Order Ella’s Takeout or Delivery
Ella’s Photos
ELLA’S ATMOSPHERE
You might also consider
More like Ella’s
Recommended Reviews - Ella’s
Start your review...
Reviews With Photos
Stopped in for happy hour deals, 10-12 dollar pizza and 10 cocktails plus bites for 12 dollars. Overall a good deal. Cocktails were super original and delicious. The French fries on the side of the sliders were EXCEPTIONAL. Pizza was good, I wish it was crispier and I felt like the white pizza would have been better without the balsamic or needed truffle instead but overall great ambience and staff and good food.
I booked a reservation through OpenTable for 5:30 PM on November 30th, as I have done for the past three years during the Huntington town parade. My friend and I were seated, dining, and consuming drinks normally while our husbands and children marched. It was our expectation that they would join us at the table once the parade concluded, as they have in prior years. Without any prior notice or warning, we were abruptly presented with the bill. When we asked for clarification, we were told we had exceeded a "time limit." At no point--during the reservation process, at check-in, or while dining--were we ever informed of such a policy. No signage indicated a time-restricted seating policy, and no other tables were asked to leave despite having been seated for comparable or longer periods. When we asked to speak with a manager, the first manager approached us in a hostile and confrontational manner. He raised his voice, came uncomfortably close to our faces, and stated that we needed to leave immediately. He threatened to have us physically removed from the restaurant. His behavior was unprofessional, intimidating, and entirely unwarranted. Oddly, The selective enforcement of this supposed policy made us feel targeted and treated differently. No other tables were given the same treatment. We knew the other tables in the room from the community. A second manager (Rachel) later approached and reiterated the demand that we leave. She partially comped the bill after learning that my friend is a Paramount Founders Room Club member. While appreciated, this did not mitigate the inappropriate treatment or the discriminatory nature of how the situation was handled. There were no guests waiting for our table at the time. No one from LiveNation cares about this community. It's so different under this ownership.
What looks like a small space when you walk in, has so much space! It's a little dark and loud in here, but it's Huntington, so you've got to expect their restaurants mimic the awesome night life. Upon being seated we were asked for our drink orders. I instinctively ordered a cosmopolitan. It was delicious!! We ordered Nonna's meatballs and the zucchini zeppole. The meatballs were out of this world and tasted just like my dad's homemade. The recipe has got to be a family secret. The zucchini zeppole were mid at best. Not heavy on flavor and all around not worth it. The main event was the pizza. We got the dark side of the moon pizza. It was absolutely insane. The smoked duck paired so well with the caramelized onions. Not your average slice and it was impressive. This place is awesome and close to the paramount. I would totally come here again for dinner or before seeing a show!
This is based off one experience... We made a reservation on open table and when we got there they said they didn't have a tables available. They were having a party in the back. We ended up sitting in the bar area which worked out fine. Sitting our child in a high chair that didn't reach the table was fabulous haha. There were a couple other hiccups with our waiter (appetizer not coming out, thought a salad came with my meal but it didn't, didn't provide us with the brunch menu...maybe a few other things lol). But once again, there was a party going on and apparently they had new software??? But generally the service was good...the bartender was great -gave us a cup filled with oranges for our toddler, they worked as a team to keep our drinks filled and the food came out fast. The food was really tasty. The brunch pizza was good, my steak was very flavorful (at first I was mad because I thought it wasn't cooked medium as I asked but it was just an end piece I picked up first), the salsa verde was really good with a hint of spice, the eggs were fluffy, the meatballs were also very good (also a little spicy but even my toddler liked them). The mimosas and aperol spritz with brunch were good also. Didn't try any cocktails but they looked good as well. I would Ella's again!
Stopped in for some cocktails and small bites. Everything was great! I loved the cocktails. The bartender was super friendly. The food was so good. We sat at the bar and saw everyone else's food that they ordered and everything looked and smelled great. We definitely want to go back to try a full dinner there!
Restaurant right on main drag near The Paramount on NY Ave. Interesting and creative menu. Many vegetarian options. Food was delicious, however my only complaint is that the portions are small for the price. I hadn't realized that it was tapas. Or as they say, "more money for smaller portions". That said, each of our dishes were excellent! Also annoying is having to pay for bread, which we did. Nothing extraordinary , essentially 2 slices of toasted bread for $5. Service was very good. Parking is on the street or in municipal lot a block away.one room is a bar with high top tables. Adjacent room has regular tables and nice environment .
Possibly unpopular opinion (given all the 4 and 5 star reviews), but there is a real discrepancy/inconsistency with menu item prices at Ella's, hence the three stars. I'll start with the good/great - pizzas were spot on as was the chicken parm (which comes out plated and sliced like a pizza, except the chicken is the crust!). There are a lot of options to choose from and the combinations were an artisanal cut above your standard pizza joint. I'd have liked to see a buffalo or BBQ chicken personally but am not going to ding them for that as there were at least 10 varieties. There's an awesome woodsy smell that'll whisk you right into that ski lodge vibe, serving also as a reminder that all the pizzas (and some other menu options) are tastefully wood-fired. Bonus points for a creative selection of cocktails and a visual "rubric" so you get quick notes on each drink (e.g. main liquor, boozy, sweet, etc). Location can't be beat either, especially if you're catching a show at the Paramount, which is literally next door! My main critique is that portion to price ratio is way out of whack for some items. Particularly, the pinwheel lasagna (6 measly bites for $30) and the wings (6 segments - not full wings - for $17). Our waitress was friendly and knowledgeable in suggesting things for us to try, but after it all, your best bang for the buck is definitely with their awesome pizzas - stick to those.
Food and ambiance were top notch, and service was excellent! Had a reservation for 6:30 and were seated right away. A waiter came to see us quickly and took our drink orders. Got our drinks quickly and ordered our food. Everything was timely and it made the experience pleasant. We had the baby kale caesar with steak which was cooked and seasoned perfectly. Got the Seventy times 7 pizza which was so so good. Crust was perfect, sauce was perfect, burrata was amazing. Can't wait to come back and try more.
I went to Ella's last week, and the menu had been cut to one small page. This is because they are changing their whole menu. I assume this is because of the change in ownership for the whole Paramount complex, which was bought by LiveNation. I'm going to withhold final judgement until I experience the new menu. My wife and I are regular patrons of Ella's, because they used to serve the best gluten-free pizza in Long Island. But last week, although they still had GF pizza crust, they had removed their dairy free and vegetarian pizza options. We just left. Customers who have allergies will understand my disappointment. To be continued!
Went to Ella's with a couple of girlfriends. I've heard so much about this place so I was so excited to try it out! I think they recently changed their menu... it used to be family style and now it's regular plates. The drinks were very good... refreshing and I enjoyed the way they were listed on the menu. They explained the type of alcohol in the drink as well as the other ingredients. The food for me, was just mediocre for the price. The appetizers were definitely the best part. I got cacio e Pepe for my meal and it was with black pasta, not squid ink, just black pasta. I thought that was a bit strange. It was served with an egg on top so it made it creamy but it really was very bland other than that. My other friends got steak and another pasta, again, just OK. I most likely won't be back for the price point of these options. Our waitress was super nice though and very attentive. They also don't have any happy hour at their bar.
This place is super cute & trendy with a chill vibe. Our server was great, checking in on us every so often even though it was busy. We ordered brussel sprouts & beets salad to share as an app. They were ok- not bad. For dinner I ordered the pizza with spinach & pesto. It was ok- nothing special. I've had better. My friend ordered the fig pizza- also ok. Nothing impressive that would leave you wanting more. Typically I'd wrap up the leftovers to take home, but I left it. If they improve the menu, I'd come back. Otherwise, it's a pass for me.
3 months ago
If my review can save others from making the mistake it's worth it. What an awful experience. We sat down at 5:45pm before a 7pm show. The only other people in the restaurant were 2 people at the high top by the bar. The first two drinks we ordered took almost 20min to arrive. Our group of 6 (once all arrived) then ordered more drinks which took also a very long time. The food was awful. Chicken breast so thick and dry, and not to mention the plates they use you couldn't actually cut it on because it was a bowl. The pasta over cooked and falling apart. The rice balls had consistency of a mashed potato. The cacio de Pepe was more like buttered noodles. Not to mention the portion size for the prices they charge. The poached pear salad was outstanding. Our last drink was ordered as some food arrived and didn't show up until the check was being paid. If you have a small menu like them, you should be able to execute it well. read more
Ella's is a great spot! Its location couldn't be more convenient -- right next to The Paramount and close to town parking. When we walked inside, we were pleasantly surprised to find a dining area you wouldn't notice from the outside. That's where my husband and I were seated. It was a very busy Friday night, so the staff was definitely juggling a lot, but they still managed to be attentive and friendly. The space isn't huge, which actually made it feel cozy and helped the service stay smooth even with the crowd. We ordered the Big Cheese pizza and loved it. The prosciutto was such a nice touch, and it seemed to be a popular order -- we noticed a few other tables enjoying the same pizza along with calamari and meatballs to share. Clearly, their comfort classics are a hit. The bar area is small but full of energy and had a really nice vibe. Overall, Ella's is a cute, cozy pizzeria with great food and a convenient location. We'd definitely come back! read more
Delicious food, great service (the hostess was especially kind and accommodating). The food was delicious and they even gave us more bread for the fondue dip (which was the highlight of the meal) A cute restaurant right by The Paramount. Our table was a sofa table with pillows and all, very cozy! I would highly recommend this spot to anyone in the area! read more
10 months ago
Stopped in for happy hour deals, 10-12 dollar pizza and 10 cocktails plus bites for 12 dollars. Overall a good deal. Cocktails were super original and delicious. The French fries on the side of the sliders were EXCEPTIONAL. Pizza was good, I wish it was crispier and I felt like the white pizza would have been better without the balsamic or needed truffle instead but overall great ambience and staff and good food. read more
7 months ago
10 months ago
I booked a reservation through OpenTable for 5:30 PM on November 30th, as I have done for the past three years during the Huntington town parade. My friend and I were seated, dining, and consuming drinks normally while our husbands and children marched. It was our expectation that they would join us at the table once the parade concluded, as they have in prior years. Without any prior notice or warning, we were abruptly presented with the bill. When we asked for clarification, we were told we had exceeded a "time limit." At no point--during the reservation process, at check-in, or while dining--were we ever informed of such a policy. No signage indicated a time-restricted seating policy, and no other tables were asked to leave despite having been seated for comparable or longer periods. When we asked to speak with a manager, the first manager approached us in a hostile and confrontational manner. He raised his voice, came uncomfortably close to our faces, and stated that we needed to leave immediately. He threatened to have us physically removed from the restaurant. His behavior was unprofessional, intimidating, and entirely unwarranted. Oddly, The selective enforcement of this supposed policy made us feel targeted and treated differently. No other tables were given the same treatment. We knew the other tables in the room from the community. A second manager (Rachel) later approached and reiterated the demand that we leave. She partially comped the bill after learning that my friend is a Paramount Founders Room Club member. While appreciated, this did not mitigate the inappropriate treatment or the discriminatory nature of how the situation was handled. There were no guests waiting for our table at the time. No one from LiveNation cares about this community. It's so different under this ownership. read more
4 months ago
What looks like a small space when you walk in, has so much space! It's a little dark and loud in here, but it's Huntington, so you've got to expect their restaurants mimic the awesome night life. Upon being seated we were asked for our drink orders. I instinctively ordered a cosmopolitan. It was delicious!! We ordered Nonna's meatballs and the zucchini zeppole. The meatballs were out of this world and tasted just like my dad's homemade. The recipe has got to be a family secret. The zucchini zeppole were mid at best. Not heavy on flavor and all around not worth it. The main event was the pizza. We got the dark side of the moon pizza. It was absolutely insane. The smoked duck paired so well with the caramelized onions. Not your average slice and it was impressive. This place is awesome and close to the paramount. I would totally come here again for dinner or before seeing a show! read more
3 years ago
This is based off one experience... We made a reservation on open table and when we got there they said they didn't have a tables available. They were having a party in the back. We ended up sitting in the bar area which worked out fine. Sitting our child in a high chair that didn't reach the table was fabulous haha. There were a couple other hiccups with our waiter (appetizer not coming out, thought a salad came with my meal but it didn't, didn't provide us with the brunch menu...maybe a few other things lol). But once again, there was a party going on and apparently they had new software??? But generally the service was good...the bartender was great -gave us a cup filled with oranges for our toddler, they worked as a team to keep our drinks filled and the food came out fast. The food was really tasty. The brunch pizza was good, my steak was very flavorful (at first I was mad because I thought it wasn't cooked medium as I asked but it was just an end piece I picked up first), the salsa verde was really good with a hint of spice, the eggs were fluffy, the meatballs were also very good (also a little spicy but even my toddler liked them). The mimosas and aperol spritz with brunch were good also. Didn't try any cocktails but they looked good as well. I would Ella's again! read more
11 months ago
Stopped in for some cocktails and small bites. Everything was great! I loved the cocktails. The bartender was super friendly. The food was so good. We sat at the bar and saw everyone else's food that they ordered and everything looked and smelled great. We definitely want to go back to try a full dinner there! read more
2 years ago
Restaurant right on main drag near The Paramount on NY Ave. Interesting and creative menu. Many vegetarian options. Food was delicious, however my only complaint is that the portions are small for the price. I hadn't realized that it was tapas. Or as they say, "more money for smaller portions". That said, each of our dishes were excellent! Also annoying is having to pay for bread, which we did. Nothing extraordinary , essentially 2 slices of toasted bread for $5. Service was very good. Parking is on the street or in municipal lot a block away.one room is a bar with high top tables. Adjacent room has regular tables and nice environment . read more
2 years ago
5 months ago
Possibly unpopular opinion (given all the 4 and 5 star reviews), but there is a real discrepancy/inconsistency with menu item prices at Ella's, hence the three stars. I'll start with the good/great - pizzas were spot on as was the chicken parm (which comes out plated and sliced like a pizza, except the chicken is the crust!). There are a lot of options to choose from and the combinations were an artisanal cut above your standard pizza joint. I'd have liked to see a buffalo or BBQ chicken personally but am not going to ding them for that as there were at least 10 varieties. There's an awesome woodsy smell that'll whisk you right into that ski lodge vibe, serving also as a reminder that all the pizzas (and some other menu options) are tastefully wood-fired. Bonus points for a creative selection of cocktails and a visual "rubric" so you get quick notes on each drink (e.g. main liquor, boozy, sweet, etc). Location can't be beat either, especially if you're catching a show at the Paramount, which is literally next door! My main critique is that portion to price ratio is way out of whack for some items. Particularly, the pinwheel lasagna (6 measly bites for $30) and the wings (6 segments - not full wings - for $17). Our waitress was friendly and knowledgeable in suggesting things for us to try, but after it all, your best bang for the buck is definitely with their awesome pizzas - stick to those. read more
2 years ago
Food and ambiance were top notch, and service was excellent! Had a reservation for 6:30 and were seated right away. A waiter came to see us quickly and took our drink orders. Got our drinks quickly and ordered our food. Everything was timely and it made the experience pleasant. We had the baby kale caesar with steak which was cooked and seasoned perfectly. Got the Seventy times 7 pizza which was so so good. Crust was perfect, sauce was perfect, burrata was amazing. Can't wait to come back and try more. read more
2 years ago
I went to Ella's last week, and the menu had been cut to one small page. This is because they are changing their whole menu. I assume this is because of the change in ownership for the whole Paramount complex, which was bought by LiveNation. I'm going to withhold final judgement until I experience the new menu. My wife and I are regular patrons of Ella's, because they used to serve the best gluten-free pizza in Long Island. But last week, although they still had GF pizza crust, they had removed their dairy free and vegetarian pizza options. We just left. Customers who have allergies will understand my disappointment. To be continued! read more
Went to Ella's with a couple of girlfriends. I've heard so much about this place so I was so excited to try it out! I think they recently changed their menu... it used to be family style and now it's regular plates. The drinks were very good... refreshing and I enjoyed the way they were listed on the menu. They explained the type of alcohol in the drink as well as the other ingredients. The food for me, was just mediocre for the price. The appetizers were definitely the best part. I got cacio e Pepe for my meal and it was with black pasta, not squid ink, just black pasta. I thought that was a bit strange. It was served with an egg on top so it made it creamy but it really was very bland other than that. My other friends got steak and another pasta, again, just OK. I most likely won't be back for the price point of these options. Our waitress was super nice though and very attentive. They also don't have any happy hour at their bar. read more
3 years ago
3 years ago
This place is super cute & trendy with a chill vibe. Our server was great, checking in on us every so often even though it was busy. We ordered brussel sprouts & beets salad to share as an app. They were ok- not bad. For dinner I ordered the pizza with spinach & pesto. It was ok- nothing special. I've had better. My friend ordered the fig pizza- also ok. Nothing impressive that would leave you wanting more. Typically I'd wrap up the leftovers to take home, but I left it. If they improve the menu, I'd come back. Otherwise, it's a pass for me. read more
1 year ago
Really enjoyed this place! The food was slightly pricy, but in my opinion fairly priced for what you get. The menu was on the small side, which I enjoyed. I believe it was a new seasonal menu. The food was delicious and the servings were perfectly sized. The inside is upscale and comfortable. Only qualm was the service was a bit slow to receive our food despite the restaurant being rather empty. Staff are polite and attentive. Would definitely come back! read more
2 years ago
I was very excited to order Ellas as our dinner choice for this years New Years Eve meal, and it was all very special. We went wild, ordered basically the whole menu, including: - Zucchini Bread- Delicious, Very Special - Beets by Koji- Alright, One Time Order -Fried Mushrooms- Very Good, Little Too Salty - Croquettes- Good, Tasty - Agnotelli - Very Good, Very Special - Skirt Steak- Savory, Special, Top Choice -Harvest Pizza- Tasty, Happy to Have Again - Nice and Smooth Pizza- Delicious The order was also taken seamlessly online through their website, they open up ordering availability at 4:30, they open at 5. Drive up service was top class, they have an area to easily pull up, they had a guy outside ready to run in and get your order, another guy who will direct traffic in a suit/mask. It was all very smoothly handled. We will definitely be returning for another high class dining experience in the future! read more
4 years ago
Excellent food (great flavors) and nice service! My husband and I went in for a little date night dinner and are really glad we decided to finally check out Ella's. Service: Very friendly and attentive staff. My husband and I were wearing masks as we entered the restaurant. We were guided to a nice table that was a good distance from other guests. We really appreciate them seating us in the least crowded area without us having to say anything! Food: All delicious! I highly recommend trying the nduja, bread, and butter appetizer. The nduja has a nice kick to it but is not overly spicy, nor does the spiciness linger. They brought out A LOT of nduja and butter relative to the bread, so we ended up taking the remainder to go. The fresh pasta was good and the tomato sauce for the parpardelle had a really rich flavor. read more
3 years ago
1 year ago
3 years ago
2 years ago
3 years ago
1 year ago
I've been wanting to try this place for some time now and finally got the pleasure. It's bigger than it looks from the outside and there's a parklet with tables outside. We opted for indoor. The drinks are very good, I had an adios amigos and really enjoyed it. We shared 2 menu items the sweet corn agnolotti and a catch a fire pizza, both really good. I LOVED the agnolotti, buttery sauce, sweet deliciousness. I very rarely get the same menu item twice I like to try new things, but this I could eat everyday. The pizza was good too, spicy mixed with the spicy sweet hot honey, it was good! I can't wait to go back. read more
4 years ago
Had been wanting to check this place out for a while and it did NOT disappoint! Drinks AND food were amazing. I got the gnocchi which was out of this world & the 93 'Til Infinity. Reservations were super easy to make & I will absolutely be back! read more
5 years ago
I was somewhat hesitant to dine at Ellas as a vegan. I stopped by the day before I had planned to dine and asked about the menu and what I could order. Basically a lot of things can be made vegan, but there is only one true vegan option in the menu as is. The anthem of the sun pizza was the only vegan option, but it was very good. I did not miss the cheese at all. It had a lot of well seasoned vegetables on it and was definitely filling. Their pizza dough/crust is really good here. My friends had the nice and smooth pizza and the wings which were both very good too, the wings come with a little bottle of hot sauce which I used on my pizza to take it up a notch. They had a special frozen drink that night, which was really nice on a hot day, but a tad on the sweet side. Our server was very nice and perfectly attentive. We were there for a couple hours catching up and she never made us feel like we were a bother. Overall the experience was good. I really wish they had more vegan options as is, rather than having to ask for things to be taken away or altered. Since they have the one vegan pizza option, one vegan appetizer option would've been really nice so that I could have easily shared an app with my friends. read more
Business owner information
Rory V.
Thank you for the nice review. We are happy to hear you enjoyed your…
3 years ago
4 years ago
Visited this amazing little spot on a visit to my bestie who wanted to show me her little town. AMAZING is probably an understatement of epic proportions. Great beers on tap and the food is creative, flavorful and wonderfully presented. Justin at the bar was super attentive and didn't mind (and could answer) my questions about the beer selections. Don't miss this place! read more
3 years ago
Excellent service and atmosphere. Great murals on the walls. Food was delicious. Burrata pizza was excellent and my mocktail was tasty. read more
Page 1 of 4
More info about Ella’s
Ask the Community - Ella’s
You might also consider
Why does Yelp recommend reviews?
8 reviews that are not currently recommended
The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.
11 months ago
1 year ago
2 years ago
2 years ago
4 years ago
6 years ago
6 years ago
3 years ago
