Their butter, butter pizza is to die for! I had no idea kale on pizza can be so good. Get that and the caesar salad. You won't be disappointed! read more

While this place has really good pizza the staff is kind of rude. Maybe it is supposed to go along with the "New York" style pizza.

Pizza was delicious. Beer was great. Great music. The crust is gentle and delicious. The toppings to die for. A great stop. read more

Favorite Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Austin, Texas

Rude service. Rude when we ordered and decided to take the pizza to go instead of staying here and made unnecessary remarks. Then messed up our order. read more

Pretty good NY style pizza. I prefer home slice better but would eat this again any day. Has 5 outdoor tables.

I would say this is the best pizza in Austin if you are looking for thin style (NY style) pizza! Definitely beats Home Slice in quality and flavor, hands down! Staff is also super friendly! I understand that it may be a little pricey, but I really haven't found quality pizza like this anywhere else in Austin! If you're coming from the east coast like me, you'll be very happy with Favorite Pizza! read more

Best pizza I've ever had! We are still talking about how good it was. Boston Bruins on the tv was a nice bonus! Service was great. Mike (the new guy) did a great job! Outside patio was great to eat. Wish this place existed in Boston. read more

Favorite Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Austin, Texas

See all

Hey, Butter Butter and the Margherita (must) and let's talk about the best caesar salad. Don't know what hot honey is? I didn't and now I am changed. And while you are waiting at the the bar with the coolest 80's decor grab a hard eight and relax. Can't wait to return and thank you my new Favorite. read more

This place being on west has made it a staple stop on the way back from the bars. Great NY style slice pizza. More of a grab and go set up but they do have some bar seating inside and a few picnic tables outside. read more

Good pizza for the price in downtown Austin. We were three of us and had a hearty meal in 30 bucks!

Pizza and staff are great! Love trying different pizza places around Austin and this was a great location walking distance from my apartment. Love the pizza! Not too thick and not too thin and the pizza holds together nice! read more

Took my kids there for some slices of pizza at lunch and I got the Hojo sandwich which is the best sandwich I've had in a while. Sadly I have yet to try the pizza as my kids ate all theirs and my 10 year old even got a second slice. The staff was fast and friendly and the place was clean with great outdoor seating. I'm already planning on adding it to our list of places to bike to with a group I do downtown pub crawl rides with. read more

Favorite Pizza - Hojo sandwich and slices of pepperoni and cheese. - Pizza Near Me - Austin, Texas

Im from jersey and its some of the better pizza ive had down here. The basil on the pepp is a nice touch. Most places used the chopped up processed basil. I def think its better pizza than the top 3 i was suggested in the downtown area. read more

I have been studying to be a master pizzaiolo for over 60 years.......which means I know pizza very well. I grew up in NY in the 50's/60's when all of the thousands of pizza places throughout the NY metro area were owned/run by Italians who made pizza :"NY style": thin to very thin crust, a very small low profile "bone" at the edge, a well balanced bright raw tomato sauce, a thin topping of mozzarella, baked crisp. Of course not all pies were the same, there were lots of variations.........but most were similar. To me, the pizza with the most sauce was usually the best, even if it meant the slice flopped instead staying rigid and you needed 2 hands to eat.......in the end the taste was most important. That is why when I see a pic of pizza on yelp is made properly NY style but does not show the redness of the sauce I will customize the pie to what I think it should be so I have a better chance of enjoying it and going back. I also do not have them cut it. When I get home I eat 1/4 then freeze the other 3 quarters. I usually heat up the slice the way they do at the restaurant.......on a preheated hot pizza stone to replicate the hearth in the pizza oven heating from the bottom. I moved to the Austin area over a year ago and have made it a point to regularly try new pizza places based on the the photos, asking them to customize to heavy sauce and light cheese. For NY style I've enjoyed Pedrosos, Sammataro, Little Italian Deli, Home Slice, Backdraft, 600 degrees, Saccones, and Local Slice. All were good, some really good. Yesterday I went took my first pie home from Favorite. The young pizza chef, took my order, took payment, then immediately made my pie in front of me so I could direct him for the proper sauce/cheese proportion I wanted. Talk about fast service!!!1 Plus he is a master, he made the pie in less than 2 minutes. He then took it out of the oven and brought it over to me so I could feel the crust and decide if it was made to my satisfaction as I asked to undercook it about 1 minute. IT was perfect. In fact he commented that it was beautiful and much better looking than his pies because it was red on top not yellow from melted cheese. Now the verdict: paper thin yet super crisp and chewy, sauce was perfect could not be better, cheese was creamy as melted in to the sauce a perfect ratio. Result: 5 stars for the pizza and service.....not to mention the price of $17 for an 18" pie. I will continue to have fun trying other NY style places and customizing to see if I can find more winners......but for sure Favorite will be my favorite pizza for now. read more

I thought lava only came out of volcanoes, but boy was I wrong. RIP to my weekend Good service, cool place. Not the pizza to order if you're with your significant other. read more

Looking forward to a pizza restaurant in the area since Frank & Angie left. Was disappointed. Toppings were minimum. Ordered pepperoni, mushrooms, and onions. Where's the pepperoni? Saving grace was the crust. No competition to Frank & Angies or Via 313. Hands down Detroit style beat NY style. Last note large pizza and medium salad was over $55. read more

Sneaky top 5 pizza in Austin to me. Hard pressed to find better ingredients and combos in Austin. Branched out and got the meatball sub and was rewarded for my boldness. Been there multiple times now and never lets me down. They sell by the slice but I've only ever done pick up fresh pies but see that they have a pretty good variety of slices. read more

Best NY/NJ style pizza in Austin. The sauce was great, crust on point, and the sausage had great flavor.

First time trying this place out and not super impressed. First the order was wrong and we didn't realize until we got all the way home. We ordered a pepperoni, basil and cherry pepper pizza and there was no basil and jalapeño instead of cherry peppers. A little over priced for mediocre pizza in my opinion. read more

I have a problem. The butternut squash pizza is so amazing, and has now ruined any future pizzas for me. I am in Austin for a girl's reunion weekend. Arrive Friday and we have ordered two of these already. Go get one, you won't regret it. Again, other than the fact that every pizza going forward will be subpar. We are here until Monday and will probably be ordering again. Thank you for changing my pizza life. read more

They close early on Thursday. Don't believe when it says 11pm close on Thursday nights. I got here at 1035 pm on Thursday night.

Best White Pizza - Seriously !! Such a delicious spot! Good vibes and good eats it's our go to spot now. How can you go anywhere else when this place definitely serves the best? Go Mets read more

Not gonna lie-- I was skeptical that anything could beat Home Slice. But after someone told me to try Favorite-- it's true. The Pepperoni was on point and the Field of Dreams (veggie) was incredible. Will be back again this weekend. read more

Favorite Pizza - Pepperoni and Field of Dreams - Pizza Near Me - Austin, Texas

Classic New York slice, great salad. Can't complain! It's a nice spot for when you want a good slice and you can tell the ingredients are good too. read more

Great pizza, great service. Solid options on drinks too. Beer, wine, and a couple of frozen cocktails. Would recommend

I love this pizza! But I don't love it when I try to call in an order and no one answers. The recorded message tells me to go online. Once online, the website says that "online ordering not available." So I call back and no one answers. So I drove 15 minutes to the store and inform the person taking my order (who informs the manager) that online ordering is not available and that they should be answering their phone. The manager says, "I guess our phones aren't working." The person takes my order and says, "it will be 25 minutes." No attempt to make it right and no apology, but it gave me time to write a review. I love this pizza, so three stars! And I'll even give them another shot. I hope they can get it together. Their customer experience needs an upgrade. By the way ... coolest pizza place rest room vibe ever! read more

Yummo ! The inside of Favorite Pizza is very vintage NY Pizza bar (at least, I think it is. Idk, I'm from the midwest). They nailed the old school look, somehow, even though you know it's all new decor! It's not very big, but they do have some indoor seating which could be fun to take advantage of. The large pizza is LARGE. Bolognese pizza, very good. Hey Butter, Butter (butternut squash, kale, parmesan cream) very, very good! and if you wanna feel "healthy", the caesar salad is special! The BEST part about this place is that they do a wide variety of sliiiices so you can try a few different kinds without committing to whole pies. What r u waiting for!? read more

I made the mistake of bringing this home to my husband and now it's an every Friday thing. The cheese is our favorite, simply amazing. I had no idea that plain cheese could taste this good!!! Put some extra garlic powder and muah, chefs kiss. The staff is so likeable and chill. Favorite pizza, literally. read more

Good classic pizza. Pizza by the slice super quick. Super cute restroom. Would recommend.

Great pizza! Good service. My wife and I ordered the small pizza and it was HUGE! I will definitely be back there next time I'm in Austin. The only reason I don't give this place 5 stars is because the entire time we were there there was a drunk guy just annoying other customers and the staff never asked him to leave. read more

This is the best pizza in Austin. Hands down. I have tried all the others, it helps that It is close to my house, but I would drive miles. If read more

Delicious! Closest to New York style I've had outside of the Northeast!

This little hidden gem on 6th and west (ok maybe not so hidden...) is some of the best pizza and definitely the best Caesar salad I've ever had. Whatever they top their salad with is amazing. I could eat it by the bag full. They also have a meatball pizza topping which is *chefs kiss* delicious. Their carry out is a different story. The Caesar salad that I'm obsessed with isn't cheap ($14 for a small, $18 for a large) and the only size available for takeout is large. After ordering this 3 times and specifically requesting that more salad be added to the container to be more aligned with the amount you receive when eating at the restaurant, I won't be ordering take out from here again. For almost $20 you get maybe half the size of a small salad unless you stay there to eat. As delicious as the salad is, I can't justify spending $20 on lettuce and dressing for 1. Favorite Pizza, lmk if y'all decide to get bigger to go boxes. Until then, this will still be my go to downtown for a slice and salad when I have time to stay and eat. read more

This place has the worst customer service ever. I love the pizza here but unfortunately the people that work there have no concept of customer service at all. I'm working downtown driving people around, I finally find a place to park for blocks from this place I get there. It is literally two minutes past 10 o'clock. There are pizzas still inside the guys like we're closed.... I'm like bro it's like two minutes, there's pizzas there, I'm even willing to take these guys like 10 bucks. I'm just starving. He's like yeah no sorry we're closed.. so this place that's been kind of a regular spot for me, I'm done like I am absolutely positively done unless management can explain to me why you're so Shystie when two minutes after close, and you still have pizzas there it wouldn't of been a big deal I have money to give you an money to tip read more

Ay this shit is fire. Just came for the first time and feel like I'm in a different city. 10 out of 5 stars I'm about to be fat af on favorite pizza. read more

Pizza was great! After leaving another nearby restaurant with not such good service, we came upon this gem! Service was great, pizza and salad were great and can't wait to make a return visit. Thank you! read more

Best Caesar salad anywhere. Pizza ingredients fresh and quality. Fast service. Totally unexpected great experience.

Delicious pizza, good drinks, easy-going vibes, I'll be back. NY style pizza by the slice or whole pie. Ordered the habeñero margarita , slice of pepperoni, and slice of margherita. read more

Favorite Pizza, perhaps the only restaurant in town whose literal name defines what this new special place will become to you, your favorite Pizzeria in all of Austin. Let me start by saying this place sits on a quaint little corner in the most charming part of Downtown Austin. I knew from the outside looking in I was in for something special, but so rarely in life do places turn out to be as good as you hoped...in this case, it was better. I will begin by reviewing the pizza since after all, this is a Pizza place. It is the most delicious blend of everything you'd ever want in a slice of heaven; cheesy, saucy, thin but soft, and oh so perfectly crispy and charred at the same time. It somehow embodies everything you'd ever want to taste and feel while devouring a pizza slice. So far I've tried the Mosquito Bite (no meat), Clarks Clam, and the Garden Pie. The Mosquito Bite was out of this world. I couldn't tell what to devote my thanks to, the fresh tomato sauce, the perfectly sweet and spicy honey, or the Fresno peppers perfectly baked into the cheese, it was simply perfection. I literally texted my family after my first slice, because I had to share how good this thing was. The Clam Pizza was everything you'd ever want in a Clam Pizza, down to the fresh surprise of a lemon wedge and whole clam garnish that took it to the next level for me. Lastly but definitely not least...the Garden Pie. When I say you have to get this pizza, I mean you HAVE to. I have never had a pizza like this before ever, from anywhere. I've never even seen this offered on a menu and yet it's so divinely simple. It's a white cheesy pie garnished with a crisp green salad tossed in a red wine vinaigrette. The combination of warm and savory with the fresh crunchy tang of the lettuce was truly incredible. Even if you are a red sauce meat loving kind of person, who calls salad Rabbit Food (like my dad) I swear this pizza will not just win you over, but convert you to a white pie addict. And yes, their Ranch is amazing and tasted exquisite with every pie and every bite. Now moving on to the restaurant itself. First of all the branding is worthy of this incredible pizza as it's extremely unique and memorable. It feels like a place that's always been here, in part thanks to the existing bones of the charming long time local Liquor store that used to call these walls home. But it goes beyond that. They truly nailed whatever vision they had for this place and it's so exciting to feel it thrive in the Austin scene. I can't say enough about this amazing little place. I hope they are here to stay and do very well because they truly deserve it. From the chefs, to the staff, to the owners, to the designers, to anyone and everyone that contributed to the formation of this new Pizza place. I absolutely love it, and I promise you will to. And for the final piece of my review I'd like to talk about their cocktails, but not just any cocktail...the FROZEN cocktails that they can for you to take home right then and there, with their tiny little can making machine, that yes...puts their delicious beverages into a branded frosty cold can ready to be popped open and enjoyed. I had the frozen Aperol Spritz and have every intention of trying their other frozen cocktail next time. How have we all lived so long here in Austin without "Favorite Pizza" ? Okay, I'm done now. Back to enjoying my leftovers because their portions are HUGE (side note). Enjoy my Austin friends, we have gained a special new place here in town! read more

Favorite Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Austin, Texas