Ordered delivery from this pizza place. Ordered a cheese pie, garlic knots and a side of extra sauce. Delivery was prompt and pizza was warm. I tried the pizza and knots right away- however I was most impressed after a while, I popped those bad boys in the oven and boy was that a great idea. I was impressed with the knots and the sauce- and pizza crust !! Yummm the crust was a little crispier then when the pizza arrived just how I like it!! When pizza arrived pizza was delicious, but the crust was just a little more fluffy & doughy than I like. The only reason why I wouldn't give the pizza 5 stars- is the sauce. There wasn't enough sauce on the pizza. I did however add the sauce from the extra side for the knots and I was satisfied. I will absolutely be trying more slices from this location :) Yum. CHEERS read more

Giovanni's Pizza - Cheese Pizza Pie - Pizza Near Me - West Babylon, New York

See all

Wow I've had some bad pizza but this one is now on top! Too much cheese for a plain slice oily and greasy which means cheap cheese. Crust was undercooked with the weight of the cheese on my first slice flopped in half and fell apart. The owner or the cook must of seen me struggling and immediately asked me if I wanted it well done from over the counter! Being polite and based on my lunch time I said "No I'm good!" I couldn't even eat the second slice. Will not be back here again... read more

Giovanni's Pizza - Greasy oily to much cheese and undercooked! - Pizza Near Me - West Babylon, New York

Very disappointed with the Sicilian pie we ordered. It is obvious that it was day old pizza. The crust was dry and brittle. The sauce was barely available on the pie and the cheese just terrible. We simply looked at each other and understood that this was old and just a tasteless reheated pie. I will never eat there again. Looking for a person in need to give the pie too read more

All I got was 2 regular slices. First of all almost 8 bucks is criminal.. I had one bite and was disgusted by it. Would've paid maybe 3 cents for their regular slice. Absolutely atrocious. Do better. How could I put less than 1 star? read more

Small, but cute spot! Never been here before because we don't live in the area but they likely do more takeout based on small seating area. 4 of us ordered at the counter and then sat at a table. Our slices were done in 5 minutes and they were all very good! A couple Sicilian (HUGE slices) and several different types of round pizza. Service was friendly and efficient throughout and pizza very good, all of it! Super crispy crust which gets them to 3 stars just for that! Hot, good cheese and plum tomato sauce and I give them 4 stars. Could have gone 4.5 stars for great service but in NYC metro area I don't give 5 stars to pizza shops easily. Definitely a good lunch stop for us though! read more

See all

Been getting pizza from here since my boyfriend and I moved to the area almost 1 year ago. Great pizza, great speciality slices. Highly recommend! read more

Average pizza joint with a variety of choices for slices. Not too much sitting room but the four of us made it work. Young lady behind the counter was friendly. Crust was different from what I like for New York pizza but flavor was pretty good! read more

Giovanni's Pizza - Pepperoni slice cheese slice - Pizza Near Me - West Babylon, New York

See all

For the price I paid this was a major let down. Pizza is good for children. (Maybe) not adults who know better read more

Giovanni's Pizza - This pizza is pretty bad. Good for small children not adults. - Pizza Near Me - West Babylon, New York

Called in an order of 2 pies, 2 sodas & plates.. called back 10 minutes later explaining how I called the wrong pizza place & asked if since they have 45 minutes left til close, if they could use those pies for other customers and refund my money. As the girl on the phone asked if this can be done, the guy in the background was screaming "too bad it's a slow night and we were waiting for her to leave she's not getting her money back" -- absolutely DISGUSTING service, and the phone girl proceeded to laugh at me as I asked why this can't be done as I've worked at a pizzeria for years and have done this hundreds of times, and spent $55 on my order. With such disrespectful people working there, can't imagine their pizza is much better. I guess they needed $ that bad, embarassing. read more

Since I was pet sitting for my sis in law, my fiancé and I wanted to grab a quick bite for dinner. We went to Giovanni's pizza since we had gone there once before. They have a daily special of two regular slices of pizza and a drink or 1 specialty slice and a drink for $5. I wasn't in the mood for pizza this time around, so I order a plate of baked ziti. The baked ziti was delicious with a marinara sauce with a slight sweetness and lots of ricotta cheese and topped with melted mozzarella. The pasta was cooked just passed al dente. Since we were eating there, they served the baked ziti on a plate. We decided to eat in the pizza place. There are a few tables to eat your meal, but probably not suitable if you have more than 4 people in your group since it's a small place. Service was very good here. We would return for another meal if we are in the area. read more

See all

Ive always dealt with Giovannis this last order was suppose to b lasagna well no height as lasagna should b 2 sheets very very very little meat globs and globs of mozzarella on top didn't loom or taste like lasagna soooo disappointed . When I called to about order the gentleman without saying hinted to me as if i was bullshitting well I wasn't guess I'll go to taste of Italy in Islip their food is consistently great and u get good portions. Vert very disappointed in giovannis ive been dealing with them for so long read more

Our go to spot for pickup Italian food. Had the pizza a few times and each time it was great. My fiancé loves their Greek salad.

Walking into this place please wear all your protective gear!!! The staff wear NO MASK OR GLOVES!!! They talk over the food spittle flying everywhere!! I get things get busy, but COVID-19!!!!! Honestly unless you're immune from covid-19 or are willing to risk poor sanitary habits for sub-par pizza; go elsewhere!! read more

We were struggling with pizza places in the area, (one had good food, bad pizza. One had Great Sicilian but bad specialty pies and were expensive. The guy across the street from here was arrested once for selling OxyContin). Then Giovanni answered our prayers. His pizzas are Phenomenal! Crispy crust, terrific sauce and great specialty slices - especially the chicken bacon ranch!!! We even tried catering for a party and our mind was blown! We ordered a balsamic blaze chicken dish as a lightweight meal that was fantastic. Broccoli rabe and sausage was delicious too. Also we ordered mini Heros (chicken and eggplant parm) were awesome as well! Giovanni and the kids that work there are always super friendly. They earned a loyal Customer for life! read more

See all

the best pizza. all entrees are home made and you can tell. A local guy works hard and loves his work. "G" is joyful and warm when you yell back to him in the middle of the dinner rush. local kids go back to the half door to watch this master at work. keep on rocking! read more

It was something to rave about, but then I had an individual specialty slice and I almost threw up. I prayed I would make it home. The garlic knots are not great. The sauce is good. I'm going to back to another place where there was a better experience. read more

I would never order from this place again. I just ordered it a baked ziti. Bake ziti is usually 11:50 in any other place these people charge me $15!! As we all know baked ziti comes with bread and salad. It was no salad, just a little piece of bread and no Fork. read more

My family and I just had the baked clams, muscles in white wine sauce and the bruschetta pizza-- WOW!! Will definitely be ordering here again read more

Best pizza in the area. Its all about the crust, the thickness to crunch ratio is perfect. Not too doughy, but not too thin. Best slice I've had since ive been on my long island 2018 pizza tour. This spot is legit!! read more

They've changed for the worse. Their pizza cheese is not 100% mozzrella and that's the end of my business

Good guy and Pizza is excellent and the service is excellent as well family and friendly environment

This is my families favorite place for pizza. The way they cook the crust puts it over the top. Staff is always very pleasant and punctual on deliveries. In a town with good pizza, we think this is the best. read more

This is by far the best pizzeria has the best pizza and food hands down you will not regret coming here read more

See all

Finally after living in west Babylon for almost 4 years I have found the pizza place that is actually good and delivers. It took many burned pizzas and all around terrible food from many other local pizza places to find this gem. The service is great. The delivery drivers are always really nice and the food is great! read more

This place is incredible. John's of Bleeker and Grimaldi's have nothing on Giovanni's. I would never have expected so much out of a pizza place in West Babylon but now I can't figure out why they aren't making television shows about it. They are the best! read more

called to order a special from there website. Needed coupon explained my printer wasnt working they wouldn't honor it on phone. tryed to use a friend printer by the time i got there they updated there website i guess because coupon was no longer on it. Used to order a least 1 a week but no more horrible service. Will Cater superbowl somewhere else this year. read more

The best pizza in West Babylon. Crust is amazing. Not just a pizza place though. All the items on the menu are superb. Great place for lunch or dinner! read more

Nice place ! First time there! The Place is clean , and the workers were very pleasant ! The cheese pie just came out of the oven , that I received my slices with extra cheese . Excellent pizza , of course very fresh ! I will come back again ! read more

I would like to rate this place higher because the specialty slices are amazing, however, I really hate walking in here. The place was just redone and it's even smaller than it used to be. The owner's family is ALWAYS sitting at one of only two tables. They are old and loud and they take the time and attention of the staff away from paying customers. Speaking of the staff, they are not very nice. They always have an attitude. The owner himself is also rude and treats his staff like crap. He spends all his time speaking in Italian to his family and yelling at his employees. The food is good but I'm not sure it's worth the hassle. Pizza places in Long Island are a dime a dozen so go somewhere else and get a better experience. read more

Ordered a pizza half pepperoni Friday night . Looked beautiful perfectly cooked crust . it had absolutely no flavor from the sauce down to the crust.don't these owners taste there products or are they just self brainwashed because it's there business. I have a great idea they should take a taste trip to the Bronx and then taste there's again. read more

Their pizza is great, best in the area by far. The crust is firm and the cheese to sauce ratio is definitely 2:1. Their prices are kind of high though. My boyfriend and I got a small pizza (half pepperoni) a house salad, 2-liter bottle of Pepsi and zeppolis (6 for $3 which is a pretty good deal since they're nice and big) but the total was over $30. HOW EXPENSIVE WAS THAT SALAD?! I'll keep going back b/c their food is worth it, it just means we only get pizza once a month :( read more

The owner is rude to his staff and customers. The food is disgusting and expensive. I would not recommend this restaurant. You can find better Italian food somewhere else. read more

Definitely the best pizza in the area. Make sure to ask for the pizza hot as some of the girls working the counter don't heat up the pizza enough, but other then that the pizza is great. read more

Love their pizza! Pasta dishes also delicious!! Don't go anywhere else in West Babylon.

I have been eating from here ever since they were in North Babylon,I moved and didn't have it for about two years then when me and my husband got an apartment in West Babylon I noticed they moved down the street I was so happy I love there dinner special a large pie,6garlic knots and 2 liter Pepsi only 21bucks the pizza is my favorite I have had others in the area nothing compares read more

The pizza is okay. Not bad. Not great. Not good. But okay. The pizza has a good amount of cheese. Has some sauce. I prefer more but the amount of sauce they have is just fine. The crust was a problem for me. It was tough. Made my jaw hurt soon after chewing. Hard tough crust. I prefer my dough softer. The taste was okay like I said. If you're looking for really good delicious pizza, I wouldn't recommend his place. Best part was the price. $15 for a large pie. Miceli brothers pizza across the street a block down is delicious and way way better. I highly recommend that place. Price great too. $16 for a large pie. read more

5 stars hands down, the owner is kind and the pizza is unlike any other. Seems like some ppl are tough critics (those giving this place a low rating) I'm from the Bronx and even the pizzerias by me don't make pizza like Giovanni's does! Keep up the great work! read more

Very good pizza for a fair price. It can get a little awkward when you are there and the employees are being yelled at though. Good pizza poor display of professionalism. read more

My go to pizza spot. They serve a variety of specialty pizza. The Spicy Hawaiian Chicken is my favorite. Inside is renovated and very nice area. There is outdoor seating. They are closed on Mondays. There are a few pizza spots to choose on that block, your best bet is to eat here. read more

Great Pizza, and the service is always great. I'm so glad there is still good authentic pizza around!