Cerrito's, CA
There is something about a good old fashioned, old school donut shop, that just makes a good solid donut with out all of the frills.
Honestly, donuts are not on my regular list of weekly or even monthly purchases but I might* purchase a single donut for myself every few months as a splurge...who doesn't love a good donut every once in a while? Goody's donuts was on my radar ever since I read Elite Yelper Derek W.'s review of Randy's donuts in Pasadena, CA in which he references Goody's Donuts and their apple fritter as being one of the best he's tried.
I visited a few weeks ago and I am embarrassed to say I have visited 3 times since, or maybe that's a testament to how good the donuts really are, I don't know...but this madness has to stop. I do know where I will be the next time I want to treat someone to a good old fashioned non foo foo donut.
So I tried what looked good to me when I walked in the door, I thought I wanted a raised sugar twist before I walked in, but it was a standard raised round donut dusted with sugar crystals that caught my eye, one bite and I did not think any other donut could beat this out. The dough is almost teetering on being similar to a brioche in taste, fluffy, airy, but substantial...I enjoyed every bite while sitting in my parked car, as the world just seemed to stop for a few seconds. This donut reminded me of a Portuguese Malasada. I also brought home the sugar twist which I think may be a different dough, rolled by hand and crispier and more dense, not your usual raised sugar twist, and a glazed cinnamon roll. I was even short on change but the nice owner Tony gave them for me to try anyway, but I did not forget and brought him some extra change to make up for it on my next visit. I shared the cinnamon roll with my husband the next day and also tasted both, and while they were good they did not beat out that raised round sugar donut.
So on the next visit, with my extra change in hand, I was a greedy gretchen and ordered two round sugar raised donuts all for myself, and enjoyed them both in the car before I drove off. When my husband found out I did not pick up his favorite donut, a maple bar, for him (donuts are really not his thing either so this request caught me by surprise), I had to make it to Goody's Donuts a third time just a few days later so I could redeem myself from my utterly selfish behavior. When I called ahead late morning (they close at 12:30 pm) to make sure they still had raised round sugar and maple bars, I walked in and I ordered and Tony even guessed my order 2 sugar raised round donuts, 2 maple bars. I added in a last maple old fashioned for good measure $5.50 out the door with the .50 cent credit card/ATM sur charge which generally might bother me but not for this shop since the offerings are so reasonably priced. My husband and I each had a round and a maple donut, and I cut off an edge of the old fashioned maple for a taste...but the round raised sugar donut is still my clear favorite.
After all of these donut spurges I have to take a break....and I didn't even make it to trying Derek W.'s suggested apple fritter which does look enticing! I will save the apple fritter tasting for another day.
Aside from trying what I might consider near donut perfection in that sugar round raised donut, Tony is the nicest man and just makes the donut buying experience that much more fun! read more