The bad: -The store is small and awkwardly arranged - the…read morefolks being served and waiting to pay block the view of the freezers so it's impossible to see the current flavors and decide what to order if you're waiting in line - they badly need a sign on the wall with the flavors (and they're constantly changing them) - this would speed up the whole flow of the store -It's not a great value for the portion size AND some trips, depending on who is working, you get a smaller portion - they need to work on portion consistency - also, you seem to get less in a cup then a cone -This summer every time I went, much of the product was droopy and semi-melted - the freezers couldn't keep up with the summer heat - they need to address that -Many of the flavors are experimental and not all are winners - make sure to ask for a taste if you're going into uncharted flavor territory The good: The gelato is the perfect texture (when at the proper temperature) and the flavors are strong and mostly excellent.

It does feel a bit unwelcoming. The 3 inside tables block the walkway to the start of the line, so…read moreI had to squeeze past two families to wait my turn. There's also a printed sign proclaiming a limit of 2 samples, which is not enough; they have like 20 flavors. That said, I felt my mint chocolate chip was perfect: creamy and minty. The small size was $8 for a cup (and would've been +$1 for a waffle cone). I fully agree with other posters about how the staff is not nearly excited enough to be working in a gelato shop. Are their managers that bad?

The yogurt was delicious the add ons were fresh and plenty plenty of parking just feed meter staff…read moreis helpful

Love the variety of flavors! Also really like that they…read morehave more than one vegan and dairy free option I grabbed chocolate with mango and topped it with Nutella crunch (so yummy!) and mango jelly balls. Decent size cups and you fill as you'd like. Realized enjoyed it!

This place is special…read more My wife and I stopped by Guerriero Gelato in Caldwell after hearing great things, and it absolutely lived up to the hype--and then some. Not only did we get to enjoy some of the best gelato we've ever had, but we also had the chance to go behind the scenes and learn about the process. Watching everything made from scratch gave me a whole new appreciation for this craft. The flavors were phenomenal: Mango was juicy and bright Espresso Chip had that bold coffee kick with perfect texture Blueberry Basil was fresh and a little unexpected (in the best way) Coconut was creamy and clean Vanilla Chip (Stracciatella) had delicate chocolate ribbons in a velvety vanilla base--pure perfection The flavors were so delicious, we forgot to take pictures--but we did leave with 5 pints. One of them was Fat Elvis, which tastes like a frozen peanut butter Reese's in the best possible way. Also worth noting: the entire kitchen and shop were spotless. Everything was so clean and organized, it instantly made us trust the freshness and quality of every flavor even more. Mike and Breanna have built something beautiful here, and you can feel their heart in every detail. Also want to give a shoutout to Amanda, who helps bring the story of this place to life online--what you see on social media is truly real. If you're thinking about going--go. Guerriero Gelato isn't just dessert. It's devotion in a cup.

This is my local go to gelato spot when I am craving ice cream or gelato. They have a variety of…read moreflavors, some unique and some classic, but it's the right mix with options for every kind of flavor you want. They serve ice cream cakes as well. Their lines are usually long during weekend nights, but that just means it's a popular spot for the locals.

It was really good ice cream! Would definitely return. I had the cherry blossom and the peanut…read morebutter pie. Even though the flavors I picked didn't go together I had to try both. The peanut butter pie was peanut butter ice cream with graham cracker and peanut butter cups in it. The cherry blossom was cherry ice cream with cherries in it. Both really good!

We visited this homemade ice cream shop after dinner at another local place. There wasn't much…read moredecor but it's a small space. The service was ok. The two girls working were not rude but definitely didn't seem like they wanted to be there. There are many different flavors that other ice cream places do not have. They are allergy friendly when it comes to peanuts and tree nuts. We each just got a small cup. It was delicious. Prices are fair.

Best ice cream in little falls! I love all of their hard ice cream flavors and the homemade ice…read morecream sandwiches. Super easy to walk to and grab a cone on a nice summer night. My favorite flavor this summer had to be the black rasberry chip. For toddlers you can ask them to only fill the soft serve cones up a little bit so they don't inhale an entire cone too ;)

I encountered this business food truck at the FIFA event at Sports Illustrated stadium…read more Be prepared for rude service and to double-check your bill at the Fairfield Ice Cream truck. I walked up and asked one of the employees, who was standing there and not helping another customer, what the ice cream sizes were. She gave me an annoyed look and responded, "What?!" Before she answered, another employee yelled from across the truck, "I have it right here. Wait your turn," while he was ringing up someone else. I apologized and said I thought I could ask her since she wasn't helping anyone. She then muttered, "You don't have to be fucking rude." When she realized I heard her, she immediately ducked back into the truck. The entire interaction was incredibly unprofessional. Then I was charged $10 for an item clearly posted as $7. I was told the extra $3 was "tax," which simply isn't possible. We even have video showing the posted price and confirming what other customers paid. I chose not to argue because I was there with my toddler and didn't want to ruin our family outing. Everyone can have an off day, but there is no excuse for swearing at customers, treating people with disrespect, or charging more than the posted price. What should have been a fun stop for ice cream ended up being one of the worst customer service experiences I've had.

I went with the three-scoop option for $9. I've been here three times during the summer, and today…read morewas my fourth visit, now at the beginning of fall. After giving this place several chances, I keep having the same issue: the flavor selection just isn't very exciting. They do rotate a few seasonal flavors--I noticed a new pumpkin one today--but otherwise, it feels like I'm looking at the same limited choices every time I come in. Nothing really makes me say, "Wow, I have to try that." Today I went with the Cherry Vanilla and strawberry, Unfortunately, it was another disappointment. I was expecting actual pieces of cherry or some real fruit throughout the ice cream, like I've had at other ice cream parlors, but it was basically just flavored cream. Very plain. For around the same price, I've been to other places with much more creative flavors, better variety, and ice cream loaded with real fruit and ingredients you can actually see and taste. One thing I definitely appreciate is that they're open until around 10 p.m. on weeknights. These days, that's actually a big plus, especially for a local spot. I respect that they're willing to keep the staff there later because not everybody finishes work at 5 or 6 p.m. Sometimes you just want to stop somewhere after a long day, grab some ice cream, and relax without having to rush before closing time. That convenience deserves some credit. I really wanted to like this place, which is why I kept coming back and giving it another chance. Happy fall, everyone!

Guerriero serves up a good Cookie Monster ice cream! Last week, I picked up a large cup for us to…read moreshare at home after dinner. Recommended!

Delicious ice cream and my kids love it here!! Something about the giant blue chair gets them so…read moreexcited to sit out in the back!!

Delish! Great choice in flavors & the ice cream is so good! I loved the pistachio! The area…read moreoutside has some benches for you to sit on but other than that that, there is no place to really enjoy it.

Scoop Theory in Livingston is awesome. Friendly service in a pleasant setting. Really interesting…read moreflavors and options to add to your ice cream. They also have pints to go. I tried the Tuscan Fig in a waffle cone. Fantastic and I wish it was a regular flavor on their menu. My Wife had a cup of Tiramisu with rainbow sprinkles which she enjoyed. We got a pint of strawberry lychee. I liked it but felt it needed more lychee. Definitely check this place out as the quality of the ice cream is top notch.

Amazing, amazing spot. No boring ice cream flavors. They're all interesting and different. Very…read morefriendly service, fresh ice cream, insane bubble cones, and great drinks. Love the place