Just had a great time and a great dinner at the Italian Food Company. The key lime pie was top…read morenotch.

Nice alternative if you're looking for something not seafood…read more The meat lovers pizza was exceptional. It's traditional Italian- super thin crust, crispy edges, really tasty. The chicken parm with spaghetti was good enough. The chicken was fried perfectly- crispy coating, not soggy as so often can be. The spaghetti was cooked perfectly, al dente. We sat at the bar- best chairs are there. Ozzi at the bar was great. This place has an authentic Italian feel to it. Real pasta, fresh made desserts and some imported from Italy. All the way around- a great experience.

Excellent food - I recommend the conch fritters and the ahi tuna. If you only have room for 1, go…read morewith the ahi! It's an appetizer, so it's not massively filling, but it is super delicious. Margarita was great, too! Ambience gives off loud, locals mixed with cool tourists. Great dock location. Highly recommend.

Yessir this is where you want to go to relax and have some great food and drink! The 4 of us went…read moreon 12/29/2025 and were so happy to be there again - we've patronized this joint several times over the years and keep coming back. The drinks are made perfectly and there's a large menu to choose from. In addition, the prices are very reasonable. When you first walk in, there's a large wrap-around bar that is usually full to the brim with happy patrons. But don't worry - walk to the other side of the bar and there's a large patio chock full of additional seating. Thankfully, the view from any angle is beautiful because you are... dockside! You are right on the water! Check their social media accounts to see the who and what - because the place is always offering some type of live music act. If you need a low-key, super casual, and relaxing environment - but also want great drinks and fare - then go to Dockside Bar and Grill.

Key Colony Inn has solid food and delivers on quality -- everything we had was well prepared and…read moretasted great. You can tell they know what they're doing in the kitchen. That said, the price point is significant. While the food is good, it's noticeably higher than comparable restaurants in the area. You're definitely paying a premium. Overall: good experience and good food -- just be prepared for the bill to reflect it.

this place is very nice air conditioned and has a large dining room. It also has a bar with lots of…read morepeople. The only staff member that was attentive was the hostess. Our waiter was angry and annoyed that I did not pronounce the name of the fish correctly and he told me I was going to get into trouble saying it like that. He seemed very annoyed with us. We were a party of six and spent quite a bit of money, I was not happy with the service.

Food was a bit disappointing and Medicare at best. Not an authentic Italian restaurant at all. I…read morewould give lower stars but our server was extremely friendly and provided exceptional service. Overall, this is an overpriced tourist trap in my opinion. 2/5 - fried conch: bot bad but would not recommend or want to order again. It's essentially kind of like a crab cake but was not that appetizing at all. 2/5 Conch soup: tasted like marinara sauce heated up with potato's, carrot and very little conch meat. 5/5 the garlic bread: was actually quite taste. Soft, warm and flavorful. 4/5 sweet potato fries: can't go wrong with that 2.5/5 meat lover pizza. Crust was a bit burnt. Toppings were good but the sauce was kinda too sour and the dough was not good at all. 10/5: service. Our servicer truly was attentive and friendly.

Unobtrusive little place, with stunningly good food. Stopped there on our way from Key West to…read moreMiami. I highly recommend the fish tacos, they were truly the best I've ever had. My husband had the lasagna and said it was the best he had ever eaten; the service was so friendly and prompt. I highly recommend this place, very well priced also. very cute atmosphere.

Bayside Gourmet is seriously the BEST!! I lived across the street for 8 months and wow wow wow. The…read morepasta is just incredible. I'm obsessed with their massive chicken parm, there's soo much melted cheese it's amazing. Also the tortellini is from another world!! So fresh, amazing cheese, and the parmesan cream sauce is so rich and delicious. My husband had the grouper sandwich once, that was also very good. They have good beer selections. Just come here, you won't regret it!! PS, sometimes the service is slow when they're slammed during busy hours, but who cares you're in the keys and good food is worth the wait. Love the food here!

Very friendly service and attentive. Food was delicious…read morebut really loved the key lime pie We ate outside on the patio and nice ambiance Yes, recommend this for everyone

I always say mistakes happen -- what matters most is how a restaurant handles them…read more I ordered carryout from Driftwood in Marathon: chicken fingers from the grill, which are supposed to come with French fries. There's a separate appetizer version that doesn't include fries, and that's what I was given by mistake. When I called, the employee remembered my order and said she thought it was the appetizer. Then she said the simplest words many places forget: "I'm sorry for the inconvenience." She immediately offered options -- refund the fries or drop off a fresh order. I chose the fries. Within minutes, they delivered a full container of hot, delicious fries to my door -- even though I had chosen carryout. The driver apologized again and even included cookies. This is how you make it right for a customer. The food is really good, and the management is even better. Highly recommend giving this place a try.

Ordered Subs thru their Mobil app. One hot ham and cheese one meatball Parm. The order was ready…read morefor pick-up at the designated time. Both were excellent with loads of meats on both Subs. Their app. Is easy to use with being able to change how you'd like it made. We will be back.

Great food and love an old school sit down pizzeria Cooked…read moreto perfection!!! You wont be disappointed

Late order Undercooked chicken wings…read moreAttitude like you don't matter Eat somewhere else

Fun vibe but. A limited menu. They brought warm pepperoni bread for the table which was a nice…read moretouch. Waiter was fun and attentive. Our pizzas were under cooked despite us requesting them to be well done. Decent meal but not enough variety for us to go back while staying at the Cheeca Lodge.

Food was amazing (and expensive). Our server, Gary, was a true comedian and kept us entertained,…read morebut the ambiance is awful. But this place has the worst acoustics and ambiance...it's incredibly loud even with just five tables inside, and if people (especially kids) are in there screaming and playing with the air hockey table then it's impossible to hear yourself think. I do love that Cheeca Lodge has so many dining options, but this one might be better for take-out to your room or to the pool/beach. I opted for the spaghetti and meatballs which was really good. And my friends got the special of the day, a shrimp risotto (for $38, which is pretty outrageous) which they enjoyed. Overall, I'd skip this on my next visit to Cheeca Lodge. And I definitely would not make a special trip here if I wasn't staying on property.

I just happened to find this hidden Italian restaurant and am so glad I did! Given time…read moreconstraints, I ordered two slices of pizza, added meatballs to the pizza and bought a bottle of Dr. Pepper for caffeine too get myself back to Fort Lauderdale after a fun time in Key West. The pizza was so delicious, I wish I had ordered a whole pie so I would have leftovers. The sauce, dough & meatballs were all equally yummy! What also made this stop so great was that the chef and "lady at the front" who turned out to be the new owner, were SO friendly, welcoming and accommodating. The chef is from Massachusetts -- you're getting solid Italian food from up north! The ambiance is of a quick Italian sandwich shop from the northeast. There are cute little table & 2 TVs. It seems like most of the business is takeaway. Either way, I'll be stopping there again in my next trip to the Keys. Free parking lot. The restaurant is very close to US1 & in the same shopping center as Winn Dixie.

New owners are awesome. After a bad experience elsewhere…read morethey reached out. We ordered 2 pizzas and 2 subs. All of the above were excellent. Pizza is the better have had here in the keys. Sausage sub was actually sausage cut down the middle and not pizza topping sausage like in the other place. AND NO STYROFOAM! To save a few bucks, use cash instead of a card. We highly recommend giving the new owners a try as units certainly NOTHING like the previous food was!