I grew up in the neighborhood, but, now live on the west coast. I have been in Brooklyn for the last month and each time I drive down Coney Island Avenue I peek into this place. I am not Pakistani or Indian and while I love the food and have eaten, cooked and researched it for many years I am sometimes intimidated to order at a new place. I finally stopped in late night with a friend for tea and sweets. Everyone was friendly, and offered to help us right away. They treated us to samples and were wonderfully generous with information in a casual and inviting way.
We selected some sweets and even though they had already offered us a sample, the gentleman behind the counter said " you have to try this too... " and plunked an additional sweet on our plate. They moved us to the more formal dining room/ event space to sit - we would have been just as happy on the cafe / store side , but, I really appreciated it in the end because my friend and I had been looking for a place to really sit and talk for awhile... the service continued to be very personable and generous - with the server bringing us ANOTHER complimentary dish of rice pudding along with our chai tea which was unsweetened and a perfect compliment to our snacks. I wish I could name everything we had but I think we had Gajar Ki Burfi (which was delicate and clean- each flavor, carrot, almond etc present and distinct) , a few Ladoo (coconut one was our fave! and you could also taste a wonderful rose flavor), a sweet donut cut down the middle and filled with cream ... and a few others, everything was very delicate and I was happy things weren't dripping in jaggery ( I had bought a box of sweets from another place in the neighborhood last weekend and while I wanted to love them- they were cloying and relentlessly sweet and everything started to taste the same AND I had driven out to Iselin, NJ in search of new places and although the sweets out there were highly decorated in silver and well respected I still found them to be so so... ). In contrast Gourmet Sweets served up really beautiful individualistic gems!
My only regret is that I will have to wait until my next visit home to try more! and hope on my next trip to sample their savory dishes which looked great in the case. It is so rare to find a place to sit and talk and dine with friends in a relaxed way, this place is open 24 hours, which I feel is a true gift to those seeking a little place to be and grab a delicious affordable meal or snack. We peeked at the neighboring tables dinner and could smell the buttery naan as they ripped it apart. Beyond the great sweets I really have to say being welcomed by the staff, made to feel at home although we were obviously "tourist" eaters and met with such generosity and interest in sharing what they liked with us made this place a true standout. I want to thank them again and next time I will have cash on my to tip the counter workers. I am attaching a photo, but, please note the colored lights in the dining room make it hard to see how different each sweet was from one another. read more