Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Goodfella’s

    2.7 (7 reviews)
    Open 9:00 am - 9:00 pm

    Goodfella’s Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Goodfella’s

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    27 days ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of David E.
    173
    27
    3

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Goodfella’s

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Italian 1,473 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Cow Patty's

    Cow Patty's

    4.1
    (119 reviews)
    2.3 mi

    We love this place! My daughter who lives in TN loves a good burger and has a vegetarian finance…read more Everyone found something to eat here that we absolutely loved! Our vegetarian opted for the build your own burger. Veggie burger on a pretzel bun w/ pallet jack, chipotle mayo, fries, frizzled onions and avocado. He loved it! My daughter and I split an order of pierogies and the amazing bacon onion marmalade burger. They even cut it up for us from the kitchen and put it on separate plates (love the attention to detail and service) My mother daughter truly enjoyed her pineapple jalapeños burger and was in heaven. Not too much heat but just the right amount of kick. Hubby is trying to be more health conscious so he opted for the Brie & Apple turkey burger. He said it was very well seasoned and enjoyed it thoroughly. We all took a sip or two of the peanut butter shake and left happy! The service was great and we complimented the owner his beautiful flowers and decor.

    Cow Patty's is a fun little burger joint right off the main drag in Wantage. And I say right off…read morebecause as you pull in and out of the parking "lot," you're doing so onto NJ-23. Be prepared! Inside, we were met with a kind staff and a delicious lunch. The boomin bloomin onion was a favorite for our crew, with the typical blooming onion sauce you know and love from the steak chains. What differentiated it was the thin slicing of the onions, which made it easier to just keep dipping a little bit more. The only letdown of the meal, which was a relative letdown given how solid the burgers and onion were, was the fries. They didn't have flavor, even though I got mine with Cajun seasoning and my wife got hers with a beer cheese dip. They need to punch up the salt fresh out of the fryer to really let the other seasonings shine. We actually overheard another table say the same thing after we finished our fries, so I don't think it was just a fluke order. That said, if you're nitpicking over the sides at the burger and shake place, I'd say you're going to the wrong places! This was a tasty meal and a stop I'd easily go back to if I was nearby.

    Photos
    Cow Patty's
    California bacon burger
    California bacon burger
    Chocolate Milk Shake!!!

    See all

    Chocolate Milk Shake!!!
    The Butcher’s Grill

    The Butcher’s Grill

    4.5
    (71 reviews)
    4.4 mi
    $$

    Butcher's Grill is always such a tasty surprise! Second time here and it never lets me down!!!The…read morefood was absolutely delicious and came out super quick. If you don't want your entrées coming out with the appetizers, just give them a heads up, because the kitchen moves fast here. We started with the mushroom dish and a hearty soup...both full of flavor and the perfect start to the meal. Then came the star of the night: the lamb chops. Perfectly seasoned, cooked just right, and melt-in-your-mouth good. Everything we tried was fresh and satisfying, the kind of food that makes you want to go back the next day. The service was on point- Friendly and attentive, and the whole space has this quirky, cozy feel, like you're sitting in your grandma's living room with its mix of chairs and warm, homey vibe. It's also BYOB, which is always a win. We brought a bottle of wine that paired perfectly with the meal. Overall, Butcher's Grill is a must-visit if you're in the area. Great food, quick service, and a cozy atmosphere that makes it stand out. Can't wait to come back!

    Overall cute whole in the wall butcher shop restaurant. They were very nice but the food was okay…read more Husband for the rib eye and he said it was great. Everything else (chicken, salmon, burger) was overcooked. I would stick to the steaks. Seems like their speciality. The food presentation was great tho! And seems like locals love it. We came for an early dinner so they were able to accommodate us but it was busy by the time we left.

    Photos
    The Butcher’s Grill
    Steak showcase
    Steak showcase
    The Butcher's cheese burger

    See all

    The Butcher's cheese burger
    Olluco Bistro

    Olluco Bistro

    4.6
    (36 reviews)
    3.2 mi

    Happened to find this place thanks to Yelp. Everything is fresh made, the people were really nice…read moreand the food was good excellent! Fries, salad and sides were awesome! Loved this place and will definitely return.

    Ummm hello? This is my new jam when I'm in town. What?! Real food, seasoned perfectly, and fall off…read morethe bone. And wait wait, I can get plantains, near Sussex?! I've been blessed ! Olluco offers homemade bbq, and some extras that will make you happy. The prices are decent too. For me, traveling with the kids is always tough because eventually you need to find real protein.....they can't survive on pizza and hot dogs for very long. We came here and got the chicken and Peruvian fried rice. The rice had great flavor and lots of veggies(peppers, zucchini, etc...). The chicken was seasoned PERFECTLY and so tender, like even the breast was juicy! We also got ribs and they were fall off the bone!! Yes finally, ribs that are seasons with a delicious rub(no need for sauce) and also fall off the bone tender. Yummo!! The place is very shack-esc lol...there's no decor and maybe 2 tables and a bar too. You can dine in but really it's more of a takeout joint, and that's OK! You can also grab drinks from the cold case. No fountain unfortunately. This is my new stop, I HOPE they stay in business so please give them a try my local Sussex friends!

    Photos
    Cuban, beef empanada, and fries
    Cuban, beef empanada, and fries
    BLT
    BLT
    Crispy pork belly sandwich,,,...absolutely crazy

    See all

    Crispy pork belly sandwich,,,...absolutely crazy
    Granny's Pancake House & Grill

    Granny's Pancake House & Grill

    4.3
    (353 reviews)
    2.6 mi
    $

    Wonderful cozy find! Best breakfast-for-dinner ever…read more We stumbled upon this absolute gem on a freezing, rainy evening after an outdoor event, just looking for a warm bite to eat around dinner time. My partner found this spot while searching nearby, and oh how happy I am that he did! I had been craving blueberry pancakes for days and was so excited to have a rare breakfast-for-dinner treat. From the moment we walked in, the warmth of the place completely melted the cold away. We were greeted by a wonderful, incredibly kind waitress, and the atmosphere inside was just so cozy and comforting. There was a lovely mix of people having their supper, including a sweet family of seven eating dinner together at the table next to us. It just had that perfect, welcoming community feel. The menu was seriously impressive. My other half ordered the southern chicken sausage gravy dinner, and it was phenomenal! I got my blueberry pancakes- my absolute favorite - and they completely exceeded expectations. I also tried the lentil soup, which was packed with flavor. Honestly, I don't think you could have a bad meal here if you tried. Our waitress (the same lovely woman who greeted us) chatted with us for a bit and was just so delightful and attentive. I even spotted a rice pudding with strawberries and whipped cream on the dessert menu that looked right up my alley, but between my pancakes and stealing a few delicious bites of the chicken dinner, I was far too full this time around! As we left, I noticed the pretty flowers and the outdoor picnic tables. I'm sure this place absolutely hops on weekend mornings, but it was the perfect rainy evening escape for us. Thank you so much for your incredible hospitality-we are officially adding this to our regular rotation when we are in the area.

    Not bad. Coffee is not that great. Service is nice. Food is uselly good…read more But then theres the coffee. I and a lot of people like LAW coffee better

    Photos
    Inside: Seating Area
    Inside: Seating Area
    1/2 waffle with fruit whipped cream and vanilla ice cream
    1/2 waffle with fruit whipped cream and vanilla ice cream
    Dirty Jersey Burger

    See all

    Dirty Jersey Burger
    Irish Cottage Inn

    Irish Cottage Inn

    3.6
    (171 reviews)
    2.9 mi
    $$

    THE FULL RUN DOWN!!! lol, I saw so many varying reviews I needed to get the official answer myself…read more My girlfriend and I came in, right off the bat, the drinks aren't very good, mojito was a NOjito, as in no flavor and all sour lol but the beer was good. We got potato skins and wings and the wings were perfect, fall off the bone as well cooked. The potato skins........perfect cheese, perfect bacon, but can we get a little flavor onto that potato? Next time. I got the pulled pork Sandwhich, it was perfect all around and delicious. The fries were PERFECT!! Crispy and fresh. My girlfriend got the stir fry, the vegetables were perfectly seasoned but the chicken could use some flavor in itself. I was told it's a bit bland like the potato. Overall, 4 stars, our server was attentive, friendly and patient with us. The food was great, no major complaints at all. I took the star off just because the cocktail wasn't very good, the base of the food we ate could use some more seasoning and flavor in the (potato and chicken). Also side suggestion would be to make a few playlists, I felt like the music was all over the place and definitely can set the mood when hanging out. Definitely would love to return, worth the stop 100%

    We went here for a 47 year old birthday party! We first had buffalo hot wings which were perfectly…read morecooked. The wings were perfect with medium heat! It was tender and the meat came off easily. The breaded mushrooms were very good! And the bruschetta was very tasty. For the main entries, chicken franchise, baked ziti, corn beef and cabbage/potatoes. The chicken franchise was so good! The chicken was very tender. The sauce was nice nice and lemony. The corn beef was perfectly salted which went perfectly with the cabbage and potatoes!

    Photos
    Decor
    Decor
    Inside of the Corned Beef En Croute... baked potatoes, cabbage, and corned beef in a puff pastry... excellent!
    Inside of the Corned Beef En Croute... baked potatoes, cabbage, and corned beef in a puff pastry... excellent!
    Entrance

    See all

    Entrance
    Blue Spice Kitchen

    Blue Spice Kitchen

    4.6
    (131 reviews)
    3.5 mi

    Called for reservation but probably wasn't needed (July 3rd and weather issues in the area) Great…read moreservice. Greeted promptly when we arrived. Restaurant maybe 1/2 full. Couldn't decide so we ordered a few apps (KFC chicken, edamame and scallion pancake) all of which were delicious. Decided to get bao buns and fried rice. Note: ordered chicken and shrimp but should have specified we wanted one dish with both meats - instead we got 2 bowls - which just means more for lunch tomorrow! Staff stayed calm when the lights flickered a few times and just said "hopefully the chefs are almost done with your meals because we don't have a generator"). Had to dodge a few broken trees on 94 on the way home but all in all a great meal! Also it's BYOB but really didn't miss the wine - Yuzu ade was refreshing on this 90+ degree day.

    I'm lost for words on this one, just go and give them your money now. It's so worth it…read more#CanIGiveMoreThan5Stars?. Make the hour drive, eat at much as you can and bring some home for the next day, enjoy every moment of it. This small sit down restaurant has an amazing selection of food and everything is cooked perfectly. The price to quality/quantity ratio is perfectly balanced. Again, I highly recommend visiting here for the really friendly down to earth service, the cute and cozy aesthetic, and exemplary food.

    Photos
    Blue Spice Kitchen
    Blue Spice Kitchen
    Akiko Curry (Top) KFC with cheese fries (bottom)  Korean Special Latte

    See all

    Akiko Curry (Top) KFC with cheese fries (bottom) Korean Special Latte
    Cravin Thai

    Cravin Thai

    4.0
    (313 reviews)
    2.1 mi
    $$

    Hands down the best Thai in Sussex county and maybe even further beyond that! My absolute favorites…read moreare the curry puffs, fried tofu and the stars of the show are the Drunken noodles and pad Thai! Also I just note the peanut sauce and plum sauces are outstanding I can literally drink them haha always get extra! Highly recommend. The staff is always so kind! Just keep in mind if ordering take out leave some wiggle room on time as it is a bit of a wait.

    We have always come here because the food has consistently been delicious, generous in portion…read moresize, and a great value. In the past, our takeout orders came in larger round containers with plenty left over to enjoy the next day. Unfortunately, that wasn't the case this time. The portions have noticeably shrunk. As you can see in the photo, the container holding the leftover chicken wings is tiny--only two wings fit inside--and the drunken noodles were packed in an equally small container. The portion was significantly less than what we've always received. It's disappointing to see a restaurant we have enjoyed for years reduce portion sizes while charging the same prices. If costs have increased, we'd rather see a slight price increase than feel like portions are being cut to save money. We hope this was a one-time issue because we've always enjoyed your food, but this experience was very disappointing.

    Photos
    Enjoy your day with your family and friends for a food out of this world
    Enjoy your day with your family and friends for a food out of this world
    The works ice cream.
    The works ice cream.
    Thaï Rita cheers

    See all

    Thaï Rita cheers

    Goodfella’s - italian - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...