1. Great American Steak & Buffet

0

Pigeon Forge, TN

Cancel

Open app

Search

Great American Steak & Buffet

1.0 (1 review)

Great American Steak & Buffet Photos

Business Info

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Great American Steak & Buffet

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

12 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Steakhouses 4,598 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

The Appalachian - Hamburger and fries

The Appalachian

4.4(339 reviews)
4.8 mi
•$$$

We booked the Chef's Table for our anniversary, and everything was absolutely amazing. We have…read moredined at many high-end establishments, and The Appalachian does such a great job of delivering exceptional food and service without the pretentiousness that can sometimes come with it. Our chef for the evening, Derek, was a wealth of information. He could tell us where everything on our plates came from, from memory. The chefs at this restaurant are THAT attuned to the ingredients they're working with. He even described what made the wines work with the food and admitted he wasn't always a wine pairing believer, but has quickly become one. Our server, Amanda, was sweet, pleasant, and incredibly accommodating. This girl noticed me lifting my hair off my neck (those open woodfire grills add an extra level of heat to the kitchen) and brought me a hand fan FROM HER PURSE. That caused one of the kitchen team to notice and bring me an electric fan. Like I said, stellar service. Even the general manager, Dan, was involved in our service that evening. It truly felt like the entire team was paying attention and genuinely wanted us to have a wonderful experience. Would I recommend the restaurant? 100%. Would I recommend the Chef's Table experience? 1,000%. Being in the kitchen, watching the team operate like a well-oiled machine, and getting dishes that aren't on the menu (I'm looking at you, tuna tartare), made it well worth it. We will probably do it again in a different season to see how the menu changes. @serenity_now_travel_concierge

Of the 5 night we were in town, we visited The Appalachian 3 times - not just for the quality of…read morethe food, but also for the quality of the people. From ensuring they source fresh, seasonal ingredients to creating a welcoming atmosphere, it's obvious that everything is done with passion and attention to detail. The night we came in for dinner, we had the joy of having Mariah as our server. We had the fried chicken skins, the à la carte ribeye and sirloin, mashed potatoes, broccolini, and summer squash, and then the cobbler for dessert. The drinks were strong pours, everything was seasoned perfectly, and the service was impeccable. Another night, we came in for drinks and dessert and had the goat cheese cheesecake and Pots de Crème. If you're looking for a restaurant that's the perfect combination of great food and great vibes, this is absolutely it.

Photos
The Appalachian - View of the tables next to us

View of the tables next to us

The Appalachian - Pork belly and Fisherman's Stew

Pork belly and Fisherman's Stew

The Appalachian - Bone Marrow App.

See all

Bone Marrow App.

Local Goat - Voted best burgers 3 years running!

Local Goat

4.4(5.7k reviews)
1.7 mi
•$$
Family-owned & operated
Free parking

Stopped in pigeon Forge to see the smoky mountains for two days while trekking to Clarksville. I…read morehave never been to the area so I was blown away. It was like a little kid Las Vegas! They literally have every fast food and chain dining experience on one block, but I didn't know that at the time but I'm tired of road trip Food so wanted to sit down for a good meal! Pulling into the parking lot and I was overwhelmed because it was huge and very crowded! We go to the desk and they tell us 25 minutes. This place was huge and very accommodating, they were getting people to their tables fast! We noticed two empty seats at the bar, so we opted to take them and had the pleasure of being served by Robert. He was attentive, made sure our waters were always full. He gave recommendations on his favorite dishes and was all around a great bartender! The guy working the other end of the bar was equally as professional. The ambience is a dark cool vibe, little trendy but people were dressed pretty casually! Answer the most important thing...The food! For an app, we got the beer, cheese fondue that came with apples, bread and pretzels. The beer cheese had a little bit of ooomph to it, which was refreshing because usually I'm not a big mustard person. The pretzel bites were incredible crunchy on the outside and soft on the inside. The apples were fresh all around the appetizer for 3 to 4 people so we took extra home. I ordered the 10 ounce sirloin cooked, medium with the web sweet potatoes and a side Caesar salad for a three dollar charge which ended up being a full-size salad! It was super fresh and gigantic for a side salad. The steak was cooked perfectly, in the middle with an insane sear. Their house, butter that they put on it truly elevated the flavor profile. I tried the sweet potatoes mashed and they were enjoyable, but I do not enjoy a sweet side with my food so I knew I was going to donate them to my husband and he said they were incredible, the flavor was definitely there just not my cup of tea, but I knew that from the beginning . He got the Caesar salad with grilled chicken! It had so much flavor and tastes incredible but yet melted in your mouth it was the most tender chicken I've ever had in my life, and the flavor was all there! Not even the slightest bit of any kind of dryness. One of the best bites of chicken I've ever had.! He ordered the bison meatloaf to go, and that comes with caramelized mashed potatoes and fried onion straws.... It smells incredible and I will update when we try it . * UPDATE: best meatloaf ever!!! Based on the quality/ experience on a very busy night- everything was phenomenal and I will return. Service 10/5 Food 5/5 Ambiance 5/5 Value 5/5

Local Goat pros and cons Pros:…read more⁃ Comfortable booths after a long day at Dollywood ⁃ Great mascot ⁃ Wide selection of food ⁃ Great sirloin steak nice and buttery crisps ⁃ Not yet owned by Blake Shelton ⁃ Good salads that are finger licking good ⁃ Many items made in house ⁃ Bake potatoes are loaded ⁃ Patriot burger (I'm still saluting) Cons: ⁃ Took over 30 minutes for food to arrive ⁃ Parking is a bit wild

Photos
Local Goat - Mediterranean Salad with Grilled Salmon

Mediterranean Salad with Grilled Salmon

Local Goat - Shrimp and Grits

Shrimp and Grits

Local Goat - Teriyaki Chicken with rice and broccoli

See all

Teriyaki Chicken with rice and broccoli

JT Hannah's Kitchen - Chicken parm pasta

JT Hannah's Kitchen

3.7(996 reviews)
0.4 mi
•$$

I am shocked that this restaurant only has an average 3-star rating. It is a casual, pub-like…read moredining experience, which I love, with outrageously good food and stellar service. After joining the waitlist online before driving to the restaurant, we were seated immediately upon arrival at a high top in the bar area. I enjoyed the chill vibe. Our server was attentive, friendly, and helpful. I ordered the Hawaiian Ribeye. Our server said it was his favorite thing on the menu and I could see why. The steak was cooked perfectly. It was marinated in pineapple ginger sauce and then basted with teriyaki. It was absolutely juicy and delicious. I highly recommend this steak, which rivals the steaks at any of those over-priced steakhouses. The steak came with a salad and I chose the house lemon dressing. I continue to dream about this creamy, slightly salty dressing. They should definitely bottle it and sell it! I chose a baked sweet potato for a side and it was huge and unfortunately not cooked through, but I enjoyed the fully cooked parts. My husband ordered the Killin Me Burger, a full pound of meat with onion straws and thousand Island dressing on a brioche bun. He said it was the best burger he's ever had and my man knows his burgers! The bun was struggling, so my only suggestion is a sturdier bun. A really magnificent meal at a fun place! I've put it on my favorites list.

Well, my sister said good things about this restaurant before our visit. I know longer speak with…read moreher. I have never seen a restaurant so ill-equipped to handle a crowd. Service was slow, tables sat empty despite the huge wait list, and the bathrooms were small (for a large restaurant). Save yourself some aggravation. Pass this place by.

Photos
JT Hannah's Kitchen - Main dining area to right of hostess stand

Main dining area to right of hostess stand

JT Hannah's Kitchen - The Side Salad

The Side Salad

JT Hannah's Kitchen

See all

The Greenbrier Restaurant - The only vegetarian meal they had. Pasta was very good but the vegetables on top were not seasoned well.

The Greenbrier Restaurant

4.4(403 reviews)
6.6 mi
•$$$

Second visit, and they just changed the menu for fall today. Same atmosphere as before, wooden…read morefloors overlooking woods. My drink was the "Dylan" again and just as good as I remembered from last time. Started with meatballs and scallops. Meatballs sauce was good, wish meatballs had pine nuts but thats just my personal taste. Scallops were 2 bay scallops in a larger scallops shell, nice presentation and tasty but hard to get any of the sauce out with the scallops from those shells...but maybe i was supposed to pick up the shells and slide them into my mouth? Both filet and ribeye cooked perfectly and tasted amazing. We were too full for dessert.

My wife and I came here for a romantic dinner on our vacation, and we generally had a good time…read more First, we didn't have a reservation, but we didn't think it'd be much of an issue since we were coming on a weekday night. Bad assumption! We almost had to sit at the bar (which would have been OK, but we kind of wanted more privacy) but the hostess found us a high-top table. We had to drive up a big hill to get to the restaurant, so I assume the view outside is super nice, but we sat indoors to get away from the heat :) In general, our server did an OK job, but I do think she could have checked on us a little more, and the service felt quite slow. Our meal started with some complimentary spoonbread (which was pretty tasty!) and a Dylan cocktail for me, which took forever to come out. The Dylan was not really my cup of tea, it turns out - I guess I'm just a beer drinker at heart :) My wife got the Caesar salad for an appetizer and then we split the Beef Wellington for a shared entree. I sampled my wife's Caesar and it was very tasty! The Beef Wellington also took a long time to come out, but the wait was worth it, as it was very good! The beef was cooked medium rare as expected and the pastry was tasty. For our side, we chose broccolini and it was seasoned well. Despite the service hiccups, we had a good experience here. I would definitely consider coming back, and I'd recommend the Greenbrier to others.

Photos
The Greenbrier Restaurant - Front lobby fireplace

Front lobby fireplace

The Greenbrier Restaurant - Lemon sorbet palate cleanser

Lemon sorbet palate cleanser

The Greenbrier Restaurant - Entryway

See all

Entryway

Great American Steak & Buffet - steak - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...