Good cheeseburger. Great french fries. But I as much as I enjoy going to 5 Guys, I can't justify the prices. Also, frequent visits can hurt the waistline as much as your wallet. Here's some health info: Cheeseburger - Calories: 840kcal | Fat: 55.00g | Carbs: 40.00g | Protein: 47.00g French Fries Calories: 620kcal | Fat: 30.00g | Carbs: 78.00g | Protein: 10.00g There are two servings of fries in one order so my wife and I shared - there were plenty. I've been to three locations in Rochester and found them all to be very consistent in food quality. This locations serves the burgers the fastest. read more

There are a number of burger choices in the area, but this chain - new to Rochester area - is definitely making an impact. Very limited menu, but not a problem for a burger place. Their burgers are quite good, but the fresh cut fries are a real standout. read more

Five Guys - Burgers Near Me - Rochester, New York

If your looking for an excellent burger that doesn't fit the average round patty persona then look no further. You can get your burger topped with anything imaginable this includes an excellent assortment of grilled toppings as well. My burger was delicious, made just as I ordered., and the fries were excellent with more then enough to go around and then some. Today I had a lunch order to pick up from work, and I was extremely impressed at the service I was given from Alex. He called me by name which was a nice touch, but he was very accommodating with my large order getting me a box and making sure I had enough condiments. This was a nice touch that a lot over other business have done. I felt like our purchase was appreciated and will defiantly order from here again. read more

If you want a juicy, fresh burger with hand-cut fries, Five Guys is the place! Yes, it's a little pricey, but you get what you pay for. I paid more at Bill Gray's down the street, and the meal was not even half as good as Five Guys. The decor is red and white, and red and white. It's definitely a place where you eat a greasy burger and fries, nothing more. If you want a classy meal, go somewhere else. There are also free peanuts for customers, so if you have a peanut allergy, stay far, far away from this place! I usually get a single burger with almost everything on it, and it's just the right amount for me. It leaves room for an enormous serving of fresh-cut fries. My boyfriend always gets a double cheeseburger with everything, and he's never left unsatisfied. Together, we share the larger portion of fries. Be aware, if you're eating by yourself or are watching your food intake, get the smaller portion. The larger portion literally fills up the entire bag full of fries. You have to excavate through the fries to get to the burgers. Not a bad problem, if you ask me. My boyfriend have tried other places, but we keep coming back to Five Guys. It satisfies the 'I need a big, juicy burger and fries' craving, and brings you coming back for more. read more

Great burgers and fries. I always get the little cheese burger with a large fry. Overkill on the fries but I love fresh cut fries. I really like the new coke machines they have. read more

I liked their french fries more than their burger. I always use lots of ketchup whenever I eat french fries from fast food place, but Five guy's fries were so good that I wanted to eat without any condiment. read more

Had to find a new burger joint now that Cheeburger Cheeburger is gone in Rochester. I'll be continuing the search. Only one kind of cheese, American, which is not really cheese so I got a regular burger. I asked for jalapenos, mushrooms and mayo. Received 4 slivers of jalapenos, a tablespoon of mushroom slivers and half a jar of mayo. There were enough french fries in the regular order of fries to have averted the Irish potato famine. They really should rename the chain 5 Guys Fries and burgers. Disinterested service kind of capped the experience. Cheeburger Cheeburger, please come back! read more

First time here with colleagues and I was impressed. Burgers were good and it came first even though it was peak time during a work week. Will try them out again read more

Its confession time. I admit: If I go about more than two weeks with out Five Guys I start getting mean, cranky, and belligerent. I hid my fondness for Five Guys from yelp for a long time now, I didn't want to reveal the place in my heart that this place holds. It's a chain, I know, I know! It's Rochester, we have a lot of good burgers around here and it's still one of my favorites. Let me tell you about the wonders of Five Guys: 1. Consistency-- food is always hot, service is always speedy considering menus are made to order. I have never had an order messed up. 2. Value. Several people are complaining about price. Really? Have you been to Bill Grays (still love you), Vic and Irvs, or EVEN WENDY'S lately? A burger, fries and drink are going to set you back about $10 wherever you go. I will say, I normally get the junior size cheeseburger which is cheaper. But the regular is two patties, that is too much. Also the fries can easily be split by two people. You can get a ton of toppings that are not additional, including grilled onions and grilled mushrooms. I don't know any other place around here where you can get those for no extra charge. 3. No up-sell. There are some other nearby restaurants that you can get a burger at but they will try to sell you a $4 strawberry lemonade, try to get you to sign up for some kind of reward card, guilt you into giving a tip for real crappy service, etc. Not here. You tell them what you want, they give it to you and with a.... 4. Smile! Speaking specifically about the Henrietta location, I have to say this is one of the only places I have ever been where the staff is CONSISTENTLY polite. The person taking my order always looks up, smiles, asks me how I am doing. The expo is always friendly, too. 5. The food quality is pretty amazing for fast food. The fries are fresh cut, crispy with skins on. They are always cooked well. Never a soggy fry. The burgers are so tasty and referring back to #2, you can get so much stuff on them. Ok, little notes: * Why do people keep comparing this place to In-and-Out? I love In-and-Out, too, but two different animals. * This is pretty much how I feel, too. Daaayyyymmmn. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DcJFdCmN98s read more

If you're looking for a burger somewhere between fast food and sit down then look no further. You can get your burger topped with almost anything. Great kosher hot dogs and the fries taste great and they do not short you on them. read more

I saw someone compare Five Guys to Wendy's with Wendy's winning out and had to step in. WHAT?........WHAT? FIVE GUYS IS THE GREATEST THING THAT EVER HAPPENED TO THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA. Moon Landing? Nope. Boston Tea party? Get real. FIVE GUYS. So in case you haven't noticed, I'm fond of Five Guys. All of them, doesn't matter the location. If you feel otherwise, than please go to Wendy's, but know I will laugh at you. read more

Very good burgers. I love the bottomless soda machines of every flavor. The fries are very well cooked and spiced. The place is getting a little expensive though. read more

While it is more expensive than most burger joints, the burgers, and cajun fries do NOT disappoint. This is heaven on a bun, and I love ever bite that I take. It can take a while to get your food if there are a lot of people here, but everything is made as you order, so rest assure that it hasn't been sitting on the grill long at all. read more

I'm a little conscious about my weight but i'm by no means a health nut who won't eat a damn burger with fries either. But let me say, the burger is good. I got the single but honestly i couldn't even think about eating a double (hey i'm a petite woman, not a body builder here). My cousin kept going on and on about how amazing this place was and was semi-disappointed when i ate it. It was good don't get me wrong but nothing spectacular that had me taken aback or anything. Just a tad greasy as well. Not going to go out of my way for it. read more

Five Guys is an expensive burger joint until you realize that 1) A single-patty burger ("little burger") is plenty big enough for an average adult, and 2) A small order of fries is enough to split between two average adults. Order like this and the prices are very reasonable. Everything is served in a paper bag that gets grease spots from the fries that they seem to deliberately dump into it on top of your foil-wrapped burgers or dogs. I think it's their signature, a grease-spotted brown paper bag. The burger was very, very good. The hot dog was Kosher-style and very tasty. The fries (we got two small orders, one regular and one Cajun) were EXCELLENT. All things considered, I'd order the regular next time, the Cajun weren't spicy (or memorable) enough. It's a noisy place, the food takes a few minutes longer than fast-food places, and they have free peanuts for you to munch on in the meantime. If you like top-quality burgers, go. If you like ambiance, a variety of menu options, or table service, go elsewhere. read more

What the hell?! Placed an online order here said it would be ready at 8pm. I arrived right at 8 and they didn't even see the order- said it still wasn't in. They didn't refund me and I had to contest with the credit card company. Will not return can not recommend. Bill grays across the street same or better quality with reliable service... plus Abbots frozen custard right in the building. read more

This was me third time here, it is very consistent. Consistently good. I am more of a dog than burger person, so I can not comment on the burgers. The dogs are all beef kosher style. Which is different from most restaurants around I always feel that they taste fattier, but that is the style. The fries are why I come. They are good and most importantly, they have malt vinegar. read more

They have a great selection when it comes to drinks and burger toppings. The reason I didn't give it 5 stars is because I won't eat the fries without dipping which is a deal breaker to me.also the burger and fries are overhyped(not #1 fries). read more

Hands - down THE best cheap burger I've found. The topping options are expansive and diverse and the staff has always been friendly to me. Great for a quick takeout option. read more

I go there 1 to 2 times a month and the burgers are phenomenal the fries are absolutely delicious and the meal makes an ordinary soda just that much better read more

This place is great! The fries are amazing, the burgers are delicious, and the service is fast.

Food is typical for a Five Guys. Service was slow and the staff in the kitchen were obnoxious making strange and loud noises and yelling the call numbers. The loud music was awful! No return trip here. Management need to attend to the staff and train them in how to deliver a positive customer experience. read more

Never again. Not only did they forget to give me bacon on my BACON burger but they also forgot to give me: mayo, raw onions and the patty was old. They forgot to give my son mayo and raw onions. The food was highly unappetizing read more

I have been here several times. Today I found the burger patties less charred - and more to my liking. The fries were also good - unlike the burned, over fried (or re-fried) condition they were prepared in the 3 or 4 prior visits. So, food was not bad. The cleanliness of the store, however, was seriously lacking. My shoes were sticking to the floor in front of the cash register. The bathroom door is greasy to the touch and stained like it hasn't been washed since opening day. Inside, disgusting. The tables and chairs have seen cleaner days. The staff member who cleaned the table next to me may as well have stayed at home today. The table, chairs, and floor around them were as dirty when he left as when he arrived. Overall, not a pleasant experience. read more

Served the wrong burger. They cooked a replacement, the way I ordered with the added surprise of food poison. The burger was under cooked as they rushed to make up for their error. I would have easily wait 3 more minutes to not spend 2 days recovering for under cooked beef. read more

The food is always so good and it is the best place to go after a tough exam! They always serve fast and they never disappoint. However the burgers can be a bit pricey which is the only reason I don't come here more often. Other then that they have a great location and I will come here whenever I run into a few extra bucks. read more

We went to Five Guys tonight before a movie. Had not been there in a while. I really can't believe the quality and how the prices have gone crazy. I remember the quality of food to be so much better. Wont be doing that again anytime soon. The prices have always been a little on the high side but the food was so worth it. read more

If you want a safe burger chain that's always quality anywhere in the US, you have two choices: In'N'Out or Five Guys. I prefer In'N'Out; but don't let that deter you. It's done up like an old-diner in most places, the chairs are passable, the burger comes in a bag, and it belongs in your face. Their lettuce wraps are a bit lazy, but certainly edible. Fries are the highlight for some people, but I personally dislike them. Too meaty(but not quite steak fries), and whatever grease they're using just doesn't appeal. The Cajun fries have a 10-foot smell-radius and I can't stand them. Good burgers, price is high- but what you'd expect. Want a burger? Don't want to make it yourself or sit for a half hour in a diner? Order it here. read more

While visiting Rochester, I took my 16-year-old granddaughter to Five Guys, not knowing that she doesn't like burgers. She was polite, and didn't say anything about her dislike for burgers, most likely because I told her "This place makes the best burgers in the world." She ordered a bacon cheeseburger with lettuce, mushrooms and ketchup. That kid demolished that burger, saying "Gram, this burger is AWESOME!" Hey, Five Guys - you made a teenage girl who doesn't like burgers, LOVE her burger. You rock! read more

I have been here many times and am always thrilled at the quality. I usually order a "little Cheeseburger with a few toppings. I have never been disappointed. These guys have it figured out. Keep a simple menu and do what you sell perfectly. I have tried many competitors and they all pale in comparison, every single one. read more

I always go for a small hamburger and little fries. I tried their hotdog, but I won't try it again.

Not sure what makes them so "famous" but I have been there three times and will not go back. This is the home of very overdone burgers and underdone fries. Great assortment of condiments but I got a bacon cheeseburger, fries and a drink and it was over $12.00. I thought Wendy's was expensive but, at least, their food is good. read more

My husband and I -LOVE- Five Guys...seriously. We don't have one in our town, so we really look forward to getting our fix when we come across one. This has taught us that not all Five Guys are created equal, and unfortunately this one is near the bottom of our list. On the positive side, the facility was clean and the staff were friendly. However, we felt cheated on the food. We're used to overflowing bags of fries and huge burgers, but that's not what we received. The burger patties were very small, about half the size of the bun (so the "two" patties made one regular patty) and our order of large fries was entirely contained by the container...no extra scoop! My husband noted it was the first time he has ever left a Five Guys hungry. This place has potential, but the franchise owner is clearly a cheapskate. We won't plan to return to this one. read more

I know a bunch of people that really like this place but it is just a burger like I would make on my grill at home, small round greasy hockey pucks. nothing special :-( read more

I know there are many places with five guys burgers but this one is definitely one of the top ones to go to. When we walked in the people working there including the owner himself greeted us right away. This place is a good place for a burger because you get to order the size burger you want and anything you want on it. They give you tons of fries to go with your burger too. the fries are homemade so they taste even better, especially when you get them Cajun style. It doesn't usually take long to get your food but if your hungry you can have free peanuts while you wait. Their fountain drinks are like most other places except they have the always good Mr. Pibb to drink which in NY is so rare. If you want a burger , but don't want to deal with the greasy fast food and don't want to sit for a while at a restaurant this is the perfect place with really good food. It is one of the best places for a burger in Rochester. read more

I first vivited five guys in the DC area in 2003. Even then it was just average. Foster's grille in Manassas was waaaay better. For the Rochester market Five Guys is a change from the standard area burger. No garbage plate here. The burgers are tasty but wraped or should I say smooshed in a foil wraper and put in a brown paper bag with a styrafoam cup full of frys. Five guys is good for a quick dinner/lunch as you are on the way to the bar. The interior is messy and looks like a reclaimed cafateria. Not the best burger in town but better than burger king...not by much. read more

The smallest option is too large. I've got the meat sweats. Too many drink options, people take forever. My peanut allergy flared up and the bathrooms were too personal. read more

The famous fries are way too greasy. Hamburgers are just so so. Can make vasty better burgers at home. Won't be going back. Prices are too high. read more

Simple is the key here. Burgers and hot dogs and nothing fancy. Is amazing, everything is greesy and sloppy and salty and delicious and the way you want it. 5 stars, all day long read more