Great classic burger drive through that has been around for quite some time in the local area. They have the best breakfast burrito I have found in Caldwell and huge coffee portions. My only gripe would be they can be painfully slow. read more

Great onion rings, good chili cheese fries and decent burgers. Was a little disappointed in the milk shakes, but with the BOGO on Friday & Saturday it's still not terrible. The ham on the hamburger was definitely different but not in a bad way. Next time I'll stick with one of the basket options but overall, solid old school spot. That being said - just because it shares part of its name with a certain chain from California does not mean it is close to that in anyway shape or form. Despite locals insisting it's better- it's too different to call one better than the other. Would come back. Tip- it's tight inside! Plan on getting it to go or eating in your car! read more

Went here on a whim....and I'm a fan. Prices are fair and reasonable for today's market. Their fry sauce is delicious. Support local! read more

Absolutely amazing, they accommodated my entire lacrosse team, of over 50 people. The food was absolutely amazing. Took incredible care of us couldn't have asked for more! Thank you! read more

Gem In & Out - Burgers Near Me - Caldwell, Idaho

I grew up in Caldwell in the 80's and loved going to this place back in the day. So of course when I come to town it's always on my list of places to visit. I get a good old fashioned cheeseburger and tots. Their fry sauce is home made and so perfect for the tots. The building is older of course but I think that adds to the charm. The staff is always so nice and helpful. read more

Gem In & Out - The menu - Burgers Near Me - Caldwell, Idaho

The food is awesome. T h e owner is really nice. There 2 for 1 ice shakes. There onion rings to die for.

Good food, friendly service. Only advice is do NOT go here during peak hours (lunch or dinner) because they are busy and the line is long. I was car #4 when I entered the drive thru line at noon and it took me a little over 10 minutes to get to the service window. read more

Gem In & Out - Menu October 2024 - Burgers Near Me - Caldwell, Idaho

See all

Service was great. Nice little burger joint in Caldwell. I had the spicy chicken sandwich, or so I thought. They had the chicken sandwich on special. I asked if the spicy chicken was part of that deal. After being told no, I ordered the spicy chicken combo. The sandwich was okay. The chicken breast was a little small to the bun. It had great flavor, but I detected no spice at all. The tots tasted good and were stove hot, a plus for me. Free refills on the drink, as it should be. The sandwich was okay, but I wanted spicy. A few pickles on that sandwich would make it better in my opinion. I will give this place another shot. read more

Gem In & Out - Spicy (?) chicken samminch and tots. - Burgers Near Me - Caldwell, Idaho

The best burgers, great onion rings and, out of the world service. No matter how busy they are, they take time to ensure each guest feels welcome. read more

Food is good. Really like their fried burrito. Burgers are also great. Chicken strips are a good choice too.

Affordable!! Convenient and Fast service!! Pricing is affordable and Great selections to choose from.

I absolutely LOVE Gem in and out. however the past few times my order has been wrong, and or im waiting 20+ minutes at the window just for my order to be incorrect. I support because I enjoy the food and that it's local. Personally I fear the issue is they need to fix the speaker boxes so employees can understand orders and make sure it's not incorrect by repeating it. (I usually don't leave reviews but this is now the sixth time Ive gotten home (across town) and it's completely wrong. again I want to reiterate I LOVE the food just the quality of service via drive thru has gone down significantly. i recommend dining inside.) read more

The food was jus ok nothing special and no mushroom burgers...inside was cute and decorated with vintage decor & theres a drive thru-service was decent read more

Burgers are the best..my all time favorite is the Gemburger! My grandkids love the burgers too

The food is good, but don't go through the drive through if you are on lunch break or in a hurry.

The best bacon lettuce and Tomato sandwiches in the Northwest!! They are awesome!! Great service and all the servers are soooi nice!!! I love this business! read more

Great service, tasty food and amazing prices. The crispy chicken sandwich is so good and we love the curly fries. I drive 30 mins out to Caldwell just to eat here. read more

This place is awesome, and my BLT was loaded with bacon and fresh lettuce and tomato! Simply a great mom and pop restaurant with a drive thru or eat-in option. It also seemed as the locals come here for their lunches too. I wasn't exactly eavesdropping but I did hear the conversation of the two farmers in the next booth over. Bathrooms were clean, so I assumed the kitchen was too. Curly fries were yummy (I ate some of the hubby's). I loved the attitude of the little old lady who took my order! Hmmm, maybe she wasn't that old! read more

Gem In & Out - BLT - Burgers Near Me - Caldwell, Idaho

first off I would like to say that the food here has always been my favorite and second, I am a new employee and I would like to apologize to anyone who had a bad experience here. our #1 priority is our customers, although our drive thru can get pretty busy we really try to prioritize the customer read more

Caveat: I am a native Southern California transplant and yes I like In & Out, but it's NOT the best burger out there. Gotta admit though, I did ask locals on the local foodies FB page, "Hey, where can I get a burger like In & Out." I did not know better. Shout out first, to 13th Street Pub and Grill in the Hyde Park 'hood. They have a burger that will 'break yo mouth'. Set a brand new standard for me. Heard about Gem In & Out from many locals and my clients, so I knew sooner or later I'd be driving thru for a burger. Got the Gem Burger meal, even though I'm not a big fan of ham. The burger was ono and so were the fries. Drive-thru moves a bit slow, but you can tell they are making it fresh as you order. Next try will be their Taco Burger. I like they have their own spin on fast food favorites and I try to support local businesses as much as I possibly can. I'd love it hit this place up more often, but I gotta work out more to justify the extra calories, fat and salt. . . but man, whatta way to go. Note: Again, no photos as there are more than enough here sharing the same things. read more

$30 for two people and food was cold, no napkins, no condiments (that were requested)- maybe off night , but we won't be back

We had a mix of good and not so good at this restaurant on this our first visit. We were very disappointed in their selection of milkshakes (only 4 flavors available) and the fact that they were handed to us already thin and runny. And their cherry milkshake tasted horrible, like fake cherry flavor. We ordered a ranch chicken sandwich which was overcooked, dry, and nearly flavorless, an order of tots which were hot and crispy, but a bit under seasoned, and a taco burger that was actually pretty good for the money. All in all, we were not impressed and will return to other fast food and take-out restaurants in the Caldwell area. At least these other restaurants have a lot of milkshake flavor choices and know how to make a thick and enjoyable milkshake. read more

Excellent food, excellent service, good people good food good prices! My favorite drive thru!

the food was good we had gotten the burger deal a little too much mayo on the burgers for me otherwise everything was good

Absolute favorite place around. My tia gets this all the time a decided to swing by and grab some myself and i now see why it's her favorite ! Freaking amazing staff and speed of service too ! You cannot go wrong with this place ! read more

This is a typical burger joint that is surviving because it is fast, friendly and reasonably priced. When in downtown Caldwell there are a number of dining choices but this place has the ability to get you fed fast. There are a lot of choices on the menu so there should be something for everyone to eat. The person taking our order was very efficient and asked all the necessary questions with a smile. The food was served quickly and tasted great. Definitely worth a second visit. This may easily become your go-to hamburger joint. read more

Skip the fast food chains and come here! Delicious burger place in downtown Caldwell. Their food is reasonably priced and their service is fantastic. Yummy shakes, too! read more

Place is soooo good!! I'd eat here everyday if I could!! Staff is phenomenal!! Go grab a burger, you know you want one!!!

I judge all burger joints by the king of all burger joints, The Viking Drive-Inn in Boise. The Gem is one of the better burger places I've been to. It's not at "Viking level" but dang good. This little mom and pop place has a great greasy spoon atmosphere and super friendly service. The Gem burger, which has a slice of ham and cheese on it is a great old school burger. It's no Eric 2 from the Viking but it's damn good. Excellent stuff....with places like this I can't imagine why any proud American would bother going to a chain burger place. read more

Gem In & Out - a long table with stools - Burgers Near Me - Caldwell, Idaho

Admittedly, I haven't been to too many burger stands in the treasure valley. That said, Gem has been one of my absolute favorites (Bad Boy on Vista is another one; however, Bad Boy on Fairview gave us a terrible experience). As others have said, this isn't anything mind-blowing. It's a burger joint that sort of screams classic. The tiny dice on the onions (I know, potentially from a Cysco truck), the "burger sauce" (different from fry sauce), the 1/4 pound patty and the tiny, grilled slice of ham... it's all just too classic. I had a meal with the Gem Burger (standard burger with a slice of ham, lettuce and tomato... added some onion), the Tater Gems (tots that are actually deep fried), and a beverage. It was all solid! More importantly, the gentleman who helped me (he recommended my food choices) was incredibly friendly and articulate. I'll most definitely be back and, hopefully, will find a reason to give this place five stars. read more

Old time favorite and still good food!!! Friendly and fast service. Thanks for caring about your customers and always sending out BLT the best read more

Food was ok but seemed really expensive 3 burgers,onion rings, tots, fries and 2 milkshakes $33.00. They don't give you a receipt so I couldn't even checked if I was charged correctly. read more

I love mom n pop places... I'll support these kinds of places over franchises ANY day. In n Out? Psh, you don't have anything on Gem! Burgers? Outstanding. Fries? Awesome. Shakes? To die for. You see... when I want a burger... I dont think about Wendy's, McDonnalds, Burger King, Carls Jr or Jack in the Box... I think of Gem In and Out! read more

Nan: Four stars! I really liked the fries and the onion rings, they were really good, just like the girl at the register said. But I loooooved the burger, I wanted another one! I'd go back there in a heartbeat! Nic: I'll race ya! read more

Hmmmm.... decent, average hamburgers. I needed to pick up some lunch for the family and wanted to try a local place. Figured they have been around for over 50 years, with a line of cars on either side of the building (for take out) and would be great. Atmosphere was quiet and looks like the place hasn't been updated since the 1970's, which I think adds to the charm. Service was pretty quick. About 5 minutes to get my order. Made sure I got the fry sauce the lady behind the counter said I must have. Got the burgers home and they were ok. Not spectacular. Just ok. Thin patty with a little shredded lettuce and their house sauce. Fries were not fresh (frozen... probably Simplot) and unsalted. Now that I know what to expect, I will still go back for a cheap fix. read more

Love this place. My favorite is the Taco Cheese Dog! Locally owned. Big youth sports sponsor. Support your local businesses!

I did not get any photos but this place has great food. The special sauce was so good and the fries were crispy. I had the Gem burger and it was great read more

Mom and pops kinda place. It was alright I'm not crazy about ham in my burger unless its a breakfast sandwich. But over all their chicken steips are incredible! They were so juicy and tasted home made. My kids loved them! I will def go back for those. read more

Sadly I had high hopes for them due to we love to support small local business. After we order our good and receive it , I looked through the food it wasn't as ordered and when I asked for receipt to conform what we ordered. I was rudely told they don't give those out and there was nothing wrong with my order. I tried to expand what I though was wrong and it wasn't how I ordered and was told NO and that's how they do things. So sadly do to the rude way I was treated and the price of the food I will not be going back. Sad to due to they are 5 min down the road from me. read more

Great burgers, been going to for years. Their prices have increased over the past few years, I would go more often if the prices were a bit lower. read more