Cancel

Open app

Search

Edith's

4.3 (124 reviews)
Open • 8:00 am - 8:00 pm

Order Edith's Takeout or Delivery

Edith's Photos

Business Info

EDITH'S ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Edith's

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

menu
Elaina V.

I can only speak on the drinks here, but they are SO GOOD! I got the limited time yerba mate slush and the coffee slush and both were amazingggg. I'm not a huge coffee drinker but the slush was unbeatable. It was light, sweet, and perfect on a warm day. The yerba mate slush was so good too, I wish it were a permanent menu item! Since I only got drinks it was a pretty quick transaction, but there was a line mid day.

Chicken Caesar Wrap
Azen N.

I've had Edith's a number of times in Williamsburg, but this was my first time trying the WV location. My friend & I split the chicken caesar wrap & smoked turkey hoagie. Caesar wrap: It has so much potential, but it didn't not do it for me. Granted I was starving so I did shovel it down. 1. The wrap was lightly coated with dressing so I had to request more - very dry off the bat. 2. The top portion had chicken, but underneath the wrap was basically all kale - like sooooo much kale I had to take some out. Can't remember if there was parmesan in there either? It was basically all kale w sprinkles of chicken Smoked turkey sandwich: I preferred this sandwich. It is quite literally the perfect beach sando. Turkey was packed it in, meat was flavorful & seemed like good quality. I also loved the toppings - pickles & pickled red onions were my faves! My one callout is that it was just a taddddd bit more saucey than I would have liked. Don't get me wrong, I love sauce, but it was to the point that the bread was getting soggy and dripping everywhere.

Chris D.

Very busy as we all know, but that staff were fabulous. I got an everything bagel and scallion cream cheese- you could tell the cream cheese had the scallions added in house, it was really nice. Bagel wasn't a New York style bagel (I don't think anyway) so it was a nice change. The coffee tahini slushie was a bit rich for me. I would have liked a smaller size, but it was a nice flavor

The Californian
Julia M.

I wanted to like this so badly but it was not at all worth the wait or the money ($16.50 for tuna!!)... wanted to go for something cold because it was so hot and while the Californian had some crisp lettuce it was bland and the tuna was too dry for me. I fear I can make better tuna at home. The challah was good and I appreciate the pickled peppers because that was like the only flavor that was there. They also told us at the register that they were out of the summer special that my cousin had really wanted to try and it would've been more helpful if they posted a sign outside saying that. Id come back on a weekday to try the tuna melt because I'd assume the cheese would give more flavor but honestly not sure if it's worth the trip/wait.

A Perfect Tuna Melt
Lynn N.

I came to Edith's to try their sandwiches after hearing such great things about their items! I was especially curious about their Sephardi Wrap and Tuna Melt, so that is what we ordered. The shop is diner styled where you order at the front and find a free seat to eat at. Service was incredibly kind and they also checked in on us too! I think the food just was not to my flavor unfortunately. The bread on the tuna melt was way too buttery for me, and the tuna + cheese was cold. Is that standard? I'm not super familiar with other tuna melts, but I was surprised. I do like how the tuna salad was heavy on tuna and lower on mayo though! The Sephardi wrap was interesting, but I think the wrap itself was maybe too crispy where it was a little hard. The dish itself was heavier than I expected. Overall, this is a great place to try but just didn't match my flavor profile.

Pastrami Chopped Cheese
Caroline O.

We got the matcha slushie and the coffee slushie but matcha not really worth- just tasted like flavorless slush. I'd recommend the coffee slushie more. I didn't really like the Sephardi wrap but if you're into cheesy breakfast wraps, I think you'd like it. The pastrami chopped cheese was good.

Crystal W.

FANTASTIC. I got the coffee slush (what I came here for), totkes, and chicken tahini Cesar salad wrap. Knocked it out of the park. The wrap was STUFFED. Filling but not greasy. The staff is fantastic, the cashier is so patient and gave great recommendations. The slushy is sooooo yummy and you get a punch card for a free one when you hit 8. Great diner feel to the open kitchen. Definitely recommend and want to come back to try more goodies.

PEC&L
Maricel S.

Edith's is worth the trip for the bagels alone, but the PEC&L takes it to another level. The pastrami, egg, cheese, and crispy latke combo on a fresh bagel is ridiculously good! Everything stayed intact until the last bite! Definitely one of those sandwiches you keep thinking about afterwards. Cozy vibe, friendly staff, and genuinely memorable food. I'll absolutely be back for another PEC&L.

Tahini Chicken Caesar Wrap
Ayda N.

Okay loved both sandwiches! The cesear wrap has a tahini dressing but it wasn't too over powering. The turkey Sammy was def a little richer so it was nice to split each one. My go to turkey Sammy is usually Court St. but this one is pretty comparable (clean turkey still #1 tho)

PEC&L
Ruby C.

Sourdough bagel stuffed with japanese-style tamagoyaki, and a shakshuka inspired bagel sandwich spotted in NYC! The secret to their fluffy egg omelette is that every bagel sammy is made with an individual omelette made in cast-iron tamagoyaki pans from Japan. Their West Village location gives off a buzzy deli vibe, with limited bar and window seating. It was packed when I went on the weekend, so it's more of a grab-and-go spot. I placed my order online in advance to skip the line. Definitely need to go back to try their sandwiches and wraps. *Middle Eastern $12.85 A saucy and herby bagel sandwich inspired by shakshuka. Made with fluffy tamagoyaki, cheese, za'atar, shakshuka sauce and scallion aioli spread. It was messy to hold and bite into, but totally worth it. I went with their signature chicago-style everything bagel, which has a subtle kick compared to a regular everything bagel. *PEC&L $16.85 They offer BEC, SEC, and P(astrami)EC, all served with a latke and tamagoyaki! The PEC&L was a bit bland on its own, but I liked that the smoked pastrami wasn't overly salty. BUT the sandwich was DIVINE once dipped in their house special sauce!

Robin Z.

Literally the best sandwich I ever had that I didn't make myself. Friendly people, especially Saint, and a very cool vibe. They should have tables outside because the place is tiny.

Zoe G.

I'm glad we grabbed a sandwich from Edith's before heading to the airport. I grabbed breakfast for lunch and got the bacon, egg, and cheese in a wrap. I loved the totkes and the special sauce that came with the wrap was sweeter. I loved their miscellaneous hot sauce bucket, cute spot with great service. My sister enjoyed her tuna melt too.

PEC&L
Huiwen C.

The Iced Cafe Slushie is divine!! The savory sesame tahini complements the oat milk so well. This is the perfect drink for a hot day. It wasn't too sweet. We also tried the PEC & L which is savory and amazing on the Chicago's everything bagel. The staff are great. It does get crowded especially on the weekend so I recommend ordering online for pickup or coming early.

Menu

See all

2 years ago

Pastrami was delicious and bread was so crispy. Best Ruben I have ever had. Highly recommend

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 2
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Amazing sandwiches sides and I loved the slushee. Even the cookie was next level. Very innovative menu in a cool space.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

got a tuna melt on christmas eve. best sandwich and nicest people ever. AND I KNOW MY TUNA MELTS OK

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 4 of 4

Ask the Community - Edith's

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Sandwiches 16,989 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

BTS - Bagel To Sandwich - bacon egg cheese bagel sandwich

BTS - Bagel To Sandwich

4.5(280 reviews)
1.6 mi•Midtown West, Theater District
•$$

We found this place next to our hotel in Times Square and we ended up eating breakfast here almost…read moreevery morning! Great bagel sandwiches (sausage egg & cheese was my favorite!) and their iced coffees were amazing! They serve them in plastic/metal sealed containers so they tend to stay cold longer. I tried 3 different coffees in 3 days and they were all great! Service can be a little slow at times because it gets CROWDED in the mornings, but I won't knock them for that. Also there is only a tiny area to sit but it's NYC so that is typical.

The ambience was really inviting as the decor was whimsical and colorful. For a rainy Sunday the…read moreplace was packed, but my husband & I were able to secure a table to dine in. For it being our first time, we were a little confused with the ordering process, and they were so busy that it took a while to be acknowledged. There were kiosks to place the order, but we couldn't find a place to request special requirements, so we had to figure out how we could order at the register amongst the slew of other customers. Our order for 2 bacon egg and cheeses were called with a biscoff iced latte and we were excited at first. But when we opened the sandwiches our bacon was just 3, maybe 4 fatty pieces when we specifically asked for crispy bacon. My husband settled for his, but I requested a reorder where they corrected the bacon issue, and even put more slices. Besides that snafu, I was excited for my latte, but was also underwhelmed by the taste. I assumed since it was a biscoff cookie latte (which I love) that it would be sweeter... The establishment was nice, and there were so many selections, so we would give it another try before writing it off completely.

Photos
BTS - Bagel To Sandwich - Easy to see menu

Easy to see menu

BTS - Bagel To Sandwich - Ube latte

Ube latte

BTS - Bagel To Sandwich - Order

See all

Order

Edith's - sandwiches - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...