Hands down the best ice cream around. And they always have unique flavors that you'll never see anywhere else.

The ice cream was very very good. However all the staff seemed highly disinterested in working there. The people before us had spilled ice cream all on the floor in front of the counter. We told the staff. They were not concerned in cleaning it up. We had to because we were stepping all in it. They seemed not trained in dealing with customers or maybe they just didn't care. Again the ice cream was quite good. But was definitely a weird experience. They also rung us up and walked back from the screen so was confusing. Will try again since it's local and was tasty read more

See all

Super cute creamery! I loved the theme and decor. As for the ice cream itself, super creamy and sweet! They had awesome flavor choices too. read more

Hometown Creamery - Inside - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Wayne, New Jersey

See all

Possibly one of the best, if not the best ice cream store in Wayne. The flavors are top notch and the selection is broad. It's perfect for a hot day or even any day, in fact, just as long as you're craving a good cone. read more

The graham ice cream here was absolutely delish! I'm so sad I didn't take a picture of it. I went like 6pm on a Saturday no line :) and the staff was super sweet. And there's a parking lot which is always a win! read more

Didn't get the best pics as it was pouring out but this ice cream parlour is a MUST TRY! So many flavors the line was out the door! The staff are wonderful! We got Baileys ice cream on a chocolate and peanut covered waffle cone and cherry vanilla on a regular cone. Both were amazing. Creamy , perfect sweetness and loaded with fruit! There are benches out door for seating and a nice modern clean setting. Can't wait to go back! read more

See all

Went on a Saturday night with the family. Lots of different flavors. The ice cream was creamy, no ice chunks in the ice cream which is to my preference. read more

Fantastic ice cream and a great spot to stop on a sunny day :) This was my first time at Hometown Creamery and I was so happy I tried it! Friendly staff and a clean, bright atmosphere with an amazing array of homemade flavors. Excited to return soon! read more

Hometown Creamery - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Wayne, New Jersey

See all

we love hometown creamery, as lifelong residents the area we had been missing a great local ice cream parlor for many years and the homemade ice cream here makes it worth the trip everytime. You can always tell the difference when ice cream is homemade with high quality ingredients. We also really enjoy trying the new flavors they come out with. they are also really great if someone in your party has an allergy to help you find something that will allow everyone to enjoy ice cream read more

Delicious ice cream and quick service. I got the raspberry chocolate chip ice scoop with hot fudge and it was decadent. I would highly recommend!! read more

Hometown Creamery - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Wayne, New Jersey

Flavor boosted ice cream! Crazy great flavor combos! Super friendly staff! Easy parking. A hidden gem! read more

After attending a performance by my spiritual daughter, we decided to go for ice cream to celebrate. First, kudos for opening until 11pm. Just enough time for some social time and good ice cream. Upon arrival, we were wowed by the number of cool ice cream flavors available to choose from. It's a small place with a counter top space and few bar stools. Clean and at 10pm if was fairly quiet. The staff greeted us and welcomed us to try flavors. After sampling, they quickly took our orders. There was a variety for everyone's taste. I end up getting vanilla peanut butter and chocolate covered strawberry ice cream on a cone. It totally got the spot!!! I highly recommend this place! read more

Hometown Creamery - Vanilla peanut butter & chocolate covered strawberry ice cream on a cone - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Wayne, New Jersey

Had a craving for ice cream and stumbled upon this gem! I was highly satisfied by the consistency and flavor. Found my new ice cream parlor! Super cute inside too. Loved the Christmas decorations. The apple pie and chocolate brownie ice creams were by far favorite. I did get a scoop of the coffee chip because I have a weakness for coffee flavor ice cream. I do have to admit that it wasn't what I expected. The coffee flavor was lacking a bit. Aside from that, they do have a lot of flavors to pick from. I cannot wait to go back and taste a new flavor. It was a very slow night, but still the staff was friendly and knowledgeable. read more

Hometown Creamery - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Wayne, New Jersey

See all

A quaint little creamery located in the shopping center of Wayne. Service is extremely helpful and patient. They have great options we opted for a classic waffle cone and butter pecan and birthday cake and passion fruit in a small cup. All the flavors were extremely rich and creamy which is a preferred quality in my taste of ice cream. The birthday cake was sweet but not too sweet in flavor with some rainbow sprinkles for an added pop of color. The passionfruit flavor was tart and had a perfect flavor. The butter pecan was rich, creamy, and had a fantastic buttery flavor. Parking is ample in the lot outside. We will definitely be back to explore the milkshake options and rest of their menu! read more

Hometown Creamery - Birthday cake and passionfruit small cup - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Wayne, New Jersey

See all

We stopped here with the kids to get some ice cream on a hot summer night. They had a lot of flavors & the overall feel of the spot was nice. Lots of cow decor! My little one got birthday cake, my husband got the fruit pebbles milkshake & I got the guava & lavender chip regular cup. Very interesting flavors - I like the lavender chip a lot. The server wasn't too welcoming so that brought down the experience a bit. I asked her for recommendations what to pair with the lavender chip & she was like "whatever." There is seating inside (bar-ish with stools) and like 4 benches outside but we decided to stay inside cause it was so hot. She was walking around the place kick/pushing the chairs into the wall aggressively making it seem like she wanted us to leave. read more

Hometown Creamery - Guava & Lavender Chip (Cup Regular) - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Wayne, New Jersey

Some of the best ice cream around !!! Really enjoyed the fruity pebbles and the cookie dough. Homemade !!!

So disappointed in tonight's visit to Hometown. $4.75 for a junior pistacio cherry. Not even a full scoop served and not one pistacio in sight. read more

I came all the way from Hawaii, and this icecream is fantastic, with that good rich milk flavor. There lavender flavors are genius and delicious highly recommend. Mahalo Hometown Creamery read more

Hometown Creamery - Came all the way from Hawaii, delicious icecream! Had the lavender chip and honey lavender 3 days in a row, genius flavor idea. Mahalo - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Wayne, New Jersey

Just go there they have almost everything they're there ice cream is the best in the business and hands down 100/10

They ran out of pistachio flavor when we went, but luckily there was a pint left so we bought it. Pistachio is a flavor I usually pick when I go to ice cream/gelato places, and it didn't live up. It tasted more almond than pistachio.. however, the flavors of butter pecan and coffee chip were great. The value/pricing for the ice cream is reasonable as well. There was a huge line so it took awhile to get to order, so just a heads up if you're not a fan of crowds. Otherwise, there's plenty of indoor/outdoor seating that was well thought out, as everyone had some kind of perimeter seating at a long table/bench. read more

See all

Had a pleasant experience at hometown creamery this afternoon! The ice cream and flavor selection was fantastic. The workers are awesome, very friendly and attentive. The place is clean and cozy with nice seating. Loved it here and will totally be back. read more

Placed an order 8 pm. Dasher was there waiting for the order and home town creamery canceled the order at 8:30 pm.

Delicious ice cream! We all loved it. Cute interior with some seating. Parking lot outside. Friendly service.

This may just be my new favorite ice cream shop in the area. Every flavor is homemade and fresh- and you can tell! I'm shocked at the quality they're able to provide given how many flavors they offer on a daily basis. I was also floored at how natural all of the flavors are- nothing artificial at all! Prices are a little high, but definitely worth it when it comes to quality and quantity. Of all the times I've been there I've tasted about 6 different flavors and each was better than the last (though the pistachio is my favorite). If you can't decide what to get, try a flight, but be warned- it's huge! read more

This local ice cream shop is so cute - it's one of my favorites in the area! They are open everyday for that sweet fix you might have. I've been driving past this shop ever since I moved to the area and finally had a chance to try it out this summer after dinner. And let me tell you, the ice cream did not disappoint! They offer hard ice cream, milkshakes, chipwich, and pints for sale. I ordered the regular cup of ice cream where you have the option to pick two flavors. I picked the coffee chip and the chocolate cookie dough. Both flavors were rich and creamy! My husband ordered a milkshake that comes in one size only and he said it was awesome! There is indoor and outdoor seating available. Or you have the option to take it to go. This is an adorable ice cream shop that really highlights and embraces the cow theme on their merchandise. Overall, I highly recommend it! 10 out of 10! Can't wait to come back! read more

See all

Excellent food. The choices are great, there's a rotation for variety, and lots of great flavor. Highly recommend it. Curly's better watch out! read more

Excellent Ice Cream, large portions, server was very pleasant, was a good find, will be back

Great place! Ice cream tastes like it's homemade! Creamy and delicious! Inside decor is modern and cute! Staff was very pleasant! Would definitely recommend if you're in the mood for some homemade creamy deliciousness! read more

Hometown Creamery - Chipwhich and chocolate raspberry - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Wayne, New Jersey

See all

I passed by this place on my way to a local restaurant, and made a stop to try their ice cream. I am usually very picky about my ice cream because I prefer creamy taste yet not too sweet. I tried the coffee chips it was a good balance of coffee flavor with chocolate chip inside, and not too sweet. I will try something new next time read more

See all

Obsessed!! We moved to Wayne from Parsippany a couple years ago and one of the only things we missed was a good homemade ice cream joint close to home. Every time I have come to Hometown, I have tried a different flavor and they are all SO GOOD! The apple pie is TO DIE FOR!! They also offer great to-go options including ice cream pie and doggy ice cream! So happy that they have opened close to home. They have found a forever customer!! read more

Hometown Creamery - Puppy Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Wayne, New Jersey

I am spoiled by Curly's ice cream in Riverdale. They're a hard place to compete with. Good service at hometown. Ambiance clean and cheerful. read more

This is an adorable place & has great ice cream. It has been a wonderful addition to the area.

Hi, my name is Lester Small I am a 52 year old, unemployed man who has been going through a lot. My wife Linda divorced me and took the kids. Ever since I have been going through an emotional mess. But ever since I consumed hometown creamery's ice cream everything changed. When I inserted their cream inside of my mouth I felt so good. I forgot all of my problems and the fact that I'm $13k in debt. Their cream is the best cream I have ever put inside of my body. Thank you hometown creamery. read more

The ice cream here is so delicious. Small batch homemade. They even have a vegan flavor, coffee swirl today. It's also very good. I got one scoop each of espresso, peanut explosion and Kahlua fudge. The Kahlua fudge flavor is considered and "adult" flavor and $1 more. This is a nice addition to the area. I recommend this place snd I will be back. The portions are huge and the flavors pop. read more

See all

Really must try this place. I can't wait to return. Tried two flavors and both were excellent. My husband wanted sugar free and they had three choices. He had the sugar free coconut and loved it. Reasonable prices for large scoops. All delicious read more

Hometown Creamery - Cherry vanilla. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Wayne, New Jersey

THE BEST ICE CREAM IN NEW JERSEY!! I love my ice cream and Hometown Creamery is top notch! {I'm going to say it... better than Curly's} It is CREAMY and has many different flavors - always adding new ones. My favorite is Dr. Pepper. The FLIGHT is a MUST! (two scoops of four flavors for $7.50!!!) read more

Hometown Creamery - FLIGHT! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Wayne, New Jersey

Tried it for the first time today and I was impressed. The best cookies and cream in my life and the strawberry cheesecake was amazing. I wasn't impressed with the cookie dough at all. Chocolate chip mint was very good. I was disappointed with how long we had to wait but it was worth it read more

Hometown Creamery - Cookie dough, mint chip, strawberry cheesecake and cookies and cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Wayne, New Jersey

Hands down, best ice cream shop! You go here and you keep thinking about the ice cream after you leave... I am still dreaming about the fluffernutter flavor I had a few weeks ago. Go check it out and enjoy. read more

To start off, the decor and vibe is great. Homey and ice cream parlor feel is there. As first time customers after hearing all the rave about this in Wayne, we decided to give it a shot. No samples......... NO SAMPLES! I can see maybe limiting it to 1 or 2 but as a NEW ice cream place, there should be some sampling to get customers in. We took the gamble and got 4 flavors: coffee chip, cotton candy, and 2 vegan flavors: cookie batter and pumpkin spice. Regular size was a good portion and likeable as you got to choose 2 flavors..... sprinkles were barely a dusting on the top. Opened up the lid and took the first bite......no flavor. Couldn't even tell it was pumpkin or coffee or cookie or cotton candy. If we could have SAMPLED the ice cream beforehand, then we would've realized how TERRIBLE of a place this was. All the rave for what?!? The cookie crumble was actually INEDIBLE! No ice cream, just ice and chunks of disgusting cookie. Do yourself the favor and stay away from this place. If you like getting ripped off, it's a scam. They know their ice cream sucks, so they sucker you into having to pay outrageous prices and then get stuck with ice cream that's got NO flavor. read more

Hometown Creamery - Cookie batter and pumpkin spice - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Wayne, New Jersey

This place is homemade, local, family owned, and made with love. This is a great place with a big variety of flavors to choose from that are constantly being updated. Everyone who works there is so nice and looks like they really enjoy being there. Love coming back with friends and is very family friendly! read more