The quality, texture and taste of this ice cream are top notch! I enjoyed my banana split like I was a young child experiencing a special, first time treat! Not only was it delicious, but it was a work of art! Obviously, it was created with love and heart Well worth the drive from Wayne. We will be visiting The Goffle Creamery often. Thank you for your dedication and hard work. Every mouthful of your ice cream is a testament to your success and creativity God bless! Denise Federico Wayne, NJ read more

They've got a huge selection -- hard and soft serve, tons of flavors, sundaes, cones, shakes -- you name it. The ice cream tastes super fresh and creamy, like the kind you remember from growing up. Nothing artificial or overly sweet, just really good quality stuff. I love that they offer both traditional and fun seasonal flavors, so there's always something new to try. Whether you're into fruity, chocolatey, or classic vanilla, they've got something for everyone. Also, there's plenty of parking which makes it easy to pop in without the hassle. It's a feel-good, no-frills kind of place that keeps you coming back. A real gem. read more

First time coming here as it really is difficult to find creameries without all the added sugar and food coloring. Upon arrival they have a small private lot in which I recommend backing in and if you have a larger suv/truck park in the plaza next door and walk over. You are greeted with adorable framed menus making it difficult to narrow down which delicious flavor you will get. I opted for strawberry as it has fresh strawberry chunks and no red food dye as the girl working promised. I ordered a small cup it was a huge portion (I ended up taking a few bites and giving it to my boyfriend). You can taste the quality difference of a homemade ice cream without all the extra sugars and additives as this has a nice texture and subtle strawberry flavor. My boyfriend ordered butter pecan in a waffle cone bowl. They make their waffle cone bowls in house and fresh and you could definitely taste it. The butter pecan was perfectly sweet with a balance of pecans to it. For our two items I believe it was $12 and change without tip. I would definitely come back and get my items to go as the parking lot gets crazy between cars and people and children walking around eating their desserts. read more

See all

Nice size ice cream for the money. Mint chocolate chip was very good. Service was quick and friendly. I recommend this place. Easy to park and across the street is a very pretty park with long walking trails. read more

Goffle Creamery - Mint chocolate chip with rainbow sprinkles - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hawthorne, New Jersey

It was pretty good. Not 5 stars worthy but good. I would come back and try more flavors. The oatmeal cookie was too sweet. The shakes are good though. The location is nice cuz there's a park across the street. Service was quick once u get tot he window but it's a long life until then. Overall good. read more

Goffle Creamery - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hawthorne, New Jersey

Really great ice cream! It was a longish line on a nice Saturday afternoon but worth the wait. You can sample the flavors and they give you a decent taste. The staff are really nice and friendly. I got the chocolate fudge crunch and it was creamy and chocolatey and delicious. A small was plenty, it was pretty big. I got brownie bites on top which weren't that many and they were okay, maybe not worth it for $1 extra. There is space to eat your ice cream in the parking lot or walk across to the park. My friend got oatmeal cookie ice cream and she loved it: Would def come again. read more

Goffle Creamery - Small oatmeal cookie in a cone - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hawthorne, New Jersey

We got lucky and there was no line. Service is always friendly. They do accept cards and cash. The ice cream was delicious. Chocolate is my favorite but also got a bite of the banana split and it was so good. The shake is my daughter's favorite. You can enjoy your items in the parking lot or take them across the street to the park. Very family friendly. Frequent customer all spring and summer. read more

See all

Ice cream was super tasty ! My son had the rainbow sorbet and finished it entirely stating it was better than another local shop. I had the bacio gelato and it was yum resembled the ferrero rocher chocolate. Service was great despite being super busy the staff were pleasant and friendly. Ambiance this is a place to stop by and have your ice cream to go or there outdoors. read more

See all

My husband saw that Goffle Creamery was voted best ice cream in Bergen County. We stopped by on a nice sunny afternoon and there was a constant line (although it moves at a good pace). There is a variety of ice cream, gelato and Italian ice. There are a lot of toppings and even an area of specialty sundaes and milk shakes. I got a butter pecan in a waffle cone, it has a good balance of flavors and wasn't too sweet. My husband got a scoop of pistachio and a scoop of vanilla peanut butter in cup. His favorite flavor was the vanilla peanut butter because the strips of peanut butter were evenly distributed through out the ice cream. Overall really cute outdoor spot and I can't wait to go back! read more

See all

I absolutely love Goffle Creamery! Their service is always so fast and efficient, which is important when coming with kids It is just a window service place, but it also looks extremely clean in there! I have tried so many of their flavors and have yet to be let down. My absolute favorite is definitely the Oatmeal Cookie Ice Cream. Their Italian ices are also super tasty! Definitely my favorite ice cream spot in North Jersey! read more

I can't believe I've lived in town for over 4 years and tonight was my first taste of Goffle Creamery, but it definitely won't be my last! This place is a super cute walk up window with something for everyone. My husband got an oreo milkshake and I got a "small" cup of strawberry ice cream with brownie bites. It's atleast 2 scoops of ice cream. I'm not super into sweets, but the strawberry ice cream is perfectly balanced and creamy. They have great packaging, so I'm confident my leftovers will be just as tasty tomorrow. We'll be returning to try more flavors before they close for the season! read more

See all

The best in the area! My #1 ice cream spot - delicious every time and great seasonal flavors.

So I live close to this ice cream shop and wasn't too happy with the ice cream . I think it was ok wasn't the best I had . so the question is "Would I go back "" No not really read more

This place is still in its infancy and they are already hitting their stride with some killer flavors. Both my wife's and my ice creams were excellent and flavor packed. We were able to try some other flavors and all were very good and made it difficult to choose. Can't wait for our next visit. FYI The owners were extremely hospitable and helpful. There's a decent amount of parking available here as well read more

See all

Ice cream was great and homemade! Service quick and friendly . Apple Pay was a great feature for paying! Clean and updated location!

This place just recently opened sometime around Easter. Everything is new inside. Ice cream: I actually got Italian ice, both blue raspberry and lemon and they were awesome. It definitely tastes homemade and I really enjoyed it. My wife got chocolate peanut butter and a scoop of their special they had this week which was graham cracker with cookies covered in honey or something of that nature. It was amazing! I was really in the Italian ice mood but I gotta come back for the ice cream. Atmosphere: It is a walk up counter - there is no indoor seating FYI. The parking lot is of decent size and it's located right on the main road. Between all the local shops you shouldn't have a problem finding parking. The place is brand new and clean. Service: The line was long when I got there, I'd say like 20+ people and we waited about 20 min to get ice cream. No big deal. The staff was very friendly and I thought the overall experience was just fine. Not many ice cream spots in the area so I'm stoked this place is here. I'll be back for sure. read more

Goffle Creamery - people standing outside the store - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hawthorne, New Jersey

See all

Well, this was depressing. 30 minutes in line snaking through a dank, dim, buggy ally to finally get to the front of the line and they're out of banana split Ingredients....its 2024, put up a sign with what you're out of and save people time...and mosquito bites. A little music on line would have improved the experience marginally instead of silently shuffling like a funeral receiving line. read more

Delicious soft serve and hard ice cream. Have been to many places touted as one of the best ice cream spots in NJ and are oftentimes left underwhelmed. This place definitely deserves a spot on the top of the list - the ice cream of the crop. You can also preorder ice cream cakes. Have ordered two in the past month and was asked over and over where I got the cake from. Will be ordering all future cakes from here when possible. Bonus that the business is owned by a local family. I don't know them personally but have had the pleasure of speaking to the wife a few times and she is super sweet. Only downside is they can get incredibly busy summer nights and you may have to wait 20 minutes or so, but it is well worth the wait. read more

Best ice cream ever. Love love love! They need to bring back the strawberry Oreo flavor though! Too good

I would not go back. Ordered cookies and cream with hot fudge. The ice cream had little bits of ice in it like it had been thawed partially then refrozen. They also gave me chocolate sauce instead of hot fudge, disappointing all around. read more

There was a very long line that wrapped around the building. Ice cream was just OK. Very sweet in my opinion.

The best cherry vanilla ever, the other flavors are fantastic too. Employees are friendly and service is quick.

Ice Cream, Italian ices, gelato and more ....... Blend in your favorites, hard shell ... so many options. Simple walk up window, next to an office. Not sure what parking would be like when it's busy. Plan to eat in your car or to take a walk in Goffle park across the street. Good ice cream, great Italian ice, clean and new. great addition to the area. read more

I've had so much ice cream in my life from all over New Jersey and beyond. Goffle Creamery, without a doubt, has the best ice cream I've ever had. It's so good that I go every weekend - usually twice. The staff is awesome. They work hard and remember your face and order. I can't recommend this place enough. Go try it! read more

What a amazing place and the ice cream OMG The best I've ever ever. Good enough to have 3 cheat days . Please try the strawberry milkshake read more

Goffle Creamery - This is the reason I'm not beach ready !!!! But OMG it's soooooo Worth it - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hawthorne, New Jersey

See all

Their soft serve is the creamiest! Cherry vanilla is AMAZING. I do wish there were more choices though. Staff is very friendly so happy they are open again read more

This place was closed on two separate occasions without any note on the window. No one answered the phone. Seemed like a good place but we never had the chance to taste :( read more

Ordered an ice cream cake for a coworker's birthday-it was a huge hit! So much better than the usual chain ice cream cakes...highly recommend and will only buy cakes there now. read more

This ice cream is delicious !! I got cappuccino crunch which was amazing and my daughter got oatmeal cookie which was also super yummy! Staff was very nice. read more

The ice cream is fresh and delicious with so many great flavor options. Staff are very friendly. It's a great spot to visit on a warm day!

My daughter and I went here today waited 45 minutes and our cookies and cream tasted like mint if we're go to wait that long make sure ice cream flavors are not mixed. Wait time and mixed flavors need to be work on. read more

Excellent ice cream! The staff was very pleasant and helpful. There was good flavor choices and lots of toppings.

A little hard to spot off Goffle Rd, but worth stopping in! Great ice cream, gelato, and Italian ice!

This was my first time at Goffle Creamery. I showed up in conjunction with a joint venture with Cousin's Maine Lobster truck at an event. It was a Friday at 12:30pm. The store operates as a permanent food truck since there is no indoor facilities (at least none of which I saw.) It doesn't have the largest menu compared to a national chain but they have the essentials. I ordered and enjoyed my large vanilla soft served ice cream cone, traditionally trying to eat as much as I could before it melts. read more

Thisnis our favorite ice cream place! Great flavors, & great service !

Great ice cream. First time there recently. Got a pint of chocolate peanut butter ice cream and it was delicious. The gentleman behind the counter said you can call ahead to get hand packed ice cream to shorten the wait which was nice. read more

Our absolute favorite ice cream shop!! The best homemade ice cream in the area! The owners are super kind and ice cream a notch above every other ice cream place! We go frequently! read more

I'm not a fan of places that charge a limit on credit cards that oars over $5 but I've never had an issue with a debit card. Typically, your credit card processing company requires to accept a debit card without a minimum purchase. That aside, don't make me feel like you're doing me a favor by taking my money. Especially when the limit is $10 and I spent $9.60. I wasn't a fan of the attitude here and if the signage for the minimum was more obvious I wouldn't have walked up to begin with. read more

Amazing ice cream and so many unique flavors to choose from (always make sure to ask about their special flavor of the day/week)! Staff couldn't be nicer! Definitely calling this my #1 local ice cream spot from now on. read more

The ice cream is delicious. Great selections. Nice portions. Fairly priced for what you get. Cute and outdoorsy; right near a park with benches to sit at. Line is usually long but moves extremely quick. read more