The seafood here is a little pricey but the quality really shines through. You can come here for…read moresushi grade fish, salmon, tuna, scallops and they also carry prepared items like soups, prepared sauces, etc. The people are the counter are always super helpful and nice. If there's something you're thinking of for a meal they'll help you through it!

We were looking for a seafood market and decided to give this spot a try. As soon as we walked in,…read morewe were greeted immediately. They have an array of seafood options available. We wanted salmon and they had a great looking selection. They were very helpful and cut our fish into smaller fillet sizes. It's a bit on the pricey side for a pound, but the quality tasted fresh, the fillets were thick, and was really good with our dinner that night. The market had food to go including hot and cold lobster rolls and other seafood sandwiches. They also have hot soup, made to order sushi, and seafood platters to go too. In addition to food to go, you can buy other market items like seasonings, sauces, dry pasta, dry rice, and other essentials to pair with your seafood. Overall, a great little market with friendly staff, but be prepared to pay a higher price for items.

Not cheap and a little small but the produce and meat are of decent quality. I often come here to…read morebuy fruit and other meats and they have a great cheese selection. I come here to peruse because they carry some fancier items you'd see at Whole Foods. Service here has always been warm and attentive. I've had workers hold the door for me and asked I needed help.

This has nothing to do with the grocery store itself, but the music. Definately the best music of…read moreany grocery store I've ben to. It's jazz, but not smooth jazz, some late 50s and 60s hard bop.

The fish in here is locally soured and the steelhead which is similar to salmon but in my opinion…read morebetter. I have been in here twice and the customer experience is great.

What a gem of a store the customer service is top notch fresh fish and all the items you may need…read moreto cook a yummy fish stick sauces fresh fish also crab cakes fish cakes made to order take home and bake food looks so fresh. All seems cleans and organized.

Fish tales is simple the best fish / seafood store in Brooklyn. They just moved down the street to…read morebigger and better location. Their fish is amazing. Prices are high but so is the quality. The service is first class. We love the guys behind the counter. They will order speciality items for you when requested. The prepared foods, sandwiches, soups, salads and even spaghetti in clam sauce -- all delicious. The place is clean well lit and we could not ask for more -- well maybe some more clams on the spaghetti! Grazie!

Wrapping up their first week in a new location, I dropped by today to buy Branzini. They didn't…read morehave to travel far--just a couple doors down on the same block, and the space is larger with seafood on ice in full display. Their prices are noticeably more expensive than other places but no one should compromise when it comes to eating seafood. As someone who has had food poisoning a few times, I like to subscribe to this mindset. From Swordfish and Tuna to Shellfish and Filets, I was told they make the trek to Fulton Fish Market (in Hunt's Point, the Bronx) daily. That's good to know. There's also a freezer packed with frozen selections such as Snow Crab legs and Calamari. I would like to see more varieties of fish ( like Skate and Monkfish) while envisioning an addition of upscale gourmet items/seafood accompaniments other than Soy and Teriyaki Sauce. If you want to be assured of eating fresh seafood knowing you're paying slightly more, check them out. (I bought two Branzini for $31).

Was in the area and noticed a new seafood shop. I don't cook a lot of seafood, but I've been…read moremeaning to, so took the opportunity to check out what they've got. First of all, everything's fresh (unless it's frozen/prepackaged like their tuna steaks). I think almost everything ins locally sourced. They had some nice red snapper, and branzino. All different sizes, and for good prices. I picked up a small 1-pound red snapper (which they cleaned for me), as well as 2 lbs of their Connecticut mussels. They also had oysters, but they were Blue Points, which aren't my favorite. Got home and cooked everything, and it was quality all around. I now know that I can house 2 lbs of mussels in a single sitting... Cash only!

I'm so glad I finally checked this place out. I got a beautiful whole red snapper for my Lunar New…read moreYear celebrations. It was super fresh and the gentleman helping me did a very complete job of scaling it and trimming the fins. I'll be back next time for the branzino! Don't be put off by the minimalist retail space! It makes sense that they'd keep it easy to clean and hose down, ya know?

For as long as I could remember, this address has always been a fresh fish market. It has changed…read moreowners many times over through the years. In my opinion, there's nothing like a stand alone fish market (as opposed to those that have a little fish section in a gourmet shop) unless it's Fairway or a similar store. I absolutely adore seafood and it's also my favorite animal protein. I've been shopping here since forever and I really like their variety of seafood. There's even a sushi section (although I've never tried) that appears to be appealing and fresh. On my favorite food holiday--Christmas Eve--when the Italian (and my family) tradition is everything seafood (no less than 7), I always find myself shopping here. This market is very crowded around that time of the year. This store has fresh and frozen assortment of both shellfish and seafood. Mussels, clams, scallops, squid, shrimp, Branzino, trout, filet of sole, filet of trout, filet of whiting, sea bass, lump crab meat, king crab sticks, salmon, crab cakes and a lot more. I tend to stay away from Tilipia and Basa. You might notice at any fish market, it's the cheapest fish by the pound. And that's because it's imported from murky waters. At least that's what I've read and believe. In addition to a variety of seafood, there are various accompaniments & condiments such as cocktail sauces, Panko breadcrumbs, tarter sauce, fish fry batters, etc. I don't think they carry every variety of fish, but there's enough. And it's fresh. One thing to note---at times, they will sell out of certain fish. That's when you put plan B into place after the disappointment. BTW, I bought one pound of clean squid ringlets. I made a fresh sauce to accompany my squid ink pasta :) Good stuff here.

Love this place. Great quality and selection of seafood along with a friendly service…read more It's a winner in my book!!!

Can't say enough positive things about this new little market. My wife and I spend a month each…read moresummer in Spain, and we are excited to see some of our favorite products on the shelves. We went in for some tapas with our one-year-old daughter, and the customer service was incredible. Everyone there working was super kind and even gave us little toys to keep our daughter occupied while we ate some delicious bocadillos and gambas al ajillo. They even have a cute little reading nook. Everyone there was so nice, and we can't wait to go back regula

An eclectic selection. Pintxos, pickle snacks and sandwiches. Clean, new and you can get some…read morespecialty shopping done.

Not only overpriced, nine times out of ten they scan an item as more expensive than what the price…read moresticker says. It's happened so many times it's clear they do it on purpose. Fraud.

Just saw somebody packing shredded cheese with their bare hands, I don't know, but I think that's…read morejust disgusting

It's actually about frustration in signing up for online shopping; I have tried randomly over a…read moreperiod of months to get a functioning account and have never succeeded. Nor can I get anyone who "does" the online service management or get relevant answers from the Contact Us link. Last night I got to the checkout, and then the site kept asking me for the order number. ??? That ended the order going through. Mohammed tried to help by doing it verbally over the phone but there were too many items to deal with. It had been a go-to-shop for me since it opened, but after an accident I can't easily go in-person and now apparently I can't shop there at all or find anyone who is responsible/helpful for the site's customer functionality.

This has been my (very) local grocery store for over a decade, and unfortunately it has taken a…read moresteep turn downhill. What was once a family-owned, excellent grocery store run by wonderful people who cared is now a Key Food with a different name. I mean that literally; they were bought by Key Food during the pandemic, and they laid off all the employees (that we loved), brought in more self-checkout, and the quality of the produce has fallen off a cliff, while the prices have climbed to extortionist levels. For the most part, the replacement staff is quite nice and usually helpful (there are a couple bad apples that seem upset you need assistance). The guys behind the prepared food counter will do a solid job on your sandwich, and the cashiers are usually pleasant and almost always efficient. They still have a rewards program where if you spend around $250 and you get like $10 credit. (Hey, it's better than nothing.) The expansion of the store a few years back means they truly have just about everything, and the beer and ice cream selections are actually phenomenal (but overpriced). However, produce we buy is occasionally going bad already, and the prices are wildly out of control. I paid $7 for two onions last week. It becomes harder and harder to justify shopping here when it's more expensive than Fresh Direct, and vastly more pricey than the fruit and vegetable spots a few blocks away. I don't risk the meat and fish any longer (not with Paisanos and Fish Tales in the hood), although Bell & Evans chicken is quite reliable. Basically, Brooklyn Fare went from an incredible market to have across street to a last-resort for items I forgot to purchase elsewhere in the neighborhood, at reasonable prices. They know we're coming in when we need something, and we're going to pay for it. Despite these shortcomings, it's still great to have a corner store that has just about everything. I can still run out and grab some milk for my wife's cookies when I've finished the last drop and she looks particularly stabby. But it's going to cost $7 for half a gallon.