Pizza Express

•$

Self proclaimed Pizza Snob here. Tried this place tonight for the first time. Been passing by for…read moremonths and finally stopped by. Firstly, the place is nice...neighborhood kind of place. Clean and well lit. The folks at the counter were friendly and helpful! Went against habit as I was craving a Tomato/cheese slice and glad I did. The slice was very warm, not blazing hot. I like it when it's very warm so I can enjoy it right away, which I did! The crust was crisp without being crunchy. The sauce, the most important part, was not overly sweet. The cheese was yummy without being salty. This was a very yummy slice indeed! Definitely going back and soon!

Affordable, yummy, and a quick delivery. Driver was nice and food was fresh. Will be back.read more

Margarita Pizza

Taco Slice ~ 4.10.26

See all

Tomato/cheese slice

Mama's

3.7(693 reviews)

Mama's catered my daughter's first birthday party and they were absolutely phenomenal from start to…read morefinish. The entire process was seamless -- the staff was so kind, professional, and communicative throughout every step. The food was delivered with such care and everything was fresh, hot, and delicious. We ordered the shrimp, oregano, penne alla vodka, and the chicken Parmesan, and every single dish was outstanding. My guests could not stop talking about how amazing the food was -- people were genuinely raving about it all day. Mama's helped make such a special occasion even more memorable, and I would absolutely recommend them for any event or catering needs. We will definitely be ordering again!

Had 3 specialty slices…read more 2 were chicken pesto and one was a cup and char grandma style w sausage meat. All looked great but were way over salted and not edible by my taste. Mommas has an excellent reputation and i will only try it again because of Mommas good reputation. I did not enjoy my meal nor did i finish it. Disappointed! Mommas do better! But Great professional counter service!

Tito's Seafood Combo

See all

Salmon & Scallop Risotto

Parisi’s Pizza And Pasta

3.8(32 reviews)

We still love Parisis! You cannot beat the sesame seed crust. I don't know how they get it coated…read moreso well. I also fell in love with their sausage pizza. It's in long strips and so amazing. The white pizza is also amazing. It always comes on time and I just can't have non sesame seed pizza anymore bc of them. They have great specials on the slice app I use weekly.

Had a chicken roll and half and chucked the other half in the trash. It had a raw dough center with…read moredry chicken which I'm very glad they were cheap with. For $10 you must do much much better.

Menu

The Vodka Margherita Pizza first time trying was amazing! Could have used a little more basil

See all

Menu

Alitalia Pizzeria & Restaurant

3.5(223 reviews)

2.6 mi

Recommend you go to Alitalia. They got the best food there and that pizza is great. Their food is…read morethe best.

Had the pleasure to be able to stop and have an early dinner yesterday at Alitalia, we used to live…read morein West Babylon over 30 years ago and haven't been there since. We had a party of 4 and arrived at about 3pm, we didn't realize that the dining room didn't open till 4pm but they let us sit down in the dining room and we had to order from the counter which was no big deal. They did have a young lady in the dining room but she said she was not a waitress, this is just my opinion but they should let her wait on tables when something like this comes up so she can get the experience to become a waitress. Food was delicious, we all had different chicken dishes and all of us loved what we had. Prices were very fair. Definitely will be going back soon. They also do a pasta night and a chicken night the was very reasonable.

See all

Mikes Pizza

4.3(69 reviews)

1.2 mi

Best pizza i've had in years. Also the cheese steak is to die for. Actually, all of the items on…read morethe menu are great. Thanks Mike!!!

What I tasted last night was pretty incredible. I've made these claims before but it's only because…read moreI haven't tried every pizza on Long Island. Mikes Underground Pizza just slid into my Number One Spot for the best pizza on Long Island. There's a lot of quirks to piss people off to get at this pizza. My father in law in Florida wouldn't have the patience to pull off this caper. -Coming from the north shore to drive south, *1000 Montauk Hwy* on the Tesla Nav will not bring you to the location, I was at the hospital in Islip. You have to put West Babylon at the end -And it's *Cash ONLY*. Now that we have the pleasantries out of the way, let's continue with the review. The 14" Clam Pie is a game changer. I've waited on very long lines at Frank Pepe's in New Haven to get their clam Apizza. It's good but Mikes Pizza is far superior. Simple with freshly shucked clams, garlic and breadcrumbs, now add the crust that a comes from a true New York pizzaiolo who doesn't cut the pizza Connecticut style (like it came out of a slasher film) and now you have a competition pizza that Dave Portnoy would give a 9.4. The Vodka Round was equally impressive. The sauce was so complex, first bite I could tell it was a home run, out the box (see what I did there) a winner. Here's my issue, I drove from the North Shore to the South Shore to an abandoned bank parking lot to get at this pizza. I know the business model is working for you but it doesn't for the customers. I have a plan! Listen, I'm ready to retire. I'm thinking about the next few years driving on the Belt Parkway to Bay Ridge and it gives me night terrors. Let's do this together! By Stony Brook, the college kids will go wild! All kidding aside, Number one pizza on Long Island. March 2026

A work of art, delivered in a work of art

Clam pizza

See all

Vodka Pizza

Caffe Catania Pizzeria & Pasta

4.2(12 reviews)

Best garlic nuts in town , and also recommend the ham and corn pizza they are the only ones that…read morehave it !! Highly recommend

I hate to be the one to give a poor review, but here it goes. The Sicilian Pie was only $21.00 10…read moreslices. Wen I opened the box, there was half a Sicilian pie in there. The pie was only half the size of a standard sized Pie ie; Mamas, or Raimos Trattoria, or Mr. Gs, or Spassos, or Joes Pizza in my area/ No wonder it was only $21.00. I thought it was a good deal when I phoned, and ordered delivery. The lady quoted that price. It was not that good at all IMO. My sister liked it however. To me it was the worst pizza I had. What really Topped it off was the dozen garlic knots I added to the order. The WORST. No Olive oil, no garlic, no Flavor. They were like dry breakfast biscuits with garlic powder sprinkled on top. Horrible. Well, live, and Learn. You get what you pay for. Good luck

Send

See all

Nico's Charred Pies

4.8(32 reviews)

0.7 mi

Delicious fresh pizza. So happy we came to try. We see outside on the patio area which was very…read morenice except when the train went by lol otherwise definitely a great find

I finally got to try the pizza. Came Thursday at noon when the open. It was beautiful out so…read morepeople were sitting outside It was still a line for pizza. The pizza did not disappoint. Super crispy can't wait to try their other pies

@stephanieeatsworld

See all

Slice

Raimo's Brick Oven Pizzeria & Trattoria

3.6(100 reviews)

1.8 mi

Outstanding, delicious pizza - they aim to please. Last minute order for lunch - ordered by phone…read moreand this restaurant delivered food super fast. Very helpful and focused on the right amount of food and add-ons - everyone loved the food - Definitely the gem of Amityville!

I think they are a great restaurant and have delicious food. We ate in a few times and the…read more Waitress service is excellent. Very attentive and friendly and courteous!! Food was excellent. Homemade bread and rolls very tasty. Have no criticisms to make only compliments to make! Would recommend Ramos for lunch or dinner. You won't be disappointed! It's a family type restaurant like we had in the old days growing up in NYC! Bona Petite!

Crappy pizza.

See all

Giovanni's Pizza & Restaurant

4.3(87 reviews)

2.2 mi

Ordered 5 pies for a pizza party I had for a customer near this location. Calledthem about 11:10am…read moreto place the order, picked it up about 40 minutes later. It was ready to go, everything was done professionally and handled nicely. They helped me to my car with the pies. Pricing was reasonable. Would definitely return.

We love this Pizzeria and the Family who owns it! The pizza the Sicilian is the best I've had in…read morethe area! They are always welcoming and it's a nice place.

Large 18" Pie

Sweet Chili Chicken Pizza

See all

Chocolate lava cake

Albert's Pizza Shop

3.4(89 reviews)

0.8 mi

•$

The best pizza dough, the best pizza sauce, and the cheese is perfect! I love Albert's pizzaread more

I will need to give it another try. The pizza was just ok and the garlic knots were not cooked all…read morethe way and very doughy. Maybe I need to try their upside down slice.