I love this place so much! Reasonable and GOOD slices and we absolutely adore Laurel (or Laura) she is a server who Is so exceptional. Kind efficient and just goes above and beyond. What a great spot-we love a quick slice of pizza and the kids enjoy the tender/fries combo. So many options and one of the few places where you can go and eat fresh good food for under $5 a plate. read more

We used Fabio's for my son's high school lacrosse team dinners. Mike and his team were great to work with and the boys loved the food. Catering was easy and fed a hungry crowd of teen boys. read more

Phenomenal Cheese Steak. Ooey Gooey Deliciousness. Hot, fresh bread. Plenty of meat and cheese! read more

Fabio's NY Pizza - Cheesesteak plain. Ooey Gooey deliciousness! - Italian Near Me - Charlottesville, Virginia

Avid pizza lover from New England. This is my go to spot! The pizza is amazing! The staff is kind and polite. The restaurant itself is clean, and offers both indoor and outdoor dining. Get the pineapple jalapeño pizza here, you won't regret it! read more

Pizza was fantastic and their sauce is phenomenal! Wish there was more cheese on the pizza but overall it was very good! Restaurant was also clean and staff was friendly. read more

Great subs..and pizza is awesome Quick and great customer service. I do wish they had lasagna and manicotti tho read more

Stumbled upon this gem while trying to figure out what to order on Grubhub. Sooo happy we went with Fabio's! We ordered two large pies - the White Pie and the Veggie Lovers pie - both were really delicious and properly loaded with toppings. The white sauce was especially good and our favorite. But let me tell you about the garlic knots - they were truly an experience - SOLIDLY loaded with garlic and butter, soft on the inside and crispy in all the right places. Def recommend Fabio's for a crowd-pleasing dinner destination! read more

Fabio's NY Pizza - Vegetarian Pizza - Italian Near Me - Charlottesville, Virginia

See all

The Sicilian pizza is so good. The crust is so deep and fluffy. It's really filling for pizza. It comes in a square so the edge pieces are the best because they have extra crust. read more

Fabio's NY Pizza - Sicilian pizza - Italian Near Me - Charlottesville, Virginia

The two people that accompanied me here would agree that it's a pretty decent slice of pizza. We couldn't beat the lunch prices: 2 slices, a salad and a drink for only $10 I got the cheese with extra cheese and the Italian sausage with onions... they put an obnoxiously large amount of onions on this pizza too much for me..: I did enjoy the cheese pizza though, just add a little more sauce and it'd be great. The salad also had a large amount of toppings on top, I heard from some people around me that you could use your phone to choose your toppings; the kiosk doesn't have that option. I can't say you have the best NY pizza because I've never had NY Pizza but when I do, I'll be sure to come back and edit my comment read more

See all

Friendly service dining in. The option for one slice of pizza before UVA basketball game was perfect!

Update 8:11pm 10/31 Sal from Fabio's called me immediately after this review to make up for the mishap below, so changing my 1 star to 5 stars. They remade the order w his team delivering the pizza and it looks fabulous (just like previous times)... check the new pics w perfect undercarriage too... thanks Sal and the rest of the Fabio's team! Waited over an hour for a cold burnt pie. The undercarriage was almost raw too. Waited in parking lot 50min longer than the email said to pick up. I ordered online including 20% tip because they usually do a perfect well done pie. I called twice while I was waiting in the parking lot but they kept telling me 10min more. I understand it was busy on Halloween, but when it finally arrived, it wasn't even hot? It's like they cooked it w a lighter? I was hungry as heck too. I used to love Fabio's.. this one was very bad.. as I said, they burnt the top and the undercarriage was rare. It's like they microwaved it, let it sit 30min, then used some kind of flame to burn the top. it was barely warm and I live 0.5mi away (8 min drive), so it couldn't have cooled in that time. Again, I have picked up from here before, so I know it used to be good. If my family weren't so hungry, I would've driven back to complain, but I needed to hand out candy.. and I didn't want to be called a "Karen".... Please do better read more

See all

Although this was our first visit ever, we were greeted treated like family and friends here by the owner Mike. The entire service staff was wonderful. Pizza was excellent. Prices were reasonable. I would strongly recommend and I would absolutely return. read more

Best pizza in Virginia by far. Very good other food as well. Dave Portnoy needs to come here. Dave Portnoy Prediction: 7.5

I've been coming here for over five years... I love the NY style pizza. The owner is very personable and friendly and will take time out of his busy day to make you feel like you're an individual customer with individual interests and concerns Service is prompt Ambience is casual and it is always very clean from back kitchen front counter dining room to bathrooms read more

When I saw the price I thought okay I in Charlottesville. This does not disappoint by any stretch. Ordering is awkward. There's a shed in the parking lot with no menu. Indoors there's a tv to touch and order. The wait staff was helpful though. The garlic knots were a bit overcooked but delicious nonetheless. read more

Fabio's NY Pizza - Antipasto Salad $10.99 - Italian Near Me - Charlottesville, Virginia

I love this place! Their pizza is sooo delicious. I can really taste the quality cheese and tomato sauce. Love doing takeout from here.

Pizza was cold upon arrival, took about 1-1/2 hrs to get here (approx. 8.5 miles), asked for no contact delivery, but no knock or doorbell was used to let us know it was here. Pizza was supposed to be a Margherita, with crushed tomatoes, fresh mozzarella and fresh basil. It was pitiful...pretty much tasted like a plain pizza with sauce. Won't order from Fabio's NY Pizza ever again. read more

Fabio's NY Pizza - Supposed to be Margherita pizza...sad. - Italian Near Me - Charlottesville, Virginia

Not only did they somehow mess up our extremely simple order, these french fries are cold and possibly outdated. The total lack of quality is apparent. I do not recommend. read more

Fabio's NY Pizza - Gross fries - Italian Near Me - Charlottesville, Virginia

Fantastic food, wonderful service and a nice little restaurant to boot. I had the seafood linguine... it was great. The appetizer was calamari, done just right! Thank you Fabio's! We'll be back! read more

Getting quality New York style pizza in the South can be tricky. As an avid lover of the pizza styles of the Northeast, I've had more slices with doughy crust and insipid cheese than I care to admit. When a friend recommended Fabio's for quality NY style pies, I had to check it out. I ordered a 14" pizza with two toppings, which ran me $20 and thus a little pricey. Still, the pie was worth it. I specified the crust to be well done and Fabio's delivered. The crust's crackly exterior gave way to a chewy and moist crumb. The crust possessed enough sturdiness to support the ample cheese and toppings. The cheese blend itself had good browning and flavor, but was perhaps applied a touch too generously. The sauce tasted serviceable; I wish it had more tang but the flavor did not detract from the experience. While Fabio's is a bit pricey, it serves the most reasonable facsimile to true New York pizza I've had in Charlottesville. It's subsequently worth a try if you're a displaced Northeasterner like me or simply want to try a good example of this kind of pie. read more

First time trying Fabio's, as a self-proclaimed pizza super fan from Chicago now living on the east coast. I have to say that based on the reviews that I was excited to try Fabio's. I was not at all impressed with the taste (very mild tomato sauce) light on the pepperoni and average crust. BTW...you're looking at 75 cents for the onions on the slice. Just not going to be my go-to place. read more

Fabio's NY Pizza - Sicilian slice and NYC slice to go. - Italian Near Me - Charlottesville, Virginia

Started eating here in 2020 when I moved to Charlottesville and my new office was a few blocks away. Their food is always excellent, prices are solid, and the quality is unmatched. It's so refreshing to eat at a place and know that you're always going to get the same great food and service. This is always my first recommendation for people in Charlottesville looking for a slice of pizza. read more

It can be hard to find great or even good pizza in Charlottesville. Fabio's is one of the better choices. The food is reliably good and, despite the same significant price increases seen everywhere else, prices remain reasonable. There are lots of typical Italian choices. Since we last visited--before COVID--the logistics of choosing and ordering have changed. Ordering is now fully automated using touch screens. When it works, it is relatively easy, although, because there are so many choices, it can be a challenge figuring out where to find your item. Staff hangs out to help with ordering if needed. Once the order is placed, if you eat inside, staff brings the food to your table. The only annoying thing about the new format is all drinks come in bottles and there is no way to get ice, if like me, nothing is ever cold enough. All in all, a solid choice for a quick, good, satisfying meal. read more

Decent Philly cheese steak and I liked the garlic knots. There's an interesting self-kiosk where you can order yourself read more

Fabio's NY Pizza - Garlic Knots - Italian Near Me - Charlottesville, Virginia

Very average actually. Pizza was too dry and wings completely burnt. Don't think will order again

Favorite family pizza pickup place. Love that you can call ahead and drive-up for them to deliver to your car. 10% military discount! read more

Pizza was fine but pasta dishes were meh. Garlic bread did not taste of garlic and was a bit burnt. Service was good. Have to order using a tablet. Stick with the pizza here. read more

We ordered delivery and it was perfect! The pizzas were ready on time and super fresh. We needed a few gluten free pizzas and the group raves about them! When I called to ensure they got our order the staff were super helpful and easy to work with! read more

See all

Great food. The Sicilian pizza is amazing. Very comfortable atmosphere. Very reasonably priced..

This is a casual pizza and sub place that offers indoor as well as outdoor seating. They have a small parking lot. I didn't have much time to grab a sandwich so I stopped in because the premium national chains that I usually go to were not in proximity. I found the sub to be roughly equivalent to what I would have received at a premium national chain however it was priced approximately 30% higher at Fabio's. There was nothing special about the taste or size or amount of meat to justify this higher price. Thus, I did not find Fabio's to be a good value. I've not tried any but you may find a better experience with other menu items. read more

This review is for the pizza only since I had it delivered by GrubHub. I had a medium Meat Lovers pizza and it was really good. The crust was not too thin and the outer edge was brushed with something, probably garlic butter, to keep it from being too dry. I really liked the sauce and the ingredients seemed fresh. Everything was cooked just right and still hot when delivered. The following day I had a cold slice -- for me a test of true flavor -- and it was just as delicious. read more

Very average pizza. Crust and sauce has no flavor. The sauce was undercooked and tasted of raw tomatoes. Too much cheese.

I prefer local restaurants, and try to give good reviews. However, when it comes to pizza I've had the best of New Haven, New York, Detroit, and Chicago. Charlottesville is not a pizza town! The best rated is a chain! Yesterday I tried Fabio's Sicilian. I was disappointed! My one bite score would be 4.5! It was doughy, undercooked, the sauce and cheese were lacking. I wish it had been better! read more