PROS: loads of parking, spacious inside, amazing atmosphere representing the 50s, prices were good, menu variety was plentiful, staff was friendly CONS: they should play 50s music in the background. When we went, half the time there was no music and when there was it was 2000s elevator music OVERALL: forget the lack of music; I recommend coming here! It's a better 50s themed diner than Johnny rockets read more

See all

Black owned restaurant in Edgar town. Great food in the main district. The servers were very attentive and stayed busy taking care of everyone in their stations. The restaurant was very retro giving you an old school experience. You need to visit if in Martha Vineyards. The food was good too read more

See all

This place is a must stop! We never miss an opportunity to visit the friendliest staff on the island with the best breakfast on the island. There's nothing else like it in MV. The 50s diner theme is great for the whole family. You'll be happy you went. read more

We stopped for brunch on a rainy Sunday morning at just the nick of time--5 more minutes and there was a line out the door, but we had no wait at all. Service was prompt and cheerful, the food was great, and the prices exceptionally reasonable. read more

We have been coming here every year when we visit the Island. Consistently fresh and good. read more

Friendly service, delicious breakfasts, hash, grits...all the oldies! Heart of town, easy access, fun ambiance.

For my 60th birthday, I chose to have breakfast with my family at the Edgartown Diner. When we arrived, we had to wait about 15 minutes for a table to become available, which seemed reasonable for a busy Saturday morning, but that was when the good time ended. We were taken to our table and had to wait about 15 minutes before the waitress came to take our order. It took at least 30 - 45 minutes for our food to arrive. Needless to say, my food (scrambled eggs, cheddar grits and sausage) was very lukewarm and BLAND when it arrived. I wish the restaurant all the best. But I will not be returning. read more

Service took about an hour total from arrival to leave for a diner kinda long but the food was as expected and the service was friendly. read more

Edgartown Diner - Menu - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

See all

My husband and I had the most disappointing dining experience this morning. We have supported this diner since it opened but today's service and food were terrible. After being seated we watched 4 tables being served their food that arrived more than 20 minutes after us. The first problem was that the diner was understaffed with only 2 waitresses for a capacity crowd. When I complained about the long delay the waitress, hostess said that it's always like this. She literally stood over me justifying why the poor service should be expected. I actually had to tell her that I did not want to argue was simply asking why we had been there over an hour and not served. We will NO Longer support this poorly run diner. To add insult to injury, the biscuits were cold read more

Such a cute hidden spot! Food was very good, and service was fast and very welcoming. Definitely recommend! read more

See all

The food is as expected, classic interior design. Now the service: it took almost an hour from sitting down to until the food is arrived. We have to ask for water, utensils after half an hour, while the customer next to us was provided with drinks and napkins as soon as she was seated. We waited outside for an hour, then half an hour inside no one came to check on us not even a glass of water. We got the wrong drink the first time. The whole crew seems very busy but not really doing their jobs effectively. read more

Our tour bus dropped us off not far from the diner so we thought it was a good option since we had only 45 minutes. It took about 10-15 minutes for someone to stop at our table to take our order. Even though we told them we only had 45 minutes, our lunch was still not served with 5 minutes remaining. We were able to get order to go and make it to bus. What a waste of time. read more

Hubby and I ate here early am before our flight back home. You might miss if you are entering from main, you have to walk through the cinema all the way to the back. Upon opening the door you are instantly transported to a 1950s diner. Oldies were playing and every inch of the wall is donned with diner memorabilia. I ordered the Belgian waffle with fresh strawberries and whipped cream. It was amazing. Crispy on the outside and warm and fluffy on the inside. My husband got the Philly omelette w/ skillet potatoes and homemade biscuits. He finished everything, even the potatoes. Plot twist....he doesn't like potatoes. I think that says it all, enter freely they've been approved read more

Edgartown Diner - Belgian waffle w/strawberries and whipped cream - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

The food here is very good! It's truly a diner style eating and ordering. You will have a bit of a wait (15-20 minutes), but the service is fast. It's recommended you review the menu as you wait, so you can order quickly. That helps them stay efficient with the waiting time. They offer brunch cocktails but not the best mix. There is not a bathroom within the restaurant. You have to ask for the key and go in the hallway. The parking is also limited, so it's best to grab parking where you find it, and walk over. The best for me were the home fries. I added peppers and tomatoes. They will accommodate substitutions and add ons for an up charge. read more

See all

Friendly, fast, and reasonable for EDG. Get the whipped cream and real maple syrup. Just do it. read more

Edgartown Diner - Waffle with fruit - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

Great food and environment. Definitely recommend! We decided to have breakfast for lunch and it was delicious!

So good, we went two days in a row! Ms. Esther is so inviting from the moment you walk in. She graciously accommodated my family including our two kids and had great food recommendations. We enjoyed the (Irish) coffee, hot chocolate, Ralston French toast, home fries, omelettes, and the cornbread just to name a few of our selections. Everything was delicious, and everyone was so nice making this a "must do" when you visit MV. 10/10 highly recommend! read more

So welcoming. We had breakfast here every day. Must have- cornbread, chicken waffles, shrimp & grits, and Southern Bennies! Service is the best! read more

Edgartown Diner - Stuffed french toast croissant - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

See all

Stopped here for lunch while in Edgartown with my son. We needed a break from seafood so we were happy with the diner. My son ordered a burger and I ordered the corn beef breakfast. I got a corn bread with my breakfast instead of biscuit or toast. The corn bread was the best part of my food. Slightly sweet and toasty. I could eat it everyday. We both enjoyed our food. The diner inside is adorable. I loved the decorations. I felt like I was actually in a 50's diner. Our waitress was nice. Highly recommend for a meal in edgartown if you need a seafood break! read more

See all

Really nice little diner. The food is really solid. We got the All American with eggs (perfectly) poached and the banana bread French toast. This unique twist on the classic recipe is awesome! Service, like everywhere we'd been on the island, was great and the people are super friendly. Maybe the "bad service" reviews of restaurants come at the height of summer when there are 900 gazillion people here. We didn't experience that anywhere and Edgartown Diner is no exception. The only reason we didn't go back is just because we wanted to try different breakfast places. Go. You'll love it!! read more

Edgartown Diner - Banana bread French toast - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

Cute small diner was busy. Food was tasty. Came out quickly. Real diner feel. Servers fast and friendly. Great stop for reasonably priced breakfast. read more

Edgartown Diner - #5. Eggs Bennie and ##2. All American - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

See all

This reminded me of a local Ruby's diner as the interior definitely had the classic diner feel to it. The staff were very friendly including our waitress, who was super nice and attentive during our stay. Amongst the group, we ordered the hash and egg omelet and chicken and waffles. The hash was okay but you can tell it was definitely from a can and was somewhat salty. Our favorite thing was the breakfast potatoes as they were flavorful and not overpowering with salt or pepper. The specialities and omelette come with biscuit, banana bread, and corn bread which they all make in house. However all three were very dry. The location is very central in Edgartown and next to the movie theater and Alchemy Bistro and Bar which is where we ate dinner one night. Overall this wasn't our favorite breakfast place in MV but the customer service made up for it. read more

Edgartown Diner - Hash and Egg Omelet - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

Went for brunch and got a Pastrami Burger and the Farmers Omelette. The burger was juicy and was a unique combination with the pastrami that worked well. The omelette was good but the home fries that came with it were just unseasoned potatoes with some of them being not fully cooked through. The waiter was super nice and it had an old school diner vibe which was cool but other then that there was nothing super special that made it stand out. read more

Edgartown Diner - Pastrami Burger and Farmers Omelette - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

Great food, great service! It felt like an old school diner. We will definitely be back there if we make it back to Martha's Vineyard.

In town for the weekend and the food was yummy. Standard bacon and eggs-cooked to perfection. Banana bread French toast-outstanding. Cute atmosphere took you back to your childhood. read more

Great Service ,, great atmosphere,, and very clean. Polite. Excellent location. Parking in the rear , if available. read more

See all

4 of us ate breakfast around 10:15. There were several booths and tables available at that time. It's a little tricky to find, as you see the sign from the street, but once inside you have to head down a corridor. It is in the same building as the theatre. Our server was attentive and friendly. The coffee, veggie omelette, eggs, corned beef hash, corn bread were good. Nothing special, your basic breakfast. The decor is fun, retro and they nailed the diner atmosphere. read more

This place might be popular, but it's hard to see why. While our waitress was friendly, the overall experience was frustrating. Service was painfully slow -- we waited over an hour for a fairly simple order, and one of the dishes still came out wrong. From the time we arrived to when we finally left, more than two hours had passed, much of it spent waiting: first for a table, then to place our order, and then again for the food to arrive. The restaurant appears seriously understaffed, and the quality of the food didn't justify the wait -- it was mediocre at best. There are far better ways to spend your time and money. read more

Took 40 minutes to get our food. Pancakes were dry. Staff was aloof. Prices were ok. I know this is a landmark but not good.

Good food. Casual atmosphere. Quick breakfast and friendly staff. Perfect for a summer morning. Highly recommend. read more

See all

Wifey and I arrived on Martha's Vineyard and our daughter suggested we try this place, she and her boyfriend had eaten here on their trip to the vineyard, The diner is located in the same building as the movie theater (quirky). After walking down a long corridor and made a left we found the entrance to the diner ( if you go right then you will be at the movie theatre). When you enter the diner you get a 50's 60's vibe (more quirky). They are open for breakfast & lunch 8am-2pm. The servers were very friendly. I tried the shrimp and cheese grits, my wife tried the fish and chips( she actually had sweet potato fries). The 8 large shrimps were well seasoned however they were a little over cooked( overcooked can leave your shrimps a little tough and chewy, just a tip for you cooks out there). The cheese grits however were fantastic, order this and you'll need a nap afterwards. My wife said her fried cod was tasty even though the sweet potato fries were a little burnt. I would still suggest you give this place a try your'e bound to find something appealing on their menu. read more

See all

Old diner classic. Great food and service ! Laid back fun breakfast place. One of many choices and worth a stop. read more

This was our first visit to the Edgartown Diner. We were pleased with some aspects of our breakfast and were disappointed with others. I'm giving it 4 stars due to the vast menu offerings; I look forward to trying some of their other dishes. The diner's decor is like stepping back in time; they did a wonderful job with the look though the lights and fans are getting a bit tattered. The service was good and bad: our server had little time for us and tossed dishes into the bus bin which rattled most everyone in the restaurant. Perhaps she was having a bad day? The food runner, however, was quite pleasant and offered to get us whatever else we needed. I ordered the Southern Bennie which is poached eggs on cornbread with gravy. My breakfast companion had the traditional bennie. Our poached eggs were spot on perfectly cooked. The cornbread was delicious and the chicken more moist than crispy - but still good. There wasn't much gravy on my dish so I asked for more; I would not do that again as the gravy did not have much flavor at all. The side of potatoes were good but nothing too special. Since our server was not very attentive, we decided to see how long we would have to sit there with dirty dishes on our table waiting for our check. After 17 minutes, she won and we gave up. We asked the other server to have ours meet us at the front so we could cash out. All-in-all, we enjoyed our meal and we'll be back to give it another try. read more

Edgartown Diner - They did a wonderful job with the decor. It's fun and comfortable. - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

See all

The decorations are so cute. We went close to closing time and still spent tons of time with us and the staff was great. Food was delicious and the fries were so crispy and good read more

Edgartown Diner - The decor. So cute - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

See all

super cute place, the food was traditional but delicious, and service was fast! both our waitress and the hostess were super friendly and polite. would absolutely recommend read more

Small place but a bit crowded at lunch time when buses are in town. Service was good, food tasty and great value in a very expensive place. Decor was a true diner experience. read more

Yes. Yes. Yes. Everything about this place is amazing. We happen to love classic diners and this place hits the mark. The service was prompt and friendly. The food was fantastic- maybe some of the best breakfast food I've had- and certainly my favorite breakfast place on the island. My boyfriend got the Southern Bennie and I cannot stress this enough: GET IT. Incredible. I had the typical eggs and breakfast meat platter which was perfect. I had my eggs poached (again, perfect). The decor is adorable. Can't wait to come back again! read more

Edgartown Diner - Decor - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

See all

Country Benedict was out of this world, eggs weren't runny but it was still amazing I'd def come back

Great place to get a meal on Martha's Vineyard. Reasonable prices and real homemade food! We all ordered breakfast without any complaints and nice size portions. The stall is great and very friendly! read more

Please do not go here. Slow and uninterested servers. Long waits. Food DREADFUL! Over easy eggs were rubbery and actually barely edible. Toast not really toasted. Bacon pre-cooked and like cardboard. Potatoes ok!! For a "diner", one generally expects a well cooked basic breakfast, but this was an epic fail!!! How does this place survive on this elegant setting???? read more