We were exploring Odenton on a Sunday in April and stumbled upon this place, which looked just disreputable enough to be a gem. Adding to expectations was the high Yelp rating. Unfortunately it sucked bad. Don't be fooled - this is not a bbq place - they don't smoke meat or anything. This is a roast beef place. Also, this should really be a one star review, but I know people don't take them seriously.
I ordered the pit beef sandwich with fries and "campfire beans." The gf had the pit turkey sandwich with fries and mac & cheese. We waited for THIRTY MINUTES to get our food, which is completely unacceptable at a take-out restaurant where you are standing around outside waiting for your food. In addition, as far as I could tell they didn't have to actually cook any food other than dunking a few fries in hot lard. Most of it was just slapping meat on bread. This place is disorganized. They don't take your name or give you a number or anything, so there is lots of confusion when it comes time to pick up your food. We saw another family just leave becaue they were so frustrated. And all of our containers of food had dirty saucy fingerprints all over them from the kitchen staff. I understand this is supposed to be a folksy place, but I mean wipe that off, c'mon.
On the positive side, the namesake pit beef on the beef sandwich was pretty tasty, although nobody asked me how I wanted it (rare, etc.). I would say I got medium rare, which is probably what I would have ordered. Seriously, the beef is alright.
However, everything else was terrible. After waiting for an eternity, we opened up our styrofoam containers to find plain sliced meat on some boring bun. The condiment station had onions and horseradish and not much else, and looked quite honestly like it was ripe for contamination with no lids on anything and people sticking their grubby hands in everything.
Something was off about the Turkey. It was a translucent color that looked like the bird must have been sick or something. It had some smokey taste to it, but we couldn't finish it because there was something very strange and terrible about its consistency. The gf equated it to the sickening, gelatinous texture that you get on really cheap deli meat.
I see a bunch of reviews raving about the fries. I love fries. Like any fry, these probably would have been better fresh out of the fryer, but they weren't. They were sort of room temperature and completely soggy. The bag was noticeably damp with grease when they handed it to us. I don't even think they had salt on them. Five Guys makes significantly better fries than this place.
The sides were a joke. The mac & cheese was as bad as you can possibly imagine mac & cheese. The sauce was some fluorescent orange cheese whiz-style vomit that had congealed around overcooked macaroni. The whole mess had cemented itself together, so when you went to fork out a bite, the whole disgusting thing popped out like a mucus plug. It wasn't even tasty in the sickening, but comforting, way that Kraft blue box is. I don't know how you could make mac & cheese worse than this. The beans were had little tiny bits of unidentified meat product floating around in them. There was nothing remarkable about them.
What else. Oh the bbq sauce I swear to god came straight out of some industrial tub of Sysco bbq sauce. I would never go back to this place. read more