I am a big fan of the speakeasies in the downtown area and recently tried Gatsby. I was a little underwhelmed by how small it was and crowded the seating area was. We had a reservation, but were seated at the bar, which I have never experienced before and definitely prefer a table. They also do not serve vodka which was a surprise. The drinks we got were good, but not my favorite out of the speakeasies in the area. read more

Such a lovely place. Quiet enough to have a great conversation with beautiful drinks. Service is five stars and I am so grateful for the dress code. It is wonderful to go to such a fun place with the BEST mixologist! read more

See all

Only gave one star because I couldn't give less. Super stuffy hostess. Had a reservation. The weather is 100 plus degrees. No where did it state that what we were wearing would prove to be an issue. We had flip flops on that cost more than most people's dress shoes. Nothing in the reservation confirmation did it mention anything about dress code. Great news for me. We get to go to Press and Pony where the drinks, service and atmosphere are right up my alley. I will not bring my friends or family visiting from out of town to this place ever based on this experience. Get with the times. read more

So disappointed. Made reservations for my sisters 40th Birthday. Got the email confirmation and called for the password as instructed. When we arrived we had a few guests with flip flops. This is not allowed and unfortunately we were never made known of this rule. When you go to their website and hit reservations, make the reservations and get the email confirmation this was not mentioned once. I even called the day of the reservation to get the password as instructed. Again this was not mentioned. I have now gone to the website and found their dress code, but for a new customer this is not obvious at all. My sisters birthday surprise was ruined. I will never go to this establishment again. I'm all about following rules but at least let your customers know in the email confirmation or when they call. This is a HUGE miss!! Owners response says everything was clearly pointed out ahead of time. It was not, simple as that. Owner is quicker to respond to a Yelp review than he is to come to the door to talk to a potential guest over a miscommunication that they created. read more

My wife and have experienced speakeasy's in the passed and enjoy most of them. We made a trip to Boise specifically to try Gatsby. It did not disappoint! From the moment we got there to the end of the experience was nothing short of fantastic! Beginning in the library, the young lady there played her part well and really set the tone for the evening. Once inside, the ambiance, decor and genuine feel was amazing. Hanna, our server was attentive and fun. The drinks were so artfully presented and creatively balanced with unique flavors. Each cocktail was its own experience. We would absolutely recommend Gatsby for anyone looking for a different and unique speakeasy experience. We look forward to the next trip to experience the Garrison! read more

Drinks were great, incredibly friendly and helpful service, and the commitment to the theme was a lot of fun. They did a great job adding a bit of performance to every part of the experience. read more

Great place over the holidays to get into the Christmas spirit! Over the holidays the Gatsby is decorated to make you cheerful and ready to wrap presents. The cocktails are very creative served in fun and entertaining ways and the staff were fantastic; from the warm and entertaining entrance to a WELCOME! from the bartender. Very attentive and knowledgeable on ever cocktail in the book. We plan on introducing to our friends whenever we can get another reservation. read more

Gatsby - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Boise, Idaho

Not impressed. I've tried a couple of times to like this place as we really need special places like this in Boise; however, it was once again not a good experience. We made a reservation and when we arrived we were made to stay outside , in the cold, for 15 min. We could have easily hung out in the book area while waiting. We sat down and our server was a bit short. Somewhat inconvenienced. It was an expensive place with sub par service. I have no problem spending $$$ but at least treat us like we matter. Ended up only having one drink which took over an hour and half. Took for ever to get the bill. Had to find our server. They can do better with the attitudes and service. read more

This was an AMAZING experience. Went on Saturday night and the hostess who let us in did an amazing job of preparing us and recommending drinks. They don't serve Cosmos or any vodka because it wasn't available in 1920s. The drink service is very entertaining and they taste great. We had the Hemmingway, the Greta Garbot, the Figgly Wiggly, the Josephine Baker and the presentation is so much fun. I don't want to post pics because the surprise presentation is part of the fun. They have a lot of mocktail options for non drinkers and I highly recommend the Hemmingway. It tastes great and is served in a fun way. The prices are totallly reasonable for the experience. We paid the same prices for drinks there as we did for cosmos at the new place we visited and it was boring. We dressed up for the occasion and it made the night so much fun. They even had a card waiting at our table congratulating us on our anniversary. The staff is so friendly and enthusiastic. Everyone was wonderful. This will be our go to for all guests. So much fun! read more

A total hit! Love the experience of visiting this speakeasy hidden in an alleyway. Gatsby serves good cocktails ranging from light to "spirit forward." A great spot to take folks from out of town for something different. read more

Gatsby - What great drink presentation! - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Boise, Idaho

The experience was so amazing! I definitely will be coming back & recommending this speakeasy. The drinks were so fun & delicious. The vibe was also really cool, the staff was all dressed in 20s attire read more

See all

Gatsby is a great place to go throughout the year but especially during Mistletoe Magic. We reserved their private room for 12 of our guests and we had a great time. The ambiance, the food, the service and the cocktails were awesome. I would highly recommend Gatsby if it's just you and a date or if you're planning a private event. read more

We had a great time. Drinks where unbelievable great. Service was great. Chocolate truffles where very yummy

This review is gonna be harsh, but considering the exorbitant prices Gatsby charges, the minimal effort they put into designing the bar, the poor quality of their drinks and the amazing competition they have in Boise, harsh is fully warranted. Entry to the bar requires a password given at a back alley door and passage through a "library" that is really just some bookshelves with a bunch of books extremely haphazardly tossed (literally) onto the shelves. I have no clue WTF they were going for by making the library look like the messiest and most disorganized in the history of books. What they ended up with looks like an overgrown frat boy's attempt to design a "cool" entrance to a "speakeasy". While waiting in the "library", the host mandatorily goes over a memorized and ridiculous script about how great Gatsby is and how fancy Gatsby is and how amazing their drinks are and how much time and money they spent building Gatsby blah, blah effing gag me with a spoon, blah. Once inside you will quickly realize that if they spent 1/10th as much effort hiring a designer as they do making you listen to them blow smoke up their own a55es about how great they are, they might have actually ended up with a decent bar with an actual upscale speakeasy atmosphere instead of, again, an overgrown frat boy's lame attempt at opening a "speakeasy". The space is nothing more than a bunch of tables and chairs in a room with an incredibly uninspired and boring bar on the back wall. No discernible effort was put into hiring a qualified designer to create Gatsby. "Hey, bro, let's put this here and that there and put up a vintage looking image of a lady grabbing her breast on that wall. Yeah bro, total speakeasy vibez, bro!" Queue frat boy high fives. There's one, single person bathroom for the entire bar and it's right in the middle of the bar. Not kidding. And it is barely nicer than a crappy gas station bathroom with cheap vintage newspaper wallpaper. Compared to the bathroom at Thick As Thieves or Water Bear, it's a dump. The drinks can best be described as meh...overly sweet...served with an unsolicited, blowing smoke up our own a55es again, speech about how great they are. They are a ridiculously horrible value. Gatsby charges Water Bear and Thick As Thieves Prices but spent a tiny fraction of what the owners of those bars spent designing and creating an actually worthwhile atmosphere and experience. Also, some of the drinks were served in what's supposed to resemble a vintage glass flask, next to a cocktail glass with an ice cube in it. The idea is you pop open the flask and pour your own drink. However the flasks were f( )k!ng filthy. The outside of the flasks were incredibly dirty and sticky. Frankly, we should have sent the drinks back and left. But we didn't. And we'll never go back. If you want a real cocktail made by a talented bartender, go to just about any other cocktail bar in Boise- Red Feather, Water Bear, The Modern, etc. If you want a real speakeasy experience in very well thought out and designed bar along with excellent drinks made by talented bartenders, go to Thick As Thieves. Unlike Gatsby, any of these bars will passively show you how great they are, they will never try to (literally) sell you on how great they are. read more

My second visit was as great as my first! It's just a fun place to go and hang out. The drinks are inventive and the glassware is super creative. Sadly, minus one star because a couple of the drinks weren't super well balanced and the service is slow - although they warn you about this when you come in. Regardless, I'll keep coming back. read more

Gatsby - Ginger Rogers - highly recommended - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Boise, Idaho

Amazing vibes and great drinks. The live music was awesome as well!! You get a true feeling of the roaring 20's

This place was so much fun! The cocktails and charcuterie were excellent! All the drinks were top shelf and so much fun to drink!!! Do not skip the Ginger Rogers or Josephine Baker!!! read more

See all

Such a fun night. You need a reservation to get the password for entrance. The concept is amazing. We had a blast enjoying the fun evening. The drinks are pricy but delicious and creative. I was sad that the Elvis inspired cocktail is no longer available. It sounded amazing. read more

Form over function. Lovely decor and idea, but isn't the point of a speakeasy that once inside, it's freewheeling and fun? At Gatsby you have to call for the password and make a suggested reservation with a $25 deposit on a credit card -- then stand in the cold until they can bring you into a lovely library anteroom to read a list of rules that includes "not picking anyone up." You are then escorted to your table and told to sit down (old Covid vestige approach?) So don't think about walking around, going to the bar, or god forbid talking to people you might want to meet. It feels like a nice room for pods of people to hang out in a sort of rule-heavy jazzy holodeck. I love the overall idea, but lighten up. This place could be a whole lot more fun. read more

It was fun. True to it's genre, this speakeasy keeps it on the down-low! Its only identification is a green light above an obscure door in a dark alley. The drinks we ordered required some table preparation which also was fun to watch. read more

Gatsby - Entrance - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Boise, Idaho

See all

Such a fun experience. Amazing presentation of cocktails, think art! Cozy, comfortable, wonderful service. Loved the Christmas theme and all of the staff were fun! We can't want to come back! read more

It has a great warm vibe inside and is in a perfect spot in the alley off 8th Street. Really nice staff. Highly recommended.

Very authentic speakeasy downtown Boise. You enter in an ally and need the password to be admitted. The vibe is very laid back. It's a fun place to sit and mingle with friends. The drinks are well made and service is good. Check it out when you're in Boise. read more

Awesome vibe. Great service. Loved the true appeal to authenticity of a speakeasy. Fun to be able to search for and explore.

Been to Gatsby numerous times over that par couple years, with colleagues from out of town, always recommend. Tonight at the request of the bartender, will not. Tuesday night, no one there, party of 8. Bartender wants to stick us in a corner "booth" that holds 5. Been there, sucks and cramped, tables are empty. We ask to pull 2 tables together, reluctan and bitching under-breatht allows us. Did I state No One is there. At end, bartender gets on high horse and berates the party. Never, after many years of being at places, had this ever happened. Afterwards politely said "bad form" on his approach to people, which told to never come back. I won't, kinda stubborn, or ever recommend. Server was fantastic, she was 5 star. Too bad the Tuesday bartender on a slow night was not a good person. Just know, he is not friendly Idaho. Disappointed that this represented what Boise offer. read more

Great place to celebrate my wife's birthday! Atmosphere was fun and different, food and drinks were great. Service was top notch. We had a great time!! read more

Everything was fantastic!! Definitely recommend! The atmosphere, the music, the presentation are all top notch!!

One of a few authentic speakeasy bars in Boise where the cocktails are outstanding the environments outstanding obviously the owner cares about about the product and the environment. read more

First time at the Gatsby, wanted to take nubby on date night. Lady at the door was super friendly and informative. Nice atmosphere, dark but not to dark like similar spots. Waitress was also friendly and helpful with our questions and had her own suggestions. Would definitely return. read more

Gatsby - JAMES CAGNEY and JEAN HARLOW - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Boise, Idaho

Yummy drinks and awesome location/environment!! Great service as well :) highly recommend checking this place out!

Wonderful ambiance with the low lighting and electro swing music. Cocktails were delicious and several came in very fun glasses. read more

Gatsby - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Boise, Idaho

See all

HIGHLY recommend coming here. The vibe is incredible and the drinks are tasty. I love the atmosphere, music and the decor. The spiel at the beginning is so fun. Will definitely go back! read more

Gatsby - Water Lilly drink - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Boise, Idaho

See all

Super cool Speakeasy and just the right touch of secrecy and difficulty "getting in" - reservations are required (or plan on potentially missing out - especially on a weekend night). In our case, we made reservations about a week in advance. Day of, you have to go online or call and get the "passcode" (which they'll only provide if you have reservations). Like others have said, you can only access via the alley and then once let in, you're in a small "room" with bookcases and mirrors (not going to ruin the surprise). Once inside, fabulous drinks (be patient - well worth the wait!). Ellie Shaw was performing when we were there Saturday evening, and dressed in era appropriate attire and the music was definitely era appropriate, too. Overall, absolutely great experience and a lot of fun! HIGHLY RECOMMENDED!!! read more

Really fun experience. The space is beautiful and the atmosphere is great. Also the staff were very attentive. So why 3 stars? 2 out of three drinks I ordered they could not make. These were classic cocktails sazerac, and A Vieux Carré. I settled for an old fashion but it was extremely sweet for my taste. read more

Beautiful atmosphere with wonderful staff. It was an escape from the hassle and bustle. Each drink was put together with precision and each person felt special...even me the DD. I will definitely plan on coming here again! read more

See all

Super cool spot, they do decorations for different holidays (right now it's Christmas themed). So many different cocktails and drinks to choose from. Have not tried the food but the service was good. Reservations needed in advance! read more

The service was the worst I have ever experienced. It was a rainy, blustery evening, the hostess kept us waiting outside in the rain for 15 minutes beyond our reservation time. When she finally let us inside, I did not have my identification with me. I am 58 years old and clearly of age. We had to leave because they would not let us into the establishment without my identification. And, the restaurant then charged us for the experience. They charged our account $120 for Bad service and nothing else. read more

First of all, amazing hospitality from when you first knock all the way until you leave. The ambiance was amazing, and me and my friends couldn't get enough of every single detail from the wall paper, lighting, and down to the carefully picked books. The food was a delicious snack to have to our beautifully curated drinks. Never been to a place like this and will return for sure. New favorite spot in the Treasure Valley! read more

Gatsby - 20k Leagues Under the Sea - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Boise, Idaho

This place really takes you back to the prohibition era! Make sure you book the tasting room so you can wear a mink coat and travel through the mine shaft! You'll need to do it to get it! And the drinks...OMG amazing! read more

Subpar drinks chosen from a limited selection made by an indifferent bartender. If the whole roaring 20's fantasy gimmick floats your boat, I'm sure you'll find this place interesting, but I've stumbled upon better speakeasies accidentally. read more

Gatsby - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Boise, Idaho