Even though their menu is massive, everything I've ever had here has been delicious. Staff is always friendly and attentive, and I love their patio seating. The cheese curds and seasonal sausage special mini corn dogs are go-tos for appetizers. My current favorite sandwiches are the Eli W. and the Munchy grilled cheese, but there is obviously an insane amount of options to explore. All of the sides I've tried have also been amazing... mac and cheese, mashed potatoes with mushroom gravy, elote, red beans & rice, even the creamed spinach is yummy. I love you, Jerry. read more

My younger daughter and i came here for an early dinner. Unfortunately, i wasn't extremely hungry so a large sandwich was out of the question for me. She ordered the Jerry G Cheez w/bacon, bleu cheese on the side and BBQ beans. I got a side Caesar salad. Wish i was hungrier 'cuz some of the sandwich descriptions looked delish. The wait staff seemed very cool and one of the servers brought a customer whipped cream for her little pooch. There was a lot of good people watching in the plaza. Our meals came out pretty quickly. The cheese sandwich was pretty large w/good cheese pull. My salad was delicious and i added the bleu cheese from the side of my daughters' plate making it even more enjoyable. Think i'll order Caesar's w/bleu cheese all the time. Turns out my daughter wasn't as hungry as she thought she was, so we brought home half the sandwich, which was good even the next day. We really enjoyed this place. read more

Five stars for the sandwiches. Zero stars for the performance art at the hostess stand. I've eaten here twice. The food is consistently excellent. Unfortunately, so is the hostility. Both times I came in to pick up a to-go order, the hostess greeted me with the kind of expression you'd expect if I'd just offended her. I gave her my name--Ryan--and both times she confidently informed me there was no order for Ryan, dismissed me, and acted as though I had wandered into a private event instead of a restaurant where I had literally paid for food. The second visit somehow managed to top the first. After being treated rudely yet again, I made the outrageous decision to tell her she was being rude. Rather than doing something radical like apologizing or checking on my order, she followed me outside onto a crowded sidewalk, yelling at me to "say that to her face." A male employee joined the spectacle, scolding me while she continued shouting after me in front of customers eating outside. I've never had a takeout order come with complimentary public humiliation and a sidewalk shouting match. The truly ironic part is that the sandwiches are good enough that I wanted to become a regular. Instead, I've learned that ordering takeout here comes with the chance of being treated like you're not welcome and humiliated. People remember how you make them feel. I didn't leave here feeling very good either time. read more

I just stopped in here for a quick drink one night and it was a friendly atmosphere for a solo, female drinker. Bartender was nice and attentive and suggested a great gin for my gin and tonic. I would definitely come back for dinner, it's a really cute place. read more

Jerry's - Nice bar and friendly atmosphere. - Sandwiches Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Really good sandwiches, really great location! We sat on the patio and enjoyed the vibes as a performer was setting up and singing in the square. I could NOT decide which sandwich to get. There are sooo many good options. I ended up on the Ansel A - buffalo fried chicken on challah. The bread was great, sandwich was well-executed. I would definitely order take out or delivery from Jerry's when I'm craving a sandwich rather than choosing a chain restaurant. So many more options to try! read more

Jerry's - Ansel A and a House Side Salad - Sandwiches Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

I just grabbed a few things to go from Jerry's to eat while I was camping out in the book cellar, across the street. The sandra oh sandwich is so good, very juicy and the flavors combine well! I also really liked the spiced apples and the other sides, the fruit salad and tomato soup especially standing out. I would definitely come back to chill in the book cellar and eat sandwiches, made me feel very cozy and at home! read more

WHO IS JERRY AND HOW DO THEY MAKE SUCH GOOD SANDWICHES??? We checked out Jerry's at the recommendation of our friends and wwwwwwwow. I consider myself a sandwich aficionado and Jerry's rises to the top. The bread was crunch, flakey and fresh. The garlic aioli on the Rachel C is some of the most savory food I've eaten. LB's skirt steak sandwich was soooo good with the chipotle sauce on top. House chips were 10/10. Could not stop stealing from LB's plate. Massive menu ensures that there is something for everyone. I will bring my friends and family back!! Service was very nice. We came at like 2pm on a Sunday so there werent many tables needing attention. Inside feels like a nice cozy sandwich shop/bar! read more

See all

I got the DAGWOOD B, and let me tell you... this thing is a full-on architectural achievement. Roast turkey, root beer ham, Swiss, pickles, chipotle chutney, pimento cheese, corned beef, fried shrimp, bacon, avocado, cilantro, red onion, lettuce, southwest mayo... what's not to love? It literally has everything. I couldn't tell where it started or where it ended... it was just one glorious mountain of flavor, and it tasted exactly as amazing as that ingredient list suggests. The beer list is huge... a pint for every possible pleasure. The sides, though... super mid. The mac and cheese was cold, and the corn elote was about 5/7ths butter. But honestly, I wasn't there for the sides. I'll be back... mostly to finish the other half of that absolute mamajama of a sandwich I couldn't conquer in one sitting. read more

Jerry's - Dagwood B - Sandwiches Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

The service was a bit random, but the drinks and snack were good. We sat outside, and there was a great vibe in the square! read more

Jerry's - Sandwiches Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

If you've ever come to Lincoln square- you know parking is always a problem. You'll look for parking longer than you will wait in line to get seated. Was very lucky to find parking right away but thus place is also easily accessible by train, bus or walking. Located in the heart of Lincoln Square, I Came here for lunch with a friend of mine. I ordered half of a sandwich (skirt steak) and their squash soup- my friend ordered a chicken sandwich with squash soup. my toddler already ate so he just had juice. The atmosphere was really nice/ not too crowded but there were a few people who were on zoom/team calls but they didn't bother us. The food came relatively quickly and the portions were decent for the price. It was all very delicious- the squash's soup blew me away how good it was. plus the view from our window was so quaint and cozy- makes me want to come back when the snowing outside just to watch the snow fall as I work remote. Highly recommend checking this place out. read more

Jerry's - Sandwiches Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

This is a nice little restaurant with a good variety of food. They have real Wisconsin breaded cheese curds, which are real and property made with very light breading and they're actually made from real cheese curds and not cheese cubes like some places offer. They were delicious. We also had the Korean Seoul burger, which was delicious. It came with 2 sides of your choice and we got fries and the slaw with kale. Unfortunately the slaw with kale has way too much cream in it. I had to drain it and dump some out. I don't mind slaw and I don't mind creamy slaw, but I don't like coleslaw soup! The fries are delicious and the service was wonderful. We definitely go back. read more

When I came in for dinner I was really disappointed that none of the sandwiches I wanted to try were not on the dinner menu and only available for lunch. Veg options were a bit limited. I had the tomato soup, which was good, and the service was fine, but I feel like Jerry's Sandwiches was a little light on sandwiches. read more

Jerry's is Lincoln Square's best kept secret when it come to enjoy good food. The sandwiches are the best and so many to select from. The staff are friendly and helpful and always make sure that the customer are having a great time. Jerry's also hosts drag queen story time, which is a thumbs up from me. I will look forward to enjoy lunch or dinner at Jerry's in the near future. read more

Jerry's - Dagwood B sandwich with french fries and fruit salad. - Sandwiches Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Pickled veggies are on point! -we had 3 orders! Mashed potatoes with pabalono gravy too! Had the Dagwoodand it was huge! Love this place! read more

Jerry's - Pickled Veggies - Sandwiches Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

We've been to Jerry's well over 30 times in the last six years and it's honestly one of the best restaurants in the area. Perfect for breakfast, lunch, dinner. Great for entertaining friends or family. Wide selection of foods, everyone will find something they want with great service and a nice patio space. read more

See all

I absolutely love coming to Jerry's! We always sit at the bar and have a good chat with whoever the bartender is that day. We are always served tasty, cold beer or cocktails of our choosing. The food is always really good and comes out without too long of a wait. I honestly don't get why the reviews are so bad. We've been coming here for a few years, especially on weekdays, and I've always had a great time. read more

See all

This is one of the best spots in the neighborhood for sandwiches. It also just happens to be burger month, which means they have lots of delicious different options. They always have a good selection of beer on tap, and some good cocktails as well. The bartenders are super friendly! read more

See all

I thought this place was so cute from the outside but would not recommend and will not be going back! After ordering food it took 45 minutes to come out. Fries and Mac & Cheese sides were cold. Fries had good taste but Mac & Cheese was bland. My side of fruit was over ripened, no flavor too soft. The Beef Brisket sandwich was too chewy which made it unappetizing. My sandwich had good flavor, but the chicken salad was too chunky--which made it messy to eat. Frankly, not even in the same realm as a chicken salad, the description should be changed. Only spoke with our waiter when we ordered, never saw him once after, had to flag down another waitress to pay our check. Atmosphere was very loud. read more

See all

Sat at the bar and had great service with the bartender. The draft beer selective is massive and is expansive. The sandwich was delicious but the star of the show were the sides. I dream about the mashed potatoes with poblano gravy and can't wait to go back. read more

Jerry's - Sandwiches Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

The food is good, that's not the problem. The staff is absolutely terrible here. On more than one occasion Nobody has come to greet me within 10 minutes and so I will have to go up and ask somebody if a waiter is coming. I wish it was a fluke, but it's not! Really good, solid food, it's the experience that is rotten here due to a lack of checking in on customers. No enthusiasm, they seem like they do not care at all to be taking care of us. A Bummer.... read more

My friend and I came here from lunch and it was delicious. She got a salmon sandwich and I got the Jeri grilled cheese that I added a bunch of yummiest too. We both highly recommend the mac & cheese as a side and the house made chips. Her server was very attentive and awesome. We loved sitting outside by the fountain it was beautiful and a beautiful day. Highly recommend. read more

Jerry's - Jerry grilled cheese - Sandwiches Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

The food is so good, sandwich, sides, everything. Don't know how anyone could leave a bad review.

I've been here dozens of times. The food is great, the staff is friendly and accommodating, and the atmosphere is welcoming. It's good for groups, dates, coffee, brunch/lunch/dinner, watching sports at the bar, grabbing drinks, etc etc. It's just delightful. read more

During my first visit to Jerry's a couple of years ago, I ordered one their sandwiches. I was mainly craving breakfast food during my most recent visit a few days ago. I ordered the quiche of the day and also cheese curds. The cheese curds here are really good! The quiche of the day was one with 3 or 4 different types of vegetables. The filling and crust on the quiche were both great. I wouldn't put the quiche at Jerry's above other places in Chicago like la boulangerie or bang bang pie, but still a solid 8/10. Jerry's has a nice-sized patio and also plenty of space inside too. read more

Jerry's - Vegetable quiche - Sandwiches Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Little underwhelming considering the prices. $5 for a cup of coffee and $11 for a 4 oz mimosa was a bit much. Food was okay, our fried eggs were dry and overdone but the chicken was juicy, and tender and the french toast was great. Service was good and the drag show was the cherry on top. Cute and comforting interior. read more

Jerry's - Sandwiches Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

LOVE Jerry's Sandwiches! In fact, it's a MUST for us when visiting Lincoln Square! Today I tried the Sandra O (so delicious, will definitely get again!) and my daughter had the Bill W (her favorite!) Portions are perfect, price is right, and such a nice atmosphere on the patio. read more

Jerry's - The Bill W. with fries and pickled vegetables. YUM! - Sandwiches Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

With so many restaurants closing in the Lincoln Square area, I finally decided to retry Jerry's. It had been at least 8 or 9 years, since the last time I came here, they served a chicken sandwich which was still raw in the middle. Luckily, I will say my experience was better than the prior occasion. However, I can't say my mind was fully blown. One thing I will commend Jerry's for is their extensive beer list. Paired with their delicious cheese curds, I can see myself coming here frequently for a beer and a snack. For sandwiches, we ordered the Ansel (buffalo chicken sandwich) and the brisket sandwich (special) with horseradish sauce. For sides, we got the potato salad, mashed potatoes with poblano gravy, mac and cheese and the greens with vinegarette. The buffalo sandwich was decent, and I would not mind ordering it again. The brisket sandwich was a let down. The beef was too thick and chewy. Some parts were flavorless and other parts were almost too salty. For sides, the mac and cheese was dry and tasteless. I couldn't eat more than a single bite. The potato salad was standard and is a decent option to order. The mashed potatoes were OK. The gravy had good flavor but was a bit thin, giving cafeteria vibes. The salad is a total pass. It's literally lettuce with too much dressing. I do wish Jerry's upped their consistency game. I want to go back, but I really don't know what I'll get when I go. read more

I am a fan. I see what Jerry's did here, kicked up typical lunch foods with an artisan touch. I am here for it. We were greeted and sat immediately and for lunch time, this place was bustling. We got the cheese curds and they were good but they had all stuck together. The seasonal butternut squash was divine and would eat that everyday of the week. The sandwiches where very good. Everything tasted fresh. Perfect place to catch a great lunch in the Lincoln Square neighborhood. Pricing was congruent with the area. Paid parking is available with the diagonal spots. Service was great. I plan to revisit again soon. They also are attached to another coffee shop (Gertrude's is what I think it's called) that serve pastries and coffees. read more

So I've been a fan of Jerry's since the days when I would frequent the Andersonville location. And I have to say the food is always great. I'm a huge fan of their salads, as well as of the sandwiches, and have never had anything I would say was not good. Though today my streak salad just felt a little sad...but it still tasted delicious, but was oddly small compared to the size of the salads normally. My friend joked that maybe they got bigger bowls. In the Lincoln Square location, I have always felt the service was a little hit or miss. Don't get me wrong, the waitstaff is always friendly and tries their best. However it just always feels like they are one of two people short, making the staff always appear stressed and chaotic. Today was better than most of our recent visits, but still felt like our server was pulling more than his share of the service...but he was a trooper and this isn't about him. The issue I had today that lowers the rating is the volume of the music. And I don't want to be that "would you kids turn it down" guy, but today was a lot. We were in the back area behind the bar and bathroom entrance, and the volume was almost unbearable. I love music and am fine normally, but today it just seemed overly loud. Everyone in the area we were in was having to yell, and pretty soon I developed a headache. Some songs were lower volume, but just when you felt it was subsiding, another blast would blare and everyone would start screaming to talk to table mates. On the plus side, hearing The Stooges and 13th Floor Elevators in a restaurant is kind of great...just maybe a little less volume. This is the first time in a while I've come around lunch on the weekend, so maybe this is the norm, but just felt excessive. I do really love coming here (3-4 times a month on average), but just can't take that blasting music. read more

Jerry's - Sandwiches Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

Great food. Great service. Amazing bartender. Cool atmosphere! . Lovely neighborhood! read more

See all

The amount of sandwiches on the menu is overwhelming but awesome! I ended up with a fried green tomato with pimento cheese and thoroughly enjoyed the meal. My sandwich was made incorrectly which isn't a problem, but it took over 10 minutes to flag down a waitress to fix it. They were very apologetic and everything ended up fine although I wish the waitress would've checked in after delivering our food. The location is great, right on Lincoln Square with a cute courtyard patio. The inside ambiance is pretty noisy and unremarkable. I live a bit far so likely won't travel out of my way to return but wouldn't hesitate to stop by next time I'm in the area. read more

28 dollars for a fish and chips plate with no side dishes or drinks and the 2 pieces of fish were tiny. I used to like this place but the waitress was curt and unfriendly. With prices like these, they will not be there for long. Sadly! read more

Surprisingly unpleasant. In their defense, they were busy and obviously under staffed. But our waiter was hostile and unpleasant. When we asked him to split the check, that's when the fireworks erupted. There were 5 of us, and the waiter brought the manager over to the table to explain to us in no uncertain terms that they could only split the check 3 ways, despite the fact that we said from the beginning that we wanted separate checks. Of course in the end, they split the check, after the manager told us not to come back. It only took a few buttons on their hand held device, and very little extra time. read more

Where do I start here?? Got a seat for 5 right away for late lunch on a Saturday. Very welcoming restaurant with cool vibes, and great menu We all had chicken sandwiches which were spot on, with side salad, fries and Mac and cheese, had pretzel for app, which would highly recommend This place is great not only is vibe cool but the menu is amazing, beer list endlist and cocktails look great Best part?? Service is on point, fast, efficient, and super nice Run don't walk and check this place out! read more

Overall 3.75 stars. Solid choice in Lincoln square. Pros: More than just sandwiches. Great service. 30 beers on tap - good ones...not Budweiser. Cons: Menu is a bit overwhelming but it's nuances once you get through. My buffalo chicken salad while being fresh was not a "traditional" buffalo...good thing I asked for more sauce. Bread is large. While tasty it's a bit much. read more

Jerry's - Fried Chicken sandwich - Sandwiches Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

This place has great food, amazing burgers, decent service and a busy old style ambiance. When there is a lunch rush expect to wait a little bit for your food! read more

Excellent selection of sandwiches, sides, and beer. The Ansel A. is the best! Especially love going when it's warm so I can sit outside in the Square. read more

We moved to Chicago 7 years ago and it took me that long to find my FAVORITE sandwich place. This place, and people, are amazing. Food delicious, staff attentive and helpful, and the margharita is excellent and I'm kind of a snob about those. Please give Jerry a chance to be your favorite sandwich place! read more

I'm currently sitting outside. Waiting. Waiting It seems like hours. I could go in again and ask for my waitperson, but they only seem to get snippier when I do. I also have to collect my belongings ( since I'm outside). The flame salad was ok. About a half an hour ago, I flagged someone asking for an iced tea refill. He looked at me like you look at a foreigner speaking an unknown language. The front desk person came out but upon seeing me, rushed back in I'm getting weaker. read more

This whole place is just so relaxing to just sit in. it's never too loud, and there's even space to eat outside and enjoy the scenery there. The employees and hosts are super sweet and are always around if you need something more or are ready to take the check. Lemonade is super good- it's got a LOT of ice though but you know thats how they get you. The burger is probably one of my favorite burgers I've had thats costed me more than my usual go-to's but getting two sides makes it worth it. Mac n Cheese is so delicious I wish I'd get more and their fries are crispy and not too salty. All love to these guys read more

Jerry's - lemonade - Sandwiches Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all