This place and their bagels were supposed to be great according to all the hoopla. We went there around 11am on a Sunday. With no line we waited over 30 minutes for then to prepare 1 iced coffee, 1 bagels w/ CC and 1 salmon & CC on a bagel. Almost $46 for the mediocre, over hyped, over priced food. No place to wait, so you stand out in the cold. Bad customer service as well. So sorry we came here. read more

I had to find out what all the rave was about with the Carmela sandwich at Edith's this year! When I saw that this beauty of a bite was making a comeback after selling out, I made sure to get my order in for pick-up the weekend before Thanksgiving. Every nook and cranny on this sandwich was bursting with flavor, and totally lived up to the hype (and I'm not even a huge fan of turkey.) In addition to the sandwich, I also tried the Latkes and Chocolate Babka, which was insanely chocolatey and delicious! While I haven't tried any other items yet, I'm sure they're all equally delicious. If it's still on the menu, run to get your Carmela before it's gone! read more

Edith’s Sandwich Counter - The Carmela - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Ordered lunch for delivery - totkes and a smoked turkey club - and both were fantastic. I've also tried the breakfast wraps and famed cold brew tahini shake numerous times at their WV location. So good! read more

Edith’s Sandwich Counter - Smoked Turkey Hero - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

I saw pictures of the coffee slushy and it looked so good and cute that I wanted one too. Sumner is almost ending and today was pretty warm so I decided to go get one. It is pretty expensive but it's worth the price! It cost me around $9 with tax and all. The slushy has tahini, oat milk, and cold brew coffee in it. It looks very cool in the cup. It's brown and white all over the place! Very nice design this slushy makes. I drank it really slow to enjoy this slushy and it was very refreshing. Not overly sweet at all either! It's like mildly bitter sweet! Tastes so good! I will get another one next time I pass by here. It's also cool the lid has a huge opening for the big straw. read more

See all

I'm not sure how this place doesn't have a full five stars. The staff is very friendly. I am a big breakfast person and I go out to eat often a very good judge of food. This place has the best breakfast sandwiches I have ever had in New York City. By far the best scrambled eggs I've ever tasted. Highly recommend recommended very unique menu, traditional, breakfast items, and sandwiches, but everything has a twist. read more

Edith’s Sandwich Counter - Oat milk and tahini slushy - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I was skeptical about an overpriced sandwich place but it was great. The ice cafe slush was refreshing and sweet. I also got the BEC&L on an everything bagel (not pictured) and that was great as well - loved the house sauce on this. Only gripe was it was a bit overpriced (as with a lot of things in the city), the meal ran me about $25. They also don't have any seating, except for a measly two chairs out on the storefront. A lot of people just end up loitering at nearby stores or stoops. read more

Edith’s Sandwich Counter - Iced Cafe Slushie - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Finally, after all this time of peering at the speckled oat milk tahini iced coffee slushie on socials, the stars aligned (meaning the traffic wasn't crazy for once) and I sucked that caffeinated bev down full knowing I had to wake up early for work the next morning. There were crunchy ice crystal moments, tempered by the smooth and bitter (contradicting?), nutty tahini. And no, I'm not an animal and I didn't pair my coffee with their Perfect Tuna Melt--the tuna was enjoyed at home after the cheeses had cooled down a little. The sandwich travels well on griddled seedy rye but for $15, I'm finding that I can make a tuna sandwich just as good. Dollar for dollar, the tuna melt here, the tuna sandwich at Radio Bakery, the tunaberry and yasha at Court Street Grocers, and the tuna melt and tunaberry at S&P lunch, and the tuna melt at Golden Diner are all great options if you're unable to source great bread and tuna. At $15, the Edith's tuna melt is the second cheapest of the listed sandwiches (Radio Bakery checks in at $14.50, but is not grilled). The totkes are worth trying however you can probs skip the Cooper's sharp cheese sauce. Their cheese sauce is made from scratch and could benefit from a touch more of sodium citrate and a longer cook--the sauce cooled down and felt a little grainy. read more

Edith’s Sandwich Counter - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Easily one of my new favorite breakfast spots in the city -- the Sephardi Wrap was delicious, super filling and I appreciated the flexibility to sub avocado to make it vegetarian. The Latke Tots were super crispy, would definitely get the share! read more

Edith’s Sandwich Counter - Sephardi Breakfast Wrap - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Obsessed with Edith's! I don't typically like breakfast sandwiches but their Sephardi wrap is so so good. The staff there are also super nice (I once placed the wrong order and was able to call and they went out of their way to fix it for me)! Since the Carmela came back on the menu, I've had it 3 times - it's SO good. I love their coffee slushie but it's a fairly big size so I like to split it with a friend! read more

Got to literally any other deli in NYC for a better BEC. Bagel is weak, staff is rude read more

Edith's was a hit! We stopped here for an early lunch after a late night and I absolutely would come back. The line was pretty small despite the place being packed, because they move fast. A lot of people carrying out, or eating outside or around in the neighborhood, as there's limited seating inside. First, they are known for their frozen cafe slushie which is basically a frozen coffee. The texture was great and something about frozen coffee is perfect for a hangover. Then, we split the chicken tahini Caesar crunch wrap which was very unique and refreshing. It was like a chicken Caesar but with tahini and kale instead of caesar salad. I wish we had the appetite to try a bagel sandwich with latke, but not this time. But, because it was so good and had fast service, we will be back! read more

Edith’s Sandwich Counter - Iced Cafe Slushie with vintage punch card - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

I got egg, cheese, avocado, and hot peppers on a multigrain bagel from here. The eggs were a tiny bit mushy, but not too bad. The bagel was fluffy and doughy. My partner got bacon, egg, and cheese on an everything bagel and enjoyed it. They provided a sauce on the side which tasted like thousand island dressing. A little odd, but it added some nice flavor to the sandwiches. They don't have a huge selection of bagel flavors, but otherwise, they get the job done! read more

The BEC with the latke was a bit flavorless... I've heard that their wraps are a lot better so maybe I would try that if I went back. The standout here for me was their TAHINI OAT MILK COFFEE SLUSHIE.... UGH I dream about it. It's absolutely perfect on a hot day. read more

The breakfast wraps are insane! They're so good and made fresh to order. If we were local, we'd be here all the time! Service was friendly and fast. We ordered two things, a breakfast wrap and the Edith and they were ready within 10 minutes on a busy Sunday morning. Not much seating but grab your sandwich and take it to the nearby park! read more

Had the Edith & the Sephardi, also tried the coffee tahini slush, latke and choco chip cookies. The wait for food was about 30mins after ordering so we came back. We enjoyed the sandwiches but the Edith's bread was a bit too crunchy and greasy for my liking, but their pastrami is good (meaty and not too salty). The Sephardi is worth the hype though, the exterior is super flakey, reminds me of a scallion pancake. I would pass on the coffee tahini slush next time. The cookies were soooo thin, very crispy, chewy & buttery, I would get again. Would def come back to try more items on their menu! read more

Edith’s Sandwich Counter - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

It is a very small shop, you order, and I would say stand outside. They will call your name and/or you would need to go inside to check and pick up your order. I got the bacon, egg, and cheese sandwich on an everything bagel and it was good! The sauce that they had on a side was a nice touch, and I also picked up some of the tabasco sauce packets for some spice! There are only 3 seating areas outside. The only "negative" thing is that, I think $14-15 for that sandwich is a bit pricey! Other than that, it was really filling. read more

Edith’s Sandwich Counter - bacon, egg, and cheese sandwich on everything bagel - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Excellent quality food. Quick service and no line. I know it's a sandwich counter but would be nice if there was a counter inside to eat at too. read more

Wanted to love this place. Don't know that it hit the mark. Got excited by the Israeliness of it but the final product got lost in translation. The menu is really fun and creative and maybe I just ordered the wrong thing. But I will say the ice cafe really was the best part of my meal. The tchina added an extra fullness to an already over the top beverage but in a good way. I will come back solely for that and try a malawach sandwich instead of a bagel. I got the middle eastern, being middle eastern myself I expected something more of in your face with loads of different spices, seasonings, and flavors. It all sort of fell flat in a heavy heart attack inducing cream (I don't know from what), egg and cheese? It was supposed to be a shakshuka, what I received was an omelet with a few tomatoes and pounds of (what was supposed to be garlic aioli) mayonnaise and farmers cheese. I honestly couldn't eat it after one bite but was hungry so ate half of it and felt sick for the next few minutes and threw the other half out. I really really want to try this place again because I think there's a lot of potential. Hoping for a better experience was just extremely disappointed the first time around. read more

See all

WOW such an amazing spot for breakfast/lunch. The Sephardi breakfast wrap has a clutch around my cold heart and it's not letting go. It's the perfect balance of savory, spicy, creamy, gooey and flakey. As the kids say, it slaps. This will be making it onto my top bites of the year without a doubt. Also, don't skip the slushies. They taste even better than they look. read more

See all

there were a bunch of customers waiting for their orders when we arrived at around noon. i was really excited to order the mushreuben but was informed that it had been discontinued, to my dismay. i ended up ordering the chickpea crunch wrap instead, which was pretty good. it took about ~15 minutes for them to prepare my order, and we were told to wait outside as the shop is quite small. i don't have much to say about the wrap besides that it was well put together and i think its nice that edith's offers a healthier and also i believe vegan option for those who may have dietary restrictions or want a healthier option. i also got the totkes which were very crispy and delicious with the dips. i'm still sad that the mushreuben was discontinued because it looked delicious but i was pretty happy with the chickpea crunch wrap. read more

Edith’s Sandwich Counter - chickpea crunch wrap and totkes - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Stopped by for an early lunch - got a bacon, egg cheese bagel. I'm just always happy to have a great new york bagel sandwich. A little expensive, and just a couple chairs outside for seating. But delivered very quick, and very accomodating atmosphere. read more

Nothing we had was inherently bad, but nothing blew us away either. It was pretty expensive too being about $40 for the 3 things we got. Totkes needed salt, sauce Carried these. Sephardi Wrap was fine but just didn't get us excited. Bagel SEC was just fine as well. I will say it's very athstetically pleasing food from pics online and in person but just didn't live up to us! I mean you should 100% try this place for yourself if you are in the area! read more

See all

Came to check out the viral Tahinni coldbrew slushie. Had two friends from out of town so figured it was the perfect time to try out this place. Got here around 11am on Labor day and the line was not too long but decided to order online to be picked up. Long story short I just ended up ordering at the counter as it was faster. I did not try their food though. The Tahini cold brew slushie was definitely interesting. Never had anything like it before. The storefront is very small so the line goes out the door. The staff were very nice and helpful. read more

See all

Had the Sephardi and I'll say the flavors meshed well together- I appreciated the spicy sauce with the good kick, but overall a bit pricey for a not very filling egg sandwich. read more

I had the Sephardi wrap and it was so yummy! The wrap is a malawach, which was so good. It reminds me of a thicker roti and is stuffed with chicken sausage, cheese scrambled eggs, roasted red peppers and some spicy aioli. I got it delivered and it still arrived nice and hot. It was the perfect size, although I am greedy and it was so delicious, I could have eaten another one! I also had the tahini blondie, which was also really yummy. It's made with tahini, white chocolate, brown butter and black sesame seeds studded throughout. So bomb! read more

Edith’s Sandwich Counter - Sephardi Breakfast Wrap - so yummy! - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

MID. SELC for $20 bucks w/ tip. Everything bagel was fine, girl told me it would be spicy. Not sure where that spice was. And I asked for it to be toasted it wasn't. Also homegirl stared me down to tip. Which I am fine doing but I waited 20+ mins for it. I prefer a more seasoned saltier sausage. And was small compared to the other parts of the sandwich. A lot of egg which was solid. Latke was the best part to me. Overall was not impressed and I can't get over the price. Other sandwich options looked pretty good so maybe I'll be back for that. But yea was ok at best and absolutely not worth 20 bucks. read more

I just left here and I'm trying to figure out why this B.E.C. was in the top 10 of B.E.C.s. Edith's opens at 8:30 on Saturday and I was first in line at 8:20. There are no tables to sit and enjoy your purchase. When your food is ready, grab your bag and hit the bricks. They do have a few tables outside. I ordered the B.E.C. With Latke, Let's break it down: The Latke is sinfully good. Crunchy with hint of onion, no one took the easy route and put the potato in the food processor. This was made by latke professionals! I can see the shredded potato throughout. The bacon, eggs and cheese? Perfection. All three items are cooked with a chefs love, all items work in harmony. So what's the issue?? Brah, we are in Brooklyn New York! That bagel was horrible! I know the pizza king, Paulie Gee has the wood fired ovens cooking everything but something is askew. The bagel didn't rise, is it raw in the middle?? All my Yelp buds gave 5 stars, I'm not seeing it. read more

Edith’s Sandwich Counter - B.E.C with Edith's Square Latke - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

My partner and I came here around 12:30 on a sunny Saturday, and were pleasantly surprised that there was no wait to order (there was, however, a decent amount of people waiting outside for their orders). They took our order, and we received the Tahini coffee slushie immediately. It was very yummy and a tasty treat to enjoy while we waited for our sandwiches. It took around 45 minutes to receive our food which was delicious. The totkes were good (albeit a bit greasy, but that's to be expected) but could have used some sort of dipping sauce.. the pastrami cheesesteak was solid (wished there was a little more pastrami on it), and the breakfast wrap was also good. Not pictured were the chocolate chip cookies which were SO GOOD. They were thin with crispy exterior but a chewy interior. The tahini and salt really brought out the sweetness of the chocolate. Service was friendly too! read more

See all

It's a small walk in place, no sit down. Order and pickup. Food is good, but I don't know why I expected better, maybe the hype? Got the signature coffee drink, that was good, very strong tehina flavor, the signature sandwich, that was the best of the things I got, would probably get again, a malawach wrap, very simple for the price, something I can easily make at home, and a latke. Took about 25 mins to get. I would probably come back to try other things but it's over hyped. Also, the zhug, people, it's a spicy sauce! Don't white wash it, it SHOULD be spicy, the one I got wasn't spicy at all. Very white washed at the moment. This place needs to be more Israeli, more spice and more chutzpah! read more

The meal I got at Edith's was one of the best I've had in a while! I shared the classic sandwich, The Edith, as well as an order of the Totkes with garlic aioli, with my sibling. Truly, it was a divine meal - the pastrami was thick and juicy and the Totkes were crispy and savory! Would absolutely go back and want to try their iconic Salted, Chocolate Chip Cookies next time! read more

Edith’s Sandwich Counter - The Edith & Totkes - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

The staff was super kind and patient with all of our questions. They let us sample slush options - the seasonal shamrock shake was good in a tiny portion but would've been too much larger, so I opted for a chocolate and my friend has the cold brew version. Very tasty and filling. The totkes were good too, though the sauces weren't my fave and I think the full latke is probably better. Will be back for a sandwich! I hope they are able to get a permit to keep their outdoor seating as there is no seating inside. read more

Edith’s Sandwich Counter - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

I mean...you haven't had a breakfast sandwich until you had one from Edith's. The flavors absolutely leap from the sandwich. It's also worth noting that the texture is wonderful. The crunch from the latke is sublime. Everytime I drop by Edith's the staff is always friendly. It's become a perfect little neighborhood spot. read more

Edith’s Sandwich Counter - SEC&L - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Came in with high hopes and left disappointed. Ordered the PEC+L (pastrami, egg, cheese, latke) with a sesame bagel. We received bacon instead of pastrami. The bagel itself was tiny, about half the size of the actual filling, and the texture was dense and hard. This sandwich cost over $20 with tip. Of course, none of the menus list actual prices so you're stuck paying whatever they type into the register. Save yourself some money and go to the gourmet cafe and cheese shop across the street instead! read more

Edith’s Sandwich Counter - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Spent a beautiful Saturday in Brooklyn and needed to stop by Edith's for a treat! We had to try their oat milk slushie, clearly! Inside there is no sit down space but basically only a walk up counter. There was a very short line so we were in and out fairly quickly. The slushie hit the spot! If I hadn't already had brunch I would have ordered their breakfast sandwich. They now have a pop up at Nordstrom, might have to stop by! read more

Edith’s Sandwich Counter - Slushie - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I want to start by saying, the staff was so kind and helpful! Helped us pick out what to order and made suggestions we went with and did not regret! We ordered the coffee slushie drink, everything bagels with cream cheese and the latka tots. the latka tots were def 10/10 would order again, you get so many and they're all so crispy and delicious. I only marked down a star because I thought the bagel was a little hard, I like getting my bagels not toasted for that soft and chewy feel but they didnt seem too fresh. That being said, I loved that there was a little bit of pepper flakes in the bagel - I've never had a bagel like that before and I loved the little bit of kick! The coffee slush was delicious and I would get it again or try one of their rotating flavors. Overall, very cute aesthetic which I think is great marketing for a place and makes it fun to post pics. The inside is very small with no seating but you can bring your order to go to a park or sit at one of their 3 tables outside on a nice day. I would def go back to try their rotational slush and one of their sandwiches because they all sounded so good but I just went with a simple bagel order. read more

Edith’s Sandwich Counter - punch card for slush drinks - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

We had their iced cafe slushie, it's a frozen cold brew with oat milk tahini, very interesting flavor to say the least. Now their most popular item is the Sephardi Breakfast Wrap with a crispy and flaky Malawach wrapped with chicken sausage, cheesy eggs, and more. I loved this breakfast item, very savory with some sweetness, solid spot for sure. read more

Edith’s Sandwich Counter - Sephardi Breakfast Wrap - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I ordered this on DoorDash, which seems to be like the right choice since there is no seating at the actual location. I got a Japanese bacon, egg and cheese on a twisted everything bagel and it is now one of my favorite bagels in Williamsburg. Although this is a sandwich shop, I was very impressed by the soft and chewy texture of their twisted bagels. read more

This was a to go order given my knowledge that this is a tiny establishment compared to its sit down restaurant. I ordered the PLE on a bagel (pastrami, eggs, latke) and the Edith (also pastrami!) that's in sandwich form. Both very scrumptious, flavorful, and heavy. It is not a cheap sandwich but it is very filling. read more

Edith’s Sandwich Counter - The Edith - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Bacon, egg, cheese, AND latke?! Hit the spot. And the staff nicely made a fresh pot of coffee for me. No seating though.

We came here for brunch and ordered three wraps/sandwiches to share: Sephardi Breakfast Wrap with chicken sausage, Scottsdale Breakfast Wrap with scrambled eggs and crispy shredded potato tots, and The Edith Sandwich with house-made pastrami. Every one of them was so tasty that we couldn't stop eating after we started feeling full. We also ordered the Iced Cafe Slushie as our morning coffee and really enjoyed this unique and flavorful drink. We dined at several Micheline-starred, Bib Gourmand or Michelin-guided restaurants during this visit to NYC, and we found the food at this restaurant tastier, more creative and more economical than at any of those restaurants. I couldn't help but wonder how the Michelin evaluators picked restaurants to give their accolades. read more