Hands down the best clam chowder I had on the island. Very flavorful! The hotel is beautiful and we wanted to check out the restaurant one night. I ordered the chowder to start and then the lobster pasta. The pasta was decent but the chowder was my favorite. Our waiter was attentive even though it was a busy night Recommend coming here for a date night, a night out with friends or even a business meal read more

Bettini Restaurant - New American Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

See all

We are guests at the hotel. We walked in for our reservation and were handed 2 food menus and no wine menu from the concierge at the front another tables around us had both menus. Food was beyond awful. The only saving grace was our wonderful server Svetlana who was excellent but for a supposed 'fine dining' experience it was just a flop. I had to send back my crab cakes as they were literally burnt to a crisp. My husband got a mocktail in a hot glass and it tasted so bad neither of us could take more than a sip. My husbands clam chowder was heavy, salty and had a coagulated layer on top. His lobster pasta came out lukewarm and completely bland. Only good dish was my lobster bisque which was very tasty. Beautiful location, lovely ambience and great server but the food was a big, big disappointment. Despite sending 2 items back, no manager came over to us. We saw a table beside us send back their entree and did not want it replaced knowing the quality would likely be equally as bad. At least they seemed to have management address the issue. Would not recommend at all. read more

Good food. Good service. Good view. However I always find it mind blogging when places charge for a block ice cube in an Old Fashion. 3 dollars... Such a cheap move for a place that wants to portray itself as upscale. Put it in the price of the drink instead of an add on if you must. read more

Wonderful anniversary dinner at Bettini. Always love the vibe here--good energy but not too loud. We enjoyed a delicious cocktail on the porch while we waited for our table care of Taylor at the bar. Dinner was wonderful (we started with the oysters then split a pasta dish and the filet) and cooked perfectly. Highly recommend. read more

Bettini Restaurant - Cocktails on the deck - New American Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

Spent my birthday dinner at Bettini and everything was delicious. The ambience and service were great, drinks carefully crafted, food delicious. We ordered the beef carpaccio, pastina, and the prime rib. All were delicious with the beef carpaccio really stealing the show. They truly went out of their way to make it a special birthday dinner. I believe our servers name was Eduardo who was exceptional and made an effort to connect with us throughout the dinner. We'll be back! read more

See all

While eating my way through Martha's Vineyard, I took a morning walk and came across the Harbor View Hotel, home of the well-known Bettini restaurant. Normally this place is booked solid when we visit the Vineyard, but around 8 AM we decided to take a chance -- and luck was on our side. We walked right in and grabbed a seat. I wasn't really hungry, but when you have a chance to eat where past presidents, foreign dignitaries, and celebrities dine, you don't pass that up. I went with the avocado toast, topped with toasted everything seasoning, heirloom tomatoes, shallots, and two eggs on multigrain toast. The verdict: it was very tasty. That everything seasoning hits different -- I need to find out where they get theirs. My only small critique is that I would have liked the bread slices just a little thinner, but that's more about me cutting back on carbs than them doing anything wrong. I'll definitely have to return during drinking hours to try their signature Shark's Attack cocktail. Rating: Solid breakfast spot. Worth the hype. I eat, I judge. The fork stops with me. read more

A Culinary Gem That Outshines Even the View - Bettini at Harbor View Hotel Bettini at the Harbor View Hotel is one of those rare places where the food, service, and setting harmonize so perfectly that you almost forget which one impressed you first. Yes, the view of Edgartown Harbor is breathtaking -- the kind that glows in the golden light of Martha's Vineyard -- but here, it's the food that truly steals the show. Under the remarkable leadership of Executive Chef Juan Martinez and Sous Chef Momo Camara, every plate is crafted with soul and precision. The scallop crudo was a masterpiece of restraint -- impossibly fresh, delicate, kissed with just the right acidity to let the sea speak for itself. The lobster bucatini came next, beautifully balanced with a subtle kick that added warmth without overwhelming the sweet richness of the lobster. And then, the beef carpaccio -- paper-thin, melt-in-your-mouth tender, and bursting with flavor in every bite. Service was flawless from start to finish. Our bartender Taylor made the most beautiful hot cocoa for my daughter -- just the right temperature, velvety, and not too hot -- proof of the team's thoughtful attention to detail. Andrei, our server, was both attentive and genuinely funny, effortlessly remembering each of my kids' names after our very first dinner. That kind of personal touch transforms a meal into a memory. Bettini isn't just a hotel restaurant -- it's a culinary destination in its own right. Whether you come for the harbor views, the impeccable service, or the artistry on your plate, you'll leave knowing you've just experienced something special. read more

See all

Our service was disappointing for a birthday celebration reservation made well in advance. Server was not knowledgeable and we expected a different experience from a 5 star restaurant on MV. Recommend better training for restaurant staff. read more

We tried this place for our anniversary dinner and it didn't disappoint. The staff were very professional and friendly, and we felt very cared for and appreciated. We skipped apps and ordered scallops (which were cooked PERFECTLY!) and the prime rib. Everything was delicious and amazingly cooked, and the duck fat potatoes we got as a side were a game changer. Everything came out at the same time and hot (which can be a miss in the US in my opinion). The price is a little steep but we were happy to pay it based on the perfect meal we had, and the amazing location. We will be back when we are on the vineyard next! read more

Bettini Restaurant - New American Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

One of our favorite spots on Martha's Vineyard - an amazing restaurant with a superb historic interior, great staff and delicious food. I appreciate that they always have at least one vegan entree that changes every year and the chef can easily customize any of the dishes to your liking. The place is ALWAYS packed in the evening so make sure you have reservations. read more

Great location with a great view depending on where you sit. Nice vibe overall. Friendly service but inconsistent. Seemed overwhelmed and unable to deliver on simple requests, like a side of aioli. Food was ok. Not of the quality and taste, though, that the price would imply. Will try again to confirm thoughts and update based on round two, but wouldn't recommend based on first visit. read more

One of my favorite places to grab cocktails on the Vineyard! The flavors are all perfectly balanced and the cocktails are delicious. Sitting at the bar walk in is usually pretty easy and the view is unbeatable. The bartenders are also so kind. read more

Bettini Restaurant - New American Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

See all

For our first time at Martha's Vineyard there were many dining options, but for an anniversary dinner I wanted something special. Called the concierge at American Express platinum to get their advice since they never steer me wrong.... They recommended Bettini's and were spot on... Located inside a hotel it has a fair view of the ocean but is away from the tourist traps which makes it work. Sunsets are worth the wait. Our server from Jamaica was amazing. Spot on recommendations ... The local oysters on the half shell were worth it & the crab cakes were lightly breaded so the flavor wasn't lost and the seasoning was a solid compliment that gave them a unique flavor. Even though we come to New England for fresh seafood, trusted the recommendation of the ribeye and it was mouth watering. Excellent service who pay attention to details and teh manager makes a point to visit every table. Great date night and highly recommended. read more

See all

My wife and I stayed at the hotel and had a wonderful dining experience at Bettini. Dinner was fantastic from start to finish. I enjoyed a couple of great cocktails and the Curry Spice Seared Alaskan Halibut was outstanding. The flavors were balanced, the fish was perfectly cooked, and the presentation was beautiful. The service was attentive and friendly without feeling rushed, which made the evening feel really special. We also had breakfast here the next morning and it was just as enjoyable. Everything was fresh, well-prepared, and the atmosphere in the morning was relaxing with a nice view to start the day. Bettini made our stay feel even more memorable and we would absolutely come back. Highly recommend. read more

We had our first dinner of the season June 12th and had a very pleasant surprise! We dine there several times each summer for many years and the food was usually OK but nothing special. But the beautiful view and atmosphere always made it worthy of repeat visits. But last evening the food was the center piece of the enjoyment ! Entrees of chicken, rack of lamb and cod were superb! Oysters and beef carpaccio for starters were also A+ I don't know if they have a new chef but someone in the kitchen is a master! Service and views were their usual perfection! Oh, a word about the outfits the hostesses were wearing. Busy takes on a new meaning. When it was mentioned to the two lovely ladies, their smile said it all! We will be back soon! Can't wait! read more

Came here for dinner on a Monday night with friends while on vacation in Martha's Vineyard. The restaurant has a great vibe and was popping off and bustling. We were seated immediately upon arrival and service was friendly and prompt throughout dinner. I ordered the baby lettuce salad to start and had the roasted chicken for dinner. My husband started with the endive salad and had the bolognese as his main. I was also able to taste the gnocchi. I found the endive salad to be more flavorful than the baby lettuces and thought the pastas were just ok, but I really enjoyed my chicken dish. read more

See all

Such a thoughtful staff, able to cater to the needs of a 3 year old through a 75 year old in a high-end but very warm environment. The food is delicious and the service is even better! read more

Came here for our anniversary a few weeks ago. Ambiance: 4/5 Restaurant is nestled near the lobby of the hotel near Edgartown Lighthouse. Classic ambiance, not too formal. Has some wine cellar vibes. Service: 3/5 unfortunately despite all my detective work to find a great spot, the service was so disappointing. Our waiter didn't know the menu, didn't know when items had run out, and the complimentary bread took about an hour to come out with the drinks. The tables next to us had similar experiences and everyone was itching to leave. Food: 4/5 this probably is what makes this place more of a 4/5 than a 3/5. My husband and I enjoyed the side of Mac and cheese, Pappardelle, and tuna steak. Really good. Especially the Mac, who would've known. Probably wouldn't come back due to service. read more

See all

We chose Bettini for our 20th anniversary dinner, expecting a memorable experience--but unfortunately, it was memorable for all the wrong reasons. It took over two hours to receive our meals, and only after we raised the issue did anyone acknowledge the delay. To make matters worse, an obnoxiously loud group at the table next to us--who arrived after we did--was served well before us. When the food finally arrived, it was cold and bland. My bolognese lacked flavor, and after asking for it to be reheated, it came back with a warmer plate but still cold food--clearly just microwaved or briefly warmed, not properly fixed. The staff seemed stressed and inattentive, rarely checking on tables and always rushing. For a restaurant that presents itself as a high-end experience, both the food and the service fell flat. A disappointing way to start what should have been a joyful trip. read more

Four stars because I didn't like the server, but the food was superb! Very expensive though! Scallops: 4.5/5 I loved the scallops and especially the orzo risotto it came with. -.5 because they reduced the scallops to three and the serving size is puny. Foie Gras: 3/5 Good, but nothing special. I liked the cornmeal pancakes it came with but the combo with the Foie Gras was not good. Lobster grits: 4/5 Small quantity of grits, not cheesy enough, kind of bland. The bbq sauce is what did it and the lobster chunks were great! Pork chop: 3/5 Underwhelming and big super flavorful. The house rib-eye: 5/5 Juicy and massive! Great flavor!! read more

Bettini Restaurant - Lobster Grits - New American Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

See all

We had an absolutely spectacular evening at Bettini. We were staying in the hotel for a quick MV getaway to celebrate my birthday. Last year I had an ok birthday dinner, the year before was the start of the COVID pandemic so going to target was our dangerous excursion and highlight of that birthday, and two years ago we were in Israel during passover and everywhere was either closed or busting at the seams with a 2 hour wait. I was way overdue for a nice birthday dinner and stakes were high. I rolled the dice and decided to dine at our hotel's restaurant. I figured, it's the off season and wasn't overly concerned about making a reservation for a Thursday evening. Waiting until the day of was a mistake as there were no reservations to be had. We were told to inquire about high top bar seating. Fortunately there was a high top table available at the time of our arrival! Birthday luck, I guess. The service was excellent, our waiter was attentive and friendly. I can't find the drink menu online and the fact that I can't remember specifics about the drink menu testifies to their quality. At the suggestion of our waiter, we both started with the bettini which was a cross between a mimosa and a martini if memory serves. It was not too boozy and just sweet enough to make for an enjoyable but strong cocktail. I moved on to a cocktail called "Spa Water" or something to that effect with gin which was also a solid drink. To start, GF ordered the clams casino which my vegetarian ass is not familiar with but I am told it's a well known and slutty dish. It was adored. I started with the belgian endive salad with ricotta salata, toasted pistachios, herbs, and truffle vinaigrette. It was light and an excellent palate cleanser for the rest of the meal. They clearly indicate the vegetarian options on the menu, which was appreciated. For my main, I went with the pecan pesto gemelli which was absolutely delicious. The gemelli were al dente with a nice bite and the pesto had just a hint of cream and was very tasty. I also threw in a side order of broccolini which was nicely topped with parm. GF ordered the pepper seared yellowfin tuna steak with roasted sweet and sour peppers and crispy cauliflower. This did not last long on the plate which I think speaks for itself. In response to a friendly joke about us being old enough to drink, GF mentioned that it was my birthday on that very day. After our meal, I was surprised with a gigantic cannoli adorned with a birthday candle. This was such a nice touch that I appreciated tremendously. The space is also decorated beautifully which is a minor point compared to the service and the quality of the dishes. This was an incredible birthday dinner and we definitely made the right choice to dine at Bettini. I can't recommend this place enough, especially for a special occasion. read more

See all

This restaurant is located inside the Harbor View Hotel, since we're staying here we decided to try it. Our server Ty was such a pleasure, very professional ,courteous and efficient. Now on to the food ,pan roasted organic half chicken with a cheese potato purée,forest mushrooms and chicken jus. Delicious. Wifey had the New England Crab cake and purée potato. This is a can't miss restaurant. Do yourself a favor and get over toBettini... just finished breakfast on our last morning on Martha's Vineyard, our server Seal(not the singer) was a friendly and very informative about the hotel and Martha's Vineyard , this restaurant has the best servers I have ever encountered. I had the eggs Benedict and my wife had the buttermilk pancakes, the food was fantastic and the breakfast vibe was amazing. I can't wait to come back to this unique hotel and their restaurant. read more

See all

The Resturant nice and the food expensive The food come out a little salty and dry also the fish not real fresh It is ok for one time but not twice the bread is very good the service is good too read more

See all

When I made a reservation here during our vacation, my husband was reluctant to try it because he hadn't heard about it from other people. Looking at the pictures of the atmosphere, the menu, and the reviews, I had a good feeling about it. They exceeded our expectations. It was our two-year-old's birthday, which they knew. Upon arriving for our reservation, they greeted her with excitement and a little stuffed whale as a gift. The entire staff was gracious and welcoming, even with such a young child entering their upscale establishment, and that warmed our hearts. We had a seat by the window with a gorgeous view of the Edgartown harbor. The service was excellent throughout our experience, the food was delicious, and the chocolate lava cake was to die for. They even put a candle in the dessert for our daughter to blow out, and she couldn't have been more excited. We will definitely be coming back here and recommending the restaurant to others who visit Martha's Vineyard. Thank you to Carmen, who took care of us! We loved you. :) read more

Bettini Restaurant - Our daughter turned 2 and we celebrated here! - New American Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

We were there a few weeks ago. If it wasn't for their desserts, this would be a one star. Our experience was not very good starting from the host that seats you. We felt we weren't welcome there and all effort was made to discourage us to seat. We ordered filet mignon, pasta and vegetable dish. Steak was 5/10. Pasta was 0/10. Vegetable was 0/10 Pasta was undercooked. Vegetable dish was literally air fired cauliflower. Desserts were 12/10. Absolutely wonderful. Location is rather nice but the prices are high but then you are at Martha's Vineyard. Overall, never coming back unless we just want desserts. read more

We've only come here for breakfast but it's decent and convenient. If you order food and want to sit in the patio, the servers cannot take the food out to you. If you decide to dine inside, the servers will take your order and bring the food to your table. The Barista Daniel was great. Food: Breakfast sandwich with bacon and on a brioche bread - Can't go wrong. Anything with butter and bacon is amazing. I had this everyday. I should have switched to sausage but couldn't go away from the bacon. The chocolate chip pancake - Kids liked it. Acai bowl - Not my favorite but only because I got it to go (and the acai bowl did not look great - it looked like mud in a container) AND it had to be mixed in with bananas. I hate bananas so I couldn't eat it. We sat outside and brought the food to our rooms one day so that was fine. We were in a hurry one time and decided to dine inside next to the door. The unfortunate thing was that our food was brought out to an empty table by another door and left there... I had to go get it myself bc it clearly was going to sit there for awhile. Overall, an easy place to grab breakfast. Town wasn't too far but starbucks wasn't opened on Mondays or Tuesdays. read more

See all

Bettini is awesome! We had the crabcake and the fillet and both were fantastic. If you get a table near the window you get a incredible view of the water. The service here can't be beat. If you're in the area of downtown Edgartown don't miss the opportunity to eat at the Bettina's. read more

Bettini Restaurant - New American Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

We really liked this restaurant. I loved that they have gluten free and vegan clearly marked on the menu. Our entire table ordered multiple plates of the octopus and everyone loved it. It was really fresh. The lamb rack was fantastic and everyone else really enjoyed their meals. The drinks were also pretty good. We celebrated a birthday, and everyone was great. The ambiance was great as well. Our server was a little slow at first, but it got better as the night went along. I would go back. read more

Exceptional food, fantastic service, reasonable prices for fine dining, and great views of the harbor during dinner. We really enjoyed our evening at the Teenies located in the Harbor View hotel. We started with cocktails, which were made perfectly. For food starters we had the clam chowder and the Foie Gras - both delicious! Our entrées were the pork pappardelle, local Fluke, and broccolini. The Fluke was very fresh and the Pappardelle was homemade. Both were delicious! We enjoyed these with a nice glass of Chianti. The dessert menu was limited and really did not interest us which was actually good because we really had no room for dessert anyway. We will definitely come back. read more

Their LOBSTER RAVIOLI!!!!!!! AMAZING! Loved our date night after my husband ran the full marathon this past weekend. Beautiful decor, super friendly and attentive staff, and excellent food! I don't often get ravioli, but I couldn't help it when I saw it was with lobster. They outdid themselves. It was excellent. Our table on the window overlooking the view was perfect. Next time I visit the island, we'll stay here at their Harbor View Hotel read more

Bettini Restaurant - Lobster Ravioli - New American Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

Beautiful ambiance, view of the Edgartown lighthouse and water, and great service, but bland entrees. We enjoyed our drinks (Derby cocktail and blueberry mule mocktail), and stuffed clams, but the swordfish and halibut entrees were so bland. Even the risotto that came with the swordfish were bland. It's not just lack of salt but general lack of flavor. I'm confused because the menu states that the food is tested rigorously before being added to menus. read more

See all

I can't even start, or end this review. Because my sox are still blown off so far away, I can't find them. 4 years ago the new owner took over this hotel and the restaurant and started making changes. The staff is AMAZINGLY down to earth yet impeccably poised and elegant with a hometown feel. Except for Rian who is also a stand up comedian with a heart of gold and a million buck smile. We came to Bettina for a wine dinner after experiencing a Michelin Star in Rioja, driving my husband to skepticism with no boundaries... And he was about to LITERALLY eat his words. A "mile long" (ok, I'm taking some poetic liberties here) table of hand-polished glassware lined a table, and the dining room was transformed into pure glitz. 10 courses, 10 pours. Wine tasting, right? EH! WRONG! 10 actual pours of wine magesically paired to what where 1/2 PORTIONS worth of deliciousness. Chef Alex Pineda came in from Marblehead with his Colombian flair and his almost fatherly love for service. With partnership from Bettina Head Chef, the duo and the blood giving kitchen staff banged out 10 AMAZING courses. In Chef's words "I don't strive for a star. I just want to cook REALLY GOOD FOOD with love. I leave it all on the plate". Yeah, he did that. Lobstah quenelle in its puff pastry shell with CAVIAR floating on a sea of lobster broth and butter. yes, he did that! Foia Gras, Pork belly, HAND MADE SOBA NOODLES from the Bettina crew in a stupid good duck broth and thin slices of duck... YEA I ate that. Tartare with caviar... and on and on. We were SO STUFFED by the end, we wondered if the kitchen was trying to assassinate us all by gluttony... Bernard, the owner gushed as he took in the glitz, the laughter, the oozz and ahhs of very VERY happy, full and satisfied visitors. NOT for the faint of wallet. A dinner will set you back $300+ pp. Yet worth EVERY sensory experience. Word of caution... DONT EAT FOR A WEEK before the bacchanal! Stupid good food, impressive wines, beautiful ambiance, attention to every detail (curse you Scott for being SO precise yes gentle handed!) and a staff that will pamper you like a newborn! read more

Went for a drink... stayed for dinner, was curious to see if they turned it around... What a game changer New chef? New menu? I can't believe this is the same place. Phenomenal meal and service. Bravo Bettini!!! read more

Bettini Restaurant - Blandest entree I've ever had :( - New American Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

See all

We ate at the bar and the bartenders were great, it was a busy night but they kept their cool and worked the bar as a team. The food was terrific: the bolognese was light and perfect portion. We had a couple pre-meal drinks on the deck too, worth it, The entire hotel staff were great. It's expensive but worth the treat. read more

So love the space and venue - servers kind but didn't take drink orders before meal order until I asked, the salads were lacking flavor - I've never had such a small piece of salmon or a Caesar salad with not much dressing on it. The gnocchi entree was gross. Desert menu limited. so, overall the menu overpriced, main dishes small portions - overall a disappointment. I'd go back just for over priced drinks at bar, sadly hardly any appetizers- and what is there is $30 for a starter that's nuts. I live here so I know prices I just expect more read more

Overpriced, below average food. I, along with two of my friends, ordered the monkfish. It was barely edible - extremely dry and ridiculously salty. We were in shock that they we're charging what they were for such subpar food. It so unfortunate because it is such a beautiful restaurant located in a perfect spot. Perhaps it was just an off night for the kitchen, but I would not go back for anything more than drinks (on a positive note - Sam our bartender in the back room was great). read more

Not sure why this place doesn't have 4.5 stars as the food is AMAZING the pesto pasta and halibut were the best I've had and I live in NYC (as was their dessert) Service is also amazing (Bridget and Alyssa who served us were incredibly hospitable) I look forward to having breakfast from this place tomorrow and may get food to go for our travel home on Saturday as well read more

Bettini Restaurant - New American Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

We had an excellent meal and experience on a busy Saturday night in mid October. From the moment we were greeted at the host station, through the end of the meal, we felt welcomed and appreciated. Our wait-person was highly attentive, noticing small details; for example, I asked her for some pepper for my carbonara, she brought a pepper grinder and added pepper, and also left a salt and pepper shaker in case I wanted more. We shared a seasonal burrata salad, served with stone fruit, heirloom tomato, honey lavender, arugula, and truffled baby peaches. It was delicious, and enough for two. For entrées, we had the Faroe Island salmon and lobster bucatini carbonara. Both were perfectly executed, and the portions were generous. We were too full for dessert. We also shared an outstanding bottle of Chardonnay from their wine list. We were staying in the center of Edgartown, Bettini was an easy 10-minute, half-mile walk from our hotel. The view would've been lovely, overlooking a lighthouse and the ocean, had it not been pitch dark outside. I would absolutely come again. read more

Bettini Restaurant - Faroe Island Salmon - New American Near Me - Edgartown, Massachusetts

See all

Bettini is a beautiful restaurant in a lovely location. We returned for a second visit last Friday, after an extremely good romantic date-night experience last summer, but were bummed out and sadly will only be returning for drinks on the deck. Speaking of drinks on the deck, that was lovely. What a view! It's self-service, however there's an extremely kind and thoughtful diminutive older lady out there who tidies up and who very sweetly brought us a small table to set up our drinks. I believe her name was Minnie? The hostess, Yelena, was also a delight. The restaurant should treasure these awesome representatives. Once the meal began, it fell apart fast. Our server was extremely brusque. It felt like we had insulted him before we ever said a word, which was pretty intimidating, though neither of us are rude, or oversensitive. Despite ordering three apps, two entrees, and dessert we left hungry. The tuna tartare was the first slap in the face, appearing without the avocado mousse or any seasoning/ponzu on a dark plate, so that the dish appeared empty. It might as well have been, as it was so small I finished it in two bites. The clams casino were tiny, and cheesy / creamy, not really what one thinks of when ordering that dish, but edible and tasted nice. My wide ribbon pasta with braised beef was also insultingly tiny and completely flavorless. Truly sad, since I have been dreaming about the Bettini pasta all year. It was so good that when we got back to NYC, I tried to re-create it at home. Dessert was served on an ice cold plate, and was too cold to enjoy the chocolate mousse. Dishes were absolutely slammed down in front of us, loudly, by our grim-faced waiters, and questions got sneers and grunts in reply. For example, we asked if we should order everything at once or if we could get apps and then mains once we had a bit of wine and bread, the waiter said, not unless you want to be here all night. :( We also ordered a full bottle of very nice wine. No wine pairing suggestions, or tastes, were offered however. After dinner there was an epic thunderstorm, which we watched from the deck while sipping bubbly. Like I said, the deck is where it's at. I don't need to pay hundreds to be treated like someone's sworn enemy, sheesh. Recommended for a pre- or post-dinner deck session, or perhaps a drink at the bar, but not for dinner or dessert. read more

Came for dinner with work colleagues who were in town for an event. The inn itself is in prime location on the island. Probably some of the best views. We sat at the bar because it was much faster than waiting (7:30 pm on a Monday was packed)! The bad was comfortable for dinning, even for our group of six people. Place definitely has a vineyard/New England vide. We tried several appetizers and my favorite was easily the sashimi. I could eat that stuff as a last meal. Truffle fries were hits, and they brought out a thick piece of toast that was the best appetizer bread I've had in a while (we definitely ordered more). For dinner I had the ribeye, and it was phenomenal. Cooked medium rare, charred and buttery. The drinks were so so. I ordered a few old fashions and each came out slightly different. One I sent back. And I got the caramel cup for dessert, which I did not like. I found the churro on top to be dry. All and all a great meal and would highly recommend if you're in Edgartown. read more