First timer came in 45 minutes before closing and was greeted like family. Emily, Leah and Bryce were welcoming and genial,I believe it added to the ambiance! I ordered a Reuben and I was told it was a favorite.. I can see why the rye was toasted correctly ( not too light not to burnt) meat sauerkraut and dressing (Russian homemade) were well proportioned.. I would like to try this place again there are a lot of different options with different cheeses but the Reuben was great. read more

Yum, yum, yum! The tomato soup is so good that I'd eat it on a 95 degree day....oh wait. I did! I love working my way through every sandwich on the board! Best staff in town. They are like friends. read more

Now you know I love a good downtown Hallmark look and this place is that!!!! It's right off of Wilson street in Batavia and they have another location in downtown Naperville. My best friend kept telling me to try it and I did....on accident, but now I'm hooked!!!!! While Christmas shopping, my man and i decided to stop here for a quick late lunch! Whew! My husband and I both ordered the sloppy Joe grilled cheese and we were left in awe!! From the soft crunchy butter Texas toast, to the flavorful sloppy Joe with American cheese. The food sandwich melts in your mouth. Try their ramen chicken noodle soup too! The flavor will impact you greatly on a cold Chicago evening. As always, let me know what you guys think!!! read more

See all

My 4yo is a bit of a grilled cheese connoisseur, however she never finishes the sandwich and certainly doesn't eat the crust. However not only did she finish the kids meal, she asked for more and then finished a whole other sandwich including the crust! Highly recommended and oh yeah my spicy smoky cheesy bacon was delicious as well. read more

Everdine's Grilled Cheese - Sandwiches Near Me - Batavia, Illinois

See all

I've been hankering to try this place for awhile. We were cheerfully greeted whem we entered. All our questions were answered on the menu. The place is very cute and has a deli like feel. The soups are homemade. I did not order the soup, but the grilled cheese was absolutely delectable! I had the Messie Jessie with 2 cheeses, London broil, horseradish sauce and a side of au jous! The Mac and cheese side was good and cheesy. My friend ordered the Nakatomi with teriyaki chicken and pineapple with cheese. All served on perfectly grilled Texas toast! Yummy!! Then, we noticed something we just had to try.... Turano glazed donut grilled cheese!!! What a great dessert! The chef came out and checked on us. We found out that they are supporting the community by hosting a food drive! What a great addition to the Batavia restaurant scene. read more

See all

I've been to Everdine's a few times now. The have a very nice staff and an interesting variety of sandwich offerings. The dining room has a deli-ish feel to it with the menu board and walk-up counter. Everything I have tried there so far has been rather delicious. With that said, it is honestly rather expensive for basically fancy grilled cheese sandwiches. It is easy for two people to spend $40 or more. It's tasty and definitely worth trying. But be prepared to drop some dough! read more

Everdine's Grilled Cheese - Ruben and cheddar, potato, bacon soup. - Sandwiches Near Me - Batavia, Illinois

If you're looking for an ultimate comfort, food experience you've gotta checkout Everdine's. Both sandwiches were amazing. The bread and the ingredients are all high-quality. Very tasty. Highly recommend. read more

Everdine's Grilled Cheese - Eddie Mac & Cheese - Sandwiches Near Me - Batavia, Illinois

See all

I saw a review from Turano Breads instagram and knew I had I to try it! 4 times later it's safe to say i might be addicted! It's so much more than grilled cheese, really good soups, sloppy "Jane" and sugar cookies that are to die for. But seriously the staff is beyond kind, love the sandwiches and happy to see you come back. *just wish the taco bout it was permanent on the menu* read more

Creative fun menu. Takes a while to absorb all the options, then there are specials. Broccoli cheddar soup is excellent. Love that they use the stalks to add texture and heartiness to soup. There is an option to add bacon. Great staff. Kelly, the owner, was busing tables AND checking in with customers. Very casual and comfortable. There are 5 min parking spots out front to encourage take out. Glad to see city of Batavia accommodating a new business in town. Thanks for the loyalty card, goal is to fill it up! read more

I had been wanting to try Everdine's for a while now and it was good. Went on a Saturday for late lunch, not crowded. I had the all American grilled cheese, which was just a grilled cheese on Texas toast. My Sister got the Hulk Smash, she said it was good, just wished there was more meatball on it, as it was very small for a smash. We had 2 drinks and shared a bag of chips, not included with sandwiches. Overpriced for what we got. read more

The staff was super friendly and happy to help with custom orders. The place was clean, and there were tons of food options. Overall, a great experience--I'll definitely be back! My only suggestion: maybe lower the prices a bit. A $10 sandwich without a side feels a little steep (or maybe I'm just cheap!). read more

Everdine's Grilled Cheese - Customized Maui Wowie - Sandwiches Near Me - Batavia, Illinois

Went in winter....when they first opened. Too chilly inside to actually enjoy. Sandwich I chose (?) was tasty, but not worth the price when I added a side of soup. If I try again I will order half sandwich and soup. $20 for grilled cheese lunch in a sandwich shop atmosphere isn't my cup of tea...‍ read more

Friendly and good. My favorite sandwiches are the sloppy mac, Socra-cheez, and original with a cup of tomato soup. Side of sloppy mac is great on its own. Google the secret menu, which seems to change. $1.99 to add a pickle feels extortionate, but the place did start in Naperville... read more

We love this spot! The last time we were in my husband and I both ordered something new and loved the selections. Be prepared to wait a little longer than expected but it is so worth it! I also love the iced tea brand they carry. read more

The Buffalo chicken sandwich was delicious, the line was short and the service was great, checked all the right boxes. I appreciate the nice touch of the artwork on the walls, overall great vibes. read more

Everdine's Grilled Cheese - Buffalo Chicken grilled cheese - Sandwiches Near Me - Batavia, Illinois

See all

Unique concept with good execution. Each sandwich is unique and we enjoyed the quality however price was a bit higher than I expected . That said the place is good and the location and decor add their experience . Definitely try it for yourself . I had the special and my friend had a standard Cuban and both delicious. read more

The Turkey Meltdown was the perfect combination of ingredients with a chipotle mayo with the right amount of spice so as not to overwhelm. Great place! read more

Absolutely nothing I would change about our food! I got the Mostly Maui Wowie (grilled cheese with ham and pineapple) and my husband got the Eddie Mack and Cheese (grilled cheese with Mac and cheese). Bread was delicious and toasted perfectly, the cheese perfectly melted. My bread to cheese to ham to pineapple ratio was balanced. The side chips and drinks were also excellent. Will be coming back soon! read more

Everdine's Grilled Cheese - The Mostly Maui Wowie - Sandwiches Near Me - Batavia, Illinois

I spotted someone's review of Everdine's and put it on my watchlist. It only took a few weeks to make our way in. I pride myself on a well made grilled cheese sandwich, but didnt realize this place would make my creations seem basic. They have a huge menu with a lot of ingredients to build your sandwich. They also have 15 or so named sandwiches to choose from. I had my heart set on a grilled cheese and some mac and cheese..so I married the two by getting the Eddie's Mack n' Cheese. That went down way too easily. A hungrier me would have had two. I supplemented with a bowl of tomato soup, which was also delicious. I spotted at least ten sandwiches that I'd like to try, so it's fair to say we'll be back often. Cheers. read more

The sandwiches are amazing I had the Messy Bessy, the horseradish coleslaw is awesome on the sandwich, so tasty. It was so good I went back a second time this week for a pickup order. read more

We've been watching and waiting for Everdine's to open in Batavia, and today they finally did! The space is bright with lots of seating. The staff was friendly and checked in with us after we got our food to make sure we were doing well. They have a surprisingly large selection of grilled cheese sandwiches, including several creative options, and if you aren't enticed by those choices you can customize your own sandwich. The Mostly Maui Wowie was like eating a grilled cheese version of a Hawaiian pizza, and the Sloppy Mack was hearty and a good choice for a chilly winter day. We enjoyed both. The tomato soup was good, but could have been slightly thicker and more savory. We'll definitely be back to try more of the menu! read more

See all

I notice how the young manager here treats the workers with decency and appreciate that as a patron. The workers are so kind and you can tell they have a positive vibe when you come in! The mac and cheese is one of my lunch time favorites. read more

Service is super great, lots of options for sandwiches. Very creative ones st that. Go!

Cute little restaurant in downtown Batavia. Soup salads and unique sandwiches. The soup and sandwich I had was excellent. It was just tomato and grilled cheese. But it was good! I will be back! The lady at the counter was very friendly. read more

After all the anticipation of this place opening I finally made it over there to give it a go last week. The service was amazing I give that five stars but the food was just alright. Wish you could do half stars it's better than a 3 but not a 4 in my book. Totally fine for what it is quick and easy and reasonably priced. read more

Had a few different sandwiches and build my own a couple times. Food is very good and consistent. Service is always fast and friendly. The dipper is the perfect amount of tomato soup for a grilled cheese. read more

Sloppy joan with a Dang root beer. Cant wait to return and try another item. My wife enjoyed the maui wowie 1/2 sandwich with a side of stuffed green pepper soup (delish!) Try it soon read more

I have catered several lunches and it's been an amazing meal every time. Every sandwich that's been ordered has been a hit. They have became my go-to option whenever I have an event to cater in Batavia or Naperville. read more

Great place with delicious sandwiches. The manager and staff have always been very friendly and inviting to us. The restaurant is clean and has a welcoming environment. My son and I enjoy frequenting Everdine's on a regular basis, and we highly recommend it. read more

Good family vibe with adult option grilled cheese sandwiches. Love the gyro grilled cheese!!

Best grilled cheese ever!! The long awaited opening of Everdine's Batavia has happened. It was worth the wait!! So Good!!! Thx yall rock :) read more

Best place ever. Delicious. Warns the soul. I highly recommend going with a friend, buying two to three and sharing to try as many as you want. read more

I love their turkey melt with the chipotle sauce! I really need to try something else, but it's so good I keep going back for that one sandwich! I do wish they would switch up their soups weekly instead of monthly, but definitely enjoying their soups too. read more

Just went there. 26 dollars for 2 sandwiches and soup. The soup was 4.50 for a small cup. PRICEY! I would say I won't go there again. Not spectacular. I would rather go to Smittys on the corner in Saint Charles. 5 stars. Delicious sandwiches. Everdine is just so so. I won't be back. ​ read more