridians like us know better than to expose ourselves to the heat and No See Um's outside at dusk). We thoroughly enjoyed the inside ambiance. Well done. The spacious patio out back did also actually look nice. I wanted to give this 5 stars but my husband was not impressed by the taste (or lack thereof) of his bacon burger so I had to take away a star. I had a delicious Woodrow Chicken sandwich piled high with their signature onions and bbq sauce. When they brought it out, I wondered how I could possibly get the huge thing into my mouth. It was enormous (see photo) and tasty. I cut it in half and ate leftovers the next day. Service was good except our waitress did seem to struggle a bit. She either could not hear us or did not understand us (language issue?). At least she kept asking us until she understood. I do appreciate that. We were skeptical but our order came out right, yippee! We even splurged by getting dessert. Can't pass up chocolate cake when it appears on the menu (rarely). It was a beautiful presentation (see photo)! Next time you are in Key Largo, give these folks a try. You won't be disappointed.

Amazing food, had the chicken Cajun pasta and it was so delicious!…read more Our server was busting her ass and never skipped a beat. She needs a raise, she was incredible! Great little spot to visit. The outdoor dining was great

The food here was very good. See below why I took off one star…read more I'd read about this place. It's off the main highway. It looks a bit ramshackle from the outside. But it is worth the detour. We sat at the bar, inside, with a view of the kitchen and cook, but I'd recommend sitting outside if it's not too hot and weather permits. That's a much better view. We started with their fried asparagus appetizer. The stalks were quite thin, and the portion small, but what we had was delicious. Especially tasty when dipped in the horseradish sauce. I'd get this again! After that we shared their fish dish. Two scoops on a plate with chopped tomatoes, chopped onions, and chopped green pepper. The cutest heart shaped crackers came with the dip. We had leftover dip so we took it home with us (in our cooler). We enjoyed it on toast later on. So the very good? The food. The not so good? The kitchen looked grungy and the ladies room was a mess. Would we come here again? Yes, but we'd sit outside.

First disclaimer that you cannot dine at this restaurant unless you are a member or with a member…read moreof Ocean Reef Club. Just an FYI based on Yelp feedback. We have eaten at this restaurant several times before when visiting ORC but had never been able to get the pizza. We booked our reservations several weeks in advance for our visit and Valentine's night. The bread basket is always delicious. Lots of choices along with nice butter and a dipping oil. We ordered a few adult beverages to enjoy with the bread and the evening was off to a great start. I knew I wanted margarita pizza and stuck to my plan. It was really good. Hubby had a small salad and a small spaghetti dish for his dinner. He liked both. We do like that they offer smaller size pasta dishes especially if you are having a salad or appetizer. Their fare is Italian but a bit higher end. You can sit outside or dine in the lovely dining room. We were able to get a window seat inside overlooking the Marina which was so nice. I chose a dessert martini instead of a food dessert and it was delicious!!! Salted Nutella martini will make you very happy. Sinful. Reservations suggestions. Enjoy.

Great for dinner and breakfast. My boyfriend and I celebrated my birthday dinner here and were very…read morepleased. The service is superb and food very yummy. We sat by the window while the sun was setting and had a beautiful view of the water. We ordered the calamari, veal & chicken Alfredo for dinner. We really enjoyed the parmesan butter. We enjoyed Giannis that we tried breakfast and found the food just as tasty. We reall enjoyed the morning views .