A true winner, GREATEVERYTHING, with a really nice Owner. Try their little Pizza's And their Fish. read more

Service was great. Waitress we had was very friendly and attentive. As far as food goes not so great. Mussels were mushy which means old and should not be served. Hopefully they will sample them before serving them in the future. The white clam sauce pizza should be taken off the menu. If you can't hold a slice of pizza to eat it because it's to soggy then it shouldn't be called pizza. One saving grace were the fries. Very disappointing for a 4 star rated restaurant. read more

We always get delicious dishes. Many options. Great specials and individual pizzas. A wonderful experience whether dining in or taking out, read more

I have to be honest. I wanted to like this place, after all there are so many positive reviews and people said the octopus is a must order. We made reservations for a Sunday night and the place is moderately busy. (Meaning there were tables, but walk ins would have been seated relatively quickly). Our reservations were for 6:30 and here we are at 7:41 with still only half our order. Honestly, the table seated next to us was outside waiting for about 5 minutes after we ordered. So here we are still waiting while they have already received their entrees even though we ordered way before them. I ordered a drink at the beginning of the meal and have not been offered a refill. The food tasted decent but not worth the over hour wait and negligent service. For the prices, I would expect a little more attentiveness and service. Don't get me wrong, the staff was nice. But we definitely felt like an after thought for everything. We had to ask for more water and no one ever came over to check on us. And when we asked about the status of our order, we were given excuses. They said every order went in at the same time. We even ordered another pizza while waiting and that came out before our entrees. We will never come back to this place. The wait time doesn't justify the service and food. It was just ok for me. Update: we decided enough is enough and cancelled our order at 7:55pm and asked for a check for the food we did eat. They told us not to worry about the check. Nice gesture but it shouldn't have gotten to this point. Never again. read more

It's been our local favorite for few years and I hosted my husbands birthday dinner here on Sunday night recently with 12 of us dining. We ordered appetizers, salads and pizzas. I didn't taste all but the white pizza and clam pizza was crowd favorite as well as octopus, polenta fries, porchetta bruschetta. The service was extra attentive, friendly. Timing for each course were on point and thoughtful throughout the entire night. I cannot wait for another night out at Grotta. read more

See all

Not everything is exactly the way that you prefer, but clearly there's somebody preparing food with skills. Some of the dishes are innovative, fresh, and memorable. Others are just good. read more

Grotta Di Fuoco - Recommended dishes Ricotta Gnocchi Parking space Difficult to find parking Parking options Free street parking - Pizza Near Me - Long Beach, New York

This restaurant was one of my new favorites in Nassau county. I ordered a personal margarita pizza with sausage and eggplant. It was really good. Our waitress was very respectful. The service was outstanding. Very busy on a Sunday night. Lots of people when we arrived! Noise level was great. Going back here once again! read more

Had such a nice evening at Grotto. Let's start with the service. It was perfect! The server, whom I had read several reviews complimenting her, was perfect. Always making sure we had what we needed without invading our space our interrupting our conversation. The food was great. We split an appetizer a salad and an entree. We can eat and are not shy. Management not want to hear this but it was quite sufficient for the two of us. The gnocchi is to die for! read more

Went for a nice romantic dinner. Great bottle of Pinot noir recommended by the server. Octopus for appetizer was delicious and the texture was perfect although a bit small. The veal Milanese was a nice light dish. The salad on top was flavorful and nicely dressed. My husband had the mixed seafood special in a tomato broth which was also very good. It's a good choice for a romantic dinner amongst all the surrounding bars. The service was very good. read more

Grotta Di Fuoco - Great pinot noir $65 - Pizza Near Me - Long Beach, New York

See all

All around everything was great. Food was solid, service was good, and the atmosphere was cool. Not the place for authentic Italian food but if you are looking for good food I don't think you will be disappointed. read more

THE BEST. Such a special little place, my absolute favorite, I always look forward to their dinner, drinks, dessert, *atmosphere* (formal tables or sit at the bar)..I go at least once a week Some favorites: the meatball appetizer, amara salad, the PIZZAS (all incredible and made fresh in their brick oven) ask for garlic chips on top, all the homemade pastas, the steak, they always have new specials and they're delicious... The cocktails!! are made fresh and they're sooo good. Everyone that works there is great so friendly, accommodating. (Only request, please bring back the burrata dish!!) read more

See all

I've lived in Long Beach for coming up on two years and jut went to this restaurant last week and it was great in all departments. From setting the reservation, to the greeting and seating from the hostess, to the more than helpful server, and absolutely delicious food as well as the tasteful selection of wine. I had the bone marrow for an appetizer which was perfection and the spaghetti with shrimp and slams whisk was delicious as well. Needless to say I will be a returning customer. I highly recommend anyone looking for a nice spot with casual ambiance that doesn't break the bank in Long Beach, this is the spot. Thanks again for great food and service! :) read more

Grotta Di Fuoco - Pizza Near Me - Long Beach, New York

See all

Oh my goooodnesss this meal was delicious. My friends live in Long Beach and really wanted to hit up Lost and Found (it's their favorite). Apparently, everyone else seems to feel the same way and on a saturday night a rez there is impossible. Although I'm bummed that we didn't get to try, I'm really stoked that we ended up at Grotta Di Fuoco instead. I walked in, inhaled the smell of fresh and delicious Italian food and instantly knew that I was in for a treat. I was eyeing basically everything on the menu, so luckily we ended up deciding to share a few things. To start, we put in an order of pizza and meatballs. The pizza was topped with goat cheese, fresh parm, pesto and some fresh veggies. It was literally perfect. The meatballs were also great and I thought that the addition of nuts added a nice crunch. For my main I ordered gnocchi with sausage which also came smothered in pesto and cheese. My friend and I split an order, and I loved how they served it to us in two beautifully presented dishes. Other dishes at the table were veal and spaghetti and clams. I snuck a few bites of the veal which was perfectly tender and served over creamy polenta. I didn't try the spaghetti and clams, but heard that it was just okay. We barely had room for dessert, but when some sort of magical peanut butter chocolate cake made it's way to the table I just had to try. Absolutely incredible. Next time I head back to LB, it'll be hard not to want to come back here. This definitely goes down in the books as one of my new favorite spots. read more

See all

Last night we popped into Grotta Di Fuoco for dinner. I was looking forward to it because the food it usually good. What I can't understand is there are no menus so you have to scan a barcode for the menu. Unfortunately the internet service in there is terrible. So in order to scan the menu I have to now join their Wi-Fi. The waitress with a heavy accent tried to tell me what the password was. She was very curt with me and acted like it was my fault I couldn't understand her. After three unsuccessful attempts at joining their Wi-Fi I decided this was to much work to do to try and order a meal. Maybe post the Wi-Fi password or something, or invest in menus! We left and went to Gio's and had a great meal there. read more

The food is great, I had the best scallops I ever had in my life! The drinks are great, The coffee martini is to die for! read more

Came here during the week. Wanted to order the veal meatballs along with a pasta dish but decided against ordering such heavy dishes as the restaurant was extremely warm inside. I went with the beet and fennel salad and a pizza. The Salad was minuscule: don't order this if you're looking for something substantial. I finished this in three minutes flat. Order the rocket salad instead. (My fiancé ordered it and seemed to enjoy it). The breakfast pizza was outstanding. Do yourself a favor and order this: it tastes even better the next day for breakfast. It comes with a slightly runny egg on top, crumbled Italian sausage and cheese. Yum. Fiancé ordered the 1/2 chicken under a brick and hated it. He wanted to swap out the carrots for the fingerling potatoes but was told that it couldn't be done. He had to order the potatoes as a separate side. Drinks were good, service was adequate, will not return. read more

Grotta Di Fuoco - Baby beet & fennel "salad" - Pizza Near Me - Long Beach, New York

See all

We were there last night and had an amazing meal.. The food was really great, creative and interesting.The ingredients are fresh and the presentation is beautiful. Various selection of drinks. Good service. Excellent atmosphere very cozy . Beautifully live music.!!!!! Reminds me of a restaurant you would see in SoHo. read more

Grotta Di Fuoco - Pizza Near Me - Long Beach, New York

See all

Wow!!! Everything is so incredible here. We had the mozzarella w prosciutto, pasta with red sauce and pizza with sausage. All were incredible. No wonder this place for 5 stars which is so hard to get. read more

Very good Italian in Long Beach. Probably the best Italian Restaurant. Service and atmosphere very good. Will definitely go back and always recommend if people are looking for Italian in Long Beach. read more

A gold Mine of a restaurant, where nothing is wrong, and the Owner/chef is Marvelous.

Pretentious and offensive in a way you never experience in LB. Adult couple, LB locals out for dinner on a rainy summer Tuesday. Walked into a completely empty Grotto at 6 PM. The hostess was snobby and unwelcoming from the moment we told her we didn't have reservations to the completely empty restaurant. We asked to sit at the bar for dinner and were practically scoffed at for requesting that. Upon sitting the bartender(bar maid?) took about 10-15 minutes to ask us(her only customers at that moment) for our drink orders. I was unaware of the craft drink made only our way policy Grotto seems to have and the bartender was nothing short of rude and condescending in explaining that to me. We were given menus and patiently waited to put in our food order.......for over 20 minutes......and then treated like an inconvenience when we finally asked if we could order. After another few minutes without getting to order we finally decided to leave and go to somewhere more hospitable and friendly. Paid our tab and politely left. 20 years frequenting most of the fine establishments in LB/PLO/AB and this was the worst customer experience we have ever experienced. It felt as if they didn't want us there or maybe it's just too snobby of an environment for us to be comfortable ‍, drove on down to Beginnings and had our usual fantastic experience there. For those of you who love Grotto, enjoy! But it's crossed off our list in a way that prompted me to write this review and I don't write many and almost never a negative one. read more

The staff there is unbelievable. We waited 45 minutes to sit outside. Fine she told us that no prob. We had to wait for a table to finish up. Then at the 45 minute mark they carry out a new table (WHAT?!?) and give it to someone else?!?! I then notice her handing the check to a table (no one else is waiting so I say something) she says if I want to sit inside I can sit now-- what? I waited an hour to sit inside where you had tables right away?!? Then the waitress didn't want to come over once we did sit. We had to get up and ask for menus, ask for someone to come order. (And I hear her next to us taking to the busboy about how she doesn't want to take our table!) The food took a while- but it was pretty good. Limited menu though and no option to add protein to a salad which would've been nice Then I see all the staff sitting at the tables smoking! What? Why are you in front of the restaurant smoking? Is that allowed? The waitress encouraged us to get dessert but never came back if we wanted to order it (and it took so long that the restaurant was pretty empty) I also overheard someone else (as we were walking in) complaining about the lousey hostess how they weren't seated because the table was for 5 and had to wait even though no party of 5 showed up the entire time) Overall good food, but bad experience. read more

Couldn't get in. Even seats at the bar are reserved. Rude hostess. Can't review the food but first impression not good

Came here for the first time tonight for a celebratory dinner and couldn't have been more pleased with our meals. Made reservations for 7:30 and were promptly seated upon arrival. The restaurant was definitely packed, and it seemed as if there weren't enough servers, since there were times the service could have been a bit better (would have loved to order a second drink), but the delicious meal outshines any glitches with service. We started with the rocket salad which was by far one of the best salads I've ever had. It's light, fresh and the lemon zest adds the perfect hint of citrus to an already delicious combination of ingredients. I can't wait to eat this again! For dinner, we both had pasta dishes- because when homemade pasta is on the menu, you don't turn that down. I ordered the squid ink tortellini, which was stuffed with lobster and served in a tomato and garlic brodo, and it was out of this world. The pasta was fresh, the dish was tasty and the portion was generous. I can never finish my main course, but I had no problem finishing this one- and I honestly didn't want my dinner to end. Since we were so pleased with our first two courses, I just had to order dessert. All options sounded delicious and unique, but we decided to go for the olive cake, which was served with a blood orange sorbet, dark chocolate ganache, hazelnuts and orange rinds-- and OMG. The combination of dark chocolate, with refreshing blood orange and moist bite of cake was perfection. This restaurant is a true gem in Long Beach and I can't wait to take friends when they visit. Just be sure to make a reservation if coming for dinner on the weekend! read more

Grotta Di Fuoco - Squid ink tortelli- YUM! - Pizza Near Me - Long Beach, New York

See all

Amazing food, drinks, service, ambiance. Best Italian food in Long Beach, 100%!!!!!!!!

Impeccable service, incredible food with a warm, comforting ambience. This place is a gem and the chef is a genius - authentic Italian comfort dishes that you can't stop eating. read more

Eh lowkey lame I had pizza there and it wasn't my fav tbh. Could be betta but other things were good ig, personally wouldn't go back but like it's not that bad whatever not a place I would pick to go but if I happen to walk by and I was starving and everywhere else was closed I would go read more

My wife and I have been here two or thee times. Cool decor. Cool feel. A nice change of pace from the pub food restaurants in the west end. Nice wine selection. Friendly waitstaff. Very limited menu. Food is ok. I can never find something that i really want to eat. Update- September 2018. Ate outside with my wife. Food was awesome. We split the rocket salad, shrimp clams pasta, and sausage pizza. Everything was so fresh read more

Grotta Di Fuoco - Is this your best?!?!? Disappointed in the pizza tonight. You guys are ALOT better. - Pizza Near Me - Long Beach, New York

I've been living in LB for years and for some reason have never been to Grotta. Finally tried it tonight, and will definitely be back! Everything was delicious, from the wine to the dessert. The place is super cozy and intimate place without being pretentious. Our waitress was sweet and efficient. We started with the octopus and veal meatballs, both of which were unreal. My fiancé got an amatricana bucatini special while I got the spaghetti with shrimp and clams. Again, unreal, especially his dish. Dessert was the olive oil cake, also very good. Can't wait to try again! read more

Went for Valentine's Day first time eating there. Had pizza was ok soggy bottom little choice of pizza . mussels were very good had to ask for extra bread nothing on menu to order don't know if we were charged . Had over priced bottle of wine and dessert a chocolate cake which was very dry small piece with little dollop of ice cream no whipped cream or sauce I asked the waitress do you have whip cream she said no and then she brought me caramel sauce didn't help skip dessert read more

I feel bad doing this but I have thought about how disappointed I was by this food multiple times now. The shaved pork appetizer was delish but the 2 entrees we got were not good. We got the shrimp and fish dish with beans and there was absolutely no taste, shrimp and fish were rubber like and beans were so hard. I should have said something while I was there. Staff was extremely friendly though read more

The. Best. Food. Ever. I've never had a better experience. My best friend and I shared the bianca pizza, palenta fries, lemon gnocchi, and the montauk tuna. We sat at the bar and Emily was our bartender/server- she was incredible. If you're in the mood for delicious Italian food (with a twist) & insane cocktails....what're you waiting for?! Get your butt here! But make a reservation bc there's never any tables it's so good! read more

Came here for the first time by recommendation of others and overall was not impressed. Two stars given for the good service and atmosphere, but my group left feeling like the food just wasn't that good. We started with the meatballs (which were the favorite) and pork bruschetta. For entrees, the half chicken was doused in lemon which took away from the other flavors, the gnocchi was just OK with the sausage being oddly crunchy and the alla Norma pasta was unevenly cooked, al dente in some places and very soft in others. Not likely to recommend to others or come back, except maybe to grab a drink at the bar. read more

Grotto is a real winner, the food here is always great. Especially the fish, and the little Pizza's. The owner/chef really knows his stuff, and the prices are right. read more

This comes from a long time resident. This meal could have been pleasant. However, I WILL NEVER patronize this establishment again. The food was fine. The atmosphere was like a a frat house. We were sitting next to two other couples all stunned at the managements lackadaisical approach to a table of six raucous clients. We spoke to "management" who apologized by saying one of the table members was moving. They offered no discounts, or apologies. Stupid as we three couples made plans to meet at a classier establishment on the north shore. This is not the first time here. We had hoped the management had wisened up. I guess it's their kind of folks. Not recommended for anyone.. read more

This was the first time at this restaurant and the last. The octopus appetizer was small and not fresh tasting, and in a sauce that was black, but otherwise nondescript. I ordered monkfish for my entrée, which is one of my favorite fishes in general. This was covered in dry Icky bacon and there was barely any fish within the bacon. I'm not even sure there was fish. It was over a bit of what I believe is orzo which was good. The brownie dessert with hazelnut ice cream was a C+ as the brownie was unappealing, but the ice cream/gelato was good. The noise level was good to fair. The service was good. The parking is abominable I won't go here again. read more

I had the opportunity of visiting Grotta Di Fuoco on its opening weekend and was more than pleasantly surprised. Dimly lit, the restaurant reminded me of the small restaurant and bar outside the entrance of the Frasassi Caves in Genga Ancona, Italy. The stained concrete floors and industrial fixtures evoked the sense of a mining atmosphere. At the end of the bar stood the brick oven, that remained as the only remnants of the Caffe Laguna, however, only in its role at the Grotta Di Fuoco has it truly been utilized and reborn. Busy, a business client and I stood at the end of the bar and enjoyed small plates and brick a brick oven pizza. We chatted with the Chef / Owner Andrew about his bone marror or gnudi with broccoli rabe pesto and were thoroughly impressed by the panna cotta with smoked figs and rhubarb or the pastry chef's olive oil cake with raspberry sorbet. I can go on and on, but seriously. Try it. Food - 10 of 10 Ambiance - 9 of 10 Parking - 6 of 10 (street parking is available, but limited) Price - Reasonable (Pizza $10-12, Meals around $24) read more

Grotta Di Fuoco - Pizza Near Me - Long Beach, New York

Amazing creativity that you rarely see from LI restaurants. Starting with the pizzas through the meal, just sensational. We got most things off the special list so I can't give exact names but the pasta with poached lobster was out of this world. The wolfish was a pleasant delight, really has a shellfish flavor, and service was top notch. The place is setup great for these wild times whether you want to eat in or outside. Don't sleep on grotta or you'll regret it!!! read more

Love the basement ambiance. The service is attentive and food is delicious! I recommend it.

Food was great! Ambiance was nice but the tables were too crowded together making it difficult to talk privately and not have everyone know your business! However I know space is at a premium so this is the way it is, and the only reason for 4 instead of 5 stars. Also somewhat noisy, and a bit overpriced. However my friend and I both enjoyed our meals immensely - I had spaghetti with clams and shrimp and he got the lemon pepper pasta dish. Very cute and romantic ambiance except for the tables being so close to each other! Love the sunken room! read more