Edgartown Diner

I was very excited to try out a new lunch spot while in town for work this past week. The space…read moreitself is adorable and the vibes are very home cooked meal which I loved. For lunch our crew ordered the veggie cake Benedict, Vineyard Benedict, veggie breakfast sandwich, cod cakes, grilled cheese and yogurt granola bowl. There wasn't a single item we wouldn't order again. They also had one of the crispiest cokes I have ever had the delight to taste. I have tried the yogurt granola bowls at lots of spots on Martha's Vineyard and this one was by far my favorite. My friend that ordered the lobster roll said it was outstanding and we all loved how crispy the bread/English muffins were. I loved Lucky Hank's and can't wait to come back for lunch and to try their dinner menu!

On today's adventure of eating my way through the Vineyard, I stopped at Lucky Hanks -- a small,…read morecozy spot with about 30 seats that feels like a true local favorite. I went with their cod cakes and eggs, served up with lobster sauce, two fried-over-easy eggs, home fries, and multigrain toast. First time ever having cod cakes, and they didn't disappoint -- light, well-seasoned, and surprisingly addictive. The lobster sauce gave it that extra richness without overpowering the dish. The home fries were crisp without being greasy, and the multigrain toast rounded it out nicely. This wasn't just a solid breakfast -- it's one I'll be adding to my own kitchen playbook. In fact, I'll be trying to whip this up for my wife when we get back home. Verdict: A strong bite, definitely worth the stop if you're on the Vineyard. I eat, I judge. The fork stops with me -- your feelings aren't on the menu.

Interior

French toast

See all

Crispy Coke

Rosewater Market & Take Away

4.3(139 reviews)

The coffee here is really solid. The espresso is typically well dialed in and the espresso itself…read morehas a classic nuttiness with notes of milk chocolate and honey. The taller Brazilian guy who works FOH (typically behind the espresso machine) is super nice and kind but everyone else that works up front by the registers are not as friendly. They have a wide variety of pastry's. The patio is amazing with plenty of seating and there's quite a bit of seating inside as well!

Friendly staff. Great food - fresh and yummy . Clean restaurant (and restroom). Recommended!read more

Inside

Avocado toast

See all

Great Harbor Market

4.0(6 reviews)

0.5 mi

Yea.... Who knew that "gas station" pizza would be a good thing! Located and situated between an…read moreintersection just leaving the town of Edgartown, MA. "Grandma " style - thick crust, fluffy dough and the pizza is so large that two people have at least two meals. Downside: limited available times that they make the pizza. Love love love!!!

A good candidate for a well-kept secret option for tasty prepared fare to enjoy during all three…read moremeals of the day. Worth seeking out past the gas station exterior and initial convenience store offerings when you first come inside. My current entree favorites are pre-made alfredos and curried dinner entrees, generally available most days of the week. Friends have recommended the breakfast sandwiches, but I have yet to try them. Pricing is thankfully more modest than the meals' sit-down equivalents, and depending on your level of hunger, they can easily be enjoyed for a second meal as well.

Grandma style Margherita with added chicken.

See all

Dock Street Coffee Shop

4.1(79 reviews)

•$

My husband and I arrived right at the 1:30 closing time. We had been searching for a place to eat…read morethat was open off season. We were unaware that the restaurant closed at 1:30. It still had many people at the counter enjoying their breakfast and lunch choices. I ordered a grilled ham and cheese sandwich. My husband ordered an omelet. BEST grilled ham and cheese ever! I've never had so much ham in a sandwich. The 3 women working the kitchen were quick, efficient and skilled. We were the last to leave. That's when I saw their hours posted. We were never rushed. So glad we found this place. We will be back.

Looking for breakfast looking for a fun place to eat instead of some fancy imase five star…read morerestaurant in Edgartown is where you can take your family go on a morning date and watch some hard workers put together some basic but very yummy items. They take credit cards over $10 but I'm sure they welcome cash more with a nice tip. The service is quick and everything's made fresh right in front of your eyes like a couple feet away from your eyes actually everything's tight and fun good music in the background if you're in Edgartown and looking for a quick to go order and it's before 1:30 PM this is your spot

French toast

Bacon Mac

See all

Menu

Behind The Bookstore

3.5(265 reviews)

I was in town for work this week with several colleagues and we dined at Behind the Bookstore…read moreseveral times for both breakfast and lunch. Service was fast and friendly and they have some of the best coffee in town. We loved the avocado salad, quinoa bowl, avocado toast and cheesy scramble. Such a great easy option in town!

We stopped into this cute little spot for coffee. Their caramel latte and red eye were tasty and…read morethe perfect late morning pick me up. The seating area was extremely cool, such a fun vibe and area to hang out in.

"Italian Toast" (basil ricotta spread, tomato & garlic confit, prosciutto, fig balsamic glaze, sourdough)

See all

Cool space

Blackbird Cafe

4.0(2 reviews)

Nice small clean cafe. Friendly service staff. I was told although didn't partake the coffee is…read morevery good. I ordered breakfast sandwiches for takeout. One of each sausage, ham, and bacon 4/5. The ingredients are good quality, but they needed a condiment to make them great.

A great coffee spot in Edgartown! The coffee is good, and the food is quick service. It's right…read morenext to Murdock's fudge, so you get to peak into the fudge place while you have your coffee and snacks.

Inside

Breakfast sandwich

See all

Inside

Biscuits

4.0(291 reviews)

5.2 mi

Great service ,, I ordered the…read more MV Sunrise Two eggs, cheese grits, & choice of toast or a biscuit.

I recommend getting there early as the wait was 15 min but can get much longer since it's in a…read moreprime location. The Cod Eggs Benedict was good! Simple meal with good flavors. The potatoes didn't add much to the dish honestly. I also ordered a hazelnut iced coffee which was less than average in my opinion, but I don't like sweet drinks personally.

Honey chicken biscuit

See all

The Art Cliff Diner

3.9(307 reviews)

6.2 mi

Food, service, and ambiance was excellent! Staff were prompt and friendly. Highly recommend…read morechecking this place out.

This restaurant is a Vineyard institution but is always crazy busy during the summer. We came in…read moreearly October for lunch, and got right in. What a charming place! So cute inside and loved the counter and kitchen visibility. The menu is varied and interesting. My husband had the "Cobb Salad" which was delicious, but I'm not sure why they call it a Cobb. Definitely different ingredients than a traditional one. We asked for extra dressing on the side, which it definitely needed. I had the fried chicken & waffles with hot honey (a special) and it was amazing!! It came with 3 large and 1 small piece of boneless chicken, and my only complaint is that 2 of the pieces were hot, and 2 were lukewarm. And they were out of iced tea. But definitely recommend.

Cute interior, with some counter seating.

Fried chicken and waffles with hot honey. So good!

See all

Seating

Espresso Love

3.6(180 reviews)

0.0 mi

I've been coming to this spot since 2020, and every experience has been exceptional from the…read morecustomer service to the food. This visit (8/17/25) was EXTREMELY different. First, it started with my smoothie order. I wanted a mango smoothie and I was told only berrilicious was available. Moments later, my friend had a mango smoothie. Very interesting that she was able to get one and I wasn't. That was a lapse in actually checking first, since he didn't know. Then, I ordered a sweet potato, black bean burger. When I started to consume the burger, I noticed that it was very burnt on the outside and undercooked on the inside not a desirable bite and it was bland. I requested another sandwich because it's a high chance it'll come out the same way, I'd rather have a tuna salad on a roll. The server then asked my name for the order (2) more times. Then, said she needed to talk to her manager about changing it. She speaks to her manager in Spanish and not talking good about me. Assuming that I don't understand Spanish as a Black woman or American. After five minutes she handed me a hot sandwich. I asked what it was, she said it's the tuna sandwich you asked for (which also had burnt toast). I responded I don't want it like this and you didn't take my order. You said you needed to speak to your manager. She cuts me off and says well what do you want? At this point a refund because your customer service is horrible. I know this is not the norm because the way the workers were looking at her and apologized to me, I knew this was out of character for this establishment. Within two minutes, another manager handled it the way it should have been, an apology for a burnt burger and an immediate action to remedy the situation (refund). That is the only reason I will return, but the server and the manager speaking bad about a customer in Spanish, is a poor look for this place. If it happens again, I will know better, and have a lot more to say because I won't be disrespected, but I will return for now.

Cute cafe. Service was good. The hummus wrap was overpriced but was fresh and tasted good. Chai was…read moreunsweetened and tasted good. Love the outdoor patio.

Turkey Club Sandwich

See all

Daily specials

MacPhail's Corner Cafe

3.8(50 reviews)

•$

Delicious lobster roll. Amazing flavor. Big chunks of lobster. Sticker shock at $32 for 1 sandwich…read more(I've been away from New England for many years) but what else can you expect on the island?! It was worth every single bite though. Friendly staff. Small little hole in the wall but just grab your Sammies and go eat by the ocean. Definitely recommend!

Best and LARGEST lobster roll on the island. Hefty warm roll filled with chilled, large chunks of…read morelobster salad. So amazing I wanted to go back for another. If you really want to treat yourself, get the frozen Arnold Palmer (frozen lemonade with iced tea) or the old school Stewart's root beer.