I love this place! I discovered it on a bagel tour and their coffee is excellent and their bagels are delicious! You have the try the pumpernickel everything bagel with za'atar and olive cream cheese. Something I never would've thought I'd like but the ultimate savory slam to your tastebuds! The lemon poppyseed is also very good! PS- try the black & white cookies! I don't have anything to compare them to but it were fresh and so so good for my husband and I's first black & white! read more

This is hands down my absolute favorite bagel establishment I have ever been to, and it's also super aesthetic, the vibes here here! The service was very friendly, the food was even more so. I was absolutely blown away with the amount of fresh, hand-made cream cheese / butter / spread selections - some of the ones that were available when I came were: Brown Sugar Cinnamon Butter, Garlic Parsley Butter, Walnut Raisin Cream Cheese, Strawberry Cream Cheese, Cinnamon Roll Cream Cheese, Olive Cream Cheese, Nutella Chip Cream Cheese, Lemon Poppy Cream Cheese, Jalapeno Cheddar Cream Cheese, Garlic Herb Cream Cheese, Bacon Cheddar, Chili Crisp, Basil Pesto... I mean seriously the options are ENDLESS. Sweet, salty, savory, you name it. I will admit, it's a bit overwhelming because you want to try it all especially because they're all beautifully displayed. Even after you pick the spread, you still have to choose from one of the many different bagel options too so.. that's the hard part - making choices! There is seating available both in and outside. It's within a great walking distance and easily visible / accessible. Love, love, love!! I'm not from NYC, I was visiting so I will be missing this place whole heartedly - until next time! read more

See all

Best bagels in NYC! Great service, fresh toppings! The Protein Sandwich bagel- excellent Vegetarian-Yum! read more

Bagel dreams come true here. Great bagels with so many creative cream cheeses to choose from. Good texture. Fast service. Clean environment. Can't go wrong. read more

Bagel Pub - So many choices! - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

This is regarding the 1385 Broadway, New York, NY 10018 location. On three occasions, I received the wrong bagels. I ordered a whole wheat sesame bagel but got a white sesame bagel; I requested a pumpernickel bagel but received a poppy seed bagel; and asked for a toasted bagel, but it was not toasted. Perhaps the cashier has difficulty hearing orders, or a microphone could help ensure they hear customers correctly. This experience was very disappointing. read more

Honestly I loved my sandwich here and was pleasantly surprised. This is my new go to lox bagel sandwich spot for lunch during the work week. Ingredients are fresh and the texture of the bagel was good. Also the everything bagel seasoning was heavy on garlic which I absolutely loved and made this one a standout. The ratio of the toppings to salmon was also perfect. My only complaint is that the general service during lunch hour seems a bit disorganized from a getting your order perspective. The woman taking orders was great. Also wish my bagel was toasted more. read more

Bagel Pub - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

See all

This place is amazing! The bagels are giant and delicious. They have a really cool display of various cream cheese flavors along with a few different types of smoked salmon that I had never seen before. The customer service was fantastic. I can't say enough good things about this place. I wish I could give them 6 stars. read more

See all

My friend and I stopped in here by chance. The cafe we initially were gonna go to was packed and this was right across the street. We honestly walked in at the perfect time because by the time we ordered our food and sat at a table it was PACKED in there. This pub was super interesting and had the most unique mix of bagel spreads. I ordered the Greek salad with avocado and a side of bacon. And for $12 the portion was insane. I asked for a second bow to split it in half and it still made two pretty large salads. That was a steal honestly. My friend ordered the everything bagel with tuna salad on one side and the garlic and herb cream cheese on the other side. If I wasn't limiting my carbs I definitely would've gotten a bagel/sandwich because I'm so serious, there were some amazing cream cheese spread combos. It's honestly like a deli pub hybrid as far as vibe so I can't really speak to the service or general atmosphere. It was just very busy, but that's just New York I guess. The portions were great and we enjoyed what we ordered. read more

See all

The works, scooped, on a toasted egg everything with scallion cream cheese. I ate it three days in a row because it was that good. And with the side of an iced latte it was... Perfection. We tried multiple bagels with our group including blueberry and the ABC bagel. All were great, and all their espresso drinks and their fresh OJ were hits as well. My biggest criticism was I ordered some uncut bagels to bring home and they were just thrown unwrapped into a big square brown bag alongside all of our wrapped sandwiches. I had difficultly finding a way to transport them to travel. I wish the staff had at least put them in their own paper bag. read more

Second time to this location and the ABC bagel sandwich was once again delicious! They pick perfectly ripened avocado. The bacon is crispity and the cheddar is the right amount on the scrambled eggs and in between the warm toasted everything bagel. Delicious! Good service! Good coffee! And a variety of milks to add to your coffee ! read more

See all

A very solid bagel place with tons of flavored cream cheese options, and other sandwiches that can easily fill your belly. The location is perfect close to a few subway stops and they move the line quickly if you're in a rush to get in and out. Their prices are reasonable and they have a nice ambience. read more

Bagel Pub - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

The strawberry cream cheese tasted so artificial :( Leo's in fidi reigns supreme, was hoping to find a closer option though read more

Pretty good, wish that they had jalopeno cheddar bagels. Limited seating, not the friendliest service. read more

I had a very frustrating experience at Bagel Pub. When I walked in, I was greeted and handed a menu after being asked if I wanted one. After that, I stood waiting at the counter for at least five minutes before anyone acknowledged me or asked what I wanted. When someone finally did, I told the woman I wanted 15 bagels and asked the price. She told me they were $2 each. As I started listing the bagels I wanted, she stopped me and walked away. She came back, I started over, and then she walked away again. When she returned with an order pad, I had to start my order from the beginning for a third time. As I continued, I asked how many bagels we were up to. She said 11, so I listed a few more. Instead of simply telling me we had reached 15, she said, "So you want 16?" By that point, after repeatedly being interrupted and having to restart my order multiple times, I was frustrated and decided to leave without making a purchase. Good customer service is about paying attention, communicating clearly, and respecting a customer's time. Unfortunately, I didn't experience any of those things during my visit. read more

Bagel Pub was efficient and absolutely lived up to the hype. Setting: Classic neighborhood bagel shop with a classic pub theme - quite the concept, I enjoyed it. Service: Easy, kind, and welcoming--made grabbing breakfast a breeze. Food: Bagels were pillowy with the perfect crisp when toasted, paired beautifully with their cream cheeses. I tried the Chipotle bacon cream cheese, and the cucumber dill; as for bagels I tried: classic, cinnamon raisin, blueberry, and everything bagels. Definitely excited to come back and try more flavors! read more

Bagel Pub - Chipotle bacon cream cheese - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

See all

I'm a total sucker for bagels with a thick slab of cream cheese, and Bagel Pub has officially won my heart with their extensive spread selection. This time around, their bagels felt even fluffier and fresher than I remembered. Don't be shy about asking for cream cheese samples--they're super generous with the scoops!! Shout out to Stephanie who gave me incredible recommendations :) ＊Fresh Lox #3 with Lemon Whipped CC I was recommended this uncommon combo, and it actually worked!? The lemon spread added a bright and citrusy contrast that balanced with the smoked salmon. If I tasted the lemon spread by itself, it was refreshing and zesty! ＊ABC Omelette Bagel One of their bestsellers from the many lunch options on the menu. It was not only visually appealing but also delicious and filling!  ＊Blueberry Bagel w. Mixed Berries CC Even though I usually go for savory, their sweet cream cheese completely won me over. I also tried their special blueberry crumb spread and it was so fruity.  ＊Pumpernickel Bagel w. Lox Spread Their lox spread is packed with salmon chunks. Such a good value if you're craving lox without wanting to splurge on a lox bagel. ＊Sesame Bagel w. Tofu Scallion Spread They offer non-dairy tofu spreads like tofu lox, tofu scallion, and tofu veggie. It is lighter than regular cream cheese. Their sesame bagel is also fluffier. I just wish they had a sweet tofu option too! ＊Coco Loco Juice, Fresh Orange Juice As a bagel shop, their drink menu is surprisingly extensive. All the juices are freshly squeezed with real fruit, and my favorite was the Coco Loco, which was a mix of coconut water, strawberry, and pineapple. ＊Iced Blueberry Matcha, Iced Banana Latte I tried their most popular drinks, and I was pleasantly surprised that both lattes weren't overly sweet! read more

See all

I was walking around and stumbled across Bagel Pub. I went in on a whim and ordered their special (ABC: avocado, bacon, and cheese), which also came with a hash brown on the side. It feels a little overwhelming inside, so I would suggest knowing what you want before you walk in. The guy taking my order did not seem very friendly, but it was fine. The place is small and busy, so waiting for my bagel was a little rough since there is not really anywhere to stand without being in the way. The bagel itself was just okay. Maybe I did not order the right combination, but it did not feel like anything special which was honestly kind of disappointing. They do have a lot of different spreads, but not many bagel options. The hash brown was pretty standard. I also chose not to get a coffee, which was included in the special, but still had to pay for one. I guess that is reasonable, but not ideal. Overall, I feel like I could have found something better for less. read more

Bagel Pub - ABC Bagel - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Very very great lox bagels! Stopped by twice and tried Fresh Lox #1 and Fresh Lox #2! Get #1 if you want something that has a zing since it's their dill cream cheese. Get #2 if you want something overall more refreshing. Great vibe and service here. Food came out fast - couldn't complain. read more

Bagel Pub - Fresh Lox #2 - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

Favorite bagel shop in NY! Surprised it is not more popular on Yelp, but glad to keep as a hidden gem. I got their lox on garlic bagel and it was SO good. Besides it being huge, and filled with generous amount of lox & cream cheese, their bagel tasted amazing. As mentioned, they are generous in their portion so I ended up eating half and taking the rest back. The shop is intimate in size, but one of the cleaner bagel shops in NY, so we really enjoyed dining inside. It was pretty busy, so we were fortunate to find a seat. The selection of cream cheese and food items were tempting to purchase, if only I was a resident! Also enjoyed their iced coffee. Would definitely come back when I visit NY again. read more

See all

Good bagel spot, had a really nice egg everything with scallion cream cheese and bacon. Would come again. read more

Bagel Pub - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

Enormous bagels -- great for lunch. Insane variety of cream cheese flavors! All priced the same so you can get creative with combinations guilt-free. Their sandwiches are huge and could stretch to 2 meals. I also brought a few untoasted bagels home and they kept really well in the fridge for a few days. read more

Bagel Pub - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

Definitely a good place to get a bagel in NYC. When we got there, the line was very long, but they are quick so definitely know what you want to get before you get up to order. I got the bacon, egg, and cheese on an everything bagel with jalapeño cilantro cream cheese. It was huge but so worth it! I also ordered the iced banana latte. I love how it's real banana and not the artificial stuff. Made the latte taste 10 times better! read more

Bagel Pub - Iced Banana Latte - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Great location and surprisingly not busy! Staff is super nice and funny too! Love the Bagel pub and my bagel was bomb! read more

Bagel Pub - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

See all

On my most recent trip to NY, I tried Bagel Pub for my very first time. Bagel Pub had a beautiful variety of spreads, which made it difficult to decide which one we wanted! We resorted to the Cinnamon Raisin Bagel with Chocolate Chip CC, and Blueberry Bagel with Strawberry CC. Both were absolutely delicious in quality and taste. The ambiance was so relaxing and not too over crowded, although it was hard to get a seat and actually sit to eat. Overall, I would return back to this bagel shop and would recommend it to anyone who is traveling there! read more

Bagel Pub - Section with all the CC Spreads. - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

Amazing bagels. So many cream cheese options. Best lox I've ever had. Friendly staff. 10/10 Would come again!! read more

Bagel Pub - Cream cheese, lox bagel - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Great breakfast spot in the city! Bagels and coffee are top notch! They have a big selection of cream cheese for everyone, and their sandwiches are amazing! Service here is 10/10; friendly, welcoming, and helpful! The pub itself is warm and comfortable feeling, and great music playing throughout the place. If you're wanting an authentic New York bagel, and want to enjoy it in a chill atmosphere, this is the spot! read more

DelectAble Grub At The Bagel Pub... My bagel prayers have been answered with this better than good bagel spot in walking distance from my midtown office. It is a tight dining, order area and check out area but it usually moves pretty quick. The order takers are cool, patient, welcoming and very considerate. The check out employees are nice and efficient. I have been lucky (or is it PB's consistency) with every bagel with golden-brown, slightly crisp crust that gives way to a chewy, dense interior with just the right amount of elasticity. I have several favorites at Bagel Pub. My usuals are BEC, Cinnamon raisin bagel with cinnamon raisin walnut cream cheese and lox with cream cheese and capers. I recently tried a nutella cream cheese and it was delicious. Bagel Pub has become my favorite go to bagel spot in NYC. read more

See all

Do not visit to New York my husband and I want to try as many bagel shops as possible. Bagel pub was on our list and we decided to give them a try. And we were not disappointed. My husband ordered the sausage egg and cheese and I ordered the locks With cream cheese. Both were absolutely delicious. The bagels are crispy and soft all at the same time. Although there was a bit of a line, the young lady at the register took everyone's order very quickly. The restaurant is cute and tiny, and they have window seating available for some good people watching as you eat your food. I would definitely come back and give them a try. read more

Bagel Pub - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

See all

first bagel stop in nyc! I was presently surprised with the serving size. I shared half of my lox and was still full. I love that the avocado balances the smoked salmon and the onion + tomatoes give it a freshness. Service was great and fast. There's plenty of seating and they let you grab your own iced water! read more

See all

An huge selection of bagels and an amazing selection of cream cheese choices. Delicious and quick service. read more

Bagel Pub - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

Love a good bagel and the decor and staff here was amazing. It's hard to find a good everything egg bagel and bagel pub hit it out of the park. The cream cheese that I got on my bagel was amazing just to write amount of vegetables. Really enjoyed this place. Great breakfast if you're in the area. read more

See all

NY is literally known for their bagels but this place serves some pretty good ones. First of all, the concept is just too cute - a literal bagel shop in a pub!?!?!! We placed food order at the counter then headed to the register to pay and order any other drinks we wanted. I got a whole wheat bagel with lox and cream cheese and iced coffee. My hubby got the fresh lox #1 with an americano. Everything was around $40 plus tip. We luckily snagged a seat while waiting for our food. The bagel itself was good and had the nice chew you want in a bagel. Of course, the cream cheese is thick - though I've seen other bagel places give it thicker. Just beware for all my lactose girlies and take your lactaid beforehand! The lox serving was also pretty generous. Overall, a solid place for delicious bagels! read more

Bagel Pub - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Tasty bagels with a beautiful display of cream cheese selections. I enjoyed a sesame bagel with plain cream cheese but will be back when I want to try another variety. read more

Bagel Pub - Sesame Bagel with Plain Cream Cheese - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Very cool vibe - huge bagel case and limited seating, but cozy. Bagels were super. Service was efficient. I asked for a plastic bag to take bagels back home, and the guy individually wrapped them in plastic! Now that's service! read more

Bagel Pub - Behind the case - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Was in NYC so I needed to make sure to get an authentic bagel. This place was a short 5 minute walk from my hotel so I gave it a try. I was impressed to see the windows being cleaned as I was walking up. Surrounded by squalor, it showed they cared. It was not busy, as NYC was recovering from the Knicks championship the night before. The menu can be a little overwhelming since there are a lot of choices. One thing they should consider adding is a steak option, which they could charge a good amount for. I ordered a western breakfast sandwich bagel and an iced caramel latte. The cashier asked what kind of bagel I wanted. I wasn't sure and asked what was good. She suggested sesame or everything. I wanted to taste the bagel and the fillings so I went sesame. I was great. Warm, and filling. I could really tell the bagel was fresh and the peppers, egg and cheese made a great combo with the ham. It was filling, I could have eaten half and just saved the rest or shared with my wife. Since I was alone and didn't want to carry half I sandwich around the city, I fought to finish the rest. It was delicious. The latte was good, probably a little too sweet, but I asked for it sweet so that was on me. Chill vibe with oldies playing. Lots of options. I have to try some lox and loaded before I leave town. read more

See all

Bagel pub is always the most convenient bagel spot for whenever I'm craving one randomly after a workout class or need a bite before going somewhere but it never disappoints! My everything bagel with egg whites, avocado, and bacon scallion cream cheese was like $12 total but the bagel they gave me was pretty huge. I'm also a fan of the honey siracha cream cheese. Kinda pricey but consistently good read more

Bagel Pub - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Cute little place with great bagels! We had to have some New York style bagels and this place hit the spot! A friendly person takes your order and it's ready in a jiffy. We sat by the window to enjoy my lox special#3 and my sister had one of bagels with a specially cream cheese. Chewy and delicious. read more

See all

The ordering system is really bad when I order online bagels are made immediately when I show up in person different story. It took 25 minutes just to get a toasted bagel with eggs and cream cheese. I see all the Internet orders being pumped out as I wait 25 minutes for a bagel that was ordered in person to be completed. also looks like too many chefs in the kitchen too many people stepping on each other's toes. I'm really rooting for this place... but they haven't changed in months read more

Best blueberry bagels per my husband, and the salmon, cream cheese with the sesame bagels was perfect! First time to NYC and they did not disappoint! Gotta be ready to order fast and hope to get a table when it's raining... it was so good we stopped in on our return layover from Europe... had the cinnamon raisin with the walnut cream cheese (it was approximately 12 degrees outside so we ran back to our hotel and forgot photos of that beauty!) read more

Bagel Pub - Happy Hubby! - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

See all

10/10 bagel with tons of cream cheese options and the iced banana latte was literally the best coffee I've ever had