Applegate Farm Ice Cream
Order Applegate Farm Ice Cream Takeout or Delivery
Applegate Farm Ice Cream Photos
You might also consider
More like Applegate Farm Ice Cream
Recommended Reviews - Applegate Farm Ice Cream
Start your review...
Reviews With Photos
It's always a great time for Ice Cream and if you're in New Jersey you need to come to Applegate Farm. They have every flavor and it's the perfect outing for the entire family. When I think of Ice Cream this is one of the first places I think of. The staff is always friendly and there's plenty of staff to get your order in quickly and move on to the best part and enjoying some Ice Cream. They also have Sugar-free options. But not as many as I wish they had. Overall it's a great and in many ways nostalgic.
Came here last weekend with a sweet treat in mind. Got the dirt cup sundae with gave me childhood nostalgia. A very big treat which can definitely be shared by at least 2 people.
Ordered: Cider Donut Sundae (~$15): Dutch Apple ice cream layered with fresh apple cider donut crumbles and caramel, topped with whipped cream, cinnamon sugar, and a homemade cider donut, served in a keepsake Applegate glass Aya's take: Is it even Autumn if you haven't had an apple cider donut!? Applegate Farms will do you one better with their Cider Donut Sundae. It's exactly what it sounds like - sweet, spiced, and creamy. It was actually super satisfying especially with the layers of apple cider donut crumbles throughout. I love that it comes with a whole apple cider donut too that you can munch on while enjoying the sundae. The caramel was a bit too thick and made it harder to eat but other than that, it was a good try. It's massive so I definitely suggest sharing among 2-3 people and don't forget to take that keepsake glass home with you! The line situation was inefficient and the staff is generally slow so keep in mind that there are multiple lines all serving the full menu and know what you want when you get up to order. Worth a try if you're in the area!
Cute ice cream place in Montclair. We stopped there on a hot Sunday afternoon and the place was slammed. Overall the ice cream is solid and the sundaes look good but they are massive!! The service is slow so pack your patience and while waiting in line there is not much air movement so on those hot and humid days/nights it's a little uncomfortable while you wait. The Shirley Temple gelati was quite good but wish they had a few more shaved ice flavors. Also, I wish they sold water or other beverages as well.
I was enticed to try this place after seeing how decadent their sundaes were, but the sundae fell short for me. Too many fixings, not enough ice cream. The quality of the ice cream is good though, I think I would have been better off with something more simple. Service was good, lots of people working there to accommodate and crowd and the barn look was very inviting.
Came here on a Sunday night and it was absolutely packed, but the lines moved fairly quickly and we were there for a total of 30 minutes (a long time fir ice cream, I know). There's a lot of parking in the back, as well as on the street. They don't have a place for you to eat the ice cream so most people I saw would just go back to their cars. I got their Graham Central and it was definitely better than others I have tried. It was like biting into a graham cracker! Their junior cup was huge and fairly priced (5.50 I believe). It was definitely good, but considering it has been named one of the best in New Jersey, it didn't fully live up to par with other ice cream places I've tried in Montclair.
Don't cheat yourself treat yourself! This is great hot chocolate you will not regret coming here. It's super tasty. I tried the gingerbread and the cookies and cream, hot chocolate and was not disappointed. It's very filling, however, so you could probably share one drink with somebody else. Service was quick and everyone was friendly. The presentation of the hot chocolate made it Insta worthy. Be mindful seating is outdoors. You might want to sit inside the car.
What a cute and charming ice cream spot! I love that it's open all year round, perfect for whenever you're craving a sweet treat, even in the colder months. They have a wide variety of flavors, so there's something for everyone. I did a one scoop sundae with the cookies and cream and everything was rich, creamy, and absolutely delicious. There isn't any indoor or outdoor seating, but there's plenty of parking available. Most people just enjoy their ice cream in their cars, which actually adds to the laid-back, local vibe of the place. It's simple, no-frills, and all about great ice cream. I'll definitely be coming back to try more flavors!
As the summer was coming to an end, we simply had to stop at Applegate Farms for our last licks of ice cream. As you're driving, you'll quickly spot a ginormous, fake cow, and you'll know you have arrived. During the summer, this place is packed, and the lines move fairly quickly. This time, during the fall, the lines were minimal. You can scan or just take a photo of their offered flavors prior to ordering. The last time I was here, I ordered their famous peach ice cream. It was good but a bit too sweet for me. My husband loved it. This time around, I ordered a Cappuccino Crunch ice cream, my husband ordered Peanut Butter Fudge Brownie ice cream, and our kid ordered a "root beer" float. Upon tasting the "root beer," we noted it didn't taste like root beer. The server explained it wasn't, as they were very low on root beer, so he substituted it with Coke instead. He also explained he's a new hire and didn't think to ask if it was okay for him to switch. The drink was okay, but we wish we had been given a heads-up. The serving size is interesting. Most of the time, their junior size is huge, so I ordered a junior, as did my husband. Oddly, when we received them, they both looked vastly different. When the server charged us, he had me as a regular cone and my husband as a junior, and the kid's drink as a regular root beer float. When we brought it to his attention, he stated he made a mistake, and he's new and had already rung it up. Oy. The place, when it's crazy busy, can obviously be a hard place to keep clean, but most of the people are very good at cleaning up after themselves. There are no chairs or tables where you can sit and enjoy, but there are barrels where you can put your drinks or cups down as you stand by, or makeshift benches by the wooden planks. There are no bathrooms, so be prepared to bring plenty of wipes, as the ice cream melts fairly quickly. The servers are very nice and patient as you decide what to get. Regarding new hires, hopefully, the managers will either train their new employees more or be nearby should the new employees run into any trouble, and not feel scared to ask their manager for help when they make mistakes. We chose not to say anything, as we all were once new hires. I give it 3 1/2 stars, but I've rounded it up to 4.
Okay the only reason this isn't a five stars is because I'm pretty sure I was given the wrong ice cream scoops lol BUT it was all still fabulousssss. Now ten bucks will get you FOUR HUUUUGE SCOOPS OF ICE CREAM and they have a million flavors. I really wish they did half scoops because I would've loved to have tried more. They do allow a maximum of three flavor samplings and they give you a hefty spoonful to taste. I ordered yellow cake batter, graham central station, maple walnut and salted caramel. I can tell you for sure I could tell what graham central was and maple walnut but the other two flavors in my cup, no idea because neither tasted like what I ordered. For one, there were chocolate chips in one of them??? No clue. Graham central was insaneeee though by far my favorite with HUGEEEE pieces of fudgey chocolate. I would get a quart of that next time. I would skip toppings because I got marshmallow sauce and there was barely any on there and it was like a dollar fifty. I will say though I was such a glutton to get four scoops so that's probably my own fault why they probably couldn't put so much on but even my friend who got two scoops barely anything on it. (I shared my ice cream with someone else I promise I'm not that gluttonous) Also we had no wait and we were there on a Sunday a bit past noon, so maybe that's the best time to go. I do also realize I went in November so maybe that's why there weren't any lines lol
PROS: ice cream was great, prices were decent, staff was friendly, menu variety was plentiful, and atmosphere was farm-like CONS: the workers moved so slow that I thought they were gonna stop. Didn't seem like they cared. A line of 20 people took 45-60 minutes OVERALL: I think this is a nice place, they have parking and seating. Along with great ice cream. But they need to speed up the process without sacrificing quality
So bomb! Every flavor I've tried is creamy and yummy! Cute cow decor outside. They're fast at service but there's usually a line, so just prepare to wait a little.
3 months ago
6 months ago
First time here and the last time. Nothing compared to my fave down the shore ice cream - Cookman Creamery. I had the rocky road and sea salt caramel chunk which was caramel with chocolate chunks and it was ok, I've had better store ice cream. I'm somewhat of an ice cream snob and compare it to my fave ice cream shop I go to every summer (although they are open year round). Rocky road was the better of the 2 flavors I tried here (& my personal favorite flavor) but I had tasted 2 mini marshmallows in the 2 scoops they gave me at the bottom of the subpar caramel chunk ice cream. Service was fine, there was a short line but in the beginning of April it wasn't as bad as I could imagine it could get at other times of the year. read more
Local well known shop! Usually busy and parking can be challenging during late summer nights / weekends. Overall excellent spot! We've loved their sundaes, milkshakes and seasonal hot chocolate drinks. Minimal seating. Would absolutely recommend, staff is usually very nice - little pricey but quality is very good and ice cream tastes fresh. Also huge fan of their hot fudge! Enjoy!!! read more
1 month ago
3 months ago
It's always a great time for Ice Cream and if you're in New Jersey you need to come to Applegate Farm. They have every flavor and it's the perfect outing for the entire family. When I think of Ice Cream this is one of the first places I think of. The staff is always friendly and there's plenty of staff to get your order in quickly and move on to the best part and enjoying some Ice Cream. They also have Sugar-free options. But not as many as I wish they had. Overall it's a great and in many ways nostalgic. read more
Ordered: Cider Donut Sundae (~$15): Dutch Apple ice cream layered with fresh apple cider donut crumbles and caramel, topped with whipped cream, cinnamon sugar, and a homemade cider donut, served in a keepsake Applegate glass Aya's take: Is it even Autumn if you haven't had an apple cider donut!? Applegate Farms will do you one better with their Cider Donut Sundae. It's exactly what it sounds like - sweet, spiced, and creamy. It was actually super satisfying especially with the layers of apple cider donut crumbles throughout. I love that it comes with a whole apple cider donut too that you can munch on while enjoying the sundae. The caramel was a bit too thick and made it harder to eat but other than that, it was a good try. It's massive so I definitely suggest sharing among 2-3 people and don't forget to take that keepsake glass home with you! The line situation was inefficient and the staff is generally slow so keep in mind that there are multiple lines all serving the full menu and know what you want when you get up to order. Worth a try if you're in the area! read more
2 months ago
Cute ice cream place in Montclair. We stopped there on a hot Sunday afternoon and the place was slammed. Overall the ice cream is solid and the sundaes look good but they are massive!! The service is slow so pack your patience and while waiting in line there is not much air movement so on those hot and humid days/nights it's a little uncomfortable while you wait. The Shirley Temple gelati was quite good but wish they had a few more shaved ice flavors. Also, I wish they sold water or other beverages as well. read more
I was enticed to try this place after seeing how decadent their sundaes were, but the sundae fell short for me. Too many fixings, not enough ice cream. The quality of the ice cream is good though, I think I would have been better off with something more simple. Service was good, lots of people working there to accommodate and crowd and the barn look was very inviting. read more
1 year ago
Came here on a Sunday night and it was absolutely packed, but the lines moved fairly quickly and we were there for a total of 30 minutes (a long time fir ice cream, I know). There's a lot of parking in the back, as well as on the street. They don't have a place for you to eat the ice cream so most people I saw would just go back to their cars. I got their Graham Central and it was definitely better than others I have tried. It was like biting into a graham cracker! Their junior cup was huge and fairly priced (5.50 I believe). It was definitely good, but considering it has been named one of the best in New Jersey, it didn't fully live up to par with other ice cream places I've tried in Montclair. read more
Don't cheat yourself treat yourself! This is great hot chocolate you will not regret coming here. It's super tasty. I tried the gingerbread and the cookies and cream, hot chocolate and was not disappointed. It's very filling, however, so you could probably share one drink with somebody else. Service was quick and everyone was friendly. The presentation of the hot chocolate made it Insta worthy. Be mindful seating is outdoors. You might want to sit inside the car. read more
What a cute and charming ice cream spot! I love that it's open all year round, perfect for whenever you're craving a sweet treat, even in the colder months. They have a wide variety of flavors, so there's something for everyone. I did a one scoop sundae with the cookies and cream and everything was rich, creamy, and absolutely delicious. There isn't any indoor or outdoor seating, but there's plenty of parking available. Most people just enjoy their ice cream in their cars, which actually adds to the laid-back, local vibe of the place. It's simple, no-frills, and all about great ice cream. I'll definitely be coming back to try more flavors! read more
As the summer was coming to an end, we simply had to stop at Applegate Farms for our last licks of ice cream. As you're driving, you'll quickly spot a ginormous, fake cow, and you'll know you have arrived. During the summer, this place is packed, and the lines move fairly quickly. This time, during the fall, the lines were minimal. You can scan or just take a photo of their offered flavors prior to ordering. The last time I was here, I ordered their famous peach ice cream. It was good but a bit too sweet for me. My husband loved it. This time around, I ordered a Cappuccino Crunch ice cream, my husband ordered Peanut Butter Fudge Brownie ice cream, and our kid ordered a "root beer" float. Upon tasting the "root beer," we noted it didn't taste like root beer. The server explained it wasn't, as they were very low on root beer, so he substituted it with Coke instead. He also explained he's a new hire and didn't think to ask if it was okay for him to switch. The drink was okay, but we wish we had been given a heads-up. The serving size is interesting. Most of the time, their junior size is huge, so I ordered a junior, as did my husband. Oddly, when we received them, they both looked vastly different. When the server charged us, he had me as a regular cone and my husband as a junior, and the kid's drink as a regular root beer float. When we brought it to his attention, he stated he made a mistake, and he's new and had already rung it up. Oy. The place, when it's crazy busy, can obviously be a hard place to keep clean, but most of the people are very good at cleaning up after themselves. There are no chairs or tables where you can sit and enjoy, but there are barrels where you can put your drinks or cups down as you stand by, or makeshift benches by the wooden planks. There are no bathrooms, so be prepared to bring plenty of wipes, as the ice cream melts fairly quickly. The servers are very nice and patient as you decide what to get. Regarding new hires, hopefully, the managers will either train their new employees more or be nearby should the new employees run into any trouble, and not feel scared to ask their manager for help when they make mistakes. We chose not to say anything, as we all were once new hires. I give it 3 1/2 stars, but I've rounded it up to 4. read more
2 months ago
Applegate Farms is a lovely place. It has gained a lot of popularity for reasons I don't know. Service was quick. The place is always busy though! Ice cream was good. I ordered mint chocolate chip in a cup. It was good ( tasted like toothpaste though-lol) still great though! read more
11 months ago
Okay the only reason this isn't a five stars is because I'm pretty sure I was given the wrong ice cream scoops lol BUT it was all still fabulousssss. Now ten bucks will get you FOUR HUUUUGE SCOOPS OF ICE CREAM and they have a million flavors. I really wish they did half scoops because I would've loved to have tried more. They do allow a maximum of three flavor samplings and they give you a hefty spoonful to taste. I ordered yellow cake batter, graham central station, maple walnut and salted caramel. I can tell you for sure I could tell what graham central was and maple walnut but the other two flavors in my cup, no idea because neither tasted like what I ordered. For one, there were chocolate chips in one of them??? No clue. Graham central was insaneeee though by far my favorite with HUGEEEE pieces of fudgey chocolate. I would get a quart of that next time. I would skip toppings because I got marshmallow sauce and there was barely any on there and it was like a dollar fifty. I will say though I was such a glutton to get four scoops so that's probably my own fault why they probably couldn't put so much on but even my friend who got two scoops barely anything on it. (I shared my ice cream with someone else I promise I'm not that gluttonous) Also we had no wait and we were there on a Sunday a bit past noon, so maybe that's the best time to go. I do also realize I went in November so maybe that's why there weren't any lines lol read more
1 year ago
PROS: ice cream was great, prices were decent, staff was friendly, menu variety was plentiful, and atmosphere was farm-like CONS: the workers moved so slow that I thought they were gonna stop. Didn't seem like they cared. A line of 20 people took 45-60 minutes OVERALL: I think this is a nice place, they have parking and seating. Along with great ice cream. But they need to speed up the process without sacrificing quality read more
1 year ago
So bomb! Every flavor I've tried is creamy and yummy! Cute cow decor outside. They're fast at service but there's usually a line, so just prepare to wait a little. read more
Went here on a beautiful, sunny Mother's Day Sunday for some ice cream after brunch and botanical garden with 4 other people. The place was PACKED. We definitely had to divide and conquer with standing in separate lines. Speaking of lines...OOOOHHHMMMMMMMGGGGGG. We were in line for over an hour and 15 minutes!!!!! When one of us finally got to the front to order, we almost forgot about the wait,...almost. I got dulce de leche and rum raisin. My ice cream was smooth, creamy and ooh so yummy. The servers there did the best they could with the crowd and was friendly. read more
1 year ago
I've been coming here for years. It's one of my favorite ice cream spots in North Jersey. During warm months the lines can be quite lengthy and parking limited, but that's to be expected. The dulce de leche ice cream is absolutely worth the trip! Although it is open year round, there are no bathrooms or seating so be prepared if it's crowded. read more
1 year ago
Totally amazing ice cream ! I love this place it's so cute ( looks like a farm ) and is spacious outdoor seating . You choose the ice cream you want and there are tons of flavors . There are a few servers and the place is packed there is always a line but they are efficient and it moves pretty quickly !I chose the homemade strawberry cheesecake it is to die for !!! Very good ice cream and we sat outside it is so cute and delicious I will definitely be returning for more :) read more
I had been dying to try this place since we drive past it everytime we go to Montclair. since the weather was a little dreary it thankfully wasnt packed. i love the farm vibe; it's a very cute place to take kids! the portions are massive so be warned. i got the junior size and couldnt even finish my cone. my husband took it as a personal challenge to finish his medium cone haha. the ice cream was very rich and fresh. i got toasted almond and he got maple walnut. the nuts in both were fresh and crunchy. my only criticism is the prices are a little higher than other places nearby. We'll def be back but it will probably be only a once or twice a year trip for us! read more
9 months ago
6 months ago
6 months ago
Decided to stop by applegate farm since we were in the mood for ice cream. The place was packed and for good reason, the birthday cake was one of the best I've ever had and the quality of the ice cream was outstanding. It was rich and creamy and you could taste the freshness of the milk. Definitely one of my favorite ice cream places and I will be back! read more
3 months ago
3 years ago
They don't honor the $2 dollar off sundae yelp coupon you receive when you check in. This place has definitely gone down hill over the years. And what I mean by that is purely the icecream flavors. It's just not as great as I tried 10 years ago. The taste is okay. I tried the extreme cookies and cream and seasonal ginger bread. It's not as sweet or extreme as advertised. Don't expect Van Leeuwen sweetness. I'd much rather stop by a grocery store and buy a pint of Ben and Jerry's and be satisfied with that over a sundae of this. There's better homemade icecream places in NJ. read more
4 months ago
2 years ago
The ice cream is very rich and fresh. I always get the peanut butter chocolate flavor ice cream. Portions are big that's why prices are a bit expensive. It's always busy they have. Parking lot behind the building that no one seems to know about. Everyone brings kids here plenty of space for them to roam around. read more
1 year ago
9 months ago
8 months ago
I've been here twice, once in the summer and once in the winter. The lines here are ridiculous and the service is incredibly slow. On both occasions I noticed couples and families split between the lines to see which would move faster. The ice cream is definitely delicious and the hype is understandable but they need a better system. In regard to their hot chocolate in the winter. I waited 40 mins on line for something so underwhelming. I'm glad I got the one that comes with a scoop of oreo ice cream because it helped it a lot but without it, the chocolate itself is so mid. it's just whatever. I've definitely made better at home. It look authentic with the machines they use to make it but it tastes almost watered down and the marshmallow they use on top is so overpowering and all over, it kind of ruined for me. It was definitely too much marshmallow, it took up most of the top of my cup and then when i was drinking i realized there was more marshmallow on the bottom. I would recommend this place if you want some genuine ice cream, but you must have patience and be prepared to wait. read more
6 months ago
Love Applegate! All of their flavors are homemade and made on site. It can get a bit crazy during the summer time and warmer days. Service is usually pretty fast unless their is a long wait! Cute little red barn with cow statues all over the property. It's a new favorite and must stop for me whenever I'm in the Montclair area. Parking is a bit crazy as it's just a paved lot with no designated spots. And from time to time people drive through a bit too fast. read more
1 year ago
Page 1 of 13
More info about Applegate Farm Ice Cream
616 Grove St
Montclair, NJ 07043
Directions
(973) 744-5900
Call Now
Order Takeout
Start Order
Visit Website
http://www.applegatefarm.com/
Full menu
Hours
Payment methods
Food & Alcohol
Indoor Amenities
Outdoor Amenities
Other Amenities
From the Business
Ask the Community - Applegate Farm Ice Cream
You might also consider
Why does Yelp recommend reviews?
46 reviews that are not currently recommended
The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.
10 years ago
9 months ago
1 year ago
2 years ago
10 years ago
8 years ago
12 years ago
7 years ago
10 years ago
6 years ago
1 year ago
9 years ago
7 years ago
9 years ago
13 years ago
7 years ago
10 years ago
8 years ago
9 years ago
