We put our names in later in the evening on a Thursday night in August. We were notified of our table just as we had received drinks at a bar where we were waiting. We told them this and they said they would hold the table. We arrived about 10 minutes later and were seated immediately, outside at the last table along the wall. It was a perfect, quiet, spot for the 5 of us! Our server, Summer was amazing. So friendly, so accommodating and a great representative for the restaurant. She made the experience even better. We shared some apps and the halibut special which was amazing and HUGE. The five of us shared this incredible special. The fish was perfectly cooked and the accompanying potatoes, salad and aioli were perfect! This was our first time there, we have been to the Port Hunter before. We will definitely come back!! read more

Absolutely loved this spot for dinner. I had been wanting to try The Covington for a while but we are usually dining as a group of six and the restaurant is pretty cozy with mostly 2 and 4 top tables. I finally got a chance to dine there with a friend during my most recent visit in late May and I was really delighted. The service was friendly and our waitress gave helpful recommendations on the menu but the food delivery was on the slower side. For dinner we shared the sweet potato rolls, smokes cauliflower, bolognese and the halibut. Favorite dish was far and away the smoked cauliflower. It was absolutely outstanding. The flavors and textures were perfection. The halibut and the pasta were also both great. Cannot wait to come back and try their other veggie dishes, mushroom ragu and pork chop which also looked very tempting. read more

See all

This is such a charming cozy spot for drinks and food! We sat at the bar and had excellent service. The staff was very knowledgeable and super friendly. The drinks were very well crafted. We shared the shrimp aquachile. It was delicious. Very fresh and serve with funky sesame rice chips. read more

Great cocktails from the mixologist!! But I have to say my tequila cocktail was 49 dollars heavy price for a cocktail read more

The Covington - Tequila martini with cherries - New American Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

The menu here is eclectic - there's some pasta, some Asian inspired dishes, some southern inspired dishes, etc. We got the bread service, sweet and spicy cucumbers, three sisters, bolognese, and mushroom ragu. The cucumbers were very good. Three sisters was creative but not our favorite because it was very squash heavy and had perhaps too many sauces. Overall, the prices are simply too steep - we live in Manhattan and can get better pasta dishes for less than the price Covington is charging. Service was fine. Friendly for the most part but he definitely forgot about us once we ordered our food, as he never checked in again. It was an ok experience read more

See all

This was a nice spot to grab a fancy dinner. The food was good, with standard options you'd expect. Love the ambiance and as expected service is stellar. read more

Outstanding. Completely outstanding. Who would've thought that a menu item as simple as a beet could be turned into such a culinary delight. They have a smoker in the kitchen and its only job throughout the day is just to smoke beets for their incredible beet salad. Are you kidding me???? That's the kind of attention to detail that this restaurant has and that every other restaurant should strive for. Details, like the servers knowing every inch of the menu. Details, like house baked sweet potato table bread. It was insane, totally insane. A perfect way to celebrate an anniversary weekend. Our server was a Serbian all star... every other server should take notes... it was a level above read more

The Covington - Sweet potato bread - New American Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

See all

Great meal, solid service. The cocktail menu had some nice twists, bread service was great apps/shared plates were on point. Particular shout out for three sisters "salad" which was a recommendation from server. Outstanding.. entrees were good but the apps and shared plates (smoked eggplant dip, beet salad, and 3 sisters) were the stars of the evening. Our booth table was a little tight for 4 people. An outside table would be the recommended spot if you can snag one. read more

We ate there last night. The food was fantastic and our waiter was sp professional and awesome. I was very upset at the hostess though for seating us at the very back when clearly there were so many other empty tables. When o asked , she said that they're reserved for 5he 5.30 and 6.00 o'clock reservations. We sat there and left at almost 6.20 and all those tables were still vacant. I didn't like the attitude and not sure why I felt like we were being judged in some way. Fyi, the prices are very high, although having been to cape cod many times, we're used to that part, but at least have some respect for every one. Wish I knew her name. Anyway I usually dont writr bad reviews but I was pretty upset. Honestly looking back we should have left. read more

Fabulous meal, wonderful and professional service, great atmosphere. We were on the patio, which is alongside the sidewalk. Might not appeal to all but we enjoy the people watching, and it added to our experience. The indoor dining room was certainly buzzing, so I'm sure they all were having a good time. I had the Nova Scotia halibut--deliciously seasoned and perfectly prepared. My sweetheart had the bolognese, which she said was delicious, and her son had the potato gnocchi, he said the ye tire was amazing, the texture was so light and airy. If we lived nearby, instead of in Virginia, we'd be here on a regular basis! We certainly hope to come back the next time our travels take us to the Island. read more

Aw man- so lucky to dine at this gem. We had reservations at another MV restaurant, but the time didn't work for us, so we called an audible and cancelled. Strolling through town, we came across this place, and wanted to take advantage of the beautiful weather and dine outside- we had to put our names down, so some not-just-window-shopping to kill some time, but got a corner table on the patio under the lights at night- lovely! Our server was super knowledgeable and recommended some dishes we otherwise would have never tried, and man, was that a good call! Their bread service and Three Sisters (the recommended dish with squash, beans, carrots, corn, saffron, romesco *chef's kiss*) were a great start, the Mushroom Ragu was delicious, and the cocktails were terrific (including the server-recommended gin). We'd be eager to return next time we're in Edgartown! read more

See all

I did not have very high expectations based off first glances at the menu, but WOW. The overall experience was amazing. All the seafood is caught the morning of, the produce has a shelf-life TAT of 3 days and all the pasta is made fresh, in-house. We had the best waitress, named Summer, who was so knowledgeable of the menu, and so sweet and friendly. The restaurant didn't seem super busy during a long weekend, which was super surprising considering how great everything was. I really enjoyed the dark and intimate ambiance. Highly recommend checking out The Covington while visiting Martha's Vineyard! read more

See all

All around horrible experience pasta bolognese-was tasteless and meatless Service was lacking to say the least and nowhere to be found Atmosphere was non existence as seated outside in far corner with view of nothing Overpriced and worst option in Edgartown where there ate so many better choices called and emailed but no effort to comp my $40 small bowl of tasteless pasta read more

The food was all delicious and the service was very attentive and kind, can't wait to go back!

Ok. First. The chef has some exceptional skills. We dined two years apart and experienced some excellent cuisine with consistency. The atmosphere is very different from inside to outdoor. Make reservations well in advance. The outdoor is a narrow walkway along the underhand of the building with a public park just I. Earshot so do not be surprised with young families at dusk making noise. The wine selection is creative and very quality. Enjoy a special night out. Alex is the server with the best stories and friendly attitude choose him. read more

See all

This would be a 3 star on food alone but the vibes and the service bring it up to a 4. The food felt pretty standard and nothing too special. The bread service was honestly the best part of the meal. However the restaurant was super cute with a nice garden patio area and the servers were so friendly. If you are more in it for the instagram pics rather than the food, this is the place. read more

The Covington - Bread service - New American Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

See all

The food and service is unmatched. Everytime we are on the island, we go here at least once if not twice a weekend. Get yourself the bolognese, spicy cucumbers and a Katama in the Afternoon (maybe 2). read more

Wait staff and manager are great, very professional. If you are a Celiac, you need to be careful. There are a lot GF options and they seem to understand the issues associated with cross contamination however.... I got very sick. I had a long talk with the waitress when ordering and was assured that everything I ordered was GF. Maybe it was a one off issue but I'm not taking a chance on that again. Sorry to say, I had very high hopes. read more

Attractive but casual looking place with food that belies the ambiance. Very innovative rich blends of flavors with every dish. We had the Three Sisters (a delightful modern twist on this ancient tradition) and the scallops for appetizers. Then the absolutely enormous halibut belly. Our server (Sarah) recommended it for two people and she was right. Simply amazing simply insane simply super intense dish. One the best fish courses I've ever had. Note the outside seating has terrible chairs so if you have a back problem ask to be placed indoors. The staff kindly moved us in after initially seating us on the patio. Thanks! read more

Based on the food experience I give it five stars! They change the menu weekly depending on the ingredients so you know the quality will be fresh. The clam chorizo bowl was rich in flavor. The pasta dish tasted like handmade pasta and all the flavors mixed well. The house made bread with garlic butter was crisp on the outside airy and soft inside. As for the service I had to give it 3.5 stars because the hostess didn't seem very eager to sit us because we had 3 kids. It was a relatively quiet week night with plenty of seating. The table service was standard. That said I will come again for the food. read more

The Covington - Green pasta with ricotta and procuitto. - New American Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

See all

We had an excellent meal here and really appreciated the service very much. We asked if we were ordering too much and the server quite honestly said yes and offered great recommendations for how to be more realistic. The food was excellent. We had a spicy cucumber dish which, while simple, was one of the most interesting and unusual dishes I've seen in a while. Slightly complaint: The acoustics aren't great, making it a bit difficult for my wife and I to hear one another. But the food was well worth it -- looking forward to going back. read more

We were immediately seated. The menu is organized in sequential way and clear. Very high in vegetarian options Partial favorites were the Spicy cucumber and kale salad. The entrees were good but not the highlight of the evening read more

See all

Tough review. I've eaten and enjoyed Covington over the years but not the recent visit. I had the seafood bucatini. The red sauce was bitter beyond belief and the seafood (lobster, clams - not sure there was much else even though it mentioned other types in the dish) were immensely dried out and tough / chewy. Okay if I was in a cheap restaurant I could hold my hands up and say I got what I deserved from a vat of this stuff, but not at $43-ish dollars. Also, the pasta was supper starchy and gooey. The bolognese was reasonable although it was a little light on flavor and meat. Most expensive plate of this I've bought $42. The kale salad starter was nice and the other started so-so. The waiter was nice - he ask how the food was, but didn't seem to get that we ate half of the seafood dish and said the bolognese was good, and the seafood was not what we expected. Smiled and walked away. read more

The Covington is not only one of my (now) favorite restaurants but one of my all-time favorites. There is nothing negative about it. The food, staff, and atmosphere were so good we ate there twice in three days! Summer and Trevor are amazing people and we instantly bonded with them. Trevor makes some of the best cocktails and non-alcoholic cocktails, period. If you are on this island this restaurant is a must. read more

As a tourist coming from the tri-state area (NJ/NY), The Covington was one for the books. On a busy Wednesday night in August, I was so glad our last minute walk-in worked out because a party with reservation canceled, it was meant to be. Our party of 4 were seated indoors and we felt very comfortable because there weren't many tables open for social distancing. The restaurant's ambiance was modern yet cozy. I felt kind of sad for the restaurant, unable to be used to their full capacity but safety first, of course. I could see the restaurant menu changes seasonally and was not too extended but it had a great amount of farm-to-table items, which is their specialty. From pasta, to fresh fish, to exotic salads, this place has something for everyone. There's plenty of gluten free and vegan/vegetarian options but don't let that discourage you. For starters, my partner and I shared the Island Farmstand salad. The salad was crafted with perfection with Martha Vineyard's grown produces. It was hard to recap all the ingredients composed in the salad but there were fresh corns, tomatoes, arugula in vinaigrette, cauliflower puree/crema and topped with roasted cheese bits. Whoever created this masterpiece should consider keeping this salad permanently on the menu (when in season). It took a while for our entrees to come but maybe it was because we ordered a huge roasted halibut for two. Our patience was tested especially when our appetites were opened up by a delicious salad. The roasted halibut belly and collar did not disappoint. The meat was fresh and had a right amount of tenderness. The side potatoes and corns were great pairings. The portion was large enough for two people. It was a great choice. Our couple friends ordered the mushroom ragu and shellfish brodo and they could tell how fresh the ingredients were. Mushroom ragu was their favorite. Overall, this high-end restaurant delivers fresh farm-to-table meals and the creators of the dishes know what they are doing. If you can only pick one restaurant to eat at on the island, this is the place. read more

See all

Really wonderful restaurant in Edgartown. Social distancing policies: excellent. The wait staff all wear their masks appropriately (over nose and mouth, not over chin) and the tables are quite spaced apart. There are a few tables out front but we actually sat in a row of tables along the side of the building, which I prefer because we don't get exposed to foot traffic. Menus are in paper. Food: really wonderful, our best meal in Edgartown. We shared the cacio e pepe(interesting take using squid ink pasta, which added a nice depth to the pasta; also really spicy, but in a good way), mushroom ragu (handmade pasta with a shiitake based sauce-really added a new dimension of earthiness to the dish) and the sole (really nicely seasoned, crispy on the outside, tender on the inside; also came with some lovely snap peas). Finished off our meal with a slice of honey pie, which was their take on an almond based pecan pie- really well done! Overall we truly had nothing bad to say about this place. I would recommend making reservations to try it out if you're in the area! read more

Stopped here after looking at a few other spots and so glad we did! Cool staff, nice atmosphere, but even better food! NY sirloin by far the best steak we've ever had. Tried to go the next day for the same meal and they were closed :( Would rate higher than 5 stars if we could! I'll be dreaming about that meal for the rest of my life... read more

Amazing food and service. Beautiful space. Highly recommend! So happy to discover this wonderful restaurant.

If you go to dinner anywhere in Martha's Vineyard- make it The Covington! First- the ambiance was cute, cozy, and trendy. The inside was beautiful/quaint and the patio was picturesque! The four of us shared the below dishes and the standouts were the Kale Salad, Bread + Butter, Bolognese, and Mushroom Ragu, but we truly enjoyed every dish. Spicy Cucumbers Bread + Butter Kale Salad Mushroom Ragu Bolognese Halibut Honey Pie Don't forget to make a reservation as soon as they are available! We went on a Friday at 5P (right at opening) they weren't even taking walk-ins. Need to go back ASAP!! read more

The Covington - Kale Salad, Spicy Cucumbers - New American Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

Ona a sailing cruise, best meal so far. Flavorful and distinctive food, not usual American fare. Wine great, service attentive.

I generally liked the food, but this restaurant is way too expensive for the quality of food and, especially, the quantity. I don't like these "small plate" style places in general, but this one was unusually small. Our group of 3 paid $200 before tip for what amounted to a few tiny and unsatisfying appetizers and a few drinks. One example- The "ham," listed as a "snack," was $20 for 4 tiny pieces. The snacks I am used to getting cost $5 and actually are enough calories to stave off hunger. The "entrees" were so crazy expensive that I didn't even think about ordering them. Paying a lot of money is okay if the food is awesome and you don't leave hungry. This restaurant fails as to both. The ceviche, all 3 teaspoonfuls served, was in fact good. read more

See all

We had an absolutely amazing experience here! Out of our 7 day vacation, we spent 3 of our nights here at The Covington and honestly wished we could have spent more. The ambience is wonderful, the service is out of this world, and the food is mouth-watering. Trevor gave such great service, we kept on wanting to come back. His creation of wonderfully crafted cocktails, personalized recommendations, and kind-hearted personality was refreshing for us amidst the typical Martha's Vineyard crowd. We left Alchemy to do another night here and it was the best decision. If you're looking for a great time, with genuine people and excellent food, this is the place to go. We can't wait to come back again #trevoristhebest read more

The Covington - The Clover Club - New American Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

We are tough critics. The clams and chorizo had a great umami flavor and broth with bread to dip. The mushroom pasta was great and the cod was nicely prepared with a decadent salad (with a lot of superfood vegetables which include radish, watercress) and a nice snap pea farro salad. The desserts were on the smaller side so it's definitely recommended to order your own. The chocolate dessert was rich dark chocolate cake with coffee and a raspberry sauce which my boyfriend described as delicious. I loved the honey pie which is a take on pecan pie. Desserts were incredible. Execution for the fish was spot on. The Pinot Noir was unique and recommended. The best dinner we had on the vineyard. read more

My mom picked this place out for our last dinner in Edgartown, we had been the year before and really enjoyed it! The ambiance inside the restaurant is very nice, there are cool wood planks across the ceiling with light peeking through, and pretty glass bottle lighting (although the space overall is a little dark). We made a reservation far in advance and got a nice table by the window. I highly suggest you make a reservation, otherwise you will probably get turned away. I'm a vegetarian and got a special vegetarian menu. Note this didn't have anything different on it from the regular menu, just listed out the vegetarian options. It's a good place for those with plant based diets. We shared the Mermaid Farm Feta Panzanella, and the green harissa was a really tasty unique touch. The peaches were great to although the dish could have used more of them! My MVM Mushroom Ragu was delicious, the mushrooms were perfect and you could tell the pasta was homemade. My mom ordered the Tuna which came plated with a large arugula bed underneath, she liked it. Our favorite part was desert however - Honey Pie! Homemade ice cream on top, crunchy almonds in the pie and fresh honey drizzle, yum! I'd like to add everything I ordered was recommended by our waitress, who did a great job. If you're in Edgartown, go to the Porthunter (across the street) one night, and go here another night for sure. One note for the restaurant , please add cappuccinos to the menu for dessert! :) read more

See all

Food, service, ambiance all terrific! The drinks are unique and top notch - best on the island! The food is incredible - my favorite is the Halibut, but I recommend it all! Great place highly recommend. read more

5 stars for ambiance. 5 stars for service. 4 stars for food. Delicious but my pasta was overcooked. Everyone else enjoyed their meals. Would recommend/return. read more

The halibut is fantastic! The atmosphere sitting outside was great. The service was outstanding. Loved it!

Phenomenal! Excellent meals, excellent service. Enjoyed the server's explanation of the dishes when we asked. Enjoyed the drinks. The steak was amazing, as was the spicy cucumbers, bread, scallops and gnocchi. Would absolutely recommend. read more

Ties for best restaurant on Martha's Vineyard (with State Road). Excellent service and ambience. Tremendous flavor and texture for all the dishes we had. Highly recommend! read more

Loved the kale salad, basil walnut gnocchi and halibut a tree. Cocktails were good as well. Ambience is nice. They have outdoor and indoor seating. Definitely make reservations couple of weeks in advance. In the heart of edgartown. They have ample of seating indoor and outdoor. Lot of vegetarian options. Chocolate torte was alright. read more

See all