Excellent lunch place! The chicken sandwich was amazing, it was juicy pulled flavorful chicken. The bread they use is homemade & pulls the entire sandwich together. Their chicken Cesar salad & soup was excellent as well. Definitely coming back next time I'm in town. Staff was very friendly. read more

Gorgers Subs - South of the border sandwich - Salad Near Me - Ithaca, New York

I've been here a few years, and this is my favorite spot in Ithaca! The bread is great.

My niece at Cornell told me about this place. Very nice people. They told us the history of the place. Subs were great. Got the chimichurri sub. Son got the hot chicken sub. Both were great. Couldn't eat half of the half sub. Portions are huge. Old school look to the place. Highly recommend this place. read more

Delicious subs in a convenient location. Fast service. Right next to Sweet Melissa's ice cream.

This had been a nice shop pre-pandemic where you could hole up at a wooden table and scarf dwon a bowl of chowder or a quite decent sandwich ... Unfortunately, in more recent times, the quality, especially calibre of meat; and the feeling of the service as well, just seemed to keep plummeting ... Then the last time I stepped in here the other day, still giving it a last chance; while I was waiting for my order I heard the clerk attempt to explicitly wheedle the promise of a tip in advance -- for a take-out order! -- from the customer who was up at the register ... The clerk acted as if doing so was part of taking the order , and I heard him say "And what you got for ME?" ?!?! I have to think my own days as a patron here are over ... If there's someone minding the store they should make sure they have good, working surveillance with audio, so that the culprit can hopefully be dismissed ... But it would take more than that to restore trust ... Otherwise they should take out the "R" in their sign & replace it with a "U" I'm afraid read more

I came up from NYC, and was in Ithaca seeing some friends. They recommended Gorgers. I was in there today @ around 12:30pm. Ordered the Bahn Mi medium. Not so much saracha, but a whole lotta Mayo. An hour in to my drive home I got very sick to my stomach w/violent bowel movements to say the least. Every 30-40mins I had to pull over to use the bathroom. This was not a fun ride home to NYC. I'm still reeling from it now. Something was clearly wrong on that sandwich today. Check your dates on your containers folks. Because I am very sick right now. One star only because I'm unable to give none. No one likes to get sick from an establishment. read more

So you want a sandwich? This is the spot and though things might seem pricey you are getting your moneys worth and then some. The sandwiches are sharable and of immense proportions and oh so tasty. I was just in ithaca for work but I know if I eas local thos would be a regular spot on my rotation... read more

Gorgers features a really good variety of sandwiches and small treats (doughnuts!), and offer vegetarian, vegan, and gluten free options, which was so nice to see. Their subs are so tasty and GIGANTIC. A large was about 14 inches long, and a small is half the size. Absolutely would recommend this stop! There's street parking right outside on State Street and we had no trouble finding a spot. Note that they only really have some outdoor seating available, so we decided to pack our sandwiches to take on a hike. read more

Gorgers Subs - Blue Fire Sub - Salad Near Me - Ithaca, New York

Fun and bohemian, Gorgers also has soup in the winter. This place reminds me of Polish restaurants in NYC's lower east side. Right near the commons. read more

Gorgers Subs - Salad Near Me - Ithaca, New York

What an amazing late lunch experience!! From the customer service to the incredible food, Gorgers is hands down the best place in downtown Ithaca to grab a quick bite to eat. Unlike many of the other establishments around this area, Gorgers is so budget friendly!! We went at a pretty awkward time (3:30), and we had a dinner reservation at 6, so we decided to only try a few of the sides. The wings and the fried pickles were phenomenal! Literally everything was homemade from the pickles to the ranch and the blue cheese dips! Next time I'm in Ithaca we will definitely be returning to try the subs which is what they're truly known for. I love Gorgers!!! read more

See all

I haven't been very impressed with my food experiences in Ithaca, but this was an exception. Gorgers has a large selection of sandwiches (tip: read them off the paper menu; the board is above the prep area is beautifully illustrated, but a touch hard to read). Our meal there included their banh mi sandwich, a chupacabra (sp?), a sweet thai chili chicken sandwich, and an order of bacon cheese fries. The sandwiches were all delicious. They come in 3 sizes: S, M, or L. Unless you are REALLY hungry, don't order the Large - the portions are generous. Even though none of us had had breakfast, our Medium size sandwiches were only half-eaten (they very kindly wrapped the remaining halves to go). The fries were tasty, but the bacon and cheese made it a bit hard to really taste the fries. I did SEE the freshly cut fries there ready to be fried, so I can tell you one thing for sure: they were homemade. Service is friendly, prompt, efficient, and skilled. They were very nice. One of our party, a resident of Ithaca, tells me that the staff there is not constantly changing, which ensures a high degree of consistency (often a problem in Ithaca). Would have given it a 4.5 if the system allowed. A really good place for subs in Ithaca (though pricier than others). Recommended read more

Terrible customer service. Change the oil in your fryer at LEAST every other week to 10 days. When fried pickles come out limp and soft burnt on the outside the oil is SPENT. Hint: you have to SCRUB or use boil out to actually clean the fryer. 30 YEARS cheffing. I could smell that the oil was old when we walked in. Used to LOVE your veggie ban mi. But man. Your employees don't CARE. And that oil left a coating in my mouth I had to swish with straight peroxide to get out. read more

Great and pretty convenient location. I am always thrilled when there are vegan options other than side of fries. The menu is fun and unique, we got a Modena sandwich and a vegan teriyaki w seitan sandwich. Service was super quick, felt like 10 mins from start to finish. The Modena was really yummy and the vegan one was great! I kinda wish it had more on it like some more veggies or something but the pineapple tasted really fresh and the sauce was great. The house-made seitan was in the form of crumbles and was really enjoyable! Great sammiches for the price, I would return! read more

Gorgers Subs - Szechuan Teriyaki Sub with seitan - Salad Near Me - Ithaca, New York

Excellent food. Medium sized "South of the Border" subs always knock me out. Best place to eat in Ithaca. Good service & awesome employees.

On a road trip and my fiancé had this pinned on the map for a stop. Loved the food, service was great, and ambiance was super relaxed. We tried their banh mi with pulled pork, bbq chicken sandwich, and fries. It was so delicious and portions were generous, so it definitely held us over for the rest of the drive. Definitely a good choice!! read more

I came to visit my friend at Cornell and she told me Gorgers was a must visit while I was here. You can order for takeout or delivery and there's street parking available on State Street. They feature a variety of sandwiches and doughnuts, and have vegetarian, vegan, and gluten free options. I'll be candid, my bar was set a bit low for Ithaca, but Gorges succeeded my expectations. It's around $10 for a packed foot long sub. I ate half of it and was already full. I ordered the Chupacabra ($10.79) and the combination of chipotle ranch and chimichurri sauce on the pork was so flavorful. The highlight of it was definitely the bread though: it was so soft and fluffy but firm enough where it doesn't get soggy. Also, the waitress at Gorges was so sweet and she even gave my friend and I free doughnuts! TLDR: Gorges is a must visit if you're at Cornell! Expect delicious, very filling, flavor packed subs! read more

Gorgers Subs - Doughnuts - Salad Near Me - Ithaca, New York

See all

I give this place a 4.5. But because it only allows whole stars, I went with 5. Too good to only give it a 4. I've only been once, just last night, but already want to visit again. I had the southwest chicken meal deal. The meal deal is a ~6" sub with fresh cut fries and a drink for $9.26. Had to have the apple topped cheesecake I saw in their cooler too. Everything was delicious. They make a lot of their own things in house, including the sub rolls. You definitely shouldn't pass this place. read more

holy moly, Yelp!!!!!! if it weren't for you, i would have NEVER walked into the place. we visited this sub shop like 2x during our trip to Ithaca. there's a lot to choose from in the area, but most of the choices are mehhhhh and mediocre food. we came back here because: - the staff is friendly, helpful and kind. - their Banh Mi sandwiches were bommmmmmb (yes, Banh Mi!!!) - menu is creative and there's something for everyone (diff flavor profile) - housemade coconut mocktails were *chef's kiss* I had the Shrimp and Pulled Pork Banh Mi's. yes, yes, yes and so much yes. I highly recommend getting the special; it comes with 1/2 sub, chips (freshly fried) and a drink. eat it outside at one of their al fresco tables. 100% in love. read more

See all

So amazing. Fresh made sub bread every day that doesn't scratch the roof of my mouth!! Perfect spicy sweet. Salad is so good I want to make out with it. And portions are huge. Definitely with the money and so so so good. Super friendly guy and great music. read more

See all

I love Gorgers so much. Undoubtedly the best sandwich in Ithaca, maybe all of New York. Certainly the best spot for food in Ithaca, and one of my favorite all time restaurants. The quality cannot be understated, this place is amazing. read more

This place is tew good. I went there for the first time with a few friends on a whim before a basketball game, and all I can say is that I wish I had known about it sooner. I ordered the Chupacabra, which came with pulled pork, chimichurri, and chipotle ranch (plus some veggies). It was so scrumptious... i'm dying to go back again! Only critique is that they could've added more sauce to the sandwich, but otherwise, I ate it uppp. Also, apparently, they bake the bread fresh every 3 hours!!!! yum read more

Wonderful place, very busy, they do have tables outside to sit at and eat. The food was delicious and the bread is homemade. They have vegetarian options as well. Must try if you in the area. read more

Banh Mi - 6" is large and delicious. There are so many subs to choose from and I am thrilled with my choice! read more

If you are in the Ithaca area, this is the place to stop for lunch. The subs are so tasty - they make their bread fresh. My ten year old thought the bread was his favorite part of the meal and I can't disagree, though my pulled pork was yum. Kudos for only allowing 1 customer at a time in the store at the counter. Ding for having an iPad credit card machine that requires you to use your fingers to sign - gross in this Covid situation. read more

Gorgers Subs - Counter menu - Salad Near Me - Ithaca, New York

This is a place that you must go after a nice walk at downtown Ithaka. During this hard sick times this venue provide a nice tropical vibe. Staff is very cordial and make you feel welcome. A.most place to visit. read more

Gorgers Subs - Main entrance Gorges Subs - Salad Near Me - Ithaca, New York

Great service even when short staffed. Amazing portion sizes. Well worth the price. Restaurant interior is cool, but if you have a large party be prepared to find seating elsewhere. read more

Every time I get lunch at Gorgers, I'm floored by the quality of their sandwiches. Service is always perfect too. Amazing!!

One of the best sandwich shops in Ithaca. It doesn't look like much from the outside, but their shrimp po' boy got me craving for more. read more

See all

Delicious local eatery. We're visiting the area to do outdoors activities and came upon it. We tried the Caribbean, pulled BBQ pork and Teriyaki. The medium sub was huge (9 in). I did eat it all but I could've done fine with a small (6 in). The Caribbean had a nice kick of spicy heat and nice subtle ginger flavor. Loved it with the purple cabbage and lettuce. The teriyaki sub was divine with caramelized onions and pineapples. Pulled BBQ pork was good too. read more

See all

Stopped by in area for lunch and was not disappointed. Great bread and great sandwiches for the price. Thanks to the fellow reviewers for recommending this spot. read more

I can't stop thinking about the sandwiches at Gorgers. If you're looking for a legit 12" sub packed w/ ingredients - Gorgers Subs is your place. We stopped by after two morning hikes, and while we were starvin', we were totally overwhelmed by the size of these sandwiches when they came out. Gorger's does not mess around. There's over 20 sandwiches to choose from on the menu + a few salads and sides. I settled on a modified Chicken Bacon Ranch and the gal behind the counter had no problemo swapping out ranch for caesar dressing. For just under $10 I got the softest hero roll everrrrrrr + tons of shredded chicken + a mountain of bacon + and all the crispy lettuce I could handle. It took so long for me to finish, and I was so full - but I couldn't let this sandwich go to waste. So so good. A couple other notes: Homemade lemonade and tea are $2.50, water bottles $1. The inside of this spot isn't anything fancy... we took our sandwiches to go and ate down the block at a table in the Ithaca Commons. read more

Gorgers Subs - modified chicken/bacon/ranch. - Salad Near Me - Ithaca, New York

See all

First time here and really enjoyed! Banh Mi , Fries and Sweet Thai Chili Sandwich are really tasty. Impressed :) Service is also great! read more

Great tasty sandwiches with so many choices. We tried the hummus and the caribbean fire subs. Good option if you are looking for a quick lunch read more

Stopped in close to closing time but still greeted with super friendly staff. I chose the Philly which didn't have much flavor at all, though the bread was delicious. I think I'll give this place another go though as reviews tell me I likely made the wrong choice in sandwiches. read more

I initially came here because this place was highly rated on Yelp and I needed a quick lunch in between meetings. The portions are big, so I definitely didn't leave feeling hungry. So, let's start with the good. It's conveniently located around the corner from the Green St. bus stop, so if you're coming into town by bus, this is a convenient place to stop in for a bite before or after a long bus ride. The staff seemed friendly. There are a lot different sandwiches, salads, and soups to pick from. And, the portion size is big, which is great that they offer a lunch special (half sandwich and a small soup)- great in the sense if you don't want to overstuff yourself- all for about $10. I also thought the French Onion Soup was pretty good. Now, onto the bad. One of the sandwiches they're known for is the Bánh mì. For anyone who has eaten a traditional Bánh mì knows that it's made with a French baguette. The bread is what makes the Bánh Mi so good. But, they don't make it with a French baguette. Instead, they make it with the sub roll that they make all of their sandwiches with and that was the let-down. Something was off about the sandwich. I didn't get the crunch from biting into it. To be fair, the sandwich wasn't terrible. It was stuffed with lots of pulled pork, but the bread wasn't great and the sauce from the pulled pork made the already-soft sub bread soggy. Would the bread have still been soggy if it was a baguette? Maybe or maybe not as much. I may decide to drop by if I'm ever back in the area. I wouldn't mind trying some of the other items on their menu, but I definitely won't order the Bánh mì again. read more

See all

Excellent hot subs, cozy ambiance and friendly staff-what else can you ask for? Delicious

Ate three bites of the banh mi and tossed it. The bread is mushy and bland. No better than a gas station. The ingredients were over powered by the hoisin sauce. read more

Gorgers Subs - Salad Near Me - Ithaca, New York

Gorgers is an Ithaca classic. I've been coming here for years, and I always seek to make a stop here when I'm in town. All of their subs are vegetarian-friendly (and tasty!) as they offer a fried eggplant substitute. Their Buffalo panda wings are delicious as well, I'll still order these even though I'm not a vegetarian any more. read more

I have been going here for years and it's always a great lunch! Much appreciation for Gorgers

Nice people, but super hot inside in summer. There was limited seating outside. We took our sandwiches to the park and ate. I had pulled pork and it was good. A lot of bread, but I love bread. My husband had a chicken sandwich and said it was okay. read more