I drive by this place all the time and never thought anything of it. Well I googled best pizza…read moreand this place came up. Went for pickup and the lot had a lot of cars also picking up. There was like 6 people working there. It must get busy. The girl who was taking phone orders was super sweet. I watched her take an order and she was even smiling The pizza was delicious. Their regular slice really good and their pepperoni "chips" so good and only like $.80 cents. I also agree it's their sauce. Also garlic knots are super seasoned in a good way. My new go to place now

I came here based on a recommendation from a guy named Pino we met in a Massapequa coffee shop…read more So thank you Pino if you read these posts. Easily, Best pizza this side of the Atlantic. Crispy crust. best sauce and cheese. Friendly service. And I'll be back for a deep Fried Calzone, an almost impossible to find favorite. My new favorite!!!!

If I can give this place 0 stars, I would! First of all the staff is rude which is insane since our…read moreorder was almost $100. I also noticed at the restaurant that the guy making the pizza was touching money but never washed his hands. Then he proceeded to go back to playing with the dough! Anyway, we get home to find a piece of plastic and a hair in our pizza. When we called, the person on the phone acted shocked. This isn't the first incident we've had but we gave this place another shot since the pizza was somewhat decent. If my child would have gotten that plastic, we would've had bigger problems. I would never return or recommend anyone go here. Unsanitary practices in the front of the store, so I can't imagine what goes on in the back.

Ordered from here for the first time. We ordered garlic knots, mozzarella sticks, and a pepperoni…read morepie. The garlic knots did not have much garlic on them, and they were very doughy. I wish they had been cooked for a little longer. The mozzarella sticks were good. The pizza was good but VERY oily. But they were very very generous with the pepperoni which was a huge plus! I'd return! Very quick delivery also.

Really solid pizza, nice people and very clean restaurant…read more We also got a chicken wrap with balsamic vinegar and it was great. Would definitely go back!

Super nice place, ambiance was amazing. The guy who served me was super nice, the hospitality…read moreinstantly made me want to come back. Buffalo chicken slice was decent, nothing that blew my mind though. To be fair, I am a tough critic when it comes to Buffalo chicken pizza so take that for what it's worth. Needed more buffalo sauce / ranch (or bleu cheese) action but it was alright, nothing special. Bonus points too for the insane fish bathroom. Definitely took me off guard and got me stoked. Overall I'd say check this place out. You'll leave feeling satisfied.

Of course we are back! We brought my son's friend who just moved here and had to introduce him to…read moresome awesome coal fired pizza. As usual, it was perfectly thin crust. We ordered a new to us pizza: Speck and it was delicious. It was our guest's favorite! This time we also tried the Depequa pie which my daughter because it was crunchy on the outside and soft on the inside. Patio seating is now open since it is summer but we chose to sit inside where it was less noisy. Service was efficient and attentive. Highly recommend!

We've had this place saved on our " go to" for so long and we decided we're in the area we should…read morejust go! And with hungry stomachs and excitement we decided we see they have a back patio let's eat there. While the space is nicely decorated we saw several staff talking to tables and making eye contact with us and not waiting us. We stayed for another few minutes before we found another staff member and asked if we could just grab a table or do we need to wait. We aren't familiar but given the previous man didn't acknowledge us maybe we could just self sit. The women told us she will be right with us and proceeded giving the other customers water. We said ok and patiently waited. I asked the gentleman at the bar if he could give location for restroom. I took my toddler with me to the long walk around. They really could use a bathroom in the back. But regardless, we went and were hoping to see we had a table on the return. Unfortunately that wasn't the case. My husband was still standing around. We waited for 15 minutes, mind you there were plenty of empty tables. I see this place has amazing reviews, I can't tell if this is just a local spot and they just service them but truly it was baffling to see several people working yet no one could give us a table. Disappointed that this was a save on our list and couldn't even taste it. Poor service

New favorite spot! So my husband and I went to Mama's in…read moreCopiague last night and wow, what a great evening. The place just feels warm and inviting the second you walk in. We had Greg as our server and I have to say, he really made our night. From the moment he came to our table he was warm, funny, and genuinely made us feel like we were the only people in the restaurant. He knew the menu inside and out and when I was torn between two dishes he gave me the best recommendation without hesitation. He checked in at all the right times without ever feeling intrusive and just had this great energy that set the tone for the whole evening. Honestly Greg alone is a reason to go back. The food was so good too. Everything tasted fresh and the portions were way more generous than I expected. We got specialty cocktails to start and they were so good we ordered another round. Dinner was delicious but the highlight for me was the homemade pistachio cheesecake for dessert. I am not even a big dessert person but that cheesecake was something else. I am still thinking about it today. If you are looking for a great night out on Long Island, just go to Mama's. You will not regret it!

** THE FOOD WAS GOOD. THE SERVICE WAS ABYSMAL **…read more This is a beautiful restaurant and I wish I could base this review on aesthetics alone. My family and I are still reeling from our experience here this week. The food here is very good. We all agreed. Unfortunately, we also agreed that the "service" was about the worst we can remember having anywhere. Our server was a male, perhaps mid 40s, light hair, little ponytail, not very tall. We did not get his name. Right from the beginning we noticed something seemed off about him. He was rushing, was clearly agitated, aggressive, and rudely interrupted us when we attempted to ask questions. Appetizer salads arrived at our table even before we were finished ordering our dinners (we still had menus) and when we asked him to *please* slow down, that we wanted to enjoy the dinner, he raised his voice and got visibly angry. We saw him walk away, throw up his hands and shake his head, all in plain view of us. His behavior continued throughout our meal and made the entire experience so unpleasant and uncomfortable. When he brought over a bowl of soup, he said, very loud and sarcastically, "There's a spoon there for ya!" Honestly, he seemed so worked up, I was worried he was going to dump the thing in my lap. Dude clearly has issues he brought to work with him. We also noticed this person openly coughing into his hands, rubbing his nose, and then serving food to another table. (We did mention this to another server as that is pretty disgusting.) We were celebrating a birthday and when we came in we asked the host at the door to please put a candle in whatever dessert we ordered. We provided a bag with a candle. Well, we ordered dessert, but the candle was MIA. Nothing, nada. When we left, they gave us back the bag, but the candle was missing. (!) By this point we weren't even surprised. (And they told us the candle had been in the dessert. It definitely wasn't) One star is for the food, the other is for the kind woman with the long dark hair who also tended to our table for the first hour or so. This is clearly a nice restaurant with a good reputation and good food, but sadly, our visit was terrible; a very bad experience and one we wish we could forget.

Good food all around here. Love their meatballs, margherita pie and chicken Marsala slices!!!read more

When I visited NY my bucket list was to find an authentic mom and pop pizzeria and this is exactly…read morewhat I got. This store is nice and clean, the service was amazing. Celli was attentive and made me feel like immediate family, like we had known each other for years. The food was immaculate. From presentation, cost, and of course taste. I will be returning every time I'm in the area.

Now this is a family favorite! Excellent flavor -…read more Good Quality - Cost effective! They have onsite seating as well as carry out or delivery options. Everything from the sandwiches to the pasta dishes all the way to the pizza and apps everything is like eating from grandmas kitchen! Haven't had a bad dish yet! Just finished a sandwich and had to let everyone know to add this to your lunch/dinner rotation!

We live nearby so we've done takeout from here a bunch of times, and honestly, it's just okay. It's…read morethe definition of a standard neighborhood pizza joint--nothing blows you away, but it's fine if you don't feel like cooking. The regular slice is decent, a little greasy sometimes but the crust has a good crunch to it. We tried the specialty pies a few times and they can be a hit or miss. The chicken parm slice is usually pretty good, but the garlic knots we got last time were super dry and felt like they'd been sitting out for a while. Service is usually quick enough when picking up, but the parking lot can be a total pain during the dinner rush depending on how busy the other stores in the plaza are. It's not a place I'd go out of my way for if I wanted a really killer dinner, but for a quick, convenient weeknight slice, it does the job.

The food is excellent at this fine pizza restaurant. It is a little expensive but worth the money…read more My favorite pizza is the chicken parm.

Prices keep rising. Just paid $10 for a slice and small fountain soda. Cash. Time for a new area…read morepizza place.