I go here with my brother and my dad occasionally and I've had several different selections from the menu including Pizza, Wings, Chicken Parmesan, Antipasto Salad, Calzones and Strombolis. Everything I've had has been great and the service has always been top notch. Great little place to hang out. read more

If you like NY style pizza, you will be happy you ordered Fishhawk pizza. Another great choice for local pizza.

As close as you get from NY/NJ pizza. Sicilian is the best I had in FL so far. Fried calamari they are not generous usually get a lot of crumbs. Would like to see them expand the menu. Maybe broccoli rabe and sausage pie , ad some specialty pies to menu new items always help. Maybe mussels too! Service - to many kids working they stare at you and need a lot of reminding. read more

Cheesesteak in the oven too long, pizza average at best. Good music, but probably won't be back.

Me and the hubby was out running around and decided to check out Fishhawk Pizza. The place was empty but it was around 2:30ish so after lunch and before dinner we took a booth and began to look over the menu. They offered a selection of Italian dishes but we both got pizza. I got by the slice (one regular and one Sicilian) I loved the regular slice but the Sicilian was to much bread and not enough sauce for me. Speaking of the sauce I was impressed. It was a good blend of herbs and spices which complimented the dough. The hubby got a 9" which is a personal pizza size it looked delicious he said he was also impressed with the flavor. The only real negative is there could have been more toppings added. But all in all I would go again and order personal pizza. read more

Stopped in for lunch and WOW. Great food and staff. Sandwich was huge and awesome my group loved it.

With so many pizza places to choose from these days, it's important to have that one "old faithful" go-to spot. Fishhawk Pizza is that place if you live in the Valrico/Fishhawk/Lithia area. Consistently good, fresh ingredients, and reasonable prices, keep me coming back. One insider tip for ya, try the Rice Balls, they are incredible, I could eat a dozen of them!! read more

The pizza was terrible. Dry, cold, waited for deliver for over 1 hr. their lack of good costomer service is unacceptable. I won't be ordering again. I rather call PapaJohns. read more

Pizza is overall very good. The toppings are fresh and the slices are huge. It's a neighborhood favorite. They are super busy on weekends so keep that in mind if you go in or call. read more

Nice local place that's better than any major pizza brand in the local area. They support the local community so I support them. Get the hot wings, extra crispy. read more

Garlic bites are delicious. Pizza came out fast, but it is quite thin and flimsy. We ordered pepperoni and it was quite greasy, which is expected with good pepperoni, but when coupled with the flimsy crust, it just made it that much more flimsy. It was good overall, but not excellent. I like the fact we can purchase a 2 liter of soda because there were 5 of us eating at the time. read more

The pizza is very good. We ordered a simple pepperoni and weren't disappointed. The cheesesteaks are not great. They use quality ingredients but was very lacking in flavor. I might order again but only for pizza. read more

Service is horrible. Placed order for carry out and showed up 10 minutes after pick up time given. Food was not ready I waited 15 additional minutes watch three kids working there did nothing other than talk. Then a second customer came in placed an order. The kid working the kitchen opens the oven and says oh I forgot about the pizza then placed it in a box and handed it to me. It was inedible yet they threw a fit when I asked for my money back. After 10 years of eating here I will not be back. The new owners have no control and don't care about their customers read more

Good pizza, better spinach rolls. The Canolis are mediocre. This is the better of the 2 fishawk pizza places.

How does one write a review rating of 2 on their favorite pizza haunt? Today we decided to take visiting family out to our favorite pizza place... We have been fans of FishHawk Pizza for years..... There have been many great visits and a few poor visits... Today's visit was the worse and raises questions in my mind... How can you get two different pizzas when you ordered them identical? Currently, FHP is batting 4 out of five on getting the crust wrong... Numerous times of getting the cut incorrect..Today we had to ask 3 times for additional plates and tableware... What is now coming into question, is whether or not we are even getting a freshly made pizza; as opposed to one sitting on the shelf waiting for someone to order a slice (our odd pizza with all kinds of seasoning on it).. This is fully supported by the fact of the many times they failed to provide the correct crust or the correct cut. One time we even received a triangle cut pizza that was then cut with an addition square cut! What a mess that was... Numerous times we have ordered extra cheese, only to be disappointed with the resulting pizza... Through all of this, we have taken the mis-steps in stride...however today was just too much... I could go on, but we decided to leave after realizing the many mistakes once again plaguing our pizzas...We finished our drinks and moved on.. We are in no way writing off our avorite pizza haunt... but rather it has been relegated to a back burner on the stove... A few new pizza joints in the that need to be checked out... read more

Best New York pizza near Fishhawk. I used to get my NY pizza downtown but now I just cross the street.

I came to have a nice outing with my family and son..... pizza was good, not the best! But what really got me is over hearing workers talking about a co worker sleeping with a manager and employee while having a family and fiancé at home! Y'all really need to teach your employees on what's appropriate to talk about at work and what's not. This disturbed me so much, I will not be back. My money will not be spent somewhere where this is going on. read more

Consistently cold pizza and mozzarella sticks. They need to ensure their drivers have capability for keeping pizzas hot. Dominos or any other pizza service is better. We keep saying,,.,"this is the last time we do Fish Hawk Pizza!" Tonight it was. Even ordered it extra done/crispy. What a waste of money. read more

Good food! I always get the Philly cheese steak. I'm not a fan of their mushrooms, but that's not holding me back from the Philly. I wish they had a better Veggie Sub. Other than that good local place. read more

Just moved here from ST Louis, went for dinner last night and was best pizza we ever had!

I have always found the pizza here, especially the Sicilian to be fantastic. Today you really had to enjoy delayed gratification, since it took almost an hour to get out meal. Good food as always, but hire some more help. read more

We've been here a couple times within the last few months and something is different but in a good way! The salads were generously portioned packed full of veggies. The buffalo chicken pizza is wow-so good! Just the right amount of kick and great flavor. The stuffed pizza with all the different meats and oozing with melted cheese totally hit the spot- just one slice will do you in! Between the five of us this was a hefty pizza and well worth the price. Our little ones enjoy playing in the arcade section while we wait for the food so that's a plus. This is a great place for the family and we love supporting our local businesses so definitely check it out! read more

Great pizza, very friendly staff. Looking forward to trying all the different items on the menu.

this place is terrible. i heard many negative remakes about this establishment from many of our friends however we decided to give it a try for ourselves. we dined in and waited an awful long time for someone to take our drink order and to order some food. kids/employees gathered around ice maker back bar but did not manage once to come over to our table until we had to call someone over after waiting 20 minutes. they seemed bothered that we were interrupting their conversation. I didn't see one adult manager. It's good to have kids employed but there should be an adult on staff to run the show. Kids need supervision. we finally received our order and it was wrong. the waitstaff blamed it on a new pizza maker, which he overheard and seemed to be annoyed that they were blaming it on him. they remade our pizza and it was wrong again. we were very annoyed at this point asked for a manager no one came over because there was no manager on duty we were told. never again will i be returning read more

The pizza at FHP is beyond compare, and the staff is pretty friendly. Sometimes, it can be a little sketchy, but it's overall good food and a great experience. Would definitely recommend! read more

Pizza was good, service was aaaa nothing to get excited about. Kind of crowded and the styrofoam cups were a bit of a put off. Appetizers are a waist of money-the basic Sysco stock into the deep fryer kind of stuff. read more

I called and ordered spaghetti marinara to go, it was terrible, the spaghetti was over cooked and the gravy was bitter with no favor. The garlic rolls were not good either. I called to inform them of how bad it was and the girl said, " we give you a credit for another spaghetti marinara. Really read more

A small group of us with kids found the pizzeria after a game on Saturday morning. Pleasantly surprised. Very friendly staff, greeted right away when we walked in. Very welcoming. Wonderful waiters, very attentive. Expansive menu and casual atmosphere. We would frequent more if we lived closer. We enjoyed the food and felt very comfortable asking for anything. Very nice place. The staff deserves recognition for their hard work and friendly personalities. read more

I love the pizza, but they really need to improve their service. The kids working here look very distracted and not costumer service oriented. But the food is great!! read more

I stopped by for a quick bite last night. As I was ordering, at the check out register I noticed a German roach. I'm not talking about a palmetto bug that could have flown in, I'm talking about a German roach, the kind that is only found at dirty and unsanitary places. When I pointed it out to the cashier, she started screaming and caused a commotion. The manager came out and made a cashier say that she was wrong and there are no roaches in the restaurant. He was very rude with me and his employees. I'm not going back to this pizza place ever again. read more

Since the change in management the food is not good. Gave it three try's and will not go back. One visit asked for crispy wings they came out like rubber when said something they gave us an attitude. Last nights visit was the worst my kid lost $5 in the change machine the owner comes out with a pissed off look on his face puts a $5 bill in and the change comes out and then question my kid but gives him the change. Then as we are all sitting there eating he comes over and say's my son did not put the money in the change machine. I say what he replies I looked at the video and walks away. So I ask my son where the money is and he say's I put it in the machine. I check his pockets the money is not in there and my son has never done anything like this before. So now I was pissed off asked the waiters for the check and gave her $5 and say give it to the owner and tell him my kid does not lie and that I was insulted that he thinks we came there to beat him out of $5 and will never be back there again. Do not waste your time for subpar food and owner that is an jerk! read more

we have been long time customers of this place for years and had great experiences in the past, but over the past few months we have noticed the quality decline. The pizza barely has any cheese, even when you ask for extra cheese. We recently catered a large order from them and it was not good. The worst though was the quality of the sausages in the sausage and peppers platter, they all had bone pieces and cartilage and we threw out half the platter. Sad that this local establishment has become worse as its popularity increased. read more

Love the 3 ft Pizza just make sure you get it cut into big slices not square ! Chicken wings are the best in Fishhawk hands down

We travel frequently to the Fishhawk area and have family in the area. We tried this place. Not so nice.. they serve pizza on paper plates. The wings came out within minutes already pre cooked with hot sauce poured over the wings. The Caesar salad was not fresh or cold and the cheese was sub par and dressing was from a store bought bottle not freshly made. We spent over $40.00 for 4 people, and I will not go back. Too bad as this restaurant is in a great place but obviously they don't understand what fresh food, customer service and real plates are about when we dine out. read more

Everything is great except for the pizza tends to be greasy. The service is great and so is the sizes of the pizza.

Really good pizza and $1 drafts and you can finish off the meal with fresh zeppoles. Love this place. However, can you guys fix the garlic powder thingy...please. read more

Best NY style pizza around. Great flavor and crust. They don't use the cheap rabbit turd sausage, it is sliced Italian sausage. Haven't had the dinners, but pizza is great read more

ordered delivery, they forgot 1 item (MY PIZZA), only handed over the bag of wings. it was clearly stated on my receipt what my order was. i told the delivery guy who brought it to us and his response was "not my problem i only delivery the food" - okay rude!! so i called the store they told me i can pick up my missing pizza because the delivery drivers are busy so i did that, and my pizza order was wrong. i wasted my lunch hour with this crap. this establishment is a disaster! read more

Everything on menu is great......real Italian food/great staff/great prices! Welcome to the neighborhood Fishhawk Pizza;). Wishing you much success! read more

While its close... It's never consistent anymore. the pizza and other dishes were great hit slowly but surely it's started to go downhill. I would hope that the owner would fix this soon as o like to support local eateries than the chains. read more