UNACCEPTIBLE. My wife DROVE 16min from her office at 2pm to place an order for a Fri.5:30pm pickup. This was for 22 people for her non-profit's celebration of the h.s.seniors who had reliably contributed for several years. We arrived at 5:30pm for pickup as scheduled, all 15 student contributors were there 5:20 set to carpool to our HOSTED destination. No one at Extreme Pizza was even aware of our prior order though was an in-person order made, 3 /1/2 hrs previous. Having not phoned but rather instead HAVING DRIVEN IN PERSON so as to make sure of the planned priority, no one there was aware. Worse no one was responsible. The onsite employees were polite but more or less unconcerned, they finished the pies, and offered a 'discount' which we could have cared less about. WorsER....THEY WERE NOT EVEN BUSY!!! I observed this. We all sat and waited more than 30 minutes- for 5 large Various pies to be constructed then baked. More than $200 for which I will forever choose elsewhere. Shameful management. No reliability and any potential quality in the eventual product tainted for sure after that. Heads Up- Service is success ,not here. never again read more

Updating because their management reached out to me to apologize and I appreciated their follow up. It seems like they are under transition of new management and/or ownership and may still be working out some kinks. I would be willing to give them a shot again in a few months once they have hit a groove to see if things have improved. read more

Good prices and a convenient location for spontaneous pizza. We have always been greeted with kindness and pizza is made to order so always comes out hot. I dont feel like a lot of their signature pies call to me, but making your own is easy. One thing to note is their beer selection, they have a lot to offer, more than I expected of such a place. Pizza and beer, good. We like sitting outside in "the yard" area of the fifth street station food court sort of area. Allows the kids to wander a bit after theyve finished but we're still eating and finishing our brews. read more

Extreme Pizza - Half Wham, Bam, Thank You Mammoth Pizza, half Poultrygeist Pizza, carryout - Salad Near Me - Charlottesville, Virginia

Stopped for a slice at lunch time. The pizza was very good, cheesy and delicious. The restaurant was very clean and the staff were very friendly. read more

Tried to order gift certificate online. Ran into issue. Website said to call store. I did. Guy said he'd call back in an hour. He never did. Service when there's a problem? Unimpressive. But, that's fine. I can leave the review on lots of sites. Besides... Christian's has better service AND pizza. read more

A great place if you like flat beer. Service was good. Wings were terrible. It looked like someone put hot sauce on some sad looking chicken nuggets. read more

Location is good! Indoors seating but also many tables outside to eat outdoors. Service is okay. Tried 14" Hanoi Fever in my visit here, and it was good; nothing amazing or terrible. Pizza is on the thinner side compared to your typical pizza hut or domino's-styled pizza. It's easy for the crust to be burnt or dry/hard when the pizza is thin, but this was not the case. Hanoi Fever in particular wasn't necessarily flavorful which was something I was looking for: bland. I ended up throwing on a lot of tobasco, cheese, and pepper flakes to add in more flavor and spice; attached image was taken prior to the addition of condiments. Jalepeños in the image are not spicy. I also tried a slice of Kickin' Chicken during my visit here, and it was also quite bland. Again, the pizza here isn't bad, but for those coming in with expectations, not all may be met. read more

Extreme Pizza - 14 " Hanoi Fever - Salad Near Me - Charlottesville, Virginia

See all

Service was great. Staff were friendly and pleasant . We order 2 pizzas and a capresse salad. Pizza was ok. Glad we only ordered small pizzas because we didn't end up finishing them.The salad look great but was incredibly bland. The restaurant has plenty of space and potential maybe if they put in a little more effort it would be better read more

I visited for the first time and did take out. Service- friendly Baked spaghetti- this was some of the worst baked spaghetti I've ever had. The sauce literally tasted sour. It was absolutely inedible. I had to throw it away because I was worried it would make my family sick It comes with garlic bread which was good and a side salad that wasn't very impressive. Calzone- super thick, overcooked dough with skimpy toppings inside I don't think I'd visit here again because the quality of food for the price just wasn't what it should've been. read more

We love to get take out here. The Wham Bam pizza is awesome! The flavors really combine for a unique taste read more

This pizza will do if you are really hungry and in a hurry. We stopped in for a few slices because we were in a hurry to get somewhere. The pizza was honestly not very good. Kind of bland, the bottom portion of the pizza is VERY thin and the crust was not the best, IMO. The crust reminded my of a piece of toast. Some people may love it, but it wasn't for me. read more

Food is okay. Not bad, but nothing to write home about. The owner is nice and seating is plenty, but overall just shmeh.

One of my favorite pizza places in Charlottesville, worth 30 bucks. It may not look like a lot of pizza from the size of the box, but when you see how judge these slices are, it's worth every penny. I also love that they use fresh ingredients and makes the pizza taste so amazing. I get the yard sale every time because it's just so good I'm scared to venture off! read more

GREAT pizza! The Everest was amazing! The wings are good too but not as yummy as the pizza. I'll definitely stop by here again. read more

Extreme Pizza - Everest - Salad Near Me - Charlottesville, Virginia

Nice little pizza parlor, there are a ton of different options of pizzas, they got beer!!! The staff were pleasant, no attitude considering the area, meaning everything on top of the hill up there seems to be a bit pricey. The restaurant was clean, went there on a Monday for lunch, it had very few people inside read more

Extreme Pizza - Eatery - Salad Near Me - Charlottesville, Virginia

The staff here is so nice. I ordered several pizzas for a party and they were ready to go in record time. I really like their wide variety of toppings and their delivery was fast as well. As far as I gathered from the owner, it's a privately owned business and he was really approachable. If your kid likes cookies they have some of those too, pretty EXTREME as well. With their more eccentric choices for toppings, this place is definitely underrated. Also someone keeps flagging my reviews because I ripped into them so let me go a bit further. Yo, people are crazy. Listen if a pizza place gets a negative review it's because the place sucks or the people reviewing are idiots. Since it's virtually impossible for a pizza place to suck it's always going to be the latter. All I see are a bunch of whiners. Uhhh my gluten free pizza wasn't the best. Uhhh pay a living wage to your workers before you charge more for toppings. Uhhh I got sausage not pepperoni (guaranteed mistake they made while app ordering). You realize it's practically the SAME MEAT? Uhhh they gave me free food because of a mistake before bringing out my real order. Uhh uhhu uhhhhhh. Get a life. Bunch of entitled clowns. Only hearing their sorry side of the story is enough to make me EXTREME puke. This place has great prices, service, and some of the more unique pizzas I've seen. Again it's impossible to negative review a pizza place. Unless they piss on it it's going to be good. It's pizza for Christ's sake not caviar-covered filet mignon from grass fed cows in Japan with artisan vegan banana fosters for the dessert. IT'S PIZZA YUPPIES. And who in the hell would expect a bread-heavy dish without gluten would ever taste good? You're lucky they give enough of a crap about your New Age disease to even offer it. Begone. Get legit and eat your pizza in EXTREME fashion. read more

I was very impressed with this pizza. The price isn't bad and the pizza is phenomenal. Dare I say the best pizza I have had in Charlottesville (yes, I have had Christian's) I got the Pandora's box with sauce, my husband got something different and loved his as well. The reheated leftovers were also just as good. 10/10 highly recommend. read more

Cashier is so very friendly and a accommodating. For her alone you should go. The pizza is tasty well topped and hot at the table. I love that they use real plates and flatware. I'm so tired of plastic! read more

Terrible customer service! I ordered delivery of the Pandora's Box pizza, which is not supposed to have any sauce at all. I know this because I've had it before and the menu also says it does not have sauce. It came slathered with a very strong tasting tomato sauce. I called the store and the employee treated me like I was stupid, told me *I* ordered the wrong food, refused to fix it, and told me to re-order through Grub Hub if I wanted the correct food. read more

Extreme Pizza - Pandoras Box pizza made incorrectly (should not have sauce) - Salad Near Me - Charlottesville, Virginia

Jacob is an awesome employee! It was a pleasure talking with him. He's also a great spokesperson. He recommended a pizza I would have never tried. I loved it "Mr. Pestado Head"- pizza with sliced potatoes! It was VERY tasty. Glad I tried it!!! Now I'm looking forward to returning to try other pizzas I normally wouldn't order! read more

This isn't your conventional pizza place. Don't except to get a classic margherita pizza here! All of the gourmet signature pizzas sounded amazing and different from anything else I've ever had on pizza before. We went with "The Spice Route" which has Tandoori chicken on it. This was incredible! I would definitely recommend -- it has an unreal Indian flavor that pairs well with the crust. You can split the type of pizza you want so you can get a good variety. It's also not that expensive so it's good for big groups. I love that you can get whole wheat crust so I can feel better about ordering pizza without it tasting any different. On the downside, this means I can justify ordering from here more often! I did takeout but inside it's clean and spacious. I will definitely be back! read more

I've only been once so far but I definitely would go back. My husband is a very picky eater, and only likes 2 pizza places here in Charlottesville and he said he would definitely go back. We ate out in the courtyard which I enjoy cuz the kids ran around. We basically got the supreme pizza. The cashier was very helpful. I will say if you're a wing person don't order here. read more

Extreme Pizza - Salad Near Me - Charlottesville, Virginia

Never been to a extreme pizza restaurant before, so I had to check it out. The variety of pizza is immense, so it's hard to decide. So many toppings you have to decide are you willing try toppings you never expect to be toppings lol. They also serve a variety sandwiches and chicken wings. I started with bread sticks until I could make up mind on the pizza I would try. If your in Charlottesville give them a try! Great customer service! read more

See all

Terrible customer service. Rude cashier. Pizza was good but they won't get our business again.

Stopped to get a quick pizza while in C-ville. Staff can be a little more attentive. I waited in line for 10 mins and 2 other guys who can work the register passed by after watching football in the dining area, before coming out to help since the main guy was on the phone taking orders. Pizza dough tasted like an english muffin, which is good because English muffins are good. Lots of cheese which is another plus. Didn't take long to have pizza ready after ordering read more

This place was clean and the staff was friendly and helpful, great location too. Our food was made correctly and they had a big selection including tons of veggie options. I'm sure everyone could find something they could eat here! I'd probably give 3.5 stars if I could. However, compared to other pizza in Charlottesville everyone in my party was really underwhelmed. Was it edible? Totally. If you're in the shopping center and craving pizza I could see going here. But, (personal preference), most of my family felt there was too much cheese and the tomato sauce didn't have a lot of flavor. I also prefer a thinner, more flavorful crust-- this reminded me of frozen pizza crust. In the future I'd drive the extra distance to Uncle Maddio's if I wanted to design my own creative pizza. I personally won't be back. read more

Very beautiful atmosphere, friendly staff, and delicious pizza. The pizza was very flavorful and the selection of toppings was plentiful!! The owner made sure we enjoyed our visit. I would give this restaurant 10 stars if I could! Definitely will become a regular customer! read more

See all

Service: I ordered takeout, the place was empty. The cashier was great. The other two individuals didn't even acknowledge me with a nod. But again the person I had interaction with was pleasant so 4 out of 5 Taste: Average at best. I ordered the Mont Blanc and despite the the flavorful ingredients they didn't seem to be flavorful on the pizza itself. The crust was not good and the pizza was undercooked (doughy). 2 out of 5 read more

I received an email for 15% off an online order. When I tried to order and enter the coupon code (expires 11/30/2020), it did not work. I called the restaurant itself for help; the young lady answering the phone said that she didn't know what to do about this problem. I asked her to please ask someone who would know how to handle this. She came back and told me that the owner was not there tonight and he is the only person who knows anything about email discounts and to call back tomorrow. I then asked to speak to the supervisor who then told me the same thing. I asked him if he was willing to lose my business rather than honor the false advertising in my email. His reply was that he was swamped and that the owner lost my business, not him and he hung up. I have ordered several pizzas from Xtreme and it has been a hassle every time. There are never more than two people working in the restaurant, the wait time is always much longer than promised, and the pizza is never worth the effort. I am very disappointed, as that this is the closest pizza place to my house. I will continue to drive to Fabios from now on, which is always fabulous! read more

Great restaurant! We went with a large group and ordered pizza ahead of time. The service was great (as was the pizza). Salads are HUGE, so you can definitely split one with another person. The prices were reasonable as well. read more

Ordered online expecting to get a decent pie. They barely put sauce on so the pie is dry and they overcook the cheese so it's crunchy. It ended up being dog food. Side Salad was good but that's not what i came here for. read more

Extremely meh. It was like getting pizza at the mall.... Or maybe like getting a DiGiorno's. My husband said the sauce tasted like canned Ragu. Save yourself the terrible and find something different to fill your stomach read more

Very pleased with my pizza and cheesecake, staff is friendly, talented and quick. Top 5 favorite pizza on my list .

Friendly staff! Great beer selection! Food was pretty good. Definitely worth checking out. I had sat at the picnic tables to enjoy the fresh air. I was able to take my drink there too! So cool! read more

I was hoping for a great new option for gluten free pizza, I will have to keep looking. To start, we got a half and half 12 inch because we like different toppings. They insisted we pay full price for each half topping (at $1.30 each). When I said I wasn't paying double for toppings, the manager chewed me out going on a tirade about how their toppings are all fresh and they pay their staff $14 per hour. I said they should pay a living wage, but I'm still not paying double for toppings. He finally agreed to give me a break because it was my first time there. The gluten free crust was limp and undercooked, somewhat reminiscent of wet cardboard. The tomato sauce was watery. I'll not ever go there again, there are other places that can do gluten free crust well. Oh, then the manager had the gall to come to our table and tell us to give them "a whole lot of stars!" read more

This place is a train wreck! There is more staff than customers and they still can't get an order right. Ordered wings and they brought out boneless because they made too many. Gave us the boneless for free and 10 minutes later bright out the right wings. Staff can't seem to find which of the 4 occupied tables food goes to despite giving us number tents to correlate the orders. He "bartender" is leaning over the bar shoveling a salad in his mouth 2 feet from customers. There are better pizza options in Charlottesville. read more

Clear signage and easy egress and ingress. Outdoor seating also. Fountain drinks and bottles. Beer on tap and bottles too. Menu has a lot of offerings pizza salad and subs. Owned by our friendly convenience store guy. Can't wait to see our pizza. The xlg is 16 inches. Had the Pandoras box with interesting ingredients. Service was good. Very quiet for noon. Tomato sauce was raw tasting bitter. Crust was premade. Plenty of ingredients but not a cohesive dish. Needs more feta less leaves more artichoke.. read more

Extremely nasty pizza. I've tried pizza from here three times and each time I've been disappointed. I don't know how to describe it but I don't like the taste, maybe the type of cheese they use. Brands/pizza places I'd rather eat pizza from than this place: Almost any frozen pizza Little Caesar's (and I don't like their pizza) Friendly enough staff but it doesn't make up for the bad pizza. Speaking of staff, I've driven behind the restaurant and seen employees outside smoking....with someone (who was smoking) sitting on something that's keeping the door open. I've given them a second star because I've tried one of their sandwiches twice. It had decent flavor but not enough to keep me coming back. Wide variety of pizzas hopefully some of the others actually taste good. read more

Really great pizza! I got the "wham bam thank you mammoth", and it was so good. They have a huge variety of specialty pizzas to choose from. The restaurant also has a really nice atmosphere. The customer service was great, and the workers were very friendly. They also do delivery! I'll definitely be back! read more

The pizza was delicious, fresh and generous amount of toppings. Would definitely return and recommend this place! We ate there vs delivery so can only comment on that. read more