1. Fishhawk Pizza

0

Lithia, FL

Cancel

Open app

Search

Fishhawk Pizza

3.3 (163 reviews)
InexpensiveNew American, Pizza
Open • 11:00 am - 9:00 pm

Order Fishhawk Pizza Takeout or Delivery

Fishhawk Pizza Photos

Business Info

FISHHAWK PIZZA ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?
Casual
Moderate noise
Outdoor seating
Good for groups

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Fishhawk Pizza

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Yummy!
Michelle D.

This pizza is delicious! Always great! The dough has an authentic NY taste. Thin crust with great flavor! The service is always great!

Sausage and shrooms!
Ben B.

Stopped in for quick bite. 2 slice special on deck! Have always seen this place driving by so I decided to take one for the team!

Calamari -Not very good here you can taste the old ness of the oil and it's chewy
Jude B.

Stopped for a quick bite and order some wings, a Caesar salad, and the calamari. The only thing worth eating were the wings, they were saucy and good. The calamari was cooked too long didn't taste fresh and the Caesar salad was average. Today's staff was not very personable, placed my order for dine in and took 25 minutes and it was packed to go. We wanted to dine in so we ate from the styrofoam boxes. Next time I'll try pizza ‍

a pizza and a side of bread
Catherine R.

Good things : Garlic knots- get them! Real bits of garlic and melted butter Basic Cheese Pizza - delicious, crust is great Large Chef salad - fresh, lots of toppings, big portion Our server was friendly and helpful Not-So-Good - We were assaulted by flies while we tried to eat. The flies almost won. Tables and bathroom little bit dirty.

Supposedly a well done cheese pizza.
Juanita S.

Complete trash!!!! Cheese shifted, cut all off, was ice cold when they delivered it. I called to let them know of the issue and Adam the manager was not accomodating. What a Complete joke. Not going back as the management was lack of and completely ignorant. Thanks again for this junk!!!!! This was not fresh, probably was for slices. You can tell by the slices and delivered too fast.

Dining area
Spencer C.

Lo and behold, I have found another pizza place like what I'm used to in New York, Brooklyn, growing up. If you're in the area, you have to try it out. But, if you asked for New York pizza "square," they won't know what you mean...if you say give me a square, they probably won't understand. But,if you ask for the individual pizza, You will get authentic New York pizza...check out the photo and this is what you will get. This is exactly, and I mean exactly what is referred to as "New York pizza. " If you want a very attentive waitress, ask for Kendall.

Slice of Sicilian Pizza
Chelsea P.

So I had ice cream with my neighbors but I was really craving some pizza. So stopped in for a slice of cheese, unfortunately for me they didn't have any slices, but they did have some Sicilian pie slices. So I opted for that instead, best happenstance! This is the best pizza I have had in such a long time! DELICIOUS! The sauce is incredible, and bursting with flavor! This was only part of the experience, while I waited for my pizza to be done in the oven, the young ladies working tonight were very attentive, and provided a complimentary drink, and were just so incredibly pleasant. When my pizza was done, the young ladies ensured I didn't need anything else prior to me taking my pizza home, and were so friendly in their goodbyes. Genuinely, not the fake server personality one often encounters when eating out.

Ummmm three pizzas in one box?

See all

14 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

12 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 5 of 5

Ask the Community - Fishhawk Pizza

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for New American 3,747 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Marco's Pizza

Marco's Pizza

2.8(20 reviews)
2.2 mi

The pizza bowls are amazing! I finally tried one and I need to go get one like once a week lol.read more

On Tuesday, July 28TH, I decided to go to my local pizza place. I've never been there before, they…read morewere having a special buy one get one. In the window they had a photo for a 16 inch New York style extra large Pepperoni Pizza for $13.99, I ordered the Bogo special. I didn't understand why my total came out to be $19.33. My family and I started to eat the pizza, but it had a funny flavor to it. The pizza was burnt on the bottom. I called the manager the next day and left a message. He did not return my call the following day. I called again and got the same gentleman. He told me I gave your message to my manager and information. I explained to him what happened and that I'm having stomach ache pain because of the burnt pizza. The manager has not called me to this day no one from management has called me. No one from Marco's Pizza has called me. I received a text from someone named Jessie that said he was a manager and he offered to put my refund on a credit at their restaurant. I declined, I want a refund to my original payment my credit card. Jessie said if I don't see a credit I would need to dispute it with my credit card company. At this point I don't think Marco's Pizza has a heart and they do not care about their customers wellbeing at all. I would not recommend this restaurant to anyone. I was very disappointed the district manager Jessie did not say anything about the stomach ache I had. No apology offered whatsoever for anything. Jesse offered to contact the owner to try and get my money refunded, but it posted to my account anyway. Thank you, Lorena

Photos
Marco's Pizza
Marco's Pizza - The back of my son's burnt pizza.

The back of my son's burnt pizza.

Marco's Pizza - My burnt pizza.

See all

My burnt pizza.

Fishhawk Pizza - newamerican - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...