The pizzas, salads and all was amazing. We had no wait, quick to deliver our dinner in a friendly environment! We enjoyed watching surfer videos and chatting with our server! Look forward to coming again! read more

A little overpriced. Penne Rosa was good but a little watered down. Kids loved their food ~portions were a bit small for price. Overall not bad for pizza and pasta. Restaurant was clean and comfortable and everyone left read more

We hadn't eaten here since before covid. Always loved their food but was a little disappointed this visit. We started with the Margherita pizza was very good (just be aware it is very very thin and works good as an appetizer but probably not for a meal we'd had it before so knew what to expect) the house salad was good with just the right amount of sweet dressing on it. We enjoyed the Fettuccine Alfredo was flavorful and a nice sized portion. The chicken parm was a disappointment. The chicken was breaded & cooked well but portion was very small. Was served on cold spaghetti with marinara sauce, which was a disappointment. read more

Fabiani's - people sitting at tables in a restaurant - Italian Near Me - Kihei, Hawaii

Good pizza and caught the great half-price happy hour deal from 2-5pm at the bar. Bartender was great too, made everyone feel welcome. Couple of local Maui Brewery beers on tap ($1 off for happy hour.) read more

Some basic Italian food. Lasagna, spaghetti, and chicken parmigiana. Bolognese sauce, Marinara and delicious creamy Alfredo. Meatballs in a rustic red sauce were my personal favorite. read more

Fresh simple ingredients yet delicious! My son has an egg allergy and we were happy to find out their pizza dough is real and eggless. We ordered the Hawaiian and Margarita. My 6 yr old ate 4 pieces after a long day in the ocean and swimming. So if you're hungry order at least 1 pizza for two people. Crust was thin, crispy but not too crispy. Not greasy at all and just delicious. Will definitely be back when we are in Maui again Mahalo read more

Italian restaurants are few and far between on Maui but it's nice to have an option for some good Italian even if you have to drive to Kihei. I ordered the Spaghetti Bolognese dish and ordered 2 meatballs to go with it with the meatballs costing a little extra each. The sauce was good and had a lot of meat mixed in, which is good because I am kinda a carnivore. The meatballs were decent size and had a good flavor. I wanted to try a dessert that they had in their case in the front but I was full and decided to try a dessert next visit. Overall, I enjoyed my experience here made the staff were friendly. I will come back to try their other dishes as well. read more

Fabiani's - Spaghetti Bolognese with 2 meatballs - Italian Near Me - Kihei, Hawaii

We live around the corner so this is our "go to" for pizza. They have great food and incredible cannolis!! It can get loud inside when it's busy, but we usually sit outside so no complaints. I highly recommend!! read more

Sorry but we need to give a low rating for being ridiculous.....they promote a "Happy Hour" between 3 and 5 PM...but this is only good if you are actually sitting down at the bar...now the bar is NOT a separate room or place but right smack dab in the middle with tables inches away but if the bar stools are all full then no Happy Hour.....maybe they should rename "sad hour" or perhaps "totally lame hour". This is so lame, the staff were not the least concerned to see 3 of us walk out and not spend a single dime, I suspect this is so common that they are immune to how bizarre this is...if it was a huge bar with tables as well as a counter but the bar stools are quite limited. We own two condos a block away that we rent out to tourists and we have a loose leaf binder where we put restaurant and other info for our guests and Fabiani's was in our books with nice comments by us.....forget it, we were going to just remove the page but then decided to instead write "Try someplace else, not worth our business" read more

The place only does happy hour at the bar but doesn't have enough seats to accommodate everyone. The food expediter told me there have been arguments over bar seats. Why not just expand happy hour to the whole dining area there weren't that many tables. There were only two people working and it seemed like they were a bit stressed. The man could barely keep up with the phone calls and the stream if food coming out. Was told to come here because they had the best pizza on the island. I find that hard to believe. The food was okay pizza had a crispy crust but was kinda floppy still. We got the maui meaty. The pizza was half price during happy hour so was only 9 instead of 18. Which was nice. We paired it with a tall Peroni. Weird that the bathroom are outside and you have to leave the place to use them. read more

See all

This restaurant is a solid place to take your guests as the food and dinner service are generally very good. Recently, we've had breakfast here twice and each time we were satisfied but the meals were not memorable. I loved their version of Eggs Benedict but the dish lacked salt or something as it didn't really taste as amazing as it should have, based on appearances. The coffee was very good. I truly think it's awesome - and this is the reason for the four stars - that this restaurant has an outside play area for patrons to use for their children who are either bored or (no surprise) can't sit still for very long in a restaurant. I think it is very thoughtful and it speaks to how the restaurant owners understand their clientele. I often see families here and this restaurant embraces that market wholeheartedly. We will likely return again. read more

See all

For the last however many years i have patroned this establishment i have always been able to add Ricotta cheese to my dinner options, now magically an "Italian Restaurant" does not have ricotta cheese. As someone of Italian heritage i find this ridiculous and unheard of. I didnt complain when the portions became smaller and the prices went up, however, i will no longer support a so called Italian Restaurant that does not have staple Italian cheeses, next they will claim they do not have Mozzarella. Alohas read more

Had a wonderful lunch with friends here. We got there and the rest of the party was there so they waved us and we sat down. Service was excellent. She was friendly and attentive. Food was delicious but a little pricey. But it was nice for our first time experience. I enjoyed my lasagna it had a good taste to it. Macaroons were a little pricey 2.50 each or 12.50 for 6 or 25.00 for a dozen. So we just got a couple. read more

See all

We came by twice during our trip - once for desserts and once for the entrees. I must say the desserts made a significantly greater impression on us - all desserts including the cheesecake and red velvet cake had this signature feature of being rich in flavor but not weight. In other words, you could eat and not feel too sloth-like. The price points on the desserts is a bit on the higher side but we'll worth the quality. For entrees, we got the stuffed scallops and the pizza. My friend is a big pizza lover as am I, and this pizza was pretty good. The ingredients are fresh and the crust is just the right size. The stuffed scallops were decent - felt a little heavy and less of a seafood taste than I would have preferred. But overall, a nice place to come by and eat. Most notably is service was excellent! Very diligent in checking in on us and making sure we were doing ok. PROS: - excellent dessert options that does not leave you feeling heavy but taste great - friendly and timely service - pizza was made with fresh ingredients and the crust was just the right size - great internal ambiance - both indoor and outdoor seating options available CONS: - stuffed scallops were a bit heavy; could have more of that seafood taste read more

See all

The true test of a good Italian place is their Margherita pizza. I was famished, didn't have a car, and selected Fabiani's because I could get dinner delivered. It was a hail Mary pass, and wow was I impressed. The Margherita (ordered with very light cheese) was as perfect as could be. Flavorful, light, delicious. I've eaten a lot of pizza in my life, including in Italia, and Fabiani's pizza is REALLY good. The Ahi Bruschetta and Caesar salad were wonderful accompaniments -- the Chopped Tomato, Garlic, Onion, Caper & Basil toppings for the bruschetta were perfect. The only thing the caesar was lacking was anchovies, but I know a lot of people aren't down with the little fishies :) Looking forward to returning. read more

Fabiani's - Ahi Bruschetta, Caesar salad, Margherita pizza to go. - Italian Near Me - Kihei, Hawaii

We really enjoy this place. I actually prefer the Wailea location but it has been closed during Covid. I love that they offer so many gluten free options (both pasta and pizza). The food is great and I would strongly recommend take-out pizza from here rather than other restaurants in Kihei/Wailea. read more

Fabiani's - Some of these specials looked great! - Italian Near Me - Kihei, Hawaii

Fabiani's makes great food! The servers were attentive, the atmosphere was cheerful, the food was memorable. It is a place we can afford to go to just once a month or so, though. read more

I almost never ever write a review but I can't go without making a comment about my experience today with the staff- food was good so two stars but wait staff not great at all. If you are visiting Maui and you don't care about service and how they treat you then my experience won't bother you but for those that do care- please read on. The service wasn't that great so I guess you get what you pay for. We ordered appetizers and entrees and prepaid for everything at the counter and gave a 20% tip. Little did we know what cr@ppy service we would get from the staff. They never came to check on us after serving the food or came to ask us if we needed anything like a refill or anything else. Even though we said excuse me and waved help for the wait staff they didn't respond AND the restaurant wasn't even full since we came in early. After 12 minutes when we finally got fed up we went to the counter and asked the wait staff repeatedly for to go boxes they said we are busy I'll come by later with them, we came back up again and finally someone gave us to go containers. We were a decently sized table of 6 people so you would think they would at minimum check on us once or twice. Other tables had 2 or 3 patrons at the table and they treated the local patrons with attention and ignored us even though we made eye contact and they kept walking away. It's so frustrating when you're out with your family having a meal and the service sucks and you tip 20% in advance. I have no idea how they got such great Yelp reviews and such a good Star rating but again the food was fine but we could have been treated better. read more

Nice man at the front of the house greeted us. Bus staff did not check on us or clear any dishes or fill water. Food was very bland, totally overcooked pasta, salad was brown with slimy cucumbers, garlic bread was the best part of the meal. Quantity but not quality. read more

Absolutely incredible! Their new vegan collaboration with Mamma Mia is a dream come true. We came for half off pizzas at happy hour. My hunni got the calzone and I got the vegan Beetza! Beetza comes with Walnut and Mushroom Tomato Sauce, Roasted Beets, Tofu Ricotta, Kale, Vegan Mozzarella on our Gluten Free Vegan Cauliflower Crust. Staff are kind and helpful. Outdoor dining area with classic Italian music. Highly recommend for vegans! They also have a vegan Bolognese and vegan risotto. Sometimes they have vegan pastries too! The house salad had a light and fresh House Lilikoi and Vanilla Bean Vinaigrette that delighted my taste buds!!! Large portions, took half my pizza to go. Great for families! read more

Fabiani's - Vegan Beetza - Italian Near Me - Kihei, Hawaii

See all

Best vegan pizza in town!! All the food is delicious! Wonderful spot. Thank you. Michelle and Jeremy read more

Wow, this place could be fantastic if it actually had an Italian chef, who knew how to prepare pastas and pizzas and sauces in an Italian manner. The area could certainly use a high-quality Italian restaurant. It's kind of strange to have to wait in line to order at a cash register counter and then tack on a service charge to have somebody just bring it to your table, but we did and gave them 20%. Nice server, if only for a minute. Also, what's kind of strange is the big screen TV replaying over and over again the same surfing images. In a nutshell, this is a fair to average restaurant in a largely tourist area that has relatively high prices for low/medium quality. Nothing stands out, on the other hand. It's very popular with the locals. apparently, the bakery is a popular destination. The Caprese salad was maybe the best appetizer on the menu. read more

Food is excellent. I had the pasta fettuccine. Beat red velvet cake i have ever had. Patio seating, its just a great place. read more

Had to try it. Decent pizza for Maui prices. The Mauian (Kahlua pork) was good and both the Meaty and Hawaiian (had to get it for grandma) was ok. Thin crust was nice. read more

Ordered a pepperoni pizza which was DELICIOUS!! I'm late in writing this review, so I forgot what else we got, but looking forward to returning. read more

SUPER service and nice drinkies...pizza crust was crispy rather than chewy (my preference) BUT it was good and the outside seating area is sooo cool/private...definitely going to return and try the meatball sub, pastas and other goodies... nice change from the Nalu hubbub!! read more

Potatoes were just bland and omlette u can get better elsewhere and services was just lacking read more

Fabiani's - Meaty omlette - Italian Near Me - Kihei, Hawaii

Very nice place and staff. The ravioli is the best dish we tried. Highly recommend. The spaghetti and meatballs were good. The cheesecake was decent. The cannolis were just average. But peroni on tap is great. Great staff. They were attentive even though they were quite busy. I'd like to try more dishes. read more

Kind of off the beaten path. Went for dinner. Ordering at the counter was easy, the guy was super nice. We sat outside. Water was brought right away, as was our drinks. Food came shortly after. Everything was delicious! We had the lasagna and spaghetti bolognese and a salad. I would definitely come back next time I'm in town!! read more

The ambiance is lovely, quiet intimate room, but the food was disappointing! We were a table of four and we were all disappointed with our meals! read more

Loved it here! Authentic Italian in Maui! Had 3 meals in 1.5 weeks. We had several dishes and a few desserts. Everything was yummy. Just like in Italy. read more

We had a fabulous meal at Fabiani's in Kihei. I had a Caesar salad that was delicious beyond description. It was followed by fettuccine alle vongole...clams galore with the broth with garlic, red pepper and the clam juice!! Service was excellent. Our server, Lynn, was very attentive and her support staff took care of us well. Other fabulous dishes ordered were the pizza of the day with mushrooms, potatoes on a garlic crust, the stuffed scallops...fabuloso! Highly recommended from five girls from Hilo. read more

This is our 2nd time eating here first time was good pizza Happy hour is a good deal plus taste good . they have Happy hour pizza and drinks the first time a few months back in dinning room but now they changed to only bar seating happy hour and pizza discount kinda sad when the bar is full and no where to sit ... We had the blackened mahi mahi which was good kinda small tho , and chicken parm ... chicken over done chewy spaghetti noodle good but sauce no flavor ... will go again but only order pizza if i can get a seat at the bar :( read more

Great hidden eatery in Kihei! Had delicious pasta and pizzas. Casual but comfortable. Nice service...we came back for happy hours ( bar only) pizzas are 1/2 off. Good selection of liquor, wines... oh and they have a bakery with the most delicious desserts! read more

Amazing food- great service! We loved the patio dining- beautiful night and it was a relaxing dinner!

Excellent Italian food in ... Hawaii! Was not expecting it to be so good, but it surpassed our expectations. So much so that we went back a few more times while on the island. Just about everything is good, but the Rosa pasta was hands down our favorite. read more

I ordered Togo a slice of red velvet cake, two orders of garlics Bread and stuffed scallops I wish I could give this more than 3 stars but food it was just okay for my husband and I and the couture forget red velvet cake I have to come back read more

See all

Absolutely no change in rating as they serve up some tasty pasta dishes! Since we visited last, they've expanded this location's menu to mirror what they serve at their Wailea location. FOOD: Caesar Salad - $9.00 (full portion) Maui's tastiest Caesar salad was still amazing a year later. The creamy dressing coated each leaf of romaine well. Stuffed Scallops - $12.00 Cheese and seafood together? That's motherland blasphemy! But, we're not in Italy and honestly, it works. Five scallops were served on the half shell and topped with a creamy mixture of goat cheese, spinach and bread crumbs. The scallops were on the smallish side and didn't have that delicious sear that I like. I think a better preparation would be to pan sear the scallops THEN finish with a broiling of the mixture on top. If you're a fan of stuffed scallops, I suggest you check out the new Bentos and Banquets food truck which serves an out of this world version. Carbonara - $16.00 The dish was more soupy than expected but tasted spot-on with creamy and savory flavors enhanced by the diced pancetta, fresh green peas and parmesan. The bucatini pasta was cooked perfectly al dente. Affordable and a nice sized portion! SERVICE: Our female server was friendly and very helpful. She assisted us efficiently with our take out dessert request and checked on us often. OVERALL: Tasty food, fair pricing & good service equals a winning combination! read more

See all

Our vegan family of four had an amazing dinner here. My husband and I shared the vegan risotto and the vegan bolognese dishes and they were both filling and truly fantastic! My kiddos (4 & 6 yo) shared some plain pasta and a kid's pizza with plant based cheese and loved it. The restaurant itself is a casual vibe with outside seating available. You order at the counter but the rest of the experience is a typical sit down restaurant. I'm just beyond impressed that they offer such a creative and delicious vegan menu. We will absolutely come back the next time we visit Maui. read more

Good food, above and beyond service! Loved the macarons, perfect dessert to end the night with.