This place just gets better and better every time I go! The wide array of vegan donuts and bagel sandwiches are the best! Every time I order the "super vegan", it is literally the best breakfast sandwich I've ever had. Plus the vegan alternatives aren't marked up in price so it's actually affordable for once. I can't recommend this place more. Just be aware, they're so popular that the line to order can get long during peak hours. read more

Wow!. Such a great bagel. Crispy outside and fluffy inside. They're so fresh and good you can hardly believe it. Definitely worth the drive across town. Highly recommend. read more

DO IT. Today we got the vegan bagels (all flavors) and they were so tasty! The donut consistency is thicker, like an old fashioned but a little bit chewier like a bagel. Whatever they're doing, it's magical. The flavors of the berry blast one were our personal favorite, but that's not saying the others weren't equally as delicious. We also got bagels (not pictured) with the garlic chive cream cheese spread. Highly recommend anything from here. 10/10 stars. read more

Frankie's NY Bagels - Boston cream, berry blast, and fluffer nutter vegan donuts. - Bagels Near Me - Eureka, California

Fresh baked bagels daily true NY style bagels with a multitude of choices and as well as several different options of slathers of cream cheese, which changes daily. Inconspicuously located on the backside of the Redwood acres complex, this tiny walk up service bakery has got some seriously tasty bagels. A bit off the beaten path but well worth the effort to find. Friendly service and efficient staff, ordered at the counter and grabbed a drink from the chill box behind me. Only took a couple minutes to get mine toasted. Quick and easy and I was outside at one of their picnic tables soaking up the sun, with my crunchy on the outside yet oh so soft, warm and chewy on the inside salted bagel and cream cheese. No pretentious crowds, or snobby service here folks - this is the real deal with a great product and friendly staff. Los who?!? 4 Stars - a little hard to find and odd hours but definitely worth a try. 00516 read more

See all

It really kills me to do this but it's just not the Frankie's as it once was. I frequent this place 2-3 times a week. The bagels are pretty good, the service is beyond amazing. But the prices of the food is robbery. They charged me 16 bucks for bagel chips and a cinnamon roll. That said, the chips weren't evenly distributed and VERY salty. It's really too bad because I love this place. read more

Never thought I would find New York style bagels in Humboldt. I'm originally from New York and these bagels are legit. Also got a bagel sandwich which was delicious! The pickle cream cheese is a delight too. read more

Frankie's NY Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Eureka, California

Hands down best doughnut I ever had. The crème brûlée one. It lived up to its name. Loved all the textures and flavor. We also ordered a bagel sandwich that took 40 mins I thought the bagel was dry and doughy. But I'll give them another try sometime. The doughnut though is so epic it gets five stars. read more

Better than the other bagel shop in town but the bagels are still really dense. I lived most of my life in NY and I would not call them NY bagels. Nice people though. read more

Really disappointing when a business advertises special hours during fair time, and then don't follow through with them - AND tell people it's because they're not making enough to be open extra hours! So disappointing for people who have driven from over 15 miles away to have breakfast, and then not be open. read more

Never thought I'd find myself utterly obsessed with a bagel yet here we are. The salt bagel is the best bagel I've ever had. It's also the first salt bagel I've ever had, so no hard feelings if you take my opinion with a grain of salt. Ha! See what I did there.. I forgot my phone in the car, so my best recollection of pricing: Bagel $1.50 Bagel with plain cream cheese $4 Bagel with flavored cream cheese $4.50 Tub of plain cream cheese $7 Tub of flavored cream cheese $9 We got there at about 11:45 or so on a Sunday, and there were about 6 salt bagels left of which I proceeded to buy them all. 1 to enjoy right away with mango habanero cream cheese, and the rest to bring home to San Jose. I could've just bought cream cheese from the grocery store, but even Frankie's plain cream cheese is so good! Luckily, they had extra freezer packs on hand and gave me a couple so I could keep the cream cheese safe in a cooler for the drive home. I believe they said the bagels are good for 3 days. I did have my last one 4 days later and it was really hard. I still managed to eat it after toasting it. I did notice there was a lot of cinnamon raisin left, so that seems to be the least popular assuming they make equal quantities of all the bagels. Of the 3 cream cheese flavors I tried, I would say plain and garlic and chive are my favorites, depending what mood I'm in. The mango habanero tasted more on the sweet than spicy side to me. Still tasty, but I think I'd just have it now and then, rather than wanting a tub at home. ***** My Star Ratings: 1 Star - Terrible. Just thinking about it makes me angry. 2 Stars - Meh. Unlikely for me to return. 3 Stars - OK. Open to coming back, but wouldn't go out of my way to. 4 Stars - Yummy! Will definitely return if I haven't already. 5 Stars - AMAZING!!! Would plan my day or even a trip around eating here. read more

See all

There's not much I can say other than absolutely awful and for $41 I felt I got robbed. Bacon pretzel dog had a piece of bacon in it. The pretzel dog had so much poppyseed all that I had to take most of it off. The only thing they had that was decent was the turkey pesto club. read more

My sister decided to take me here, being her brother I was like "ughh ok let's try this place out" in my head... Next thing you know Im eating this cheddar jalapeño bagel like a rabid dog foaming out the mouth! Holy crap, best bagel I ever had and it's the smallest bagel place in Humboldt county without a doubt. This place makes bagels that aren't obnoxiously dense, they have the right amount of soft/dense ratio, also the perfect amount of crisp if you want them toasted. Don't get me started on their bagel chips either, I personally call it a "healthy man's crack" although that can certainly be taken two different ways. My mom ordered 4 bags and we ran through them in 4 days, now we're going through withdrawals! Listen I'm not kidding when I say you guys gotta give this place a shot, Im notoriously picky about food and I vouch for this place. read more

I'm from the north east and these are rhetorical BEST bagels I've had since leaving home. No offense to other bagel places in the area... but Frankie's blows them out of the water. They have plenty of delicious choices and the bagels are insanely delicious. I honestly dream about them. Go, and get em toasted. read more

Best bagels and smear in Humboldt. Definitely worth the ordering the night before and planning your morning around it. The pickle cream cheese is amazing and the things dreams are made of. Really want to try the donuts. Only reason not giving five stars is the counter staff is sometimes not great but I get it because it's so busy. Excited to see this place grow and thrive. read more

I love this place! The bagels are top tier and the dill pickle cream cheese is something I have never had anywhere before and it's delicious. They have the best donuts and everything is so fresh and delicious. The service is always fast and friendly. A hidden gem! Once I discovered it I became an instant repeat customer. Highly recommend just wish they were open more days. read more

Please don't kick me out of Humboldt for saying this, but I'm not a huge Los Bagels fan. So when Frankie's came along and broke up Los Bagels' monopoly, I was thrilled. Frankie's is tucked away in an obscure corner of Redwood Acres and was a tad hard to find at first. It's a walk-up, hole-in-the-wall, with some of the best bagels I've had. There's the run of the mill flavors (everything, salt, plain, etc.) to inventive (beet, rainbow sprinkle) with a similar variety of cream cheese flavors (plain, garlic chive, mango habanero, etc.). Also bagel dogs and bialys! My Jewish father-in-law with *very* strong bagel opinions was a fan of Frankie's, so there you go. read more

Location was interesting but didn't disappoint. My wife and I got the jalapeño chedda (vegan) with vegan cream cheese and they were the most nostalgic to the real thing I've tasted on top of being the most high quality bagel I've ever had. Super fast service and no long lines. Went 2 days in a row and drove 20+ minutes out of the way and would do it again the next time we're in town! read more

I lived in NYC so I can't give it a 5 but it's the best bagel less the a trip. Doesn't quite chew the same as fresh ot the oven NYC but happy to have them! They were out of O.G. Onion Baileys but they make them. I got a jalapeño popper but not the same. read more

Started out really bad, not much better than Los Bagels, definitely not in the same class as Safeway's bagels. But has improved some, still not a very good bagel, but if they keep trying they could earn a second star in 10 or 20 years. read more

According to my NYC born wife, the best bagel she's had on the west coast. Love the bagels. Love the friendly service.

Must try!!!!!! We are from San Diego and on our way home and needed breakfast. I am so sad I can't have these every day! Service was fast and so nice! read more

I am amazed by how kind and attentive the employees are! It was hard to find them so I called in and one of the employees came right out to help me! They were both very kind! read more

Frankie's NY Bagels - Donuts! - Bagels Near Me - Eureka, California

Best bagels in the county. Locally owned and operated. They sell out quick. order online. They're that good.

In the area on Friday morning so I decided to stop by for a bagel and coffee. I was pleasantly surprised. Bagel was beyond great. Nice and crunchy on the outside. The bagel was so good I had to get a half dozen to go. This is a hidden gem. The owners have done a great job with the inside. Plenty of seating. I enjoyed looking at the artwork for sale while waiting for my bagel to be toasted. read more

Bagel and service are good location is a little rough but that's life.... I feel like the cost is what marks it down a star.

Best bagels, cream cheese flavors and customer service! The salt bagel with pickle cream cheese is my personal favorite. I come here 1-2 times week, and I never eat out that's how good they are. I haven't tried anything here I didn't like. My husband said the jalapeño cream cheese is actually hot which he loved. read more

Frankie's NY Bagels - Salt Bagel with Pickle cream cheese. Picture was an after thought. - Bagels Near Me - Eureka, California

Excellent NY bagels, made right here in Eureka, CA. We love their bialy's, jalapeño cheese bagels, raisin cinnamon, everything bagels, sesame seed, etc. read more

Hidden away in an incubator slot out at Redwood Acres, a 5 star bagel maker is doing a sell out business. Frankie's makes the best bagels in town, meaning we are not at the mercy of the bagel mafia, Los Bagels. Over the years, LB has gotten more and more expensive and smaller and smaller bagels. I can use my bagels without the attitude some of the help exudes at either location. Anyway, Frankie's bagels are as good as the Village Baker's in Bend, the holy grail for us. Soft, but chewy with great crusts. Great, great, great!!!! But, you got to be there early to get some of these bagels on Saturday or Sunday. Be there or be square. read more

Drove way out of our way to come here on a road trip through the area- weird location but def a startup, so get there a bit early, follow the signs and enjoy the vibe while your options are prepped. As a fellow ex-pat New Yorker, I appreciate what this dude is bringing to the west coast. Def way better and small batch quality than other options in the area- the salt bagel w butter was legit. Bonus points for the insanity of importing Zweigles red hots from Rochester and making a hot dog in bagel option! We brought ours to a coffee shop in town but a nice outdoor sitting area if the weather obliges. Def worth dipping in and picking up a bunch to bring home if you live nearby. Will look forward to seeing what this fella cooks up in the future when I return! read more

Delicious old-school bagels, delicious donuts, period. Both are, to the best of my knowledge, tied for the best in Humboldt (bagels with the cool guy who sells only at farmer's markets, small-batch donuts with Mcintosh Farm Country Store in Valley West). The "only open on weekend mornings" thing makes it sound exclusive, but the fact that you order what you want from the website the afternoon/evening before means that there's no risk of showing up to find them sold out, or driving to Eureka only to find nothing you want, and you don't have to show up first thing and stand in line to get the best choices. You can also pre-pay online, which makes it really convenient--place an order, pay for it, then show up any time the next morning and just grab it. Tip: The pickup window is hidden way around the back through a gate near the corner, so the first time you go it's kinda hard to find. read more

Frankie makes the best bagels! He's always coming up with new and exotic flavors of cream cheese too, but my favorite by far is the dill pickle cream cheese. There are only a few days a week you can visit this hidden gem, and I would say the earlier the better, because he closes up shop once he sells out. Tiny and tucked away behind redwood acres, this small shop is standing room only, but there are some tables outside and if the weather is nice, you can enjoy your bagels on the back patio. The cheddar jalapeño bagels are my personal favorite, but Frankie wows many with his gluten free bagel flavors that taste no different than his regular bagels. A nice treat for people who have to avoid gluten! read more

See all

I grew up near NYC and we had the best bagels every week until I left for college. We love great bagels and finding bagels as good in other locations can be a bit of a challenge. Fortunately, I found Frankie's NY Bagels soon after moving to the Eureka area. I am a regular customer, as Frankie's bagels are tasty and have an authentic taste and feel to them. Frankie also offers gluten-free bagels and has great flavor. Way to go Frankie! read more

Finally a local bagel I won't chip a tooth on. Great selection of bagels and spreads. Awesome way to start a weekend morning. Tucked off the beaten path but perfect for a nice outdoor breakfast or for quick on the go. Hoping one day for eggs/veggies as options. read more

These bagels are sooo good! I love all the different flavor Combos. It's actually my first experience with a NY style bagel. & it blows any other bagel I have tried out of the park. Yum pickle cream cheese read more

If I could drive from SF once a week for this egg and cheese sandwich I would. I'm an east coast bagel snob and this is the best bagel I've had in a very long time. Seriously impressed. Seriously devastated not to live closer. read more

Real, traditional bagels in Humboldt County. Finally! Worth the search to find the location. You won't believe the marvelous flavors. Frankie is a creative genius. read more

I'm in from out of town, and the first thing my local friend asked me when I woke up on Thursday morning was, "do you like bagels?!" Well, actually, not to be dramatic or anything, but bagels and I are soul mates. So, yeah. I like them. Why do you ask? "Well, this place called Frankie's is a bit of a drive for us, but it's totally worth it, these bagels will blow your mind." Sold. Here's the thing - when we got there, we found out that they were closed! But no sooner did the owner tell us they were closed so that they could fill catering orders, did he invite us in for some fresh baked bagels on the house. He said he had just a couple of extras. I've been far and wide. I've had bagels everywhere it counts, NY included. I promise you that these bagels are a game changer. Support this business. Help them grow big and strong so they never stop serving these bagels. Thank you. read more

Frankie is so creative and detail oriented, it's insane! I went today with a friend to get bagels for myself and others. One friend is lactose intolerant, so his bagel was wrapped in a different color paper to easily distinguish which one was the vegan. I swear, Frankie is one of those people that has more hours in the day than the rest of us; he just does so much! I've had Frankie's bagels, his cream cheeses (try the pickle flavor!), bagel chips, bialys and once, a bagel dog. They were all outrageously divine. As soon as you take your first bite, you'll be spoiled against bagels from anywhere else, they are THAT good. Do yourself a favor and Just Taste It! read more

The only reason to never eat one of Frankie's bagels is that no other bagel will compare, and each time you eat a bagel that is not Frankie's--you will be disappointed :/ read more

Seems like an ordinary bagel, the outside is a little bit harder than i would like but, the interior is delicious. Couldn't complain too much for the snack. Pretty good as a sandwich as well. read more