A little pricey, perhaps, but worth it as an occasional treat. Excellent subs! I've had about half the varieties on the menu and loved them all. Tonight it was the Modena. Last time it was the Cuban. Yum! read more

FANTASTIC SERVICE and incredible donuts. The bread is made in house, very pillowy yet substantial. The prices are extremely affordable and the portions great. I got the coconut shrimp sandwich which was crispy but i believe very overshadowed by the bread itself. It tasted mostly of vinegar and perhaps could've benefited from more shrimp or a balance of ingredients. The donuts were phenomenal! Chewy, soft, squishy, and full of flavor from the dough. I very much recommend them! read more

See all

The sandwiches are amazing! As a vegetarian, I really appreciate that any sandwich can be made vegetarian. The homemade seitan is a delicious meat substitute and definitely worth trying. read more

Great friendly staff and service. French fries: Hand cut. A little over done but very good. Fried pickles: fresh and very good with nice ranch dipping sauce. Shrimp po boy: fresh baked bread with nice crunch. All flavors worked well. Could have used more shrimp. Overall solid. Buffalo chicken: fresh baked bread. Sauce is a good classic Buffalo but shredded chicken lacking flavor and a little dry. Average. Tried multiple house made sauces and they were all excellent. Prices reasonable and staff is great which pushed my review to 4 stars. Sandwiches can get better. Will return. read more

See all

My sister and I were headed to a show across the street and wanted a bite to eat before the show. The box office suggested Gorgers to get a quick bite. It's a small spot I figured go grab a sub thinking usual deli food but this place was not that. They had chicken, pork or beef subs several different ones to choose as well as sides. The staff was only 2 people. The one person was getting things together the other was waiting on people, packaging and also preparing food. They were very busy maybe could have used one or two more people any way. They ran out of bread after my order so my sister had hers put over fries. You can get everything prepared as a sandwich or a bowl which is a great option. I ordered the Stallone which was steak cheese lettuce and balsamic. I ordered double fried French fries and some donuts that were basically fried dough in cinnamon sugar. My sister ordered cheese steak over fries. She mentioned the cheese sauce was cold and not much steak. My sandwich had a good amount of steak would have liked a little more but flavor was great, bread was very good fries were crispy and delicious. Donuts were about what you'd expect. All in all it was pretty good. I'd try it again on a not so busy night. read more

Gorgers Subs - Menu board - Chalkboard menu with handwritten food options at Gorgers Subs in Ithaca, NY, featuring diverse cuisines and sandwich options. - Salad Near Me - Ithaca, New York

See all

We arrived around 2-3pm in the afternoon on a weekday and the place was empty. We ordered a medium sub each, and panda wings ( eggplant). The wings were so good, and we thought very fair portion for the price - great tang on the Buffalo sauce and the eggplant was fried well and not overly greasy. The sandwiches were both great . We're both a bit of bread / sandwich snobs being from Philly and their house baked rolls met pit standards :) we were pretty full after eating half of our medium sub, and brought the other half home for dinner. We would have been roll me home STUFFED if we finished the medium Great sandwich shop, I would recommend based on our one visit ! read more

See all

After two visits in a space of days, this place quickly became a favorite of mine. A mere FIVE stars are definitely not adequate! Strolling down State Street one early morning, I noticed a guy in the window of a sub shop rolling out dough, placing it in a baguette pan, obviously in preparation for baking. Whoa! Fresh baked sub rolls. Needless to say, I made it a point to stop back for lunch. As it happened, my first day at Gorgers was also the first day for Lilly, their new cashier. Lilly and all the staff were really friendly and welcoming. I got the Blue Fire sub, which was excellent. A great balance of spiciness and blue cheese creaminess. Deputy Yelper got the Po' Boy, which she pronounced as excellent, too. Great value for the money. Only after ordering did I notice that the menu (very discretely) says that all subs can be made with eggplant or house made seitan. How cool is that? I discussed this with Bart, the owner - he wanted to know if I was satisfied with the flavor balance in the sub - which I was, and I promised I'd be back. On a return visit later in the week, Bart immediately recognized me from before, and recommended the Seitan version of the Mushroom & Swiss sub. Let me just say that my Deputy Yelper, upon tasting Seitan sub, conceded that her long-held dislike of seitan was a serious mistake. Definitely a home run! Take note all vegetarians and vegans. Not only is there the house-made seitan and house-baked rolls, they have an espresso machine. So along with a delicious sub, you can pick up a latte. It doesn't get better! read more

One of my favorite places in Ithaca! They have such a vast variety of subs which are stuffed with fresh ingredients too. My favorites are their Buffalo Chicken and Bahn Mi subs. The Buffalo Chicken is well seasoned, moist, and tender. It's then loaded with lettuce, tomatoes, and onions that add a series of textures and freshness. The Red Hot sauce and Blue Cheese accompany each other so well to provide that perfect heat and tanginess. Their Bahn Mi sub is definitely not your traditional báhn mì, but a really good sandwich nonetheless. The bread was perfectly warm with a crispy exterior and chewy and soft interior. The pulled pork is also tender and juicy, and I love the additions of pickled carrots and cilantro to cut the fattiness and grease of the pork. The Mushroom and Swiss sub was less flavorful in my opinion, and the shredded grilled steak was dry and didn't seem marinated. The addition of the swiss wasn't very homogenized with the steak either. The Chicken Bacon Ranch was okay, but felt very very heavy afterwards. The Po'Boy was also decent. Overall, this is a great place for subs, and I highly recommend trying it out! They also have vegetarian options that are also good. read more

Gorgers Subs - Buffalo Chicken Sub - A sandwich with fresh lettuce, tomato slices, and shredded vegetables in a white bread roll, placed on brown paper. - Salad Near Me - Ithaca, New York

When in Rome...or this case Ithaca. Wow what a sandwich! The bread is baked fresh in house all while orders are being taken and food is being prepared. They seemed short staffed on this Saturday lunch hour and had a jammed order printer. Despite the issues and a line out the door they were fast and kind. The sandwiches were yum. We got a BBQ chicken and a chicken bacon ranch. There are lots of choices including vegetarian. Do NOT forget the double fried fries; amazing. Their house coconut lime aid was delicious according to my partner. This place is legit and great post hike at Buttermilk. read more

Gorgers Subs - View while I wait to order what I told is the best sandwich in town - The image shows the inside of a bakery or sandwich shop with bread bags, a baking tray with dough, and various supplies visible through a glass window. - Salad Near Me - Ithaca, New York

So delicious! Everything was perfect, well worth going out of your way to try it. Buffalo shrimp poppers were amazing texture and flavor without being too spicy. The subs had everything you'd want--complementary textures, delicious soft bread, unique flavors and solid portions. Great vegetarian options by offering seitan in any sub, which was well-cooked. Service was friendly and quick. read more

See all

Absolutely amazing banh mi. Maybe best I ever had. Every part of it was delicious. The pork, the cilantro, pickled veggies, bread and sauce. Top tier fries. Rap and hip hop playing in the restaurant. 10/10 read more

See all

Original food made fresh and original combinations of ingredients. Sauces are different and good. Friendly staff and they have put items on the menu when we requested them. Great guys read more

If I had three, thumbs, I'd give them all up!! We really enjoyed these subs. Easy, quick and right on the main promenade. Lots of choices. Thank you Gorgers! read more

This turned out to be a really fun place. We're just walking through downtown Ithaca literally just trying to see what we can find to eat. We see this place from the outside and go in and have a look! It's a bit tight inside and they are thoroughly working hard behind the counter. But we were helped by a friendly lady who let us thoroughly grill her about the menu. I settled on the bonh mi Vietnamese sandwich. Was so good! Just full of flavor and ingredients and definitely worth the price. The baguette was so fresh and I thoroughly remember just how soft and tasteful it was. One of the best I've ever had! We sat outside and just thoroughly enjoyed the sights. Definitely will try this place again next time I return to Ithaca! read more

Gorgers Subs - Banh mi - A banh mi sandwich on a white baguette, garnished with cilantro, shredded carrots, and cucumber slices, with a background of pink paper. - Salad Near Me - Ithaca, New York

I came at 7:15p on Saturday while store closes at 8p. They tell me they are out of all sandwiches. That's it. Nada. It's one thing to run out of a particular meat or dish but to be completely out of everything shows me a poorly run business. Arguably you can say it's excellent bc they sold out for the day but this establishment has been there for a while to plan better read more

The lady was very friendly toward customers. We enjoyed our subs. I wished that we had known about this place earlier so I would've visited more. read more

Service extremely fast and the food is incredible. Might be one of the best sandwich spots I've ever eaten at. So much variety and options for everyone, I've already tried 5 different options and all just blow it out of the water. Best place in town! read more

Most delicious! Hubby had a Cuban Man Salad. Lots if veggies, meat, over French fries. I had a Bahn Mi over Jasmine rice. Serious deliciousness!! read more

Gorgers Subs - The menu - A black chalkboard menu displays food options with handwritten text, decorated with stickers and a cartoon pig illustration, in a restaurant setting. - Salad Near Me - Ithaca, New York

This place is amazing. The menu behind the counter was outdated so they had all of the options on paper. Between the banh mi and the South of the border we had two massive sandwiches to split. The real winner HAS to be their little doughnuts. They have cinnamon & sugar and Maple glazed. They are little round balls of heaven. We got the 6 pack and they were so light and airy and amazing. If you're not feeling a sandwich - there were salads, vegetarian options, and other sides on the menu. Anyone could easily find something here to enjoy. DEFINITELY will be back read more

Gorgers Subs - South of the border - Salad Near Me - Ithaca, New York

This place is the best! In town for a work trip and went in for a quick lunch and my food was ready within 5 minutes. The place itself has a nice Ithaca feel to it and the lady at the counter was the sweetest. Will definitely come back if I have future trips here! My salad was DELICIOUS too! read more

Gorgers Subs - Chipotle Bacon Salad - A takeout salad contains black beans, cilantro, chopped vegetables, and two containers of dressing, served in a brown cardboard box. - Salad Near Me - Ithaca, New York

Found Gorgers on Yelp. Did not disappoint. Love that the menu up on the wall has been left unchanged for many years, you have to order from paper menu on counter. The homemade bread is sooo good. Plenty of fillings in the subs. Bacon was plentiful and cooked perfectly. The house made drink was refreshing but not too sweet. The workers were so pleasant. Wish we lived closer, this would be our sub shop!!! Oh. And the french fries, possibly the best i have ever had. Actual potatoes. Perfectly crisp. Perfectly salted. Yum. read more

Came to Ithaca because I'm a flight attendant and had a layover here. Wasn't gonna get food but decided to check out this sandwich place anyway. Glad I did cause wow!! The people working were very nice and very welcoming. I ordered a small teriyaki chicken sandwich and let me tell you, it's NOT small!!!! I was debating getting a medium and I'm glad I didn't. Couldn't even eat the small one. Haha!! It came on the softest most delicious bread I've ever had with shredded chicken, onions and grilled pineapple pieces in a teriyaki sauce. The pineapple was a bit too sweet but still really good. I think that combo would be AMAZING in a honey bbq sauce. Still good with the teriyaki tho. The place itself was small. At first I thought it was closed cause I didn't see lights or anything but that's probably cause it was very bright outside. They have a few tables against the wall where you can sit and eat and I do suggest you stay. Soak in all the yummy smells coming from the grill right next to you. Would definitely come back if I'm here again. Great job Gorgers!! read more

Gorgers Subs - Teriyaki chicken sandwich - Salad Near Me - Ithaca, New York

I came here a few days ago after not coming here for about a year, and I'm still convinced that Gorgers makes the best sandwiches in town. Even better - no one seems to know about this place and there were about three people in the entire restaurant on a Saturday evening. I got the banh mi, which was absolutely enormous despite me getting a 9 inch "medium" option. I eat a lot of Banh Mis at home, and Gorgers' take on it was quite good. It definitely has some differences - they put way more meat and carrots on the one here. Honestly, I think the sandwich might be better if they put a little less filling in the sandwich (and mixed the ingredients together so that I wasn't taking bites of only meat/carrot). However, it was still bussin. Service is always super fast and awesome read more

What a fabulous little hole in the wall! My partner and I split a delicious Bahn Mi sandwich. I should've gone with a larger size because it was so so so good! And really good service. read more

This comfortable hole-in-the-wall delivers on every bite. On a recent visit to Ithica, I was looking for somewhere to fill my teenage son up, and we were pleasantly surprised by our experience. Seating is limited, but the food is exceptional. The Bahn Mi was one that I will now use as the fold standard. Also, while it might sound easy to make, their fries were cooked to perfection and were spot-on! read more

Best subs around! I love the fresh meats and vegetables. I had the best Cuban sandwich around here. I highly recommend this Real Deli shop!

My husband and I shared: - Caribbean Fire - Pork Banh Mi - Chupacabra Between the three, the Chupacabra was my favorite. All three were good though. They were a bit inconsistent though, some bites were dry and others had a ton of sauce. Be ready for a lot of bread. Everyone raves about the banh mi and we loved the sandwich, just don't expect a classic banh mi. The bread is a soft sub bread, not a crispy baguette. This is a great stop for lunch in Ithaca. read more

See all

Amazing! Yummy bread . I got the steak mushroom swiss . The doughnut was the perfect dessert.

It's hard to find a local restaurant that care's so much about the quality and originality of their food. The fact that they make as far as I can tell everything in house is mind blowing to me. We love their bread, but when you want something lighter get it as a salad and boom you have hands down one of the best salads in Ithaca. Staff, food, and service are all just excellent. read more

I've been here a few years, and this is my favorite spot in Ithaca! The bread is great.

My niece at Cornell told me about this place. Very nice people. They told us the history of the place. Subs were great. Got the chimichurri sub. Son got the hot chicken sub. Both were great. Couldn't eat half of the half sub. Portions are huge. Old school look to the place. Highly recommend this place. read more

Pretty good sandwiches, especially the Banh Mi. The soup was well made as well and fries were good. I would pass on the special drinks in the fridge though, those weren't particularly good. read more

See all

We came here after driving up from NYC area, and after stopping by the Ithaca falls for a quick lunch. And I was soo impressed with their sandwiches! I ordered the Banh Mi and the Shrimp Po' Boy. Our favorite was definitely the Banh Mi! At first I was skeptical of getting the Banh Mi because it was the only Asian sandwich on the menu. But I was so impressed with the flavoring they were able to pack into that sandwich with the perfectly tender pulled pork. To be honest, I'm usually not a fan of pulled pork. But I finished every last bit of that sandwich! The size of the sandwich was also massive. Could have easily shared between two people honestly. The Shrimp Po' Boy was a bit on the greasy side and the shrimp was a bit overcooked, but still was a decent sandwich. Definitely coming back here for the Banh Mi if we're ever up in Ithaca again though! They had a couple of tables for outside dining on the sandwich. But we just ordered to-go online. Definitely order ahead because they are popular and busy! read more

Gorgers Subs - Inside - Salad Near Me - Ithaca, New York

See all

Delicious subs in a convenient location. Fast service. Right next to Sweet Melissa's ice cream.

So you want a sandwich? This is the spot and though things might seem pricey you are getting your moneys worth and then some. The sandwiches are sharable and of immense proportions and oh so tasty. I was just in ithaca for work but I know if I eas local thos would be a regular spot on my rotation... read more

Little but Mighty! This place is fantastic! No indoor seating but OH the food! The sub bread is amazing. So soft on the inside. All subs are offered in bowl over rice, as a salad or over French fries. The fried pickles come with the most delicious dill dipping sauce. The portions are very generous and the prices are reasonable. Service was great. I highly recommend read more

See all

Excellent lunch place! The chicken sandwich was amazing, it was juicy pulled flavorful chicken. The bread they use is homemade & pulls the entire sandwich together. Their chicken Cesar salad & soup was excellent as well. Definitely coming back next time I'm in town. Staff was very friendly. read more

Gorgers Subs - South of the border sandwich - A sandwich featuring shredded chicken, sliced jalapeños, onions, and cilantro on a bun, served on brown paper at a restaurant. - Salad Near Me - Ithaca, New York

This had been a nice shop pre-pandemic where you could hole up at a wooden table and scarf dwon a bowl of chowder or a quite decent sandwich ... Unfortunately, in more recent times, the quality, especially calibre of meat; and the feeling of the service as well, just seemed to keep plummeting ... Then the last time I stepped in here the other day, still giving it a last chance; while I was waiting for my order I heard the clerk attempt to explicitly wheedle the promise of a tip in advance -- for a take-out order! -- from the customer who was up at the register ... The clerk acted as if doing so was part of taking the order , and I heard him say "And what you got for ME?" ?!?! I have to think my own days as a patron here are over ... If there's someone minding the store they should make sure they have good, working surveillance with audio, so that the culprit can hopefully be dismissed ... But it would take more than that to restore trust ... Otherwise they should take out the "R" in their sign & replace it with a "U" I'm afraid read more

i got the medium chupacabra and it was really good. perfect portion for one hungry person! i think if i got a small, it would not have been enough! the mix of the chipotle and chupacabra sauce is amazing! next time, i will order extra sauce on the sub! the service was really fast and i didn't have to wait long at all. the lady at the front register was very friendly. it's a must-have in ithaca because of the fresh bread subs! i always recommend to people who come to ithaca! read more

Gorgers Subs - medium Chupacabra Sub - Salad Near Me - Ithaca, New York

I'm a carbaholic through and through. Even though I'm a vegan, one of my favorite things is and always has been a delicious hunk of break with a delicious hunk of meat, and Gorgers delivers. Any sub can be made with seitan which is loaded onto an amazing sub roll to the point that you really have to stretch your mouth to take a bite. The sub rolls are made fresh in house daily. They do no have vegan cheese, so I just ordered subs that did not include cheese because I hate paying full price when I've omitted ingredients. Well, this strategy worked perfectly because the chimichurri sub is probably the best one on the menu. Caution - it can be very oily sometimes, but it is delicious and bursting with fresh herby goodness. Second best is the Blue Fire, a spicy sweet mustardy sauce. The Sweet Thai chili is also tasty and features pineapple, but ordering three 12 inch subs is something we cannot do again. Oh, and the FRIES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Some of the best french fries we have every had. Have to get those fries. Ithaca is truly an awesome vegan destination and Gorgers is part of that. Ordering on-line is a cinch and you can choose "vegan" for any item. There is some sidewalk seating. Masks are required. They can bring the order out to you or you can go in and grab your paper bag full of goodness. read more

Gorgers Subs - Take -out! - Salad Near Me - Ithaca, New York

See all