Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Grist Mill Wild Eats

    5.0 (1 review)

    Grist Mill Wild Eats Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Grist Mill Wild Eats

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    7 years ago

    Helpful 8
    Thanks 0
    Love this 8
    Oh no 0

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for New American 1,815 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Zuppaman

    Zuppaman

    4.8
    (67 reviews)
    2.7 mi

    We were in town for a baseball tournament and knew we had to try Zuppaman after reading all the…read moreglowing Yelp reviews. They were absolutely right. It was a smaller store front, cozy and a hidden gem! The restaurant has so much personality, with years of awards proudly displayed throughout the dining room. Before the food even arrived, we knew we had found somewhere special. We started with the Bistro Onion Soup and the Red Pepper Lobster Bisque. French onion soup and lobster bisque are two of my all-time favorites, so my expectations were high. The Bistro Onion Soup absolutely delivered--rich, flavorful broth, perfectly tender onions, and an incredible blanket of melted cheese. Easily one of the best onion soups I've ever had. The Red Pepper Lobster Bisque was equally memorable. The sweetness of the roasted red peppers paired beautifully with the lobster, creating a unique twist that really worked. My husband and older son both ordered the Momma Mia. A spaghetti sandwich? We were intrigued! My son gave it a 9/10 and said it tasted like a lasagna sandwich. He'd order it again without hesitation. My youngest chose Ziggy the Piggy and declared it "the best sandwich I've ever had." That's high praise from a 10-year-old! He gave it a perfect 10/10, and the sandwich was nearly as big as his head. Honestly, reading the menu made us want to come back just to try everything else. Every item sounded delicious. What made the experience even better was the staff. They were warm, welcoming, and genuinely seemed to love what they do. That kind of hospitality is hard to fake, and it made us feel right at home. If you're passing through--or even if you're not--Zuppaman is absolutely worth the stop. We'll definitely be back the next time we're in town.

    After a jam packed morning of amusement at Cedar Point, we found Zuppaman - and that truly was the…read morebest part of the day! I had the Rueben and my husband and Ziggy the Piggy... oh my word they were both amazing! We wish we had been able to try the soup, but will definitely be back.

    Photos
    Zuppaman
    Shroom a zoom zoom
    Shroom a zoom zoom
    Popper sammich and Build Your Own Sandwich

    See all

    Popper sammich and Build Your Own Sandwich
    Shore House Tavern

    Shore House Tavern

    4.5
    (146 reviews)
    2.2 mi
    $$

    When in downtown Sandusky, you can't find better food, better service, nor a better vibe than Shore…read moreHouse Tavern. The place radiates friendliness and you truly feel like a regular when you walk in, warmly greeted right away and taken care of the entire duration of your meal. My family had returned after a long day of theme park food and I needed something lite - and their seasonal salad was just what I needed. It was a very generous portion with some of my the sweetest strawberries I've ever had with candied walnuts, feta cheese, and a delicious vinaigrette to go along with it. Skip the theme park dining when you can - or at the very least, supplement it with this delicious cuisine and friendly service.

    Our first night in Sandusky landed us in this small tavern right across Lake Erie…read more Very casual vibe and everyone was very accommodating but seemed overwhelmed. For an appetizer, we ordered the wedge salad and the Buffalo Chicken dip. I got the perch dinner for my main course. The kid got a chicken sandwich and my wife got the brisket Mac n cheese. They said that the kitchen was backed up. Honestly, it was totally not an issue. We were just relaxing, watching the game and chilling after a 7 hour drive from NJ. What was an issue was...... appetizers came out exactly the and time as the main courses. WHY????????? It couldn't have taken that long to throw blue cheese, bacon and tomatoes on a chunk of lettuce and pump out the Buffalo Chicken dip and then worry about the main courses later. Now we have to decide, do we want to eat the entrees or even touch the appetizers. That alone always ruins everything. Food was very good. Like I said, people were very nice but you just can't bring everything out at once. Defeats the point of "starting" with something.

    Photos
    Interior bar area
    Interior bar area
    Perch basket
    Perch basket
    Exterior

    See all

    Exterior
    Dockside Cafe

    Dockside Cafe

    4.3
    (225 reviews)
    2.3 mi
    $$

    Your establishment is truly an absolute treasure. The food was nothing short of spectacular, and…read morethe star of the show for me was undoubtedly that lobster roll truly out of this world.Your drink menu is seriously impressive too. And those Malibu buckets. What a blast. I actually made it my mission to try every single flavor you had on offer, and they were all fantastic and so much fun. I loved the relaxed vibe of the whole setup. It's super convenient how you just pop over to the outside window to place your order, and then grab your delicious food right by the bar. But the absolute best part was kicking back at one of your outdoor tables, right by the lake. It's such a perfect, serene setting to just unwind and enjoy the beautiful views. Honestly, your entire team really made the visit special everyone was so incredibly friendly and welcoming, which just added to the wonderful experience.

    This was our first trip to the Sandusky area and this place rated highly on here…read more We didn't realize until we arrived that this is essentially a glorified concession stand in a marina and not a "restaurant." Think snack bar at the roller rink or high school football game. Granted the menu is far from a snack bar and I do give them credit for aiming high with some pretty aspirational dishes. While other reviews suggest table service, that was not our experience. You ordered at the counter, given a pager, and fetched your food when the devices beeped incessantly. You buss your own table too. My wife ordered the lobster roll, which was rather competitively priced. Unfortunately, it was primarily filled with lettuce and tomatoes, with an OK amount lobster meat. She didn't care for the celery and green onion mixed in, not traditional lobster roll ingredients. I had the perch tacos, a first for me. Again, novel idea but lacking on execution. A few thin fish strips in each taco were more breading than fish. My wife couldn't have more than one sip of her cocktail and my IPA was warm. Anything waterside will have a natural appeal but the furniture and seating area is nothing more than a sidewalk. $61 for a serve yourself concession stand experience is more fitting for a stadium or sports arena.

    Photos
    Can't beat the view!!
    Can't beat the view!!
    Lobster roll, Rum Punch & Dockside iced tea!
    Lobster roll, Rum Punch & Dockside iced tea!
    Bucket drink

    See all

    Bucket drink
    The Fresh Pot

    The Fresh Pot

    4.0
    (4 reviews)
    2.1 mi

    This right here speaks to everything that's good and needs to survive as this is a small DIY…read moreoperation in a co-op kitchen! On this given night it was The Fresh Pot serving up all their goodies for those who come about as the days each of the vendors are in this kitchen are totally different so you gotta plan accordingly. Coming here with my friend we got the seafood boil it was a mix of crab legs potato's and some other goodies cooked fresh making for what you know was totally good! They have an abundance of other options as well so there is definitely something for everyone at The Fresh Pot so you really can't go wrong paying them a visit. Who knows when I'll come back for them but I know I'll definitely be back here to checkout another vendor because these small businesses are the ones we all should be going to! Overall yummy food good prices and a very friendly staff with all that you really can't go wrong coming here!

    Wow, I can't stop raving about the steam pot! It was so full of flavors; the fresh potatoes and…read morecorn, the perfectly seasoned sausage, the delicate crab legs, and the suprisingly flavorful hard boiled egg. The jambalaya was hands down the best I've ever had. Ordered the steak and it was so tender it cut with a butter knife. Will definitely be coming back to try everything on the menu! Super friendly service, found them through Groupon.

    Photos
    Vegan Hot Dog add toppings to it how you want it
    Vegan Hot Dog add toppings to it how you want it
    Chicken Philly cheesesteak sandwich, mouth watering chicken, cheese, peppers & onions, mayo, lettuce & delicious
    Chicken Philly cheesesteak sandwich, mouth watering chicken, cheese, peppers & onions, mayo, lettuce & delicious
    The kitchen

    See all

    The kitchen

    Grist Mill Wild Eats - newamerican - Updated July 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...