In all the years I've been going to First Slice, I haven't been to this location. I'm not sure if perhaps it replaced the one that used to be in Lillstreet Art Center (though perhaps that's the one on Montrose). It's nestled into a little commercial area in Ravenswood Manor RIGHT next to the Francisco stop on the Brown line. Parking is probably often not bad, though perhaps I just stopped here at a good time. But I do think parking would probably be easier than the other locations, where it can be tricky. The cafe itself is fairly small, smaller than the Ashland location. But they may have outdoor seating in the warmer months too. Luckily they seem to have all the goodies that the other locations have, including the French Silk pie that is my weakness. read more

See all

Delicious, fresh food-- so many options that sounded amazing. I got the chicken and guacamole sandwich with a side salad. The sandwich had an excellent balance of flavor, no ingredient overpowering the others. And the side salad was perfectly dressed and had a hint of spice. Staff were friendly and knowledgeable. Most customers just stopped in for a pick-up or to-go order, but I found it an enjoyable place to work while enjoying my latte. The latte was a bit weak for my taste, so I ordered an extra espresso shot-- I will do that by default when I return. The space well-lit with natural light and a few tables. It was a little warm but I prefer that to a blasting AC, even on an almost 90 degree day. The do have to bake those pies after all. Got my pie to go but I'm sure it will be delicious. read more

First Slice - Chicken and Guacamole Sandwich with a Side Salad - New American Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

I feel sad to write a bad review, but I felt like I had to. I walked in 30 minutes before close. No one was there. I shouted over the counter into the back saying "hello" to see if anyone was there. No one came for several minutes. Finally one of the cooks saw me and told me to wait a sec and called over the cashier. I ordered a curry chicken salad to go, as I thought it would be the easiest option for the kitchen. I'm sad to say it is close to the worst salad I have ever had. The chicken is completely dry and tough to chew. Besides the curry seasoning, it was totally flavorless. I do not think any salt was used. The greens were just chopped lettuce. There's no dressing, no zest, no flavor, no variety.. I also ordered a slice of pie, and was handed a pre-packaged piece of pie (not one served from the window). There was what appeared to be a melted orange candy of some kind on top of the pie. I asked the cashier what it was, and she told me it was a candy egg leftover from Easter. I stood there, genuinely confused for a minute, thinking I had lost my mind and didn't know what day/week/month it was. Easter was 18 days ago. I just awkwardly said, "oh, okay" and walked out. If you're going to sell pies that have been frozen, considering skipping the melted Easter candy next time. The whole experience left a (ahem) bad taste in my mouth. The staff is friendly and the pie is generally pretty good, and I will return for that, but skip the salad next time. read more

Absolutely amazing pie!!! Freshly baked and delicious. Tea and coffee is good and sandwiched or a pick me up is a great spot! Staff is amazing, friendly, welcoming and always a beautiful smile when you walk in! If you are an out of towner and want some new come here it's the spot! It is vegetarian, gluten free, and some trace tree nut friendly. read more

We are now obsessed with first slice! We have been meaning to go here for years and somehow everything we are available to go they are closed. We finally found an opportunity after five years and holy crap it's delicious! We started off with fresh lemonades and slices of pie. The winner of the pie is always the peanut butter slice. My husband ordered a sandwich with ham and cheese with a side of chips while mine was a delicious turkey and avocado with a side salad. Guys, this place is so good. Such quick service, nice local feel, and great ambiance. We will be coming back and making an effort to learn their hours and go when they are open. read more

See all

Ordered Cuban sandwich and a slice of cherry pie for take out. Was really looking forward to both. The pie did not disappoint. The sandwich, on the other hand, did. I really wanted to like it. Especially since this was my first time ordering from here. What ruined the sandwich was the bread. It was all wrong. A Cuban sandwich calls for a crusty bread. If you can't get actual Cuban (or Puerto Rican) bread (which in Chicago, you can), a crusty bread of some sort could work. Even focaccia or a baguette. But a soft slice of Turano style bread just didn't work. I suppose if you've never had an authentic Cuban sandwich, it might not make a difference, but if you have, you'll be disappointed. I will order from here again, but I'll make a different choice. I look forward to working my way through the menu...especially the pies. read more

I got a veggie lasagna for my friends who are new parents. It's one of my favorite things to eat! Bake at home! Yum!!

My employer also enlisted First Slice for our Thanksgiving Pie Give Away. They have a large variety of pies to choose from. In addition to the traditional pies, they also create some unique ones. The s'more and chocolate peanut butter pies looked divine. The rep was helpful and patient with our orders. Pies were delivered on time for the give away. I'd definitely recommend First Slice to my family, friends and companies looking to cater. read more

See all

The pies are great but this is not a good place to stop for morning coffee. The carrot muffin I got was super stale and the coffee was just fine. They seem so thoughtful about their other items, you would think they could nail breakfast pastries and coffee. I love supporting small neighborhood businesses but will not be coming here again except for pie. read more

I love first slice! This was my first time going to this location. It's a bit small and we happen to be there on a super busy day, so we took our food to eat in the park across the street instead of eating inside. I ordered the goat cheese and poached pear sandwich. They really stuffed it with a variety of vegetables! It was amazing! So many places don't know how to do a good veggie sandwich but this place has it down. It had cauliflower, onions, mushrooms, pear, goat cheese, spinach - so many flavors and textures! I also got a slice of the peanut butter and chocolate pie (the last slice!). The pie here is so good it's impossible to not get a piece, and they have so many different kinds to choose from! Even though they were slammed, the food came out pretty quick. And I appreciated that they had free water on a hot day! read more

So, I've been going through a tough time recently, and yesterday thus expressed itself as "Heck it, spend way too much money on delivery. Yes, order 5 slices of pie." Ma'am, that was the best decision of my life. I ordered: French silk, coffee toffee, Michigan sour cherry, blueberry cheesecake, and key lime. I started with the key lime...I took my first bite and I had to lie down to process what was happening inside my mouth. And I'll admit that I was skeptical! Because I'm a key lime pie purist, and First Slice has a layer of cream on top. But it's AMAZING. Like....really. Next was coffee toffee. Nice, heavy coffee flavor. Delicious. I just now finished devouring the blueberry cheesecake, which might be my favorite thing in the entire world. Gearing up for the last two, which I have no doubt will make me weep. OMG just give them your money and thank me later. read more

Cute and cozy place with cheerful staff and absolutely delicious pies! Highly recommend the polka dot pie: it's almond flavored and absolutely divine. read more

What maniac decided mustard and pickle relish should be on a spinach, mushroom, and cheese sandwich? Because that sort of crazy thinking deserves an award. It's freaking delicious. The polka dot cheesecake is a real treat, as is every pie I've had there. I really appreciate what they do for the community to address food insecurity and was shocked to see that, while I've told everyone I know about them and sung their praises, I have failed to write a yelp review! But I've talked myself into walking down to get dinner, so let's call it even? read more

First Slice - Cute little pizza! Looks better than tastes, but can't beat the $7 price. - New American Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Great pie! Love the Cherry Michigan Sour pie. It's an go to automatically. Amazing sandwiches and salads for lunch time! Great portion sizes too! read more

I just had to walk out of this place minutes ago. They 100% don't want customers and will actively try not to serve you. It's currently 5:48pm and went in to pick up a couple pizzas and a polka dot cheesecake for my kids. Even though they publicly say they close at 7pm, the attendant told me they close at 6 and can't serve me. To my surprise, I said I thought you closed at 7, and also it's only 5:45 right now. He said they can't serve me the pizza because it's past 5:45pm. I'm completely surprised because it's clear they just don't want to work and would rather leave early than make a sale. I hope the owner realizes what's happening and either trains the staff or makes some changes. Otherwise vacate the location and let a business take that spot that cares about customers. read more

First Slice - New American Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Great cookies and pie. Quiet indoor and outdoor seating and you can see the train pass by which is cool

Delicious pies and scrumptious sandwiches! I enjoyed the pumpkin pie and chicken curry sandwich.

Nice location by the train station attracted me to stop by and try their food. Super welcoming hosts, but I was unpleasantly surprised by the amount of plastic waste generated by each order. No matter if your dine in or take out they give you a box to go with plastic forks, plastic containers for dressing Quite disappointed and likely won't go back read more

I had a much better experience here than my visit to the Ashland location of First Slice. First of all, First Slice in general, has a great cause. They help feed folks in need and help employ those who are in a halfway situation. The food is wonderful. The atmosphere is warm and cozy. It is located conveniently right off the Rockwell Brown Line stop. I enjoyed the French Silk and the Peanut Butter pie. They had been properly dethawed which was not the case at the other location of First Slice. This will definitely be one of my favorite cold day hangouts. I really love the fun wallpaper. The floor also has a lot of character. My only wish is that they had some more seating space for singles or couples. However, I know resources and space is limited. read more

See all

A neighborhood gem. Their iced coffee is delicious and so is their hot chocolate and their blueberry scones. They are a pie joint, so I'm looking forward to trying my first slice next time. The environment is cozy, colorful, and I really enjoy how natural light radiates throughout the joint. There are a few tables, but seating has never been an issue for me. During the warm months, they also have outdoor seating. Also service is always friendly! read more

First Slice - Iced coffee - New American Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

I don't know who is left that doesn't know First Slice is amazing but of course it is. Legendary pie but also good food. So lucky to have one a short stroll away. read more

The curry chicken salad sandwich was excellent. So was the polka dot cheesecake. Great friendly service in this very reasonably priced little neighborhood cafe. I highly recommend it! read more

First Slice - Polka dot cheesecake. - New American Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

I could eat from Here breakfast lunch and dinner. Favorite neighborhood spot! Quality, fresh and such home cooked and baked goodness. Such kind staff too! Can't recommend highly enough. read more

Rosa J.'s weekend may be involved with "crowd controlling," "baby-sitting," and "sanctioning"...and yes, those are some of my responsibilities as a retail professional. However, no matter what she does for living by day, she will always be a Chicago foodie. This morning I took a walk, with hubby, to the east end of Albany Park on Manor Ave. by CTA Francisco Brown Line station. I've been a resident of Albany Park for two (2) years and have never visited "First Slice." First Slice is a cafe that serves classic western-style quick bites for breakfast and lunch, quality-brew coffee, and of course, gourmet pies. I've been to many cafes in Chicago that are more hipsters-friendly or catered to workers who would only hang out with their PC or Mac. "First Slice" is totally welcoming for the entire family. In fact, I saw many little neighborhood kids patronizing. One (1) of the sweet boys, surprisingly, picked out a bottle of grapefruit juice and helped mama with the door. What a gentleman at such tender age! And he's going to be a foodie in the next generation since he knows his "fruit." Ok, look forward to seeing you at the Yelp Elite event in the year of...2035 (when I turn 50)! Anyways, sorry for digressing. I now have to talk about the Mediterranean quiche and the Chicago veggie sandwich we ordered. The young lady was very personable and helpful for suggesting items on the menu, since their menu was pretty extensive. All the ingredients they used were very fresh. They quiche was seasoned nicely; it had a good texture and wasn't "crusty" because it was made-to-order. On the other hand, the choice of cheese for their Chicago veggie sandwich was brilliant! They used the medium-aged cheddar, which complemented the spinach and onion very well. I almost wanted to order another kind of sandwich, but I knew I would have a plenty of opportunities since I live nearby and I enjoy taking a walk meandering "MY" neighborhood. There was one that would tickle your fancy: "Duck & Mozzarella" sandwich! What would that taste like? I hope it would taste "crack-lissimo." Well, if that wasn't funny, I apologized for trying too hard. Unfortunately, I no longer take the brown line to commute to work. Otherwise, I would pop in here more frequently. I'm not a huge "pie" person, but they complete my equation with other items that are wholesome and healthy. Overall, "First Slice" has left me a great first impression, so I will be back when I can. read more

See all

Great pie! Boyfriend picked up a slice of french silk and the blueberry cheesecake. Rich and packed with rich flavor! read more

First Slice - French silk - New American Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

Fabulous pie coupled with a mission to feed the homeless?! Now that's a business I'm happy to support. After meaning to sample the pies for years, I finally stopped in this afternoon for a sweet treat with the fam. The kids chose a piece of the chocolate strawberry cream pie and finished every last morsel. The hubs opted for the French silk and it was pretty darn perfect. I went with a lemon poppyseed biscotti and a hazelnut latte. The biscotti was tasty but the pies are definitely the stars of the shop. The latte was just lukewarm which was a bit of a bummer, but the strangest thing was that the coffee cup sleeve smelled very strongly of perfume. Hmm...In any case, I'd be happy to return to indulge my sweet tooth once again and sample a couple of savory menu items as well. Oh, and one last tip: Bring your own cup and save $.50 off your coffee! read more

First Slice - New American Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

This is a nice little neighborhood gem near my apartment in Albany Park. I have been here a few times and usually have the quiche, which is simply awesome. Filling but not too heavy. The iced coffee is very good (I usually drink iced latte), and I wouldn't hesitate to order one of those again, especially in these warmer months. Last time I was there, I ordered the mac and cheese with lobster. VERY good. Lots of flavor and not super heavy, which isn't great when it's in the 90's outside. Overall, this is a great neighborhood spot. I'm glad I live nearby. read more

Cute little place, clean environment, small but not crowded. Coffee is solid and reasonably priced. Hot chocolate is good. The only gluten-free baked good is a peanut-butter cookie. which is just okay (doesn't hold together well- eat it with a fork). Nice addition to the neighborhood, and perfectly located for commuters. Fair warning: the CTA brown line rumbles by, and creates a bit of noise. It can also get pretty stuffy inside in the summer. There is outdoor seating, though. There is a bathroom in back, through the kitchen. read more

This location is always well kept and has a variety of choices. Their coffee is good; if you are like me and do not like the taste of hot milk, they do have soy and almond. They also have specials up on their wall everyday. The staff has a lot of positive energy and they make your stay feel like you are in their home. The location is small, cozy and everything a little cafe should be, in my opinion. I have enjoyed myself every time I have stopped by. The Francisco Brown line is right next-door and it does make noise, but nothing to make a big deal about. If you are looking for a small quiet place to eat, drink and use your computer to get work done like me First Slice is your spot. I suggest that you visit before you actually listen to the bad reviewers. Some people are too spoiled. Learn how to appreciate the little things in life. ;) [CPaynes] read more

First Slice - BYO Veggie Omelette w/side of hash browns and salad. Very yummy! - New American Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

This is a place that really cares about the community. They do a lot of outreach to help feed families who are underserved. Plus, the pies here are delicious. My favorite is the key lime and Michigan sour Cherry. I love pizza Friday's where you can get an entire personal sized pizza for $6-$7! They're delicious! I will say as a word of advice; try to call ahead of time as it is a made to order pizza made fresh so it takes about 25 minutes to make. And for those complaining about the hours (They have the hours posted on the door out front, gues s some people are just too lazy to read) Businesses are sometimes slow to update their websites, so it's always a good idea to check the hours posted out front and not take it out on the employees :) read more

We love First Slice! They're so involved in the local community and it's amazing to be able to walk a few blocks to get some pie slices in the morning or afternoon. Deeply recommend the Coffee Toffee, Chocolate Peanut Butter, and Key Lime pies! read more

There French silk pie is amazing . I went to see their selection and have little expectations because I'm picky when it comes to pie. However, I decided to try their French silk and it was so delicious. I had to go the second day to buy another slice because one slice was simply not enough. read more

Great hidden gem! You'd miss it if you're just driving through the neighborhood (which I did!) This is a great lunch spot! I went on a Friday at 11am with a friend. She got an iced coffee, I ordered an Americano and a slice of Mediterranean quiche (served with a side salad). FIRST BITE- SCRUMPTIOUS!!! It's very fresh and included goat cheese, sun dried tomatoes, and mushrooms. Sooooo good! I will definitely come again! Oh yes, and my Americano was delicious. The place got busier as we ate, but wasn't crazy packed. I hope to return and eat some of the delicious pies and sweet treats they offer! Because I love to bake, I almost always skip on desserts anywhere outside my home, but some of their goodies caught my eye! read more

Delicious quiche and pie! The mini quiche is great for four people, and the chocolate peanut butter pie was very rich and almost like eating fudge. And wonderful customer service. A neighborhood gem! read more

I went in today in honor of Pi day. They had their pie slices-buy one get one 1/2 off. I was beyond excited! I grabbed 2 cause I'm working 2nd shift today and gluttony. I just needed pie. I have the chocolate peanut butter pie and the traditional apple pie. I tasted the chocolate peanut butter pie. It was so creamy and good! I'm at my work desk just enjoying the deliciousness! Since it's on the route to my job, I'm definitely going back. Update: I went back for French Silk Pie. I have a problem! read more

First Slice - New American Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

Some of the best pie I've ever had. We get their pies for every celebration. My favorite is the Apple die, but their Michigan Sour Cherry is amazing too. read more

Beagle found this place with his little puppy nose and brought us here. No, really... I have pictures to prove it! Some weekend mornings, I am too burnt out to cook. On those days my handsome Boyfriend will suggest a walk and a coffee. Here, our Beagle wanted pie, or maybe quiche, or maybe baked treats... They were all good but what I really, really adored was the duck and mozzarella sandwich- delicious, wonderful textures and I seriously debated getting another. Yes, two sandwiches, all for me. Shut up, it was that delectable. I got a slice of pie and shared it with Boyfriend and Beagle. Boyfriend had the mediterranean quiche with salad and there were no leftovers- which means it was scrumptious. The guy at the counter was cute and sweet- which I appreciate tremendously. Coffee was decent and the outside benches in the sun are wonderful on a bright Spring morning. We will be back. You can't beat the cause- feeding the hungry! read more

First Slice - Beagle wants pie! - New American Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

Just wonderful! I mean really tasty! Delicious! We needed quick easy take out food, and I knew they also stocked cream top whole un-homogenized milk, which is my milk jam for sure! Two birds with one stone, milk we need and food we want. Three small pies happened; apple - really really good, strawberry rhubarb - even better, and balsamic raspberry pear - this one is by far my fave, not too sweet, all sorts of deep lush decadent raspberry flavor, the consistency makes me smile just thinking of it, I feel like I could just sit and eat a whole one of these (big one) and call that dinner, it's got to be good for me right, all that fruit? We also did a couple triple combo 70's salads and they were all good, figured, we might not like one, and figured do a tour of the 70's salad play list, and they were all good, but I really liked the tuna and chicken cucumber best! Last but not least, a heat in our own oven, Mac and Cheese, it's pretty much my fave simple home style no added meat or gimmick Mac N Cheese ever! Now I am super curious to check out the subscription program which also is for a cause, feeding Chicago's hungry, I'm all about that, especially while eating such delicious, wonderful, tasty, sustenance! Have a slice, you will be glad you did! read more

Pie-O-My! The Food. Slice Ravenswood Manor ("Albany Park") specializes in slices of pies which rotate based on date and which location (there are multiple locations). Fruit Pies Like Michigan sour cherry, strawberry, blueberry, apple, peach, a mixture of fruits, etc ; or unusual pies like Balsamic Raspberry Pear Pie, Red Wine Poached Pear Streusel; traditional like pecan; cheesecake based like plain, or with fruits, or seasonal flavors like pumpkin. It's a pie place. Soups lean towards "Hearty Soups" with roasted flavors, whole grains, or chili. There are standard and special soups. Food leans towards a touch of something savory or with a twist like goat cheese. There are Community plates which setup multiple items for sharing. There are deli salads to create a duo or trio sampling. Many items have an organic label. Some maybe sourced locally. I tried the roasted veggie sandwich with two sides for $10. It was savory. I added hot sauce to kick it up. The bread was fresh. A suggestion would be to chop the veggies a bit so they don't 'string out' on each bite. Loose Leaf teas are available for tea lovers, presented in a pot. Customers can ask for hot water refills anytime. The Scene The customers on my visit were local, quiet, and some regulars plus a few newbies. There is small playlot nearby which attracts a few parents going to and from. Most customers seem to order and be on their way immediately or after a short visit during my weekday midday visit. The Service On my visit, the front counter was super uber mix of friendly, local, and straight shooter anticipating needs and asking question, plus providing some direction to people on what to try with a curious mind, and where to find stuff in the cafe (Annette). Annette is mentioned in several other reviews and she might be 'not so secret' asset to differentiate this shop's service 'authentic not corporate' feel. The counter can be busy, so you might wait a minute while they provide service to each customer and manage the shop. The Facilities. The cafe is small with 4 tables inside, two of them are community. Outside it's three tables. The cafe had soft indie pop music on my visit. Next to the cafe is the Brown Line, and it has a slow muffled rumble. WiFi is free. The Restroom is in the kitchen, and is Employee grade with a cleaning closet mixed in. recommended for those looking for a local small cafe, local service, local twist on the cafe menu especially if you like to try some locally sourced pie. Give it a try! read more

Best pies in town! First time customer and definitely a returning customer. We ordered Chocolate Cream and the Coffee Toffee. I cannot get over the freshness of the pie. Staff is friendly. Great pie selection and beverage selection too. I would love to try the Peanut Butter Pie, but it constantly gets sold out. read more