I visited Cake & Cone off of a strong recommendation from my brother. Unfortunately, my experience was very mid. I ordered a hard shell birthday cake cone and my girlfriend got a cookies & cream shake. The hard shell tasted pretty good but the ice cream inside was already melting when it was given to me. It made for a very messy time and I couldn't enjoy it the way I should have. My girlfriend's shake was ok but the oreo pieces were way too big. The shake was more like a McFlurry or Blizzard rather than a shake. It still tasted great, but if you order a shake you should get a shake. A friend ordered fried Oreos and they were fantastic. I'd definitely get these again. My brother told me their fried Nutter Butters are even better. Service was average as were the prices. My experience wasn't bad enough to completely turn me away, but next time I'll have to try some other things on their menu. read more

See all

I ordered a kids size icecream which was $5. A lot for the size. The rum raisin had hadn't any raisins and was no real flavor bland. Then the worst was ice crystals through it. Not fresh. Never again I'll go to another read more

Always a nice little treat especially as the weather gets warmer! My go to is a salted monster and cake batter milkshake. There's also seating in the back and a small lot for parking. Highly recommend Cake and Cone! read more

After dinner I swung through this place. There's no seating, it's grab a go. Don't be surprised to see a line. There's a lot of choices. The cake batter was on point and they give you healthy scoops. The fried Oreos, wow I wish they gave you more. If you're in the area with a sweet tooth, give this place a try. read more

Cake & Cone - Fried Oreos - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - East Rutherford, New Jersey

See all

Cake and cone is a great ice cream place. They have a wide variety of options! The people behind the counter are always very nice to me when I'm there. Super good treat on a hot day, even if it's not hot out. read more

Cake & Cone - Strawberry soft serve cone w/ spilt sprinkles - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - East Rutherford, New Jersey

Best ice cream in the East Rutherford area. I miss living in that town so much that I still go back just for the ice cream. Marble crunch always! read more

They give real large scoops of hard ice cream . Their ice cream is rich and perfect ! Obsessed ! Cake and cone 100x better than store bought ice cream and baskin Robbin ! read more

Stopped by after dinner and didn't have the best experience. The ice cream seemed old. The toppings were lacking flavor. I probably won't be going back. read more

I have gone to this place twice. During my first visit, I had a soft serve on a hot summer night. It was great! The second time was another hot day during the fall. I shared a cherry bowl with whipped cream on top with my son. Both of us had stomachache afterwards and we are not lactose intolerant. read more

Cake & Cone - Swirl cone - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - East Rutherford, New Jersey

See all

Maybe it's because we came towards the end of the day but I wasn't a huge fan of Cake&Cone. I ordered coffee ice-cream with Oreo pieces and the ice-cream wasn't as creamy and flavorful as I thought it would be. read more

10/10 Recommend, the strawberry 2 scoop cone. Would also get the ice cream sandwiches. The two girls working there were great! Got our food super fast. Very old aesthetic, and generally a chill place to be (Gotcha hehehe) read more

Absolutely delicious. It's an ice cream stand with great prices and fresh ice cream. There are no seats. It's amazing. Definitely try it. Definitely. read more

Cake & Cone - a hand holding a cone of ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - East Rutherford, New Jersey

This place is my most fav ice-cream place in the area. They get super busy during summer months and in peak winter they are mostly closed. The line moves quickly and even if it doesn't you get the enjoy warm weather while chatting with your friends. Everyone around are happy because it's an ice-cream parlor so the vibe is pretty positive. Their soft serve is good and their hard ice cream is amazing too. Usually we order black cherry or chocolate. They unfortunately don't carry chocolate brownie fudge anymore and have increased their prices a lil bit. They also accept credit card and the servers are very friendly. They have a backyard with tables and chairs if you wanna sit there and eat. Their parking is mostly packed in summers and sometimes you have to wait for a car to leave. read more

Cake & Cone - two scoops of chocolate ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - East Rutherford, New Jersey

See all

This place is a ripoff! They raised the prices again. Just bought 2 small cups of ice cream and paid $12!!! These people are insane! Totally taking advantage of the customers. What's a real shame is that they are fleecing school kids of much needed money. I will never go back to this pathetic business. You're much better off going to a supermarket and getting two half gallons of premium ice cream for you and the family. Don't give this place any more of your hard earned money. I hope they go out of business!! Such a scam! read more

This is my all time favorite ice cream shop! Handmade ice cream, fantastic flavors and so many options I could have an anxiety attack. This gem of a shop is right in East Rutherford and has plenty of parking. Also there's a space in the back with little tables to sit and enjoy your favorite delicious sugary treat. I love coming here in the summer, they're open late and I try a new flavor every time. The workers are extremely friendly and hand out samples if you're torn between two flavors. What really makes Cake and Cone stand out is their soft serve. They have some awesome flavors that you really don't see too often for soft serve. Tonight my friend tried the Black Raspberry and it was to die for. On a waffle cone, what more can you ask for? This is definitely the ice cream shop to come to if you wanna try some fun flavors with friendly service. Lines may be long during evening hours but it's so worth it! read more

See all

Delicious soft serve ice cream will come again. We are from out of town so it was nice to have some dessert at a local ice cream shop.

Went here to celebrate my kid's birthday. Soft serve is huge. Mint chocolate chip was good. But pistachio tasted weird. The berry flavor was great. read more

I've been curious about this place for a while. I want to be fair, so I won't be too harsh. I wanted a funnel cake. I got the funnel cake, but it's nothing like the ones you get down the shore. This was a heavy, cakey, greasy lead donut type of thing topped with about 1/2 cup powdered sugar. I ate about 5 bites and I had to toss this glob of greasy dough. Sorry, I just can't eat this. I'll be back, but I'll try their ice cream next time. read more

Cake& Cone has been around since 1954. I was staying in the area and searched on Yelp for soft serve and Cake& Cone popped up. As soon as I walked up to the window I was greeted by the young employee. I needed a minute to look at the menu, but had thoughts about what I wanted. I ordered a cherry dip top cone, my usual at any creamy whip. This one was good , but the ice cream was a little to runny for a perfect ratio of dip top to ice cream. The parking lot on the side has about eight spots. read more

See all

Okay so my boyfriend and I stumbled across this place and had to try since I absolutely love ice cream. The ice cream was delicious! Creamy and rich in flavor. The only problem was it was so hot we were licking our cones like it was a race to the end! We didn't try any cake mixed with our ice cream because we just stuffed ourselves at dinner. The price is half of what we pay back at home! read more

I was so excited to try this place since they serve deep fried Nutter Butter, deep fried Oreo, and funnel cake sundaes! I ordered the deep fried Nutter Butter sundae here with cake batter and peanut butter ice cream. The deep fried Nutter Butter cookies that topped the sundae were delicious! Unfortunately, the ice cream wasn't that great. I would of rather bought Ben and Jerry's from the super market! Both ice creams had a nice texture, but the flavors were disappointing! The cake batter didn't have any cake pieces or frosting swirled throughout, and the peanut butter ice cream vanilla base was bland. There also wasn't barely any peanut butter in the peanut butter flavor. Both ice creams had a good texture, but zero flavor. Although I loved their sundae menu, I wouldn't come back here for their ice cream. read more

See all

Overrated. Lady wasn't too attentive, for a mom n pops store. She also let someone else cut me in line

Friendly staff. It's ice cream how could you go wrong? Lol pricing is pretty good! No room to sit is the only problem if you ask me.

If you're looking for really good soft serve , this is the spot. It's nothing crazy like you usually see these days with some of the ice cream shops that get creative. They're very basic and old school with what they do. Really really good ice cream , would definitely come back. read more

Cake & Cone - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - East Rutherford, New Jersey

I've never been here before. It was my first time. I wanted to try the cannoli flavor It's a fantastic place ! There's not much to say read more

This place can get pretty busy in the summer months but they move the line quickly. This is my go to place when i am craving some ice cream! They have tons of different flavors to choice from and make great shakes. They have a small parking lot or you can street park. read more

Some of the best ice cream ever and my favorite way to end a meal after getting sushi at Nizi a two minute walk away. Get the pumpkin soft serve it is the best!! Pumpkin flavor is not overwhelming and the soft serve has the softest fluffiest texture I've never had anywhere else read more

Cake & Cone - Pumpkin soft serve in the kiddy cup size - generous portion and the best, fluffiest soft serve! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - East Rutherford, New Jersey

cute, side of the road little ice cream spot !! Reasonably priced and classic flavor options, ice cream sandwiches, shakes etc. I ordered vanilla soft serve w rainbow sprinkles in a medium cup which can easily be enough for 2! The staff is really friendly and there is a parking lot next to the shop. Would def be back :) read more

Cake & Cone - Vanilla soft serve - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - East Rutherford, New Jersey

See all

Two words. Salted monster. You are welcome. I hate that this place closes during the winter. That's my only complaint read more

Right now I don't really know how anything is there. I paid for a cake yesterday and when I went to pick it up along a lunch order they were closed. Now I don't know whether I paid for a cake and won't get it. Left messages and haven't heard back yet. We'll see... Picked up the cake and it's probably one of the best ice cream cakes that we've ever had!!! Will definitely be back! read more

Great local ice cream shop. All homemade, big variety, good service. Decent size lot to sit in car and enjoy. read more

Cake & Cone - Cookies and Cream in a Waffle cone. Very good. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - East Rutherford, New Jersey

Dairy Queen in Rutherford got kicked to the curb when I discovered Uncle Charlie's down the street. And now I find myself ghosting (look at me pretending to be hip and using cool slang terms!) Charlie's to move up a town now that I found out about Cake & Cone after seeing some Yelp friends' positive reviews. Looking like the classic ice cream stands you usually find down the shore off of the minor highways Cake & Cone have all the usual options and a slew of cool and interesting (homemade) flavors to boot. Parking lot and a 'backyard patio' (where you can hear the neighbors from the apartment building behind the store coughing and yelling at their TV's). Solid pricing. Big servings. Friendly staff. And they also offer up some 'real food' (like mozzarella sticks) - I guess for the kids to spend their paycheck on after their paper route. (Look at me proving I'm an old man since kids haven't delivered newspapers for decades now!) read more

The hard ice cream is very smooth. Don't expect abundant parking, but pop open your trunk and hang out for a while. I still like Ice Cream Charlie's better but this place has good variety. I'm not sure how many people actually go for the hot food. read more

This is simply the best ice cream place in the area. I come here almost every day and it just gets better and better. read more

Cake & Cone - Cake and Cone - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - East Rutherford, New Jersey

First time there. Pretty good. Got the marble crunch in a waffle cone. Wish the cone had a paper wrapper (the napkin stuck to the cone and i ate around it) read more

I've drove past this place on numerous occasions, but it wasn't until a nice warm day in September, that I tried it out. Located on Patterson Ave. in Rutherford, the location is easy to get to and the store has a pretty sizeable parking lot. The staff seems pretty friendly, but the ice cream leaves something to be desired. I ordered a small cup, which was a good size at $3.65. I was able to get two flavors of ice cream, Lucky charms and Nutella chip. Unfornately, even though the size was generous and the price was pretty good, the taste just wasn't there. It tasted very similar to something from a supermarket freezer. I mean the ice cream just didn't have that home made or in house made taste to it. It wasn't bad by any means, I guess I just expected more. read more

Cake & Cone - Lucky charms and Nutella chip - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - East Rutherford, New Jersey

Their ice cream is usually very good quality. However, the last few times over the past year they've been sold out of Nutella!

We have come here twice in a month already after discovering it. Kids had soft ice cream kiddie cone, I had a vanilla shake and hubby had soft ice cream root beer float. He loves it. All ice cream tastes great. Done well. read more

It's a walk up ice cream stand that also sells hot food out of another window. The hot food section appeared to be closed when we were there. The line got quite long shortly after we arrived - we just lucked out with timing to avoid a long wait. Nice selection of flavors. The free kiddie cone with check-in was a nice plus. We got a small cup, which was generously sized for $3.65. The mango ice cream however, lacked flavor. We buy a mango ice cream from our local Indian grocer that beats this hands down. However I bet some of their other flavors must be great - else I don't think you'd see the long line of customers. So I would come back ... but try a different flavor next time. read more

See all

delicious ice cream, great service. stop getting the over processed stuff you get at the super market and spoil yourself sweet at cake and cone. Also have had their ice cream cakes twice, they had vanilla and chocolate with crunchies and fudge. yum read more

Cake & Cone - ice cream birthday cake. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - East Rutherford, New Jersey

See all