Overall, great food. I ordered steak tartare as an appetizer-it was very flavorful and very different from anything I've ever tried at a restaurant. For an entree I ordered the scallops with fregola and beets. I had never tried this type of pasta before, and it was definitely tasty. I'm a all about trying new things and sometimes this doesn't turn out so well, but this time it was definitely a hit. On the other hand, it took awhile for the waiter to get us our drinks, our food and our bill. They started to get busy when we walked in, but I feel like we shouldn't have had to wait 35 minutes to get our check. Also, he wasn't sure what any of the drinks we were asking for were, and this was a bit unsettling. The food was great, but I was less than impressed by the service. read more

I go to the Flatiron pretty regularly. I find it to be one of the better restaurants in Dutchess County, and definitely home to the best steak I've had. The drinks at the Flatiron are strong and delicious. In the summer, there's a fantastic raspberry martini, and a bourbon + cider fall cocktail. Both are noteworthy. The Flatiron is one of the few local restaurants I know that has a rotating menu of cheeses, both domestic and imported, and also for beer. The service, in my experience, is always good, although at peak moments things can be a little slow. To me, this is understandable, as they are not the biggest operation. Soups are fantastic, both the summer seafood soup and the fall cheese & ale soup. The crab salad, beet salad, and brussel sprouts salad are all noteworthy. I only ever get steak there and it has always been cooked to order. The meat is tender and flavorful. Desserts are consistently good, with the exception of the ice cream, which just doesn't hold up as well as other menu items. I would choose the Flatiron over a lot of nearby places, including Rhinebeck staples like Terrapin. The service is more attentive and the food is more innovative. read more

Up for the weekend from the city. Sunday night before heading home. Soooooo glad we tried this place. Had soft shell crabs, some salads, some scallops ( in my Brooklyn dialect) and a cheese plate to finish with martinis and wine throughout. Kathy was wonderful. Great service with a smile! ;) read more

Flatiron - Slow Sunday. Great service and food - Steakhouses Near Me - Red Hook, New York

See all

Very disappointing experience this evening at Flatline. My wife and I arrived two minutes early for Dinner, at 4:58. Doors Locked, inside lights off. As we walked off, I looked at the sign which said that they opened t 5:00. I go back and peer through the glass door, and there's the staff. Four or five people are standing around the bar, a few of them look at their watches,then at me. By now it's 4:59 ( I looked at my watch) and still no reaction. No " Hi, we open in a minute, but please come in and have a seat, maybe we can get you a drink " no nothing. I'm glad they're busy enough to turn away long time, heavy tipping, repeat customers. I won't ever repeat this mistake. read more

It's been some time since I've been to Flatiron, and I see that many people thoroughly enjoy the restaurant, but this doesn't reflect my experience at all. First my server was totally unprofessional and under-trained. She couldn't answer anything about the menu, or the way the food was prepared. Also she was sluggish getting drinks, taking our order, etc. Now I understand staffing in upstate NY can be a challenge sometimes, but my server was bottom of the barrel for sure. As for the food, it was Poorly prepared...and overall disappointing. My steak was horribly overcooked, as was my parties wild salmon. Meanwhile our vegetable sides were completely overcooked, under-seasoned, and unappealing. In addition to the sub-standard meal, it took nearly 20 minutes for the server to return with our check after it had been asked for. Considering the poor service, poor food, and moderate price I will not be returning. Also, one could do MUCH better in the area. read more

Love the atmosphere, amazing food, and amazing staff. If you don't try the mac & cheese you are missing out! read more

Had an early dinner there tonight. Service was excellent and answered questions about the cheeses and a number of other dishes. We had and shared: The shredded Brussels Sprouts salad, the 5 cheese plate and then each of us started and then brought home the hanger steak and the duck breast. Next time I'll go more European and start with mains then the salad and finish with the cheese plate. A half carafe of the house red and we were very pleased with a delicious meal. Hoping to go back by after tomorrow's Garlic Fest and have a dessert! Great place, Great Staff, Great Menu. Enjoy -Ron Carter read more

Charlotte and I had dinner reservations for 6:30p Friday, July 6, and it's a good thing we did. The place was filled, but we were immediately seated at our reserved table. We started with an appetizer of Brussels sprouts, which was very good, and I ordered a flight of five brews on tap, which is $12 and come with a brief list identifying what you are drinking. The beers are changed frequently so ordering a flight is always something new. For dinner, we had beef hamburgers, medium-rare, Char's with Tallegio, mine with Gorgonzola. Both were perfectly cooked and delicious. I asked the waitress for a glass of house red to drink with my burger, she made a couple of recommendations and I left the choice to her. The selection was perfectly paired to my burger. For dessert, we shared two selections: a chocolate brownie served with a small coffee shake with bourbon, and a chocolate souffle, which the server completes at the table with a small scoop of ice cream. We loved both, although the shake far out shown the brownie, which was less fudgie than I prefer. The service throughout our meal was attentive, cordial and well-informed. We've eaten here numerous times and have never been disappointed. read more

Flatiron - View of the back area of the dining room from mid-dining room. - Steakhouses Near Me - Red Hook, New York

See all

The Flatiron was delightful beginning with Jessica, the beautiful owner along with her husband and ending with the lemon soufflé and delicious homemade ice cream sandwiches. We enjoyed the perfectly cooked Salmon and finger-licking fried chicken, Steak and hambergers plus I might add the French fried potatoes were so good...definitely a place to call your favorite! read more

Flatiron - Loving the Flatiron Restaurant- Thank you for a wonderful evening - Steakhouses Near Me - Red Hook, New York

I love Flatiron! Great menu, caring staff. The wines by the glass and beer selection is fabulous. I have never been disappointed by a meal here. And they have oysters!!!!! And really really good ones!!!!! PS-in the summer they have a spiked herbal lemonade that is SO good read more

My partner and I are still talking about this place a month later. We came here not expecting too much...in fact we didn't even stop the car to go here since it's called flatiron and I don't eat meat, and headed into Rhinebeck instead. But seeing how crowded Rhinebeck was, we went back to Red Hook. I kind of want to apologize for only giving this place 4 stars. It's because I've only been here once and it's not really 5 star dining in the best way- it's casual, easy going and relaxed. It cares about its beer menu and has fries. That kind of place. Let me begin with beer- Berlinerweisse! First time I've seen this in the US. They gave me my syrup on the side so I could enjoy it on the tarter side. Mmmmm. I got a brussel sprout salad that had so much going on taste-wise. It was a lot of food. I enjoyed but was jealous of the boy who was making happy noises while consuming his chowder. Ordered food. I ordered these crepes on a whim and he got the steak. When we got our food, I won. I actually won with a veggie dish at a steak place. The crepes were in-friggen-sane with this reduced, intensely umami romanesco tomato sauce, tiny tomatoes bursting with fresh tomatoes, mushroom and cheese. The steak was apparently done perfectly, but he chose the wrong sauce. Now, dessert. It gets its own paragraph. We got FOMO watching these souffles parade by- one table ordered one and then immediately ordered 2 more. We knew this had to happen despite being stuffed. Glad we did. We talked every night we were in Milan about going back just for the souffle. The person who mentioned the funny smell is right. What IS it?? read more

From the food to the service, it was excellent in every way. The Shepherd's Pie with Lamb was amazing. The burgers, and chicken, were also on point. Good wine and beer selection. Chocolate souffle dessert was on point, too. It will get crowded, so make a reservation, or come early. You'll be glad you did. read more

My first visit to Flatiron about a month ago , had a great time , food , service and atmosphere were terrific. I would highly recommend dining here depending on your vaccination status as NYS is opening capacity to 75% March 19. read more

Do not miss this place when you are in the hudson valley. All the cured meats, pates, and breads are made in house. The staff is friendly and professional, the food is incredible, and they definitely know how to make a martini. read more

I hadn't been here in over a year, but suggested to some friends who just moved nearby that we head there for dinner on a Saturday night recently. The dinner was very good. Not excellent, not 'just' good. I'm conflicted in saying this, because so many of the elements of the restaurant are great, but the somewhat lackluster service leaves me less than jazzed about the place. As for the good elements; the winelist and btg selections are great. I heard that the proprietress used to work for Frederick Wildman, a great small wine importer in NYC. GREAT selections at fair prices. The menu is very good, too. Roasted oyster appetizer was very tasty, and my 6 oz. flatiron steak was cooked perfectly. Fries were great, the homemade ketchup a little watery. One more little gripe--my Brussels sprout salad, while fresh, was a little overwhelmed by a shower of grated cheese. For raw greens salads, I'll stick with the kale salad up the street at Mercato. Back on the positive side, I really like the range of sauces available (included) with the steaks. All in all, a very good meal. I think, though, that this will be the place we come for grilled hunks of beef...which we don't do very often anymore. Still, this will be our steak house. read more

Ordered a Thanksgiving dinner given the current situation this year. We loved it! Thank you so much for all you do.

Our appetizers came out and we were both thrilled with them! Mike had Free Range Chicken Soup with Farro and a Buttermilk Biscuit. He really enjoyed it! He let me taste the soup, and it was the chicken-y-est soup I've ever had. So good. I had a salad of Shaved Brussels Sprouts with Butter Roasted Walnuts, Grana Padano, Lemon and Olive Oil. This truly ranks among the best salads I have ever had. The lemon and olive oil dressing was really tart which was so good with the Brussels sprouts. And you know how I feel about Grana Padano cheese. I LOVE Grana Padano cheese - having that included in the salad just sent it over the top! As happy as we were with our entrees we were slightly less impressed with our entrees and sides. Neither of us found our steaks to be all that remarkable, and our home-cooked versions of each side we ordered were better than the ones they presented. Mike had the Hanger Steak with side of Chimmichurri Sauce (unfortunately, neither of us caught that the menu said Steak Frites, and we ordered an additional side of fries. The waiter neglected to point this out too, so we have a massive amount of lack-luster fries on the table). I ordered the Grass Fed Filet Mignon with Arugula & Balsamic Vinaigrette. The filet was a little over cooked and not seasoned particularly well. It was definitely a disappointment. For sides we had Creamed Spinach and Cheddar Mac & Cheese. The spinach was difficult to eat and came out of the dish in one whole piece. It lacked the requisite creaminess too. Interestingly, the mac and cheese also lacked creaminess. We also had a plethora of french fries, but I've already told you they weren't so hot. Moral of the story is, though the space is beautiful, and the appetizers were fantastic, the entrees just didn't hold up. I'm afraid we won't be back. read more

Good food great service. Hanger Steak was perfectly medium. Roasted Root vegetables were nicely seasoned and perfectly cooked. Wife's Shrimp and Grits had tasty Swiss Chard and thick bacon slabs. Dining room got pretty busy but the atmosphere was pleasant throughout our meal. read more

Flatiron - This was a 6 oz Hanger Steak.. with roasted root vegetables. Perfectly medium and deliciously accented with house-made garlic butter. - Steakhouses Near Me - Red Hook, New York

What a fantastic restaurant! Everything we have eaten here has been superb with highlights including the beef burger and tomato pasta. The staff is also extremely friendly and helpful. Highly recommended! read more

Well this story begins 7 year ago, I was working with a group of people who enjoyed sharing stories of their fine dinning experiences, and often a visit to Flatiron in Red Hook NY. Or as the locals say "Redook"was among the stories being shared,I however well intentioned never made it to see what qualified for all the great reviews! So, last night my husband, Frank our friends Mike& Melissa found our way to Flatiron.Worth the long awaited experience.the atmosphere was warm comfortable,not fancy. It was a busy evening first Saturday after Valentine's day so perhaps many dining for post weekday celebration... So I will say the service was slightly slow but we were not in any hurry. Okay here it is husband ordered app.octopus with kimchi He loved it, I did too, then hand made bratwurst w/ sauerkraut omg.delish peerless.perfection of flavor balanced, memorable. I had hanger steak slightly under cook for my medium rare request but really good our company had same steak and enjoyed,also had scallops lovely but she thought the veggie side was too spicy (no such thing on my palate) mngmt. offered dessert on the house, they took my comment regarding the steak seriously, ordered chocolate souffle... splendid despite I only had one tiny taste hubby devoured it, when asked, was it good? Could only smile with a drop of chocolate remaining on his chin! We totally enjoyed the evening and highly recommend a visit do not wait 7 years! We are planning our next visit soon. read more

Very long waiting... But excellent burgers, and not bad wine. Nice ambiance but maybe noisy... One advice : don't be in hurry... read more

Excellent food, friendly staff, great atmosphere. Highly recommend!!! My kids and I will drive from Fishkill to Red Hook just to eat here on a week night. I can't say enough about how friendly the staff are here and the food is always delicious. One of our absolute favorites! read more

Got take-out from here last week. I really wanted a burger and it was great.

Probably the best meal I've ever eaten in my life! Fabulous food and service!! We will be back! Had the NY strip with potatoes and substituted the garlic Swiss chard for the asparagus (just not an asparagus fan), everything was perfect. read more

Had excellent oysters and the Panko crusted scallops were awesome. Husband loved his filet mignon & the choc soufflé was off the hook delicious. First time here but will definitely be back!! read more

This is a review of the catering services for our wedding this past October. We booked Flatiron because their food is delicious. Their food gets 5 stars and it is wonderful and if you have an opportunity to eat in their restaurant I highly recommend you do. The staff and service *in the restaurant* is fantastic. I do not however, recommend their catering services. First the good - they do allow you to work with an outside baker, they are capable of setting up in a variety of locations (as long as your rental company provides their ovens etc.), they offer a variety of drinks packages, the final headcount isn't needed until you're practically at your wedding which is useful. Now for the rest. We had several bumps in the road while planning our wedding with Flatiron, while initially it seemed to go smoothly communication was a bit of an issue. It was difficult to get updated menus, it often took weeks and there were still mistakes and errors listed. We had requested a beer & wine only package that was supposed to also come with soft drinks and non-alcoholic beverages. We were told that we would have two beers and a red and white wine - whereas for $5/pp more we could have had a full bar. I didn't want a full bar, a point I made clear from the beginning, and I had originally been told we could have up to 5 beer selections and more than just two wines. My wedding planner had to step in and assist. They were able to get the Guinness my mother drinks and in the end we had two reds and two whites but it was unclear from the beginning what we would be getting for our money. We did not however have any non-alcoholic beverages served beyond pitchers of water and the hot apple cider we special requested for the beginning of the wedding. We had also opted for a family style service and in our discussions they had recommended that we have our guests pick an entree and the sides be served family style. We thought that sounded reasonable and collected our guests' entree requests presented them a month before the wedding and were told that everything was being served family style. I remarked that I was concerned some guests would not get enough food that way, and my main concern throughout this entire process was that all my guests be fed enough. I was assured they would and my wedding planner seconded that. The day after the wedding I find out that several of my guests never received an entree and only some of the sides. I find out further that one of the chefs had dropped an entire platter of meat. It appears that while I had told my guests it was family style, in the moment of revelry people often forget, and the servers never explained the platters as they were delivered. I emailed my wedding planner and she apologized and reached out on our behalf. While Flatiron also emailed to apologize abut the incident they did not offer anything to make up for the lost meals. My father (the bill payer) called and sorted things out and we were able to get back a partial refund for the dropped meat (4% of the total bill). Among other snags was the inability to ever receive a proper invoice detailing all the costs. We had received an estimate however some costs were percentages based on headcount and what was ordered, so we were aware of the ballpark range. However when final payment a week prior to the wedding was requested we received an email through our wedding planner with a number. I asked several times for a breakdown and proper invoice and never received one. Obviously we paid for fear that there would be no food at the wedding. Thankfully we had a beautiful wedding, and gracious guests who did not trouble me or my husband during the event about any of their concerns. While my table was served almost all of the food (we were missing one side but when 5 are served that's not a huge deal) it was delicious and just as tasty as when we ate at the restaurant. However, the sometimes unprofessional manner of dealing with Flatiron does not outweigh everything else and I cannot recommend their services for catering large events like weddings. read more

This place was good at the beginning of our meal, then horrible at the end. I went here with two friends. I ordered a ribeye steak, which I was honestly excited for. My friends ordered rabbit confit, softshell crab, gnocchi, and scallops with spatzle. The food my friends ordered was great, but the steak I received was well done instead of medium-rare. That would have been okay except for the fact that the next steak was bloody raw. So I sent it back. This was not what I was expecting for a ribeye steak priced at $30. It was an extra $5 for a side of "grilled" asparagus (which was burnt as well). The owner comes out, proceeds to argue and try to lecture us! She claimed that the last steak was cooked "to a perfect medium-rare". As well as how wonderful the chef working was! As if this would change the fact that the steak was still prepared improperly. Or that this would in any way change the serious lack of professionalism she was showing. She was very rude, disrespectful, and tried to have the same steak out again! This time burnt to a crisp. Very unprofessional, though I will say that the servers were great. Everything would have been fine if the owner had not been so rude. It's a wonder this place gets any business at all! I will never eat here again. read more

I have been to the Flatiron several times and the menu, food, and service have always been outstanding. The menu is local, fresh, and focused, and they have great beer and wine selection as well. This past weekend, we had the crab salad special, filet Mignon, salmon, and lamb burger and everything was amazing. Highly recommended! read more

This is a long-overdue review from back in mid-May when I brought my girlfriend up to visit the CIA where the owner Craig and I were classmates. I have since left the grind of the restaurant biz but appreciate good food and drink both of which Flatiron excel at! We started with a House Charcuterie with Cheese plate which included house-made pork pate, three local cheeses, pickled veg, chutney, and bread. Really, really good stuff! Next we both had Flatiron's signature Grilled Hanger Steak Frites which was easily one of the most delicious steaks I've ever eaten which was accompanied by shoestring frites and your choice of sauce. I chose the wild garlic aioli, while my girlfriend had the chimmichurri; both utterly awesome with the tender and perfectly cooked steak. They also have a nice selection of wines and microbrews here; I had a beer tasting flight which included the very excellent Old Speckled Hen and they recommend a good wine for my girlfriend who was happy with her choice as well. To finish the night off we had the orange-scented brownie which came with a milkshake and the chocolate soufflé. They, along with the fresh French press coffee served there, were some of the best desserts we've had in a very long time. It's been a long time since I've seen Craig, but was very impressed overall with the professional, non-overbearing service and the level of the food he puts out. He's definitely a CIA grad! We are definitely coming back to eat here next time we come to the Hudson Valley. read more

My wife and I have eaten at Flatiron on four occasions. We've had a good experience one out of the four times. The menu is very spotty. Simple items like their oysters or the duck burger are quite good but some of their other items (e.g. a recent salmon entree) can be overspiced and just poorly executed. We've also had very spotty service at Flatiron. All together not a very satisfying dining experience. We would love to see them improve but it will be a while before I try Flatiron again. read more

AWFUL! From management to waitstaff these are some of the most horrendous, most appalingly mannered people I have ver had the misfortune to encounter. The quality of the food has severely declined since it's opening & the decor and atmosphere has always been sad at tasteless at best. Do yourself a favor and head up the street to Mercato, or Charlie O's for that matter! read more

We had a great time there last night for their annual murder mystery dinner. This is our third time going and we will continue to go each year. The menu for the murder mystery dinner was a set menu. If anything, the meal could have been a bit better. I had the lobster roll but the lobster was on the cool side and should have been warm. My wife had the shepherd pie and did not like it at all. Although we were not impressed with the food last night I would not hesitate to go back for dinner. I have had dinner there before and it has always been great. With the set menu and a full house for the murder mystery show, I would still have to give this a high review. read more

This is a SERIOUS casual dining place. With Rhinebeck a stones throw away- and I'm sure- where all the action is, this is a gem of a restaurant on it's own (deserved) merit. 90 degree day in May so we ate outside. Late brunch menu - Sunday. Didn't want French Toast or Eggs, but this brunch menu included lunch items. Plenty of choices to suit your fancy. Burgers, Steak, Tuna, and more. Started with the baked oysters, done in a light BBQ sauce, 6 large oysters incredible juicy, tasty and perfect. Maybe the best oysters we'd ever had-anywhere! The Tuna dish was like a picture from the Food Network. Rare inside, sliced over greens, olives, fingerling potatoes, spring greens and a dipping sauce. My wife loved every bite, took several pics also, as it was a work of art. The burger was grilled just right, moo-ing rare, on a great hand made bun, but the best addition were the two grilled tomatoes atop the Stilton cheese I chose from the multi cheese choices. With the spring greens salad & light vinaigrette, this was also in the top 5 burgers of a lifetime. Good beer & wine choices -reasonably priced. After the meal, the chef sent over a citrus creme brulee. Just a perfect ending to the perfect meal. Water served in re-used wine bottles, nice touch. The waiter could not have been any more knowledgeable or nicer, as were all of the wait staff. I would not want many to find out about this place, what a great secret hideaway this could become! In Manhattan they'd be breaking the doors down to get in. So visit sleepy little Red Hook in Dutchess county not Brooklyn and enjoy some very serious food. read more

The first day they opened, we asked for a take-out menu to try some stuff, just to get a taste of what was in store. We ordered some clams, and another entry. When we got our food, the bill cost about $20. I hoped it was worth what I was paying for. When I got home, I was disappointed. The clams were so small and the entry was soo small, my hunger wasn't satisfied at all. And it was quite expensive for two little meals. read more

Ribeye was tender, very tasty and expertly cooked- good char outside and med-rare, as requested, on the inside- good quality meat and great flavor. Oysters and clams were fresh and delicious. My dinner companion had the pork chop special and was very happy with it. Service was attentive and quick, with a smile. Can't say anything bad about the place, will certainly go back. read more

Great server and knowledge of James and his food experience is amazing . The scallops were awesome and the ny strip steak hands down off the hook 5 stars. Atmosphere is quite and nicely decorated our cheese plate was very delicious can't wait to go back sorry no pics of food but amazing . Beer on tap was local and my wife's cosmo excellent choices. Highly recommend this place read more

After the meal I had here, I can't imagine ANYONE giving it a bad review! Absolutely one of the best meals of my life, great service, great beer, perfectly cooked... I can't think of one thing that went wrong. I've never liked grits before and the cheesy ones I had here were heavenly. Best creamed spinach I've ever eaten and the meat fell off the bone on everything we ordered. Can't wait to make the 2 hour drive to do it again : ) read more

How could anyone on here write what they did about this place? You fools, this food is incredible. I've come here every time I am in Red hook and always get their incredible and always changing cheese platter and the hangar steak. I have tried other things that my friends have ordered so I've had a lot of the menu and still excited to keep coming back and try it again. The staff is awesome also so I'm not sure what that one person's comment was about. read more

Still really like this place. The bartender Chris is really nice and makes a great Cosmo. Would like to see s larger menu and they should offer variety of the prix fixe menu. It's been the same for a long time read more

This place is great. We like it so much that we make a point to stop by whenever we are our way from NYC to VT. The food is consistently amazing and the service superb. The rack of lamb is absolutely delicious as well as the strip and filet mignon. We got to meet some of the locals here and they all agree its one of the best in the area. B read more