After growing up and living in New Jersey for 45 years, there was never any shortage of great bagel shops. The western states are a wasteland when it comes to good bagels. Frankie's fills that niche. The staff are super friendly and there is always a good selection of bagels, just like the Jersey Shore. Salt bagels could use more salt (the big chunks like in NY & NY). I've been here a couple times and If I lived closer, it would be my go to breakfast spot. Will definitely go back. read more

Great establishment love the bagels and donuts. The whole family loves coming here almost every weekend. Would I recommend you know I would 10 out of 10 read more

See all

Visiting from out of town for my wedding and we are staying with friends in Eureka. Driving in: watch for signs, you can miss it! Once you make the right turn in it opens up into a big parking and you will see more signs (love it) Inside: very large sitting area inside. Kind of a mini art gallery as well. They have many different artists up on the walls. It was nice to take a walk around and check out local artists while I waited. Menu: Nice selection of bagels and sandwiches, but they also have a "build your own" option. They also have a selection of donuts, juice and coffee/espresso drinks. Ordered: The San Franciscan This was sooo good! They recommeneddd the Garlic Salt bagel and I liked the added taste from the salt that complimented the whole sandwich. I added bacon to mine (custom) and it was such a delicious breakfast. I had ordered 3 of these, but mine was a bit special. Plain bagel w cream cheese I love a good bagel in the morning and this place was shockingly good, better than most I have been to in my travels. Definitely a place to try! Post wedding: I really want to try the bagel dogs! Unfortunately I learned the hard way that they are not open mon-wed because I wanted to go back after the wedding and it was closed. read more

See all

Easily the best bagels and donuts in all of Humboldt!! My boyfriend and I have made it a habit to try and come here twice a month (which sometimes turns into twice a week). Each visit we are blown away with how consistently wonderful the food and service is. We love Frankie's!! read more

See all

Really big location inside. The music and decorations were nice. They had a display of all their pastries and such. I tried a sesame bagel that's was awesome and a crème brûlée donut which was unfortunately pretty bland. Still would try again but get something different read more

Frankie's NY Bagels - Food cases - Bagels Near Me - Eureka, California

Friendly service and vegan options but bagel was sub par. Ordered a toasted everything bagel with vegan cream cheese. Bagel is the texture of sandwich bread, not bagel (effectively an everything Kaiser roll). Bagel was slightly warmed, not toasted. Vegan cream cheese was applied to a single side making it so you can't split the bagel and have to eat it as a sandwich. Located inside a building in an industrial park with poorly delineated parking. Overall disappointing as a traveling vegan, baker, and fan of bagels. read more

Such amazing donuts, treats, drinks, bagels and sandwiches. My wife and I go every weekend and the staff are so friendly and fast, and if anything is ever wrong, they fix it fast and are so kind and accommodating! Such a wonderful part of the community read more

This place is a Hidden gem. We accidentally ran into it while we were at the fairgrounds. And to our delight, we tried the jalapeño popper, bagel, dog and the cannoli pistachio chocolate donut. What a treat! The restaurant was pretty chill and low key! And the service was placed your order at the counter, and the orders were filled promptly! read more

Frankie's NY Bagels - Cannoli, pistachio donut. Delicious, very sweet. - Bagels Near Me - Eureka, California

Awesome business, amazing bagel sandwich selection and lots of other treats, the dining area is very big and theres lots of local art for sale around the whole place: Staff is wonderful and welcoming. 1000% recommend to come visit!! :) read more

Best Bagels in Humboldt bar none. Best Dougnuts, Best spreads, all around great stop. Clean facilities, and a lively, upbeat, and inclusive atmosphere. total fan of the San Franciscan on a garlic salt bagel... the specialty cream cheeses.. try pickle cream cheese on a salt bagel toasted.. yum! well done and thank you! read more

Frankie's NY Bagels - Garlic Salt Bagle toasted.. The San Franciscan! - Bagels Near Me - Eureka, California

As a former New Yorker, I heartily approve of Frankie's Bagels! Great , chewy bagels, terrific service and great artwork to look at while you're waiting for your order! read more

I placed a to go order at Frankies and they were slammed. I was early and they apologized but still completed the order on time. Food was great. We were both happy. read more

Bagels toasted to perfection, worth the wait. New flavors every week ( pizza is my favorite). And delicious doughnuts like crème brûlée and chocolate chai. A true breakfast masterpiece, everyone should try Frankie's at least once. read more

Frankie's NY Bagels - chocolate chai and the crème brûlée doughnuts - Bagels Near Me - Eureka, California

Amazing, truly. Incredible bagels, well-made sandwiches and exceptional service. The people are positive, gracious and seem to enjoy what they do, going the extra mile and making everything more enjoyable. The bagels are excellent and their cream cheese options make for great complements or additions to sandwiches. The dill pickle cream cheese is a can't miss. Their donuts are also absolutely worth trying- not too sweet and they regularly have fun flavors and combinations to try. Parking is easy, there's plenty of seating, and vibes are solid. Could t recommend more highly. read more

Good food when fresh.. terrible service. Pricey. Just rude af for no reason. Hit or miss

Went in for donuts before work and they were incredible!! I got the Lemon poppyseed, triple Chocolate, chocolate raspberry, and the huckleberry and they all are smashing! Can't wait to go back to try there actual bagels there!! read more

It's way better than other bagel places. Location is a bit out of the way, but the bagels are worth it! McKay bagel was bomb. Pastries are amazing. Expect about $20+ if you're gonna get bagels and coffee drinks. Not sure how busy it is for breakfast, I came at lunch time. read more

What an Amazing experience Frankie's is ! The Staff is a delight and the foods I have tried are remarkable! Just really good,clean flavored food ! Thank you for what you bring to us in truly good fare ! My family are forever patrons read more

Fast service, friendly, donuts and bagels are delicious! The texture is unique to this area. Squishy and soft. Great lattes. Kids corner is so fun! read more

Frankie's NY Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Eureka, California

This business has great potential but is poorly run. I have been in three times and two of those times were less than satisfactory. For example I ordered a toasted bagel and waited 20 minutes for it. It was not busy and when asked why my bagel hadn't come I was told that the preparer likes to do several orders at once and then bring them all forward at the same time. The next time I came in all 3 coffee pots had been allowed to run out. I think they need an onsite manager read more

This place is awesome. As a vegan it is hard to find great food outside of large cities. I had the best restaurant meal I've had in a long time. Awesome! Epic! read more

Fantastic every time in a cute hidden location next to Redwood acres fairgrounds. My New go to bagel spot I won't go anywhere else..

We went a bit out of our way to find these bagels and donuts and were so glad we did! The bagels have great texture. They even have a table full of games to keep kids (and those young at heart) entertained. read more

Frankie's NY Bagels - Bagel and schmear + donut - Bagels Near Me - Eureka, California

See all

We love Frankie's!! We come every weekend for fresh bagels. They are delicious, especially when they're still warm... which is often!

Friendly staff, nice atmosphere, great food and coffee! I often come here with my family and it's always great.

Best bagels in Eureka. Lots of specials. Good pastries. Tons of space to sit and eat. Great service.

Amazing find. Really delicious bagels. I had the New Yorker (lox, cream cheese, capers) on a celery salt bagel. Scrumptious! So I ordered a sesame with olive pimento cream cheese for later. Service very friendly. 5/5 read more

The new ownership of Frankie's has led to some really positive developments! I love the new big space (though a water station would be great), expanded hours, and lots of fun new options for bagel toppings. Their vegan donuts are fantastic! The bagels do seem smaller and their vegan cream cheese is now made from coconut which is both less healthy (saturated fat) and kinda unappealing when heated (turns clear and disappears) than non-coconut options. I don't know what kind of vegan cream cheese Frankie used before but I believe it was different. Now I order other toppings like hummus or just get a donut. read more

First time at Frankie's and it was pretty good. I ordered a couple pastries from the case (Nutella twist and Oreo fritter). Both are okay. Oreo fritter has good flavor but was hard. It would probably be soft and a better experience if we got it fresh, but I got there closer to their closing time. The Nutella twist was just okay. It was a bit dry. I was hoping it would be buttery or oozing. Now for the bagels, I got a pizza bagel on a garlic bagel for my kid and it was really good. My kid liked it. My husband got a utopia sandwich on plain. He liked his sandwich but didn't think it was worth the price. Tasty but probably won't get it again. I got a the ny bagel (lox, cream cheese, red onion, and capers on an everything bagel. It was alright. The bagel was a little tough but the toppings were good. It's what I would expect from a ny lox bagel sandwich. Overall the food was decent. The inside was spacious but the tables were a bit close together and our table was dirty, so were the few others that were open. One worker offered us a bag of bagels to take home. He was so nice and friendly. read more

Frankie's NY Bagels - Utopia (ordered without avocado) - Bagels Near Me - Eureka, California

See all

the bagel sandwich was delicious. then i tried a donut and was won over! soft and yummy, i wanted more. just have to go back and glad i live nearby! this unique spot has tons of space to sit and even a play area for your little ones read more

My favorite bagels in Humboldt. Soft and chewy in the best way. You can build your own sand which any way you want. They make all their own cream cheeses and have so many sweet and savory flavors. read more

Frankie's NY Bagels - Breakfast Bagel Sandwich - bacon, egg, tomato, red onion, avocado, garlic & chive cream cheese - Bagels Near Me - Eureka, California

I love their bagel chips. I haven't had an opportunity to try anything else but if the rest of their menu is as good as the bagel chips, it would be very good. The chips come in several flavors in a paper bag filled to the brim. Good choice for the price. Try it. You will like it. read more

Met friends here. They have a great selection. The staff was friendly and helpful. I had a bagel and lox that hit the stop. The location and ambiance is interesting but does the job. read more

Bagels are good, service is GREAT but as prices have gone up quality has suffered a little bit. Example bagel chips were 5-6 bucks a year ago and now they're pushing 9 dollars a bag. Bagel dogs 8 dollars too. I get it that the cost of everything has gone up, but not that much. It's still a very good bagel. Definitely recommend. read more

Ridiculously expensive! 2 bagels for $29 they charge for hot sauce and even to toast your bagel thats an extra charge! They charge you FOR EVERYTHING. Oh and they are ABSOLUTELY NOT New York bagels there tiny compared to real New York bagels Just finished eating NOTHING SPECIAL! read more

I want to like this place. The bagels are dense, and the doughnuts are made from the same dough as the bagels, which is an unusual texture. But I like that they have vegan options. However there is a huge problem between front and back of house. A toasted bagel with cream cheese order is sent to the back kitchen and it took 20 minutes for the order!!! For 1 bagel. And the prices are sooo expensive it's kinda laughable. Extra charge to toast, a charge for mustard, a separate charge for everything! read more

Great atmosphere, delicious bagels, very friendly staff. The only thing I wish was different is that their packaging isn't sustainable. I ordered for here but was served all disposable packaging, rather than plates and mugs. I don't want to knock them down stars for this, but hope management sees this and considers more sustainable serving for eating in orders :) read more

Open near redwood acres fair area, fairly quick service, yummy bagels, and tons of spread options. Yum yum! read more

The addition of the beautiful pastries is sensational, pleasing to the eye and my taste buds were very hapPy with cranberry scones with a hint of lemon. I also chose well with the Fern Canyon Sandwich on a Poppyseed Bagel, absolutely delicious‼ read more

As an avid bagel and donut connoisseur, I'm pleased to say that Frankie's NY bagels is hands down the best shop around. Not only are the donuts, bialys, bagels, and everything else they create amazing... but you are also greeted by the warmest, kindest humans! This is truly my favorite little place and I highly recommend, you will not be disappointed. :) read more

See all