Frankie&#x27;s NY Bagels

Rolled into The Greene Lily for a Sunday morning breakfast @ 9am…read more My crew of 5 were greeted by staff minutes prior to opening time. Staff here aims to please with coffee and water being poured routinely throughout the breakfast. My table had a highlight of orders to include the 2x2x2, Chipotle Benedict, Backwoods Benedict, and my Chicken and Waffle Sammy. Prior to ordering breakfast you must try the beignets! Fresh, tasty, and hott! Not only was the service excellent and food tasty the historic building this restaurant sits within makes for a unique dining experience. 5 stars! I'll be back.

I was given the recommendation to eat here by our AirBnB host Jennifer, from up in McKinleyville…read more This place was wonderful. Cute colorful building, clean, and smelled wonderful walking in the door. We ordered the mimosa flight and it was fun to have our waitress choose the flavors for us. This arrived on a long plank in the cutest mini mason jar glasses. Then we ordered a side of French toast, a Bloody Mary (it had a tahin rim!) and the half and half, which is a half order of the regular eggs Benedict and a half order of the backwoods Benedict. Both were incredible! Eggs cooked perfectly, buttery smooth hollandaise sauce, and the freshest rosemary breakfast potatoes I have ever had. Not greasy at all, just beautifully cooked and full of flavor. The service was lovely and fast. We look forward to coming back again.

The bar area, very quaint.

Bacon and potatoes

See all

Bayside Farmstead Café

4.5(146 reviews)

5.6 mi

Excellent food options (and what a sizable menu!) The coffee…read moredrinks are really good as well. Ample sitting room inside. Parking is a little rough, but not debilitating. Food came out quick even for our party of 9 and was hot and fresh!

Organic coffee! That's great. I also got a golden milk…read morelatte which is honey- sweetened. I asked for light honey and it was good. The frittata had been made in bulk in a square pan, and my rectangle serving was missing a chunk at one edge, but the flavor was pretty good. My husband had pulled pork hash and he enjoyed it. There are lots of baked goods here as well, and it is across from an elementary school; I suspect kids get a nice treat after school some days!

Really cute cottage Cafe selling simple menu items, coffee and tea

Veggie Frittata

See all

Mimosa of the day!!

Kristina's Restaurant

3.8(373 reviews)

2.9 mi

The food was cooked perfectly including the toast. Service was excellent. The building is…read moremaintained excellent despite not being new. The seating is well maintained no sagging seats in the booth. Counter seats are available. The coffee was average for a breakfast dinner.

Literally the best burger in the county! There is no other place like it. The atmosphere is nice…read morelike an old diner sort of feel with friendly faces and good food. Always busy so come on off times to get food quicker. Burger and fries are the way to go. Seriously the best

Counter and booth seating

Haven't eaten the garlic bread but looks delicious and my husband says it tastes great!

See all

Right at the "Kink" in 101, where you get this Sunset!

Cocina Oaxaqueña

4.8(102 reviews)

1.1 mi

Service was delightful. Restaurant was clean and comfortable. The food was delicious. Not your…read moreaverage Mexican restaurant featuring regional specialties from the Oaxaca region. Give it a try, I trust you will enjoy it as much as we did.

We have been coming to Eureka for 5 consecutive years every summer vacation, but just last year we…read morediscovered Cocina Oaxaqueña, I got the chilaquiles and I knew I wanted to come back. This year we got tacos al pastor and asada, also a torta de asada and some enfrijoladas, Mexican mocha and everything was delicious. My favorite torta but the tacos were so good too. Now the Mexican mocha is a must try you will not be disappointed.

See all

Los Bagels

4.0(489 reviews)

2.8 mi

Los Bagels is always on my list of must-stops whenever I'm in town! Their bagels are perfectly…read morecooked, and they have so many options when it comes to spreads, proteins, and toppings, so there's something for everyone. Easily some of the best bagels in town! It can definitely get busy on the weekends, so I recommend going early to beat the line. Even when there is a wait, the staff does a great job keeping things moving, so the line usually goes pretty quickly!

Stopped by for a quick breakfast on our way to Oregon. The shop is located centrally in old town…read more It's cutely decorated and the staff were very sweet. I ordered the bacon scramble on a Parmesan bagel. I wish I ordered the jalapeño cheddar bagel but I didn't see them until I ordered. The scramble itself was good. Hearty bacon and eggs were cooked well. The bagel was a little crispy for my liking instead of doughy. Also the Parmesan got a little burned when it was toasted. The coffee was a huge let down. Very weak flavor and watered down.

05.26.25

Bacon Scrambagel

See all

Café Waterfront

3.4(456 reviews)

2.7 mi

Brunch time on Sunday. Stumbled upon this historical location by following the live jazz...always a…read moregood thing. This cool place had the best Clam Chowder we have ever had. Then fresh fish, egg dishes and white wine etc...everything was excellent. Not many coastal spots next to ocean with such good taste, parking and history.

Place is truly lovely charming with historic decor lovely friendly stuffs foods are so delicious…read more anyone come and visit Eureka pls come to cafe waterfront taste the savor 10 out of 10 Bravo from Long Beach CA

Side salad w/balsamic

See all

Specials of the day.

Gill's By The Bay

4.0(419 reviews)

5.7 mi

What a great stop! We were driving north and my son asked me to look for cioppino, so of course I…read moreturned to Yelp. Gill's leapt out at me. Even though they didn't have cioppino, it was the perfect choice. Sitting out on the patio with the breeze and the sun and the bay with pelicans and gulls flying and flowers all around was great in itself. The food and warm service people made it incredible. We had the best clam chowder I have ever had - thick, creamy, sweet with clams, and amazingly not heavy at all, just perfect. The hot crab sandwich was a special, so that made up our minds on one thing; and it was excellent. The onion rings were highly recommended by the waitress and the guy at the next table who had just gotten a serving. The breading was perfect and nicely seasoned, and the inch-tall rings of sweet white onion - wow. Giant, delicious onion rings. My son was attracted to the blackened sole but I persuaded him that we needed the clam cutlets because - cutlets of razor clam, seriously? And they were cutlets, a thing we had never seen, nicely breaded and delicious. We like clams. The fries were okay, just fries. The tartar sauce was light and an excellent tangy counterpoint, and the cocktail sauce was truly amazing. We were impressed. Both plates came with a small slice of tasty watermelon, too. We left very full and well-satisfied but not feeling weighted down. If you are ever in the area before 3pm on the days they are open - do not miss Gill's on the bluff By the Bay.

The food was great! My family couldn't not have enough good things to say about it! Here is just…read moresome of the things we tried. ONION RINGS: 7.5/10 the seasoning was amazing & the batter was a bit thick FRIED CALAMARI: 7/10 seasoning was also amazing SIDE SALAD: 10/10 hit all the boxes CLAM CHOWDER: 8/10 PATTY MELT: 7/10 FISH AND CHIPS: 8.3 KIDS GRILLED CHEESE: 9/10 Our server was Mariah she was super sweet as well funny! The atmosphere was super cute it gave small town vides!

Salad

See all

The Cutten Chalet

3.9(87 reviews)

1.1 mi

Best breakfast in town with the greatest servers! ALWAYS well taken care of. The food is hot and…read morefresh - made to order.

Good food, served fast -- perfect stop along the Redwood Highway!…read more If you're driving north or south on the 101 -- also known as the Redwood Highway during this stretch -- and find yourself near Eureka in Humboldt County, make sure to stop at The Cutten Chalet! The food was delicious, but what really stood out was the service -- absolutely incredible! Everyone works together like a true team: friendly, attentive, and always checking in to top off your coffee or see if you need anything. Even when it's busy, the food comes out super fast and fresh. Our server, Debbie, was fabulous! She's been with the restaurant for over 20 years -- and you can tell. Loyal, personable, and excellent at what she does. If you're traveling with kids, there's even a cute little park and zoo at Sequoia Park Garden nearby -- perfect for stretching your legs before getting back on the road. Highly recommend this spot for anyone looking for good food, fast and friendly service, and that warm, small-town atmosphere you can only find along the redwoods.

Hashbrowns & omelette

See all

Golden Harvest Cafe

3.7(259 reviews)

3.4 mi

If anyone asked me where is the best place for breakfast in all of Humboldt County, I would say,…read moreGolden Harvest Cafe. Everything they make is delicious, never boring or plain; they are original & creative, flavorful, generous and the service is kind.

Great breakfast spot! Very popular, even on a Monday morning. I had the classic breakfast, chose 2…read moresides. Everything was great and tasted delicious. Service was wonderful. Even if just passing through, worth a stop for breakfast or brunch.

Menu 11/28/25

See all

Breakfast goodness

Cafe Nooner

3.7(173 reviews)

2.0 mi

Friendly Vibes, Great Food -- Hoping for More Organic Choices…read more Cafe Nooner is a warm and welcoming spot in Old Town Eureka with a creative menu and hometown charm. I had the vegan breakfast burrito with avocado (no cheese), and it was flavorful, satisfying, and clearly made with care. My latte with an extra shot was smooth and well-balanced -- a perfect start to the day. The service was friendly and made me feel right at home. While everything was fresh and delicious, I'd love to see more organic options on the menu in the future. Still, a great experience and definitely worth the stop!

Cute little place. Good prices. Got the mimosa flights - but they weren't marked so weren't sure…read morewhich was which. Sausage gravy wasn't my fave but food was good!

Entrance

Meze Platter

See all

Indoor dining

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

2 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Cody H.

164

10

18

8 years ago

Illeagally sells retail, and only has a permit to sell wholesale. Terrible owner who abused their employees and unsafe conditions. Stay away from Frankie's, they are bad buisness read more

Dylan R.

0

7

1

3 years ago

It takes too long to get food. The donuts are good. read more

Frankie's NY Bagels - bagels - Updated September 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Eureka, California Restaurants near Frankie's NY Bagels

BEST of Eureka, California Coffee near Frankie's NY Bagels

BEST of Eureka, California Things to Do near Frankie's NY Bagels

BEST of Eureka, California Cocktail Bars near Frankie's NY Bagels

BEST of Eureka, California Desserts near Frankie's NY Bagels

BEST of Eureka, California Breakfast near Frankie's NY Bagels

BEST of Eureka, California Shopping near Frankie's NY Bagels

BEST of Eureka, California Pizza near Frankie's NY Bagels

BEST of Eureka, California Thrift Stores near Frankie's NY Bagels

Best of Eureka

Things to do in Eureka

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Frankie's NY Bagels also viewed

Los Bagels

4.0

(489 reviews)

Los Bagels is always on my list of must-stops whenever I'm in town! Their bagels are perfectly…read morecooked, and they have so many options when it comes to spreads, proteins, and toppings, so there's something for everyone. Easily some of the best bagels in town! It can definitely get busy on the weekends, so I recommend going early to beat the line. Even when there is a wait, the staff does a great job keeping things moving, so the line usually goes pretty quickly!

Stopped by for a quick breakfast on our way to Oregon. The shop is located centrally in old town…read more It's cutely decorated and the staff were very sweet. I ordered the bacon scramble on a Parmesan bagel. I wish I ordered the jalapeño cheddar bagel but I didn't see them until I ordered. The scramble itself was good. Hearty bacon and eggs were cooked well. The bagel was a little crispy for my liking instead of doughy. Also the Parmesan got a little burned when it was toasted. The coffee was a huge let down. Very weak flavor and watered down.

Los Bagels

4.1

(417 reviews)

I've been coming to Arcata for the past 10 years and Los bagels is one of the places that stands…read moreout in my mind as outstandingly Humboldt in spirit. They make bagels with a delicious fusion of Latin American flavors. With quick prompt service and quality ingredients you truly can't go wrong. This last time I went, I had the privilege of sitting in their backyard patio which had great sun coverage with their fold up umbrellas. They even had a set of cornhole and a basketball hoop and ball! Quite the family friendly place! I loved it!

Disgustingly stale bagels and terrible customer service…read more I get it, this is a small city and I am sure it gets even smaller when college kids go back home for the summer. When I arrived in the morning, it was very busy. I liked the decor of the inside & outside, specifically the themed mosaic planters. I honestly had higher expectations since this place was decently rated, but I was disappointed with the quality of the bagels. They were so bad that a store bought bagel would have tasted fresher. The girl working the register was rude and unfriendly. Overall, I would not come back here and luckily, I live nowhere near this place. I've had fresh bagels from many cities, small and large, yet somehow Los Bagels were the worst.

Don's Donuts Pizza & Deli

4.1

(227 reviews)

Originally I intended to grab a pie at another restaurant but upon arriving I found out that place…read morewas no longer in business and this ended up being the next place nearby. It's conveniently located near the town square. Upon arriving I noticed a person cleaning the storefront window. Then I walked in and noticed how clean the establishment was floor, tables and condiments bar. Even the donut case seemed spotless. The donuts looked amazing, I just couldn't pass up getting a few. I had a half pepperoni and half combination pizza and it was not greasy or soggy. Headed out to the dunes to watch the sunset and eat pizza. Best way to finish the day. Super friendly staff, smiling the entire time.

Donuts. Donuts for da cheap. Pizza for da medium. Perfect place after getting shit facedread more

The Donut Mill

4.7

(89 reviews)

Please indulge me as I review The Donut Mill using two hypothetical donut situations…read more 1) If I get anywhere near this place I'm like an old satellite that's lost the ability to avoid the Donut Mill's gravitational pull before my face collides happily with a pile of donuts. 2) If my doctor tells me that each donut from The Donut Mill will cost me an hour of my life, I will choose to leave this earth with a mouth full of donuts and a smile.

Best donuts in town. Filled maple bar got that good good cream filling and that apple fritter PHAT.read more

Hole In the Wall Great Sandwiches

3.7

(227 reviews)

My longtime sandwich go to!…read more The name says it for itself. It is a small hole in the wall. I love the updates they have done with the place. Not only have they added a fence but they have added two benches aside from the long wooden bench.

Pretty standard sandwich shop. Sandwich was standard and the bread (from the local Brio Bakery) was…read morequite good. Meat quality seems fine and there is a good ratio of meat to veggies. The cheese used was quite good. I thought it was expensive compared to other places, $17.25 for a fairly standard sandwich. Staff was nice and friendly and there is a picnic area to eat outside their small store. Overall: 3.6/5

Happy Donuts Express Asian Food

3.6

(119 reviews)

I havent been here years never thought the donuts were special. Though I haven't visited in person…read morein about 5 years until this morning, I recently had their apple fritter a week ago which a coworker had brought in to work. It left a very waxy film in your mouth unlike donut mill which makes exceptional apple fritters. I assume they use some solid frying oil like shortening or something. But the real reason for leaving this review is as I came in. I asked for a round glazed cinnamon roll. It was 6.95. An apple fritter was 6.95. A dozen donut holes was 5.95 a glazed donut was 2.95. Are you absolutely out of your mind? The donuts are so mid tier and youre charging more for that filth than a local bakery does for their pastries. Absolutely out of your minds. We would always make fun of this place because the lady would be so obnoxious and always be like and then and then and then what else what else you want what else you want and then what else you want. Like nothing I want one donut that's it. Thank god she wasnt there this morning and it was some other gentlemen. I gladly told him I didn't know donuts were so expensive and I walked out. How does this place still exist a dozen regular donuts are 40 dollars

Quite literally the best doughnuts in town!! The service is fantastic, and you're always remembered…read moreand greeted by name. I recommend Happy Doughnut for everyone who wants high quality food at a reasonable price.

Central Sandwich

4.2

(131 reviews)

I think this is the best sandwich place in Humboldt County! I love their roast beef on a dutch…read morecrunch roll. Perfecto. It isn't easy to find dutch crunch and other shops in the area don't come close to Central Sandwich's quality. It's worth the drive to McKinleyville!

Our first stop on the way up to Redwood National Park. We came right during the lunch hour. It…read moreseems like a favorite local lunch time spot as the staff had a nice stream of phone calls and customers coming in to order sandwiches. Lots of rolls to choose from including sourdough by the slice. I got The Big Turkey, which is your classic BLT with turkey and avocado. My SO got the Dinner Sandwich, which includes roast beef, bacon, smoked Gouda, tomato, lettuce and chipotle aioli. Honestly, can't complain. I'm not going to pretend to be an expert on sandwiches, but ingredients tasted fresh, bread was nice and soft, and there were plenty of fixings to choose from.

Pile High Deli

4.3

(59 reviews)

Awesome deli that we stopped at during our roadtrip! We got the mortadella sandwich on Dutch crunch…read moreroll and muffalatta sandwich on sourdough both of which were piled high and filling. The Dutch crunch roll was so good, I haven't had it elsewhere! Service was quick and easy and we were able to customize our sandwiches with toppings and the works. A good grab and go stop that was clean and convenient.

Every time I come up to Humboldt county, I always make sure that I stop at Pyle high deli. Their…read moresandwiches could last you at least 3 or 4 days. They're so big. The meat and everything is nice and fresh. The people that work there are very accommodating. They always ask you what you want on your sandwich so that you can make it to your perfection. I wish I had taken a picture of the sandwich I had but the next time I'm up there I will take a picture and repost it. Great place to get a sandwich. Definitely going to go back!!.

Golden Harvest Cafe

3.7

(259 reviews)

If anyone asked me where is the best place for breakfast in all of Humboldt County, I would say,…read moreGolden Harvest Cafe. Everything they make is delicious, never boring or plain; they are original & creative, flavorful, generous and the service is kind.

Great breakfast spot! Very popular, even on a Monday morning. I had the classic breakfast, chose 2…read moresides. Everything was great and tasted delicious. Service was wonderful. Even if just passing through, worth a stop for breakfast or brunch.

Brio Breadworks

4.5

(33 reviews)